I don’t see why unelected administrators should get to decide what a university’s “values” are, much less impose them on anyone.
Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds
June 24, 2022
HOW’S THAT SPACE PROGRAM COMING ALONG? Arecibo observatory scientists help unravel surprise asteroid mystery.
JEFFREY CARTER: Citadel Moves to Miami.
WHENEVER I HEAR THE WORDS “PLANT-BASED” I GROW SUSPICIOUS: Chicken bests plant-based meat alternative for protein intake, study suggests.
A FEW MORE THOUGHTS ON DOBBS: First, it’s a big win for the rule of law — by which I mean not so much the opinion as that the justices stood firm in the face of unprecedented threats ranging from Chuck Schumer’s “pay the price” language to mobs and an actual armed assassin showing up at their homes. A Supreme Court that can be bullied is a Supreme Court that will be bullied. Unlike Roberts’ flip in the ObamaCare case, the majority here held firm, which will discourage bullying in the future.
Second, the likely result is that a few states will ban abortion entirely, a few will permit it for the entire term, and for most it’ll look something like Europe, with abortion easy to get for the first 12 weeks or so, and much harder after that. (The Mississippi law in question here, which allows abortion for any reason through the 15th week, was actually more liberal than many, perhaps most, European laws).
States won’t be able to ban interstate travel for the purpose of getting an abortion because interstate travel is a separate constitutional right. Congress will not be able to guarantee a right to abortion because its 14th Amendment power to enforce the rights guaranteed by the 14th Amendment doesn’t apply to abortion, which the Court has found isn’t protected under the 14th Amendment. It will not be able to either protect abortion or ban it under its commerce power because abortion isn’t interstate commerce, and is a traditional subject of state regulation.
It’ll take a few years to shake out, but we’re likely to wind up with what we would have had by 1976 or so if Roe had never been decided — a spectrum of laws around the country that will be adjusted over time based on experience and the views of the electorate. Though, of course, the norm may be stricter than it would have been without Roe, which called into being a huge pro-life movement that probably wouldn’t have existed otherwise.
UPDATE: It’ll be interesting to see if this reduces the flow of immigrants from blue states to red. That’ll be a measure of how much people actually care. To be honest, I kinda hope it does slow the flow.
WHY DO ENVIRONMENTALISTS HATE SEQUOIAS? Bipartisan group defends sequoia tree bill in California despite opposition. “A bipartisan trio of lawmakers defended the ‘Save Our Sequoias Act’ on Thursday despite more than 80 environmental groups signing a letter to Congress opposing the act earlier this month. The bill introduced on Wednesday is aimed at expediting reforestation and protection efforts in California’s Sequoia National Forest.”
REDUCING THE SURPLUS POPULATION: Global Food Crisis ‘Will Kill Millions’ By Disease, Health Executive Warns.
The global food crisis sparked by the war in Ukraine will kill millions by leaving the hungriest more vulnerable to infectious diseases, potentially triggering the world’s next health catastrophe, the head of a major aid organisation has warned.
A Russian naval blockade of Ukraine’s Black Sea ports has stopped grain shipments from the world’s fourth-largest exporter of wheat and corn, raising the spectre of shortages and hunger in low-income countries.
The knock-on effects of the food shortages mean many will die not only of starvation but from having weaker defences against infectious diseases due to bad nutrition, Peter Sands, executive director of the Global Fund to Fight Aids, Tuberculosis and Malaria told AFP this week.
“I think we’ve probably already begun our next health crisis. It’s not a new pathogen but it means people who are poorly nourished will be more vulnerable to the existing diseases,” he said in an interview on the sidelines of a G20 health minister meeting in the Indonesian city of Yogyakarta.
“I think the combined impact of infectious diseases and the food shortages and the energy crisis… we can be talking about millions of extra deaths because of this,” he said.
Flashback: Looming food shortages is the next ‘slow-moving disaster’ to hit world.
SUPREME COURT RELEASING DOBBS OPINON RIGHT NOW, BY ALITO. Roberts concurs. Breyer, Sotomayor, and Kagan dissent. Roe and Casey are overruled.
Scotusblog is liveblogging the announcement.
The opinion is here. “Held: The Constitution does not confer a right to abortion; Roe and Casey are overruled; and the authority to regulate abortion is returned to the people and their elected representatives.”
Beware the “night of rage” in response.
And from Scotusblog: “Interesting, The majority uses very similar ‘history and tradition’ language that was used in the New York gun case, but this time finding there is no ‘history and tradition’ that grants a constitutional right to an abortion.” It’s hardly surprising that history and tradition might support things with a history and tradition, but not things without a history and tradition, so I don’t think that’s really very interesting. Nor is it contradictory, as this seems to imply. I’m not a big fan of the Scalia history and tradition approach, but it’s a well-laid-out methodology and one that a majority of the Court holds.
Note that the entire release, with opinion, concurrences, dissent is 213 pages, but talking heads are no doubt already speaking as if they’ve read it in its entirety.
