Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

GOVERNMENT AS CREEPY STALKER: CDC Bought Harvested Phone Location Data to Track Covid Lockdown Compliance. “The CDC seems to have purposefully created an open-ended list of use cases, which included monitoring curfews, neighbor to neighbor visits, visits to churches, schools and pharmacies, and also a variety of analysis with this data specifically focused on ‘violence.’”

Maybe they’re so afraid of “violence” because in their hearts they think they deserve some. Or maybe because they’d respond to a Republican administration with violence.

BOB MCMANUS: It’s ridiculously hard to put people in jail in NYC. “Police say Edison Cruz of the Bronx has been trying hard to go to jail, which is not easy to do in New York City. He kept getting arrested and they kept letting him go and, so really, what’s an up-and-coming convict to do?”

Plus: “There is no hoarier cliché in the American conversation than ‘guns don’t kill, people do.’ But its depressing ubiquity doesn’t make it any less true. Thus, no gun-violence policy is going to succeed if it isn’t focused as squarely on criminals as it is on weapons.”

BOY, THE LEFTIES ARE TRASHING THE NOTORIOUS RBG NOW FOR NOT RETIRING SOONER, BUT THEY FORGET THIS: Supreme Court leak confirms Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s prescient warning about Roe v. Wade: Ginsburg firmly supported abortion, but she lamented the court’s decision to unilaterally create a new ‘regime’ on the subject.

Ginsburg warned against major judicial shifts in a 1992 lecture at New York University, citing Roe as an example.

“Measured motions seem to me right, in the main, for constitutional as well as common law adjudication,” she argued. “Doctrinal limbs too swiftly shaped, experience teaches, may prove unstable. The most prominent example in recent decades is Roe v. Wade.”

Ginsburg noted that Roe struck down far more than the specific Texas criminal abortion statute at issue in the case.

“Suppose the court had stopped there, rightly declaring unconstitutional the most extreme brand of law in the nation, and had not gone on, as the court did in Roe, to fashion a regime blanketing the subject, a set of rules that displaced virtually every state law then in force,” she said. “A less encompassing Roe, one that merely struck down the extreme Texas law and went no further on that day, I believe and will summarize why, might have served to reduce rather than to fuel controversy.” . . .

Ginsburg went on to contrast the court’s landmark decision in Roe with a slew of decisions from 1971 to 1982 in which the court struck down “a series of state and federal laws that differentiated explicitly on the basis of sex.”

Rather than creating a new philosophy of law and imposing it on the nation immediately, “the court, in effect, opened a dialogue with the political branches of government.”

“In essence, the court instructed Congress and state legislatures: rethink ancient positions on these questions,” Ginsburg noted. “The ball, one might say, was tossed by the justices back into the legislators’ court, where the political forces of the day could operate.”

I suspect that if things had been left to legislatures, we’d have something like what’s common in Europe, easy availability in the first 12 weeks, much more difficult after. By European standards, by the way, the Mississippi law in question in Dobbs, which allows abortion for any reason through week 15, isn’t extreme at all.

THE ATLANTIC: What Alito Got Right. “First, it’s important to understand the question before the Supreme Court. It is not ‘Should American women possess a right to abortion?’ but ‘Does the American Constitution protect abortion rights?’ The distinction is of paramount importance. The Court’s job is not to determine which rights we should possess but rather the rights we do possess.”

Sorry, literally shaking over the bigotry of asking if women should possess a right to abortion. It should be “birthing people” or “people with uteruses.” It’s Current Year, people!

ANDREW MCCARTHY: The Supreme Court’s integrity demands its leaker be prosecuted — and the decision released now.

It was entirely appropriate for the court to confirm that Justice Samuel Alito’s draft opinion in the Mississippi abortion case, Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health, is not at this point an authoritative ruling of the court. There could understandably be public confusion on that point, so it was incumbent on the court to clarify.

But there are unwelcome consequences to even appropriate actions. The obvious one here is that with the court having assured everyone that there is a draft opinion but it is not yet a final ruling, radicals prone to intimidation tactics know that now is the time to act.

Moreover, they have targets. Besides Alito, four conservative justices have been reported as members of a majority that favors overruling Roe v. Wade and Planned Parenthood v. Casey — Justices Clarence Thomas, Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett.

This is why the opinion must be formally issued forthwith. The viability of the court as a deliberative judicial institution is at stake. If the opinion or the vote tabulation were to change in any meaningful way, it would appear that the justices caved to intimidation tactics — which would simply breed more intimidation tactics. We’d have not the rule of law but the law of the jungle.

To be fair, that’s what the Democrats want. Or think that they do.

OPEN THREAD: This time, you’ll listen. You’re forgiven.

IT’S NOT WHAT YOU THINK, TIK-TIK! Yes, Those Are Dolphins With an Anaconda. There’s a Perfectly Good Explanation. Or maybe it is what you think: “Afterwards, we were able to observe on the photographs that the adult males were sexually aroused while engaging in object play with the anaconda.”

Takeaway: “I don’t think that the snake had a very good time.”