Author Archive: Ed Driscoll

THE NEW YORK TIMES IS WORKING OVERTIME TO MAINSTREAM MAMDANI:

As Noam Blum of Tablet tweets, “The weirdest part about this piece is that it has nothing to do with the title. The piece is not about how Jews love Mamdani, nor does it offer any examples of Jews who love Mamdani. I’m legitimately confused by the choice of this title for anything other than rage baiting.” Which brings us to this banger of a headline, which ran on Tuesday:

We really do need a new definition of antisemitism apparently!

And: NYC mayoral nominee’s anti-Israel views, political rise closely tied to Palestinian activist Linda Sarsour.

UPDATE:

UPDATE: To circle back to Michelle Goldberg’s headline atop this post:

ROGER KIMBALL: Minuting the minutiae.

For most mortals, most of the time, the deliberations and periodic eructations of the Supreme Court can seem like so many bulletins from the Office of Circumlocution.

Every now and then, however, the Court’s declarations mesmerize the public’s attention.

So it was on Friday, June 27, the last day of the Court’s term. Four cases were up for its scrutiny. One case, a congressional redistricting case in Louisiana, was pushed off to the fall term. (Often described as a “voting rights case,” the real issue is whether redrawing the map to create black-majority districts is permissible.)

Many Americans were happy about the 6–3 decision in Mahmoud v. Taylor, which held that parents in Maryland may opt to keep their children out of primary-school classes that feature “LGBTQ+” storybooks.

The same people who applauded that decision were happy about the 6–3 decision in Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton, which upheld a Texas law requiring age verification to protect minors from accessing porn sites on the internet.

But the case that really galvanized the public was Trump v. Casa, in which the Court finally began to deal with the outrageous spectacle, unknown until the twentieth century, of district court judges issuing universal injunctions or restraining orders in order to stymie executive—i.e., presidential—actions that they dislike.

Read the whole thing.

HAMAS CHIEF ‘WHO MASTERMINDED OCTOBER 7 ATTACK’ IS KILLED BY ISRAELI AIRSTRIKE, IDF SAY:

The Hamas chief allegedly behind the attacks on October 7 has been killed by an Israeli airstrike, according to the Israel Defence Forces (IDF).

In a post on X on Saturday, the IDF reported it ‘eliminated’ Hakham Muhammad Issa Al-Issa in a targeted airstrike on the Sabra neighbourhood of Gaza on Friday.

Describing him as both ‘one of the founders of Hamas’ military wing’ and Hamas itself, it said: ‘Issa led Hamas’ force build-up, training, and planned the October 7 massacre.’

It continued: ‘As Head of Combat Support, he advanced aerial & naval attacks against Israelis.’

The attacks on October 7, 2023, saw thousands of Hamas fighters storm into southern Israel where they killed 1,320 Israelis and took a further 251 hostage.

The IDF claims Al-Issa ‘played a significant role in the planning and execution’ of the attack as well as serving as Head of the Training Headquarters.

The post also suggests he is ‘one of the last remaining senior Hamas terrorists in the Gaza Strip’ and ‘a key source of knowledge’.

‘The IDF & ISA will continue to locate and eliminate all terrorists involved in the October 7 massacre,’ they added.

Curiously, the IDF causing the mastermind behind the slaughter of music festival attendees to assume room temperature won’t make the attendees and headliners of Glastonbury very happy, or the likely future mayor of New York:

DEVELOPING: Thom Tillis Announces He’s Not Running for Reelection:

Politico yesterday: Trump threatens Tillis with primary challenge.

RICH LOWRY: Blast ‘em: Get rid of the blocky brutalist buildings that blight our nation’s capital.

[T]he FBI is also departing its HQ, designated by the UK building materials retailer Buildworld as the ugliest building in the United States and the second ugliest in the world.

The moves are in keeping with the spirit of President Donald Trump’s executive order stipulating that federal buildings should “respect regional, traditional, and classical architectural heritage in order to uplift and beautify public spaces and ennoble the United States and our system of self-government.”

That EO should be considered common sense, but has several trigger words for defenders of the architectural status quo, including “traditional,” “classical,” and perhaps foremost of all, “beautify.”

In response, the American Institute of Architects expressed its “strong concerns that mandating architecture styles stifles innovation and harms local communities.”

According to The Nation magazine, Trump’s initiative is part of an agenda to “to make historical architecture on the whole inextricable from Eurocentric white supremacy.”

In short, it’s an unforgivable offense to want a government building to look nice.

Brutalism, with its blocky, minimalist structures made of poured concrete, was a creation of a post-war Europe that wanted to embrace the fresh and new and to economize on rebuilding.

Although the name “brutalism” perfectly captures the aesthetic effect, it actually comes from the French for raw concrete, béton brut.

Amazing – the far-left Nation magazine’s hatred of Trump has them defending the design concepts of a prominent member of Vichy France: Le Corbusier was ‘militant fascist’, two new books on French architect claim.

Headquarters of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, FBI, The J. Edgar Hoover Building at 935 Pennsylvania Avenue NW in Washington, D.C., Thursday, March 23, 2017. Construction finished in September 1975, and President Gerald Ford dedicated the structure on September 30, 1975. (AP Photo/NewsBase.)

JOY REID OUTDOES THE LEFTISTS WHO LIKE TO CALL TRUMP HITLER:

Reid then claimed that Rubio was hoping to inherit the MAGA mantle: “Marco Rubio is doing what he’s doing now because in his mind, he thinks that somehow he can inherit the cult of Donald Trump. That when Trump is aged out and when the devil takes him home, when he goes back below earth, from whence he came, when his soul — when the man — when the creature to which he has sold his soul takes him — he thinks that he will inherit that cult … they all think it. They think they can inherit the cult.”

Flying headlong into crazyville, Reid then likened Trump to Jim Jones: “What they don’t understand is that when Jim Jones was gone, there was no other Jim Jones. There was only one Jim Jones. And when he killed all those people in the forests of Guyana, even his son could not become the next Jim Jones. Because cults are sui generis. They worship one person — not even God — they worship one god. And these people are a monotheistic cult. And the mono — the god — is named Donald Trump.” Uh-huh. And so does Reid think that Trump is going to force all of his followers to drink poisoned Kool-Aid? Coming from her, it wouldn’t be a surprise in the least.

She’s not even the first to make the comparison. In August of 2021, the Washington Examiner’s Paul Bedard reported in his “Liberal Media Scream” column: New CNN low, comparing Trump ‘cult’ to Jonestown massacre.

This week’s Liberal Media Scream features CNN’s Brian Stelter’s Trump Derangement Syndrome hitting a new low, inviting a comparison of the “cult” of Trump to the Jim Jones cult killings in Jonestown, Guyana, in 1978.

On his Sunday show, Reliable Sources, the liberal media nag brought aboard Rep. Jackie Speier, who survived the Jonestown massacre, to equate the “cult of Trump” with the mass murder-suicide of 918 followers of Rev. Jim Jones. “I wanted to hear her thoughts about the comparison, the notion of the cult of Trump,” Stelter said in setting up the welcoming California lawmaker.

Stelter played along: “It’s scary to hear that when you have observed the Trump phenomenon, you have seen similarities to Jonestown.”

Stelter had opened the segment by relaying feedback from international viewers asking, “Why doesn’t the American media just call out Trump for what he is, call Trump fandom for what it is? Sometimes they use the word, cult.”

Do Reid and Stelter know that Jones was a central figure in the San Francisco Democrat machine in the 1970s? The Road to Jonestown.

 

RIP: Dave Parker, Baseball Hall of Famer and MVP winner, dead at 74.

Hall of Famer Dave Parker has died at the age of 74. The Pittsburgh Pirates announced Parker’s death before their game on Saturday.

Parker played for six teams during his 19 major-league seasons, 11 of those seasons with the Pirates. He also played for the Cincinnati Reds, Oakland Athletics, Milwaukee Brewers, California Angels and Toronto Blue Jays.

During his MLB career from 1979-1991, Parker batted .290/.339/.471 with 2,712 hits, 339 home runs, 526 doubles, 1,493 RBI and 154 stolen bases. He won World Series championships with the 1979 Pirates and 1989 Athletics, was a seven-time All-Star and earned consecutive National League batting titles in 1978 and 1979.

In 1979, Parker won the NL MVP award with a .334 average and .970 OPS with 30 homers, 34 doubles, 117 RBI and 20 steals. He finished second in NL MVP voting in 1985 with the Reds, leading the league with 125 RBI.

If there’s thunder tonight, you’ll know why:

PAST PERFORMANCE IS NO GUARANTEE OF FUTURE RESULTS:

Back in December 2008, the face of NBC News begged the leader of the Democratic Party to raise gasoline prices: Tom Brokaw suggested that then-President Elect Obama tank the economy even more than it was by the end of the year, by sticking it to commuters’ wallets:

Let’s talk for a moment about consumer responsibility when it comes to the auto industries. As soon as gas prices dropped, consumers moved back to the larger cars once again. The SUVs are the big gas consumers. Why not take this opportunity to put a tax on gasoline, bump it back up to $4 a gallon where people were prepared to pay for that, and use that revenue for alternative energy and as a signal to the consumers: “Those days are gone. We’re not going to have gasoline that you could just fill up your tank for 20 bucks anymore.”

The New York Times and the Washington Post were also fine with this idea back then, when it might have been implemented on a national scale. Now that it could — pardon the pun — tank a potential Democrat front runner in 2028, omertà.

BOB VYLAN, GLASTONBURY AND THE BANALITY OF JEW HATRED:

If you can’t see it now, you never will. The sight of tens of thousands of people at Glastonbury yesterday joining in a spirited chant of ‘Death, death to the IDF’ was the sight of us officially becoming a very different country, I fear. One in which anti-Israel hysteria has so flawlessly rehabilitated Jew hatred that it has become unthinking, conformist, almost mundane. Something that Home Counties idiots can jive to before adjusting their hot pants and heading off to catch Charli XCX. Something that is broadcast by the BBC into millions of homes. The banality of the new anti-Semitism.

Let’s not muck about here. When punk-rap duo Bob Vylan called for the killing of Israeli soldiers yesterday – as they warmed up the crowd at the West Holts Stage for every Israelophobe’s new favourite Irish rap trio, Kneecap – they weren’t opposing war. They were calling for war, and on the one army on Earth charged with protecting Jews from genocide. The army now at war with a jihadist cult that murdered, raped and kidnapped its way through an Israeli festival not unlike Glastonbury on 7 October 2023. The army that almost all Israelis are expected to serve in. Indeed, those making excuses for that sickening call-and-response yesterday hopefully don’t know that Hamas justifies killing Israeli civilians on the grounds that they are basically all tainted by national service. That they are all enemy combatants. Death, death to that IDF?

Whether we got here by ignorance or conscious hatred is pretty much moot. The end result is British Jews – at Glasto or at home – watching thousands whoop as Jew-killing slogans are recited. Frontman Bobby Vylan also treated the crowd to a deranged rant about the indignities he suffered working for a ‘Zionist’ at a record label, because he had to listen to his boss talk favourably about Israel. I wonder if he knows that the vast majority of British Jews are Zionists. I wonder if he cares.

I wonder if he knows the back catalog of the man whose stage name he borrowed? I wonder if he cares:

Meanwhile, more peace and love coming from the British pop music scene: Met won’t prosecute Kneecap over ‘Kill your MP.’

How low is too low? Kneecap seem determined to find out, judging by their never-ending mission to troll the UK. But last month even the West Belfast trio seemed to go too far, after a video emerged of them calling for the death of British MPs. It prompted a grovelling statement from the band, insisting that they would not incite violence against any individual. Real hard men, eh?

