Author Archive: Gail Heriot

STILL TRYING TO SHUT THEM DOWN:  In both New Mexico and California, efforts to shut down immigration detention facilities are on-going.  Honestly, I’ve toured three of these facilities in my capacity as a civil rights commissioner. They weren’t half bad.  One of them was really quite nice—so nice my progressive colleagues were a bit stunned.  It was amusing to watch the looks on their faces as the guide was showing us around.  They were so sure they were going to be shown hellholes.

LAWS OF SUPPLY AND DEMAND:  The subminimum wage gives the severely disabled a chance to have a job and feel productive. Their parents and siblings know that.  That’s why they supported it so strongly when the issue was brought before the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights.  It’s less clear who is behind its repeal.  But there is a whole lot of effort behind that repeal.  One thing is for certain, if you repeal it, a whole lot of Down syndrome adults with jobs will end up jobless.

MAYBE I’M HANGING OUT WITH WRONG KIND OF GUY: But I’m pretty sure I’m right about their reactions.

DEFUND THE LEFT:  “Stanford student senate allocates thousands of dollars to fund Matt Walsh protesters.”  Seriously, a lot of problems could be eliminated if only colleges and universities weren’t so rich.  If you give these folks a nickel of your money, you’re making a huge mistake.  And if red state legislatures don’t start whacking state university budgets, they are making an even bigger mistake.  All conservatives and libertarians should wake up every morning thinking about new ways to defund the left in large and small ways.

LOOKS PRETTY BAD:  More ghastly news about teachers’ unions..  (Note that if you click through you can follow me on Twitter.  Now that Musk is there, I’m getting to like it there.)

I CAN’T SAY I’M SMILING:  Amazon is terminating its Amazon Smile program whereby customers can direct a tiny portion of the money they spend at Amazon to the charity of their choice.  Amazon says it wants to concentrate its money on programs with greater impact.  That’s its right, of course.  But I fear the translation should go something like this:  We’re not that keen on the charities that our customers choose.

Amazon’s policy of deferring to the execrable Southern Poverty Law Center on the question of which charities are really hate groups is well known.  For example, the company excludes the Alliance Defending Freedom from the Amazon Smile program on that basis.  Now it won’t have to try to justify that exclusion.  It can direct its contributions to the groups it really likes and not worry about its customers’ preferences.

UGH:  Jason Riley reports that according to an annual survey of school leaders “schools saw a 56% increase in ‘classroom disruptions from student misconduct’ compared with a typical school year before the pandemic.”

Instapundit readers know what I think about about all this.

JOHN B. DAUKAS:  “It’s time for a bright-line ruling that discrimination is unlawful.”

Yes, indeed it is.  The statute has been saying that all along.  In 1978, Justice Lewis Powell, out of timidity, set us on the wrong path.  It’s time to get back on the right path.  Nothing less than that will be effective.

One of my favorite Supreme Court quotes comes from Wilkerson v. McCarthy (1949):  “A timid judge, like a biased judge, is intrinsically a lawless judge.”

WILLIAM S. CONSOVOY, RIP:  Will Consovoy, a lawyer’s lawyer, has died at the age of 48.  This is huge loss for the conservative movement.  Will’s death was not unexpected.  But I was hoping he would survive long enough to see the fruits of his labors in the Harvard/UNC cases currently pending before the Supreme Court.

REST IN PEACE, MR. JOHNSON:  Now and then, an author comes along who really changes your life.  Paul Johnson was one of those for me.  I carried around Modern Times, A History of the Jews, and A History of Christianity with me in the 1980s.  Johnson could be both the erudite historian and the combative polemicist.  He was never boring.

The revised version of Johnson’s A History of the American People contains a paragraph on California’s Proposition 209.  You wouldn’t believe how thrilled I was when I saw it.  (Look, Ma!  I made the history book!  No, not by name, but by the name of my project ….)

 

TRANSGENDER WARS:  The 11th Circuit and the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Western Virginia have both recently issued decisions on transgender issues that are consistent with the law instead of consistent with what fashionable people would like the law to be.  And there are a couple of other cases pending in federal court.  If there is a cert petition in the 11th Circuit case or an appeal in the Southern District of West Virginia case, the American Civil Rights Project will likely be filing an amicus curiae brief based on the argument contained in Pete Kirsanow and my comment.

SUPREME COURT:  These days I wake up every morning wondering when we’ll hear from the Supreme Court in the Harvard/UNC cases.  Most likely it won’t be till June, but you never know.  In the meantime, here’s a reminder of one of the most powerful policy (non-legal) arguments against race-preferential admissions policies.

MERRY CHRISTMAS, JAY:  You da man.  Thanks for saving two dozen lives during the Buffalo snowstorm.  As a torts professor, I can tell you that you committed no legal wrong by breaking into a school during an emergency (Ploof v. Putnam), but that (technically at least) the school can force you to pay for any damage you caused (Vincent v. Lake Erie Transportation Co.). But don’t worry, they won’t.  Today, they love you.  (And if they do try to make you pay, I’ll cover it.)

THIS CAN BE FIXED:  The ABA is trying to strong arm Hofstra University’s law school into hiring faculty by race and sex.  The same thing is happening here at the University of San Diego.  The Supreme Court won’t be able to stop this kind of overreach just by issuing a strong opinion in the Harvard and UNC cases.  But in the future Congress can stop it.

(By the way, dear readers, if you know of other cases, in the last ten years or so, of accreditors attempting to dictate diversity to the schools they accredit, please let me know.  I am trying to collect that information.)