She says she was fired for making an anonymous complaint when the surgeon figured out it was her. No such complaint was filed. She is being fired, though: “Additionally, Cargle has not been fired for the operating room allegation at Harbor-UCLA in unincorporated West Carson, but is facing termination for her conduct with a patient and staff at USC Medical Center near downtown L.A., DHS said, declining to elaborate.”
TRUST THE SCIENCE: NIH spent $500 million on research linked to faked results by former Harvard scientist. “The federal government poured over half a billion dollars into medical research based on fabricated results from a Harvard scientist, according to a recent Reuters report. The analysis published on Tuesday found that the U.S. National Institutes of Health spent at least $588 million on research related to Piero Anversa’s hypothesis that adult stem cells can regenerate heart tissue and cure heart disease. . . . Some of this money came after the federal government had been notified of problems with Anversa’s research. More than 40 percent of these funds were awarded after March 2013, after the federal government had been informed of allegations against Anversa.”
DAVID HARSANYI: The Supreme Court’s Decision Is a Huge Win for the Constitution. But there’s this:
The modern left doesn’t even bother pretending they believe the Supreme Court has a responsibility to act as a separate branch of government and adjudicate the constitutionality of law. Rather than even ostensibly offering legal reasons for their ire, Democrats simply demand the Supreme Court uphold public sentiment (or, rather what they claim is public sentiment), even though SCOTUS exists to ignore those pressures. The fact that that attitude has congealed as the norm in one of our major political parties does not bode well for the future of the Republic.
The left doesn’t value any institution except to the extent it advances the left’s goals of the moment. On the other hand, the traditional flaw of the right is that it respects institutions too much, regardless of whether they’re actually performing their assigned functions. The right, at least, seems to be learning.
MY OLD USA TODAY EDITOR DAVID MASTIO: USA Today demoted me for a tweet — because its woke newsrooms are out of touch with readers.
They really are. Plus: “I was demoted after I tweeted, ‘People who are pregnant are also women.’ . . . What I do worry about is that Gannett shareholders are being taken for a ride. Gannett’s story is that it is becoming the USA Today network in which newspapers in dozens of states will embrace diversity, reflect their communities and bubble up a uniquely accurate view of America that millions will pay for. But what if our journalism is written by people who look like America but sound like the Harvard English Department? What if we look like our communities but don’t think anything like them or share their values and priorities? Readers are bound to notice.”
Oh, they have, which is why my local Gannett paper has shrunk down to something more like the Thrifty Nickel.
And check out David’s new home at Straight Arrow News.
AS THE SUPREME COURT ADVANCES CIVIL RIGHTS, States with strict gun-permitting laws consider next steps. Cue “massive resistance” to the Court’s latest civil rights decision.
HIGHER EDUCATION BUBBLE UPDATE: Faculty Salaries Fall 5%, The Biggest One-Year Drop In History. And this is before the recession/depression got started.
BIG LAW FIRMS ARE MAKING A TERRIBLE DECISION IN CHOOSING CULTURE-WAR SIDES HERE: Former SG Paul Clement on Leaving Kirkland & Ellis After It Decided to Withdraw from Second Amendment Cases.
With things like this, and Jones, Day dropping its representation of Donald Trump under pressure ginned up by the Lincoln Project, big law firms are now morally responsible for whoever they do choose to represent. When they represented accused Al Qaeda terrorists, they moralized about how everyone deserves representation. But they clearly don’t believe that now.
If people choose to organize to get them fired by governments and institutions because of their politics or clients, they will only have themselves to blame.
In addition, dropping ongoing matters for political reasons verges on unethical.
THE DOJ IS JUST A POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE WITH LAWYERS AND GUNS NOWADAYS: Dems Lose Their Minds, DOJ Makes Concerning Statement on SCOTUS Gun Rights Decision. “NY Gov. Kathy Hochul didn’t take the decision well. Indeed, she said they would fight for even more restrictions, despite the Supreme Court’s decision. Hochul said that if the Court wanted to consider the original meaning of the Constitution, she was willing to go back to ‘muskets.’ She revealed not only how extreme she is, but how ignorant she is of the law.”
Well, she’s like Andrew Cuomo but dumber and less telegenic.
Plus: “The DOJ also issued a concerning statement, again not saying that they would uphold the decision but saying they ‘disagree.'”
When Democrats like what the Court does, it’s the supreme law of the land. When they don’t like it, it’s just, like, some court’s opinion, man.
THE RULING CLASS GETS THE UPWARD REDISTRIBUTION OF WEALTH IT WANTS: Joel Kotkin: Class is back: The global cost-of-living crisis has made obscene inequalities impossible to ignore.
June 23, 2022
JOHN HINDERAKER: Supreme Court Case Prompts Anti-Religious Bigotry.
SO APPARENTLY TODAY WAS JUSTICE THOMAS’S BIRTHDAY:


