Author Archive: Robert Shibley

CHATGPT CAN GET OFF MY LAWN. Should professors do anything differently when students can use ChatGPT to generate answers and essays? I have a suggestion: go back to handwritten, closed-note (and closed-device) bluebook exams. Exam problem solved. Papers are trickier, but I suspect making ChatGPT generate a 10- or 20-page paper that sounds believable is about as hard as writing the paper itself.

WAKE FOREST’S ADMISSIONS GAMBIT: Is replacing explicitly race-based affirmative action with “early action” that favors first-generation college students a workaround to that pesky Supreme Court? Wake wants to find out. Seems like a big risk that you might have to let in lots of the dreaded white people from Appalachia, though…

ACADEMIC CONFERENCES ARE A SCAM. “Rules preventing the display of book covers with images of bones.” At an anthropology conference. You will not be surprised that the author’s talk this year got canceled for being about gender, which is at this point par for the course.

REFORMING POST-TENURE REVIEW. I’ve seen it weaponized too often to be enthusiastic about post-tenure review, but ironclad academic freedom guarantees for all faculty, regardless of tenure, would go a long way towards addressing the concerns with the degrading of tenure protections.

‘WHITE LOGIC’ AND ‘JEW PHYSICS.’ I was hoping they’d at least give us a cool cyberpunk-style dystopia, but the totalitarians just keep doing the same boring and predictable stuff over and over again. We deserve a better class of authoritarians stamping on our faces forever.

NO, VANDERBILT ISN’T GOVERNED BY “PRINCIPLED NEUTRALITY.” But expect “strange new respect” for UChicago’s Kalven Report, which says that the university should not be taking sides on controversial issues, in the wake of Hamas’ atrocities. Such a position makes it harder to cheaply virtue signal in a 2020 riots-type situation, but becomes extremely convenient when you have hired lots of people with views such as “those dead babies had it coming, amirite?” Williams College is already on board. More colleges should join in. Yes, they will be doing it for the worst possible reasons, but those who are powerful but unaccountable rarely do things for any other reason.

N.C. PASSES LAW REQUIRING STATE UNIVERSITIES TO CHANGE ACCREDITORS. They can choose between any of the (formerly regional) accreditors, instead of having to use the unfortunately named “SACSCOC,” so there can be some competition, but they must change each decade so that some fresh eyes can see what the colleges are doing.

A different section of the same bill also requires porn websites to do age verification. As a parent of teenagers, I understand why folks push for this, but that’s probably unworkable, unconstitutional, and an especially bad idea in an age when the government is looking for any means to control information and who gets to see it.

THEY HAVE TO GET MONEY SOMEHOW. Colleges, under pressure (or mandates) not to raise tuition, raise “fees” instead. Including “fees” that are used to pay for faculty and administrators’ salaries. I have news: such money is “tuition,” regardless of its label.

20 YEARS OF ENORMOUS GROWTH IN SPENDING PER STUDENT IN NC UNIVERSITIES. Your state’s probably not much different. And we’re running headlong into a generation of people like me whose parents could afford tuition at a place like Duke at a stretch, but who can’t themselves afford it for their kids even though their lifestyle is otherwise about the same. More bad news for goodwill towards higher ed.

UGH. WAY TO GIVE THEM MORE IDEAS. “What can you do if the government declares you dead?” Basically nothing, and you can’t sue them thanks to sovereign immunity. Expect this to start happening to Trump supporters in about 10 seconds.

AUSTRALIA BANS BAD GRADES. “University students who score less than 50 percent in their exams will be entitled to a slew of educational life-savers. University-funded tutoring, counselling, examination do-overs, special exams, and extended deadlines… [A] hefty fine of $18,780 per student will be introduced for those institutions that fail to help their students rise above the 50 percent benchmark.”

NORTH CAROLINA’S MARTIN CENTER FOR ACADEMIC RENEWAL TURNS 20. A lot of progress has been made in NC higher ed thanks to their work, including making our state the national leader in campuses lacking speech codes. I’m proud to be on the board (though I can’t take any credit, that goes to the staff!).

FIFTH CIRCUIT TO UNIVERSITY TRUSTEES: YOU HAVE ACTUAL RESPONSIBILITIES. Professor Timothy Jackson wrote to the University of North Texas’ Board of Trustees asking for them to intervene and stop his persecution on bogus racism charges. They ignored him, and the state pled that the Board “had no direct connection with the specific acts of retaliation,” even though they had the power to stop it and failed to do so. Importantly, the Court didn’t buy this–and that’s good news. Maybe trustees who are accountable will finally start holding those below them accountable as well.

WHAT HAPPENS WHEN SCHOOLS ABANDON MERIT: A review of Heather Mac Donald’s new book, which contains nightmare fuel like this “gem” from a Julliard professor to a black student: “Have you practiced?” The student’s response: “I don’t have to. I’ll always have a job.”

ARE FACULTY REALLY ‘FLEEING THE SOUTH?’ Supposedly due in significant part to “generally conservative political climates in Florida, Texas, Georgia, and North Carolina.” I live in North Carolina. Colleges here aren’t notably conservative, and the governor is a Democrat. From experience at FIRE and in private practice, I can tell you that Texas colleges are frequently very liberal. So color me skeptical.

DOES TENURE MATTER FOR ACADEMIC FREEDOM? Mark McNeilly’s analysis of FIRE’s numbers shows that it does. But it should matter a lot more if it is to be worth the downsides.