Of course, cynics suggested that Kneecap’s capitulation had less to do with genuine remorse and concern for the likes of David Amess’s family, and more to do with an effect on ticket sales. But now the not-so-funny trio can sleep easy, for Steerpike has checked and counter-terror police have confirmed they will not be charging the group over a November 2023 video in which they say ‘the only good Tory is a dead Tory. Kill your local MP’.

I’m so old, I can remember back to last year, when such language could get one arrested in England: How one woman’s racist tweet sparked a free speech row.

In July last year, prompted by a false rumour that an illegal immigrant was responsible for the murder of three girls at a dance workshop in Southport, Connolly posted online calling for “mass deportation now”, adding “set fire to all the… hotels [housing asylum seekers]… for all I care”.

Connolly, then a 41-year-old Northampton childminder, added: “If that makes me racist, so be it.”

At the time she had about 9,000 followers on X. Her message was reposted 940 times and viewed 310,000 times, before she deleted it three and a half hours later.

In October she was jailed after admitting inciting racial hatred.

Three appeal court judges this week ruled the 31-month sentence was not “manifestly excessive”.

Stephen O’Grady, a legal officer with the Free Speech Union (FSU), said the sentence seemed “rather steep in proportion to the offence”.

His organisation has worked with Connolly’s family since November and funded her appeal.

Mr O’Grady said Connolly “wasn’t some lager-fuelled hooligan on the streets” and pointed to her being a mother of a 12-year-old daughter, who had also lost a son when he was just 19 months old.

He said there was a “difference between howling racist abuse at somebody in the street and throwing bricks at the police” and “sending tweets, which were perhaps regrettable but wouldn’t have the same immediate effect”.

It’s like Prime Minister Starmer has multiple different standards of justice for his nation. Two tiers, as it were:

One British comedian does an awesome Norm Macdonald impersonation:

Alas, England in general seems determined to remain a safe space for people who want to kill Jews, based on the ideology of current management.

UPDATE:

CHRISTIAN TOTO: Is Mel Brooks Torching His Legacy in Real Time?

Quick, what was your favorite scene from “History of the World, Part II?

Don’t have one? Never saw it? Wasn’t even aware such a project existed?

You’re not alone. Hulu’s ill-fated attempt to revive Mel Brooks’ 1981 comedy didn’t rock the culture. Reviewers were mostly kind, but the streaming series came and went without much fuss.

Blame a crowded marketplace or the fact that it’s hard to duplicate Brooks’ brand of silliness even when he served as an executive producer on the miniseries.

Looking back, it was funnier to leave a film like “History of the World, Part I” as is. The title is part of the joke, no?

Now, Brooks is back. Twice. Is it wise to dust off his comedy classics to appease an industry desperate for IPs?

Will new, inferior Brooks titles diminish his canon?

He just announced a belated sequel to “Spaceballs,” his intermittently funny “Star Wars” spoof from 1987. The original isn’t a classic like “The Producers,” “Young Frankenstein” or “Blazing Saddles,” but it gently skewered George Lucas’ franchise in memorable ways.

Spaceballs isn’t that good as a film, but it’s become much loved because Brooks was one of the first to parody the sci-fi genre, doing for the Star Wars franchise what Blazing Saddles did for westerns and Young Frankenstein did for the 1930s Universal monster movies. But most of Brooks’ post-Young Frankenstein movies failed to work at that same level of excellence, but because of the titles that Toto mentions above, Brooks’ cinematic immortality as a comedic director is assured, no matter how bad the latest product that trades on his goodwill and small involvement turns out to be.

UPDATE: A Look at Mel Brooks’ Illustrious Life and Career in Photos As the Legendary Actor Turns 99 Years Old Today.

OLD AND BUSTED: “If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?”

The New Hotness? If a CNN journalist announces to the public that she doesn’t watch CNN either, will anybody hear it?

RIP: Bill Moyers, Elder Statesman of PBS Journalists, Dies at 91.

