RUY TEIXEIRA: Big-Tent Politics Wonât Save the Democrats. As Teixeira writes, âvoters know whose tent it is, even if a few heterodox guests are allowed inside:â
A recent New York Times conversation between columnist and âabundanceâ advocate Ezra Klein and progressive author Ta-Nehisi Coates illustrates the problem. Klein, a proponent of big-tent politics, tried to persuade Coates of its necessity. â[A] huge amount of the country, a majority of the country,â Klein said, âbelieves things about trans people. . . that we would see as fundamentally and morally wrong. . . . What politically. . . should our relationship with those people be?â
Coates, unsurprisingly, rejected the premise. As far as he was concerned, those people were on the other side of a moral line: âIf you think it is okay to dehumanize people,â he said, âthen conversation between you and me is probably not possible.â
Of course, Coates has no problem dehumanizing people himself: The Toxic World-View of Ta-Nehisi Coates.
His monstrous passage about 9/11 is a good summation of where heâs coming from. He writes of the police and firefighters who died running into the burning buildings in a forlorn effort to save all the people whose bodies were about to be obliterated into dust, âThey were not human to me. Black, white, or whatever, they were menaces of nature; they were the fire, the comet, the storm, which could â with no justification â shatter my body.â
More from Teixeira:
But the telling detail is in Kleinâs own phrasing. He described dissenters from progressive orthodoxy as âfundamentally and morally wrong.â His version of the big tent, then, is that some Democrats, particularly those in conservative areas, should be permitted to adopt wrong and immoral positions for the sake of expediency. But the positions of the party on those issues will and should remain the same. You can come into the tent, but the left will still run the show.
That wonât work. Advocates of the big tent must face the facts: The partyâs many unpopular and unworkable positionsâon everything from energy to identity politicsâhave to genuinely change if Democrats hope to win back skeptical voters. Simply holding their noses and letting a few candidates deviate from orthodoxy wonât work.
Take immigration. Democrats have had little to say about Trumpâs successful efforts to close the southern border, but much to say about his deportation measures, which they see as cruel and immoral. That, as Josh Barro notes, doesnât add up to a change in party position. To win back votersâ trust, he argues, the Democrats âmust acknowledge that the Biden administrationâs policy of laxity was a failure,â and put forward better enforcement measures of their own. He adds: âIf Democrats are only seen talking about how the government is doing too much enforcement, weâll be seen as the anti-enforcement party, and thatâs politically deadly.â
And that is precisely whatâs happening. The party increasingly looks like the anti-enforcement party that doesnât want to deport anyone. And that image means that a Democrat running in a conservative area can try to carve out a tough-on-illegal-immigration profile, butâeven assuming the activists leave him or her aloneâthe partyâs overall stance on immigration enforcement will mostly negate any benefit from the candidateâs heterodox position.
Thatâs because Biden administrationâs âpolicy of laxityâ wasnât a failure, it was a strategy, and voters knew it:
â Jared Bernstein, member of Bidenâs Council of Economic Advisors: âOne thing we learned in the 1990s was that a surefire way to reconnect the fortunes of working people at all skill levels, immigrant and native-born alike, to the growing economy is to let the job market tighten up. A tight job market pressures employers to boost wage offers to get and keep the workers they need. One equally surefire way to sort-circuit this useful dynamic is to turn on the immigrant spigot every time some groupâs wages go up.â
â Trump administration senior adviser Stephen Miller in February of 2021: Bidenâs Immigration Plan Would âErase Americaâs Nationhood.â
â âLabour wanted mass immigration to make UK more multicultural, says former adviser. Labour threw open Britainâs borders to mass immigration to help socially engineer a âtruly multiculturalâ country, a former Government adviser has revealed.â
â Tom Cottonâs Response to Kamala Harrisâ Border Failures Should Be the Default for All Republicans: ââYou know, Laura, Kamala Harris didnât have to go all the way to Guatemala and Mexico to find the root causes of this border crisis because theyâre not there,â Cotton told Fox News host Laura Ingraham [in June of 2021]. âThe root causes are in the White House.â He further explained that it âhappened on January 20th when Joe Biden took office, and he essentially opened our borders, reversing very effective policies that had our borders under control.ââ
Speaking of Kamala and immigration, the Biden “Politburo’s” border stance made the Bulwark rather cross last November: