Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

VIRGINIA POSTREL RESPONDS TO MY POST ON SYNTHETIC MEAT: I don’t really see us as being as far apart as it sounds though, and I’m glad to see her picking up on the importance of institutional trust if you want to promote a dynamic society. As for whether I’ve gone from “dynamist” to “80% culture warrior,” I’d say that I’ve decided that our current culture is increasingly hostile to dynamism, and that trend must be fought. I believe Elon Musk has come to the same conclusion. We could both be wrong of course, but are we?

SIX MONTHS OF DRIVING a Rivian electric pickup. The Insta-Wife and I saw one in the wild yesterday, stopped next to us at a red light on Kingston Pike. She really liked the way it looked.

AWFUL NEWS: Longtime blogger and friend Gerard van der Leun has entered into hospice care.

Here we are the last time I saw him in the flesh, at the wrap party for the OG PJ Media a bit over three years ago.

We sold the website, but we kept the Orb Of Power.

THE FBI IS LOOKING INCREASINGLY SHADY: Ex ‘top FBI agent’ who investigated Trump for ties to Russia arrested over alleged ties to Russia. “An FBI agent who investigated the Donald Trump Russia collusion [claims] has been arrested for colluding with Russia. You can’t make this stuff up.”

Sadly, you don’t have to.

THIS IS MORONIC, SINCE “GUN VIOLENCE” IS MOSTLY A PHENOMENON OF GANGS IN SELECT DEMOCRAT-RULED CITIES: Pediatricians are giving out free gun locks to approach the gun violence epidemic as a public health crisis. And it’s a behavior problem, not a “public health” problem. Gun accidents involving children happen, but they’re a tiny fraction of the “violence” deaths, which gun locks do nothing about.

Given the public health and medical professions’ patent incompetence in dealing with actual epidemics, let’s take a pass on giving them a role in addressing things outside their limited professional competence. Though I suppose handing out useless-but-harmless gun locks is better than normal by recent standards.

SOME USEFUL THOUGHTS ON UKRAINE AND RUSSIA FROM JOSHUA TREVIÑO. I think this is paywalled, but here’s the meat:

Russian defeat in Ukraine is one thing, and very much in the American interest, but it does not follow from this that the strident maximalism of the dedicated anti-Russians is at all an obvious good. To pick one example, have a look at this piece from “queer Ukrainian journalist” Maksym Eristavi, arguing for a fully “[p]artitioned, disarmed, and decolonized Russia” as the sole plausible and desirable strategic endstate for the war.

This is definitionally extremist, but not particularly unusual — and many of the people endorsing it are adjacent to the American center-left “thought leadership” crowd who reliably end up publishing at The Atlantic, Foreign Policy, and so on. It gains purchase for a couple of reasons. One is the the thesis advanced by Richard Hanania that their views on Russia are almost entirely a subset and product of their views on sexual politics. This is probably correct. The other is simple ignorance, amplified by a pervasive inability to think about strategic affairs in any coherent manner.

The reality is that a maximalist end to the war — defined in Eristavi’s terms — is profoundly undesirable to the United States. We’ve been in this situation before, which is not to say we’ve learned from it: it was American insistence that guaranteed the dissolution of the old Habsburg realms after 1918, which is almost universally regarded in retrospect as a long-term strategic error. Fostering the collapse of a unifying state in east-central Europe meant that region’s transformation into a generator of far worse catastrophes than imagined at that collapse. The same would be true of a partitioned Russia, which would effectively see the Eurasian steppe returned to the status quo ante of more than four centuries past — not just a periodic mechanism of erupting violence, but also likely prey to a powerful China. This seems opaque to those whose historical horizons extend perhaps twenty minutes into the past, but the course of human events is insensible to that deficiency.

As we’ve mentioned here at Armas many times, the post-1991 rollback of Russia’s western frontier by nearly three centuries was a great victory, no less than what that polity earned, and deserves to be defended. But we cannot lose sight of the big picture. There will be a Russia when all this is done — and it will look mostly like the Russia we have now. There is no loss in it, and it is not a thing to be regretted. The talk of “partition” now is fantastical and deranged, yes, but its danger is not in the threat that it might happen. It won’t. The danger is in the threat that a Western policymaker might think it will — and act as if it were so.

Well, of course, it also raises the stakes for Putin, et al., and makes some catastrophic action on their part far more likely.

Drastically weakening Russian, and displaying to China that the West and its allies aren’t the pushovers some of its generals have been claiming, is worthwhile. Turning a substantial portion of the planet’s dry-land surface into a bunch of warring failed states is not.

INSURRECTION! Democratic Congresswoman Katherine Clark’s daughter accused of assaulting Boston police officer at protest.

Congresswoman Katherine Clark’s daughter is accused of assaulting a Boston police officer who was trying to arrest her after she allegedly defaced the Boston Common bandstand Saturday night, according to police.

Before the arrest, 23-year-old Jared “Riley” Dowell from Melrose had been seen defacing the Boston Common monument with spray paint, according to police. The tagging read “NO COP CITY” and “ACAB” (All Cops Are Ba******).

Somebody tell her it’s not 2020 anymore.

WHAT HATH TRANS POLITICS WROUGHT? “It’s politically weird to be a very liberal Democrat and find yourself shoved in bed with, like, the governor of Texas. Am I supposed to listen to Tucker Carlson?”

Maybe if you had, we wouldn’t be in this mess.

Plus:

I’ve been a teacher for quite a while. Teaching has always been loosely aligned with liberal values, but I never felt like I was part of an explicit political organization until the last few years. The zeal with which school systems have pursued and advocated for left-wing identity politics no longer feels like being “supportive,” it feels like we’re being persuasive: join us, children, as we dismantle the evil systems (systemic racism! the patriarchy! the gender binary!) that your parents have wrought.

It’s frankly a little bit creepy and cultish at times, and it needs to stop.”

Good luck with that. They literally can’t stop, because woke politics is not just cultish, it’s basically a cult.

DON SURBER: So Irrelevant They Won’t Stop Talking About Him. “Paul Ryan is peddling a new book. To gain attention, he had to declare Trump is finished — again. . . . Calling Trump old news was how Ryan got in the news. He is not the only one working that scam.”

Paul Ryan calling any politician washed up is rich.

SELF-DEFENSE EXPERT ANDREW BRANCA: Manslaughter Charge Against Alec Baldwin in Shooting Death of Halyna Hutchins Fits The Known Facts. “I see a lot of hand-wringing attempting to assign blame for this tragedy to, it seems, everybody other than Baldwin. Frankly, the intensity of these efforts suggests to me that they are part of an orchestrated crisis management initiative put into play on Baldwin’s behalf—and that’s a smart move by Baldwin, if in fact that’s what he’s done. It’s why such crisis management firms exist.”

HIGHLY PLAUSIBLE: Fact Check: Quincy Institute Says DC Think Tanks Have Too Many Foreign Conflicts of Interest. But the usual pot, kettle thing applies:

Why it matters: Clifton was criticizing the Atlantic Council, a think tank that came under fire this week following a Washington Free Beacon report that its president published a glowing CNBC op-ed about the United Arab Emirates without disclosing that the group had taken millions from the Gulf monarchy.

After the Free Beacon reached out to the Atlantic Council, CNBC added a lengthy editor’s note to the story that noted the “obvious conflict of interest.” The Atlantic Council, meanwhile, added notes to its other stories about the UAE and acknowledged its failure to properly disclose the UAE donations in other stories on its website.

Context: Since forming in 2019, the Quincy Institute has been marred by a series of conflicts of interest involving scholars linked to foreign governments. Its cofounder is Trita Parsi, a pro-Iran activist accused of serving as a foreign agent of Tehran.

The European Parliament last year suspended Quincy contributor Eldar Mamedov over his undisclosed lobbying for Morocco and Qatar. Mamedov, who advised the European Parliament, has authored more than 50 articles for Quincy, none of which disclose his foreign influence work.

Amir Handjani, a non-resident scholar at Quincy, has been linked to a spy operation targeting critics of Sheikh Saud bin Saqr al Qasimi, the authoritarian ruler of Ras Al Khaimah, one of the seven kingdoms of the United Arab Emirates. Handjani has served as a fellow at the Atlantic Council as well.

Analysis: It’s true that the Atlantic Council shills for Turkey and once took donations from a shady Ukrainian energy firm linked to Hunter Biden. But the Quincy Institute has its fair share of foreign conflicts of interest, too.

As the old saying goes, those who live in corrupt houses shouldn’t throw around accusations of financial impropriety. Sure, Quincy’s claim about “Washington-based think tanks” may be true, but the institute glosses over the fact that its scholars are covered in just as much muck as the influence-peddlers at the Atlantic Council.

Maybe they’re basically all crooks.

WHY DO LEFTIST EDUCRATS HATE ASIANS SO MUCH? 17 Northern Virginia Schools Withheld Merit Awards From Mostly Asian Students As Gov Calls For Legislation. “About 75% of semifinalists for the National Merit award that were not notified were Asian students, the Fairfax County Times reported.”

Can I call ’em, or can I call ’em?. To be fair, it was an easy prediction.

UPDATE: From the comments: “Are we supposed to believe that 17 schools decided upon this course of action independently? It was obviously coordinated from a central entity. What is that central entity?”

NO, THE ONES AIMED AT DEMOCRATS ARE FAKE: Not all special counsel investigations are created equally.

Special counsels Robert Hur and Jack Smith have been tasked with investigating President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump, respectively, for their mishandling of classified documents.

Although the Nov. 2 discovery of Biden’s first batch of classified documents had not been publicly reported when the Trump special counsel was announced on Nov. 18, the Department of Justice had been briefed. So Attorney General Merrick Garland knew then that if he appointed a special counsel to investigate Trump, he would be pressured into appointing one for Biden when the news eventually broke. Considering he’d already taken the extraordinary step of ordering an FBI raid on Mar-a-Lago to retrieve “sensitive” material, his failure to appoint a Biden special counsel for the same offense would have been impossible to defend.

However, we’re quickly learning that not all special counsel investigations are created equally. The differences between these two investigations could not be more glaring.

By tailoring the scopes of the two special counsels to serve the DOJ’s purposes, Garland accomplished three objectives: he satisfied public calls for equal treatment under the law, he minimized Biden’s potential legal jeopardy, and he provided the DOJ with a ready excuse to withhold document requests from House GOP lawmakers.

Compared to the wide scope of the Trump special counsel investigation, the scope of the Biden investigation is far narrower. Robert Hur is tasked with investigating the “possible unauthorized removal and retention” of the classified documents found at the Penn Biden Center and his Delaware residence. And although Hunter Biden had unfettered access to at least one of these locations and is alleged to have engaged in a lucrative influence peddling scheme from which his father, the “big guy,” may have benefited financially, he is not mentioned in the appointment letter, and thus remains out of the special counsel’s reach.

On the other hand, Jack Smith is authorized to investigate Trump’s “efforts to interfere with the lawful transfer of power” and the “certification of the Electoral College vote,” the classified documents that were held at Mar-a-Lago, his potential obstruction of the government’s efforts to retrieve the documents, and any matters that arise directly from the investigation. Obstruction of justice will be the likely focus of this special counsel.

In addition to the disparity between the scopes of the two special counsels, there are Grand Canyon-sized differences in the DOJ’s treatment of the cases.

That’s because the DOJ is a bunch of political hacks and hit men, presided over by Chief Hack Merrick Garland.

A SMALL MEASURE OF ACCOUNTABILITY: Alumni lawsuit against Yale over trustee petition ballot ban moves forward.

Plaintiffs Victor H. Ashe, who has served as an ambassador to Poland as well as a state legislator and mayor in Tennessee, and Donald G. Glascoff, Jr., retired chair and co-partner of one of Wall Street’s oldest firms, filed the lawsuit alleging that Yale’s governing body “is engaging in the most obvious form of voter suppression and denial of rights of free expression of opinion,” according to the court complaint.

The President and Fellows of Yale consists of 19 trustees, six of whom are alumni trustees elected by Yale alumni. The corporation also includes the Connecticut governor and lieutenant governor as ex officio members. The Connecticut General Assembly in 1872, established that six trustee seats should be held by alumni who were voted on by eligible alumni.

Since 1929, Yale has had two paths by which alumni could be nominated and receive a vote for the alumni trustee position – nomination by a committee consisting of Yale Alumni Association board members and officials, or by petitioning for and receiving at least 4,397 Yale alumni signatures.

Ashe petitioned for and received over 7,000 signatures to get on the ballot for an alumni trustee position in 2021, campaigning to make Yale more transparent and highlighting that Corporation meeting minutes are embargoed for 50 years. Ashe eventually lost out to David A. Thomas President of Morehouse College in Atlanta, who was nominated by the committee.

Reached for comment, Ashe says he has no problem with losing the election. His concern in filing this lawsuit is the elimination of the petition process and creating a secretive, insular process limited only to insiders.

Connecticut should amend Yale’s charter to require more open procedures, in the public interest.

POST-CPR TRAUMA IS REAL:

Nothing really prepares you for CPR, even if you’re certified. Compressions on a mannequin pale in comparison to pressing on the chest of a person who was walking and breathing moments ago, and suddenly stops. Real-life CPR is not light and glamorous like the movies may portray it. It’s exhausting and forceful, violent even — enough to break ribsopens in a new tab or window. The first time I did CPR, on a frail, elderly man who’d collapsed in the street, his chest gave way with a cracking sound that made me sick. Performing CPR is gut-wrenching and terrifying, and witnessing it is no better.

Dealing with human bodies that are in trouble is often messy and disgusting.