Bill Moyers, who carried an unblemished air of moral conviction* throughout a 43-year career as a broadcast journalist, mostly in his later years for PBS, died Thursday in Manhattan, the New York Times reported. He was91.

Moyers was characterized by an insatiable and wide-ranging intellectual curiosity, but he was deeply concerned not only with how things are but how they should be.

He was also well known for his views that the mainstream media reflect the bias inherent in their ownership by giant corporations whose goals align with those of the right.** But despite uncovering disappointing behaviors on the part of politicians and various institutions over the years, Moyers was fundamentally an idealist.

* The moral conviction was certainly there in spades, but so were the blemishes:

● “Bill Moyers [asked] the FBI to investigate two men who were ‘suspected as having homosexual tendencies.’”

● “Whatever happened to Bill Moyers’s promise to disclose conflicts of interest?”

● “After 30 years of railing for separation of church and state, Bill Moyers comes to the aid of the Rev. Jeremiah Wright.”

** Comcast, Disney, CNN, and CBS could not be reached for comment.

THEY WEREN’T EXACTLY PEACE LOVING BEFORE IT: Left-Wingers Enter New Depths of Rage Over Supreme Court’s Nationwide Injunction Ruling.

As RedState reported, the Trump administration scored a major victory on Friday after the Supreme Court ruled that district court-level nationwide injunctions exceeded judicial authority. That will throw a wrench into the left-wing strategy of seeking universal relief in a select few left-wing jurisdictions across the country and hopefully return some actual balance to the separation of powers within the U.S. government.

Of course, while the decision was a victory for common sense and for voters who would prefer judges not overstep their bounds to essentially operate as president, it was a defeat for Democrats who have relied on that abuse to remain in power even when they lose. On MSNBC, Melissa Murray melted down, claiming the Supreme Court had “dealt a death blow to the rule of law.”

Similarly, Democrat strategist Julie Roginsky is having flashbacks to Randi Weingarten’s muddled “No Kings” rally earlier this month:

Which seems strange, because at the start of Obama’s first and third term, leftists went beyond thinking of Obama as a king. In 2009, Newsweek’s Evan Thomas declared that Obama was “Sort of God,” and in 2021, anticipating who would be running the country again, far left Jacobin magazine published a similarly-themed cover:

Speaking of three terms, people once warned about that sort of thing, before Democrats rolled right past that guardrail:

RIP: Lalo Schifrin, Acclaimed Composer of Mission: Impossible and Mannix Themes, Dies at 93.

His résumé also included work on Coogan’s Bluff (1968) — that kicked off his long association with Eastwood and director Don Siegel — Kelly’s Heroes (1970), Charley Varrick (1973), The Eagle Has Landed (1976), Telefon (1977), The Nude Bomb (1980), Black Moon Rising (1986), Money Talks (1997), Something to Believe In (1998), Tango (1998), Bringing Down the House (2003) and The Bridge of San Luis Rey (2004).

His cool, percolating Mission: Impossible theme, set to an unusual 5/4 time signature and commissioned for the fabled CBS espionage drama that bowed in September 1966, netted Schifrin one of his four Grammy Awards and one of his four Emmy noms. It still serves as a vital link to the Tom Cruise movie franchise.

Schifrin said it took him just three minutes to put the theme together, and he composed it without seeing any footage from the show.

“Orchestration’s not the problem for me,” he told the New York Post in 2015. “It’s like writing a letter. When you write a letter, you don’t have to think what grammar or what syntaxes you’re going to use, you just write a letter. And that’s the way it came.

“Bruce Geller, who was the producer of the series, put together the pilot and came to me and said, ‘I want you to write something exciting, something that when people are in the living room and go into the kitchen to have a soft drink, and they hear it, they will know what it is. I want it to be identifiable, recognizable and a signature.’ And this is what I did.”

Brilliant and versatile composer who could work in many different styles depending upon what film or TV series required.

QED:

And:

ANDREW SULLIVAN: Trans Extremism is Backfiring on Gay People.

