Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

ATTACHING A PRICE TO “MASSIVE RESISTANCE:” Should State Officials Receive Qualified Immunity for Creatively Resisting Bruen?

Most qualified immunity cases involve state actors engaged in legitimate policing, who make reasonable or negligent mistakes about the law. These mistakes, moreover, are often made by police in the heat of the moment, in difficult circumstances (e.g., while potentially under the threat of force). The Supreme Court has tried to shield officers from such liability for fear that it will chill them from vigorously performing their duties. In contrast, these states, through their combined regulations on sensitive places and private property, are intentionally trying to subvert Bruen’s specific holding. These policies, moreover, are not split-second judgments made in the heat of the moment; states have pursued these laws after extensive deliberation. The Supreme Court has never said that qualified immunity protects state actors who intentionally seek to violate a recognized constitutional right simply because the legal artifice they employ has not been the subject of a prior court decision.

I would abolish qualified immunity entirely. But in this case there’s certainly no “good faith” argument to be made.

THE PUBLIC HAS DIFFERENT PRIORITIES THAN ITS MASTERS: Most aren’t sold Martin Luther King Jr holiday is important.

Just 34% told the Rasmussen Reports survey team that it is “most important.” Another 13% called it the “least important” federal holiday. And the bulk, 48%, said its importance is “somewhere in between.”

But the results also suggested that how the nation feels about the importance of the day should not detract from how they view the man most famous for his nonviolent demonstrations for civil and black rights before he was assassinated in 1968.

The polling outfit said 83% of voters have a favorable opinion of King, including 50% who have a very favorable opinion.

And a growing number of people believe his call for unity and equal opportunity has been met.

Nonsense. If the problem has been fixed, who will sell us solutions? Or impose them.

GOOD: German police clear out environmental protesters including Greta Thunberg. “Of course it’s no secret why the Green party changed its tune on Lützerath as well as other issues. Russia has pulled the rug out from under the Germany economy by shutting off the gas supply last year. Germany has been forced to look for other supplies of energy which led to the Greens reversing course on nuclear energy and the expanded use of coal. In short, the Green party has accommodated reality and the protesters have not. . . . So the two year occupation ends in a total loss for the environmentalists who were betrayed by their own party.”

Like I said, good. They’re enemies of civilization.

THE DAVOS CROWD WON’T BE THE ONES EATING BUGS: Cozy Davos luncheon crowd includes Manchin, Sinema and…Coons? “That last name is a puzzler, let me tell you. He surely wasn’t invited for his intellectual heft. But he is gullible enough to eat the bugs if someone told him to.”

MY NEW YORK POST COLUMN: Get Woke, Go Broke: How Higher Ed’s Push for “Equity” is Backfiring, Hard. “Far be it from me to criticize hiring people based on their ability to do the job instead of the polish of their résumés, but this is a huge departure from the past, and it spells bad news for the people who’ve been selling the polish. If employees are no longer hired based on credentials, the market for credentials is going to head south.”

20 YEARS AGO: With Incessant Postings, a Pundit Stirs the Pot. It hasn’t changed all that much, although with various people constantly trying to get me fired from my day job, I’m somewhat more interested in making money. And my daughter has graduated beyond “Arthur’s Second Grade.”

OOPS: WaPo Columnist Says the Quiet Part Out Loud About Biden’s Classified Doc Scandal. “Joe Biden’s classified document scandal continues to rage, with legions of liberal pundits, legal scholars, and congressional Democrats making the most predictable and irrelevant excuses for why an aging, dementia-ridden old man can keep state secrets unsecured in his garage. Biden got busted for having classified materials at multiple locations, including his residence in Wilmington, Delaware. Liberal America just got slapped in the face; the moral grandstanding that was pervasive and incessant after the FBI’s raid on Mar-a-Lago last summer is now looking increasingly ridiculous. . . . The Left has no defense, so they’re going with their go-to line: it’s okay when we do it because we’re Democrats. That’s what Washington Post columnist Jonathan Capehart said on PBS Newshour, saying the Trump and Biden classified documents scandals are different because—in his eyes—they just are. Well, that settles it.”

OPEN THREAD: Just be yourself.

THE NAVY’S RECRUITING PROBLEMS: The Manning Shortfall Bow Wave is Only Starting. “It appears that the recruiting and retention challenges are breaking above the ambient noise at the start of 2QFY23. We go through these cycles, but if things seem a bit different to you this time, your instincts are right.”

Once you pass a tipping point, you tip. And the other services are facing the same problems.

SHE WAS A STUNNER IN HER DAY, WHICH WAS MOSTLY BEFORE I WAS BORN: R.I.P., Gina Lollobrigida. Best line: “I knew right away that Rock Hudson was gay, when he did not fall in love with me.”

HE’S SUCH A PUTZ: As a senator, Joe Biden helped kill President Jimmy Carter’s CIA director nominee because he allegedly mishandled classified materials.

Biden assured Sorensen that he would help guide him through the process. As Sorensen recalled, Biden had led him to believe that he had the senator’s “enthusiastic” support, telling him that he was “the best appointment Carter has made.”

When Sorensen came under attack from Republicans, though, Biden shifted his position and went out of his way to dig up an episode from Sorenson’s past that would serve as a red flag against his confirmation.

Putz.