As Sullivan sees it, the fight for gay marriage had always been one that emphasized this was a change for consenting adults which wouldn’t change how the nuclear family worked for straight people. They could still get married and raise their kids whether the gay couple down the street were married or just living together. The argument from the pro gay marriage side was this changes things for us but not for you. And obviously that worked. It worked not just in court but it worked in the greater population. As noted above, opposition to gay marriage became a minority position even in the Republican Party. But the trans rights movement completely undoes that tacit cultural agreement.

In the gay rights movement, there had always been an unspoken golden rule: Leave children out of it. We knew very well that any overreach there could provoke the most ancient blood libel against us: that we groom and abuse kids. You can bring up your children however you like, we promised. We will leave you alone. We will leave your children alone.

So what did the gender revolutionaries go and do? They focused almost entirely on children and minors. Partly because the adult issues had been resolved or close to it, and partly because true cultural revolutions start with the young, it meant overhauling the education not only of children with gender dysphoria, but of every other kid as well.

Kids all over the country were impacted. Your children were taught in elementary school that being a boy or a girl was something they could choose and change at will. Your daughter found herself running against a trans girl (i.e. a biological male) in athletics. Children in elementary school got to pick pronouns, and some children socially transitioned at school without their parents’ knowledge or permission…

Soon enough, the right began associating what used to be the lesbian and gay movement with this gender extremism, and the L.G.B.T.Q.+ movement responded not by moderating tone or substance, but by closing ranks, seemingly determined to prove its point.

Indeed:

HOW IT STARTED:

How it’s going:

More here: City-run grocery stores, defunding police, safe injection sites: What to know about NYC’s next potential mayor.

Related: Cheerful Boxing Day wishes from Mamdani!

DRILL, BABY DRILL! Trump Touts Cheapest Summer Gas Prices Since 2021.

President Donald Trump’s White House proudly announced Friday that America has the lowest summer gas prices in four years, since the first summer after Joe Biden took office.

In a White House press release, the Trump administration noted that even leftist mainstream media has acknowledged the positive trend in gas prices. The Trump administration has prioritized oil and gas drilling to boost our energy independence since January, and it is already paying off.

The press release announced, “Americans are seeing the cheapest summertime gas prices since 2021 — more than 20 cents lower than one year ago — as President Donald J. Trump delivers on his promises of lower prices, stable inflation, and higher wages.”

MSM, Barack Obama during his three terms, hardest hit.

WE NEED A COMPLETE AND TOTAL SHUTDOWN OF THE WASHINGTON POST UNTIL WE CAN FIND JUST WHAT THE HELL IS GOING ON THERE: Washington Post journalist busted by DC US Attorney Jeanine Pirro for allegedly possessing child porn.

A Pulitzer Prize-winning Washington Post journalist was arrested and charged after authorities allegedly discovered child porn on his work computer, DC US Attorney Jeanine Pirro announced Friday.

Thomas Pham LeGro, a 48-year-old video editor at the news outlet, was taken into custody on Thursday after FBI agents raided his Washington, DC, home and discovered a folder on his work laptop which contained 11 videos depicting child sexual abuse material, according to Pirro’s office.

FBI agents also discovered “fractured pieces of a hard drive in the hallway outside the room where LeGro’s work laptop was found,” during the execution of the search warrant.

Legro made his first appearance in District Court of Washington, DC, on Friday and has a detention hearing scheduled for next Wednesday.

Related: Pulitzer-Winning WaPo Reporter Charged With Alleged Possession Of Child Porn. “By 2018, LeGro and the staff had won a Pulitzer Prize for ‘purposeful and relentless reporting that changed the course of a Senate race in Alabama,’ exposing Roy Moore’s alleged sexual harassment of underage girls in 2017 while he was the GOP nominee for Senate.”

HEGSETH UNVEILS NEW NAME OF USNS HARVEY MILK:

The US Navy has officially changed the name of its ship honoring slain gay-rights icon Harvey Milk to the USNS Oscar V. Peterson in commemoration of the WWII Medal of Honor recipient.

“We are taking the politics out of ship naming. We’re not renaming the ship to anything political,” Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth said in a video address. “This is not about political activists, unlike the previous administration.

“Instead, we’re renaming the ship after a United States Navy Congressional Medal of Honor recipient — as it should be,” he said. “People want to be proud of the ship they’re sailing in, and so we’re renaming it after a Navy chief.”

The USNS Oscar V. Peterson is a replenishment oiler that provides support to carrier strike groups at sea.

Okay, yes, yes, he was a Canadian, but what a brilliant virtuoso on the piano:

WE MUST RECLAIM THE WORD ‘PROGRESSIVE:’

I’ve grown tired of hearing the term progressive used to describe people and policies that embody anything but progress. The word suggests a movement toward liberty, reason and human dignity. But what now passes for “progressive” ideology is a regressive assault on foundational principles: race-based social engineering, denial of biological truth, hostility toward the rule of law and an obsession with censorship disguised as compassion.

Progress gave us the abolition of slavery, universal suffrage, constitutional government and equal protection under the law. It was built on Enlightenment ideals – reason, open inquiry and the primacy of the individual over tribe. The ideologues now claiming the label have rejected those very foundations. They call for defunding police, institutionalizing racial favoritism, redefining sex as a matter of feeling and punishing speech that deviates from their ever-shifting orthodoxy.

Let’s be clear: this is not a progressive left, and it’s time to retire that label altogether. What we’re dealing with is a movement of Neo-Jacobin ideologues – absolutists who don’t seek reform, but reeducation. Like their namesakes from the French Revolution, they speak the language of justice while enforcing ideological purity through coercion and public shaming.

As Calvin Coolidge said on the 150th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence:

About the Declaration there is a finality that is exceedingly restful. It is often asserted that the world has made a great deal of progress since 1776, that we have had new thoughts and new experiences which have given us a great advance over the people of that day, and that we may therefore very well discard their conclusions for something more modern. But that reasoning can not be applied to this great charter. If all men are created equal, that is final. If they are endowed with inalienable rights, that is final. If governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed, that is final. No advance, no progress can be made beyond these propositions. If anyone wishes to deny their truth or their soundness, the only direction in which he can proceed historically is not forward, but backward toward the time when there was no equality, no rights of the individual, no rule of the people. Those who wish to proceed in that direction can not lay claim to progress. They are reactionary. Their ideas are not more modern, but more ancient, than those of the Revolutionary fathers.

It was also during the 1920s, as the late Fred Siegel wrote in his 2014 book The Revolt Against the Masses, that “Progressivism” stole a huge base from laissez faire classical liberals and rebranded as “liberalism,” after the brutal, racist Woodrow Wilson had made such a hash of the P-word during WWI:

For the ardent Progressive Frederick Howe, who had been Wilson’s Commissioner of Immigration, the pre-war promise of the benign state built on reasoned reform had turned to ashes. “I hated,” he wrote, “the new state that had arisen” from the war. “I hated its brutalities, its ignorance, its unpatriotic patriotism that made profit from our sacrifices and used it to suppress criticism of its acts. . . . I wanted to protest against the destruction of my government, my democracy, my America.” As part of his protest, the thoroughly alienated Howe distanced himself from Progressivism. Liberals were those Progressives who had renamed themselves so as to repudiate Wilson. “The word liberalism,” wrote Walter Lippmann in 1919, “was introduced into the jargon of American politics by that group who were Progressives in 1912 and Wilson Democrats from 1916 to 1918.” The new liberalism was a decisive cultural break with Wilson and Progressivism. While the Progressives had been inspired by a faith in democratic reforms as a salve for the wounds of both industrial civilization and power politics, liberals saw the American democratic ethos as a danger to freedom at home and abroad.

Having spent the 20th century running roughshod over the traditional definition of liberalism, and with progressivism now becoming increasingly tainted, it’s entirely possible that the left may rebrand once again, just as they did a century ago.