MY NEW YORK POST COLUMN IS ABOUT THE K-12 IMPLOSION: “Can graft and racial politics save public schools? Just maybe. Let me explain.”
Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds
February 7, 2023
THE DEEP STATE PROTECTS ITS OWN: Pentagon Won’t Name Official Who Divulged Misleading Info About Chinese Spy Balloons During Trump Admin. “The Pentagon won’t address or explain the misleading statements. They won’t identify the person or persons who issued all those statements.”
I’M GLAD HE’S CALLING ATTENTION TO THE BRUTALITY AND ABUSE THAT CHARACTERIZE DEMOCRAT-RUN CITIES: Tyre Nichols’ Parents To Attend Biden’s State Of The Union Address.
LEARN TO CODE — OH, WAIT: Dell To Dismiss 5% Of Workforce As Tech Layoff Bloodbath Continues.
GOOD, THAT WILL MAKE IT HARDER TO CONCEAL RACIAL DISCRIMINATION: ABA House Of Delegates Rejects Proposal To Make The LSAT Optional; ABA Council To Consider Next Steps At Feb. 17 Meeting.
REMEMBERING The Conflagration at Waco.
As the 30th anniversary draws near, I recommend Dave Kopel and Paul Blackman’s No More Wacos: What’s Wrong With Federal Law Enforcement and How to Fix It.
Spoiler: We didn’t fix it.
MARTIN GURRI: In Search of a Right Populist Agenda: Merely opposing the Left’s hegemonic power is not enough.
American politics resembles a three-way scrum. An institutional center, dominated by a guardian class of elites, who manage pretty much everything in modern society, faces persistent assaults from the populist Left and Right.
On close inspection, the three contending parties can be reduced to two ideological streams: the politics of control and the politics of incoherence. Terrified by the rise of populism, the elites have hardened into what the French would call an “extreme center,” claiming a right to rule in perpetuity by reason of its superior virtue and moderation. Democracy has been redefined as the electoral triumph of the center. Candidates from outside the fold are deemed “semi-fascist” and thus illegitimate.
A vast apparatus of control—an octopus-like conglomerate of institutions that includes the federal bureaucracy, the news media, and the digital platforms—has been deployed to stop the populist wolf from crashing through the door. The panic evoked by Elon Musk’s purchase of Twitter betrays an unhappy suspicion that the beast will break in anyway. The system is as nakedly rank-based as Marie Antoinette’s France. Having assumed guardianship over the complexities of twenty-first-century life, the elites must govern because they are who they are.
Ostensibly, the center seeks power to preserve the establishment.
Well, more like it uses the establishment to preserve its power.
Plus: “The politics of control unite the extreme center and left populism: at present, the two factions share an uneasy alliance. This is only partly a contradiction. The center is ideologically exhausted and requires justification for control. In identity and environmentalism, the Left supplies that justification. The center is also aware that institutional power has decayed and verges on collapse. By its ability to summon the digital mob, the Left can offer social control over a restless public. At any rate, left populism today is not revolutionary but performative: it needs the media to build a proper stage on which to strut. The young rebels are often the children of the elites, getting credentialed in moral drama before they ascend to leadership.”
JOEL KOTKIN: The Nonprofit Threat.
The predilections of the ultra-rich will likely loom over politics and policy debates for decades to come. In the U.S., nonprofits’ assets have grown nine-fold since 1980. In 2020, nonprofits brought in $2.62 trillion in revenues, constituting more than 5.6% of the U.S. economy. And this process is just beginning, as the boomers begin to leave behind their riches. The consulting firm Accenture projects that the Silent Generation and baby boomers will gift their heirs up to $30 trillion by 2030, and up to $75 trillion by 2060.
Yet this bounty will be highly limited due to the rapid concentration of assets in ever fewer hands, with the top 1% in the U.S. increasing their share by roughly 50% since 2002. The class implications of this process are profound. The winners clearly will be the small pool of big inheritors, as we already see in Jeff Bezos’ ex-wife, MacKenzie Scott; Bill Gates’ now-discarded wife, Melinda French Gates; and Laurene Powell Jobs, the left-leaning publisher of The Atlantic and the widow of Apple’s founder.
The laws regarding nonprofits should be tightened dramatically. This isn’t rich people building hospitals and libraries. This is something close to an unelected branch of government controlled by big money. That’s made possible only by laws that were originally drafted with regard to things like hospitals and libraries.
February 6, 2023
REPUBLICANS: YES, PLEASE. Biden’s State of the Union address should be the wokest in history.
AN OBSERVATION I MADE ELSEWHERE: “No society can entirely do without intelligentsia, but they’re like gut bacteria –valuable, but they have to be constrained in number and kept in their place or disaster ensues.”
THEY’RE NOT COMPETENT, JUST SELF-CENTERED, ENTITLED, AND UNPRINCIPLED: Deep State? After the China balloon fiasco, call it the Derp State.
That doesn’t mean they aren’t a threat to democracy.
UPDATE: From the comments: “The way you know that 9/11 wasn’t organized by the CIA was that the attack worked.”
Ouch. José Ramon Fernandez smiles.
OPEN THREAD: Share your pearls of wisdom.
I HOPE WE’RE NOT TOO MESSIANIC, OR A TRIFLE TOO SATANIC: Grammys Go With Devil Worship In Primetime.
Related (From Ed): Everything old is new again! The Rolling Stones performed “Sympathy for the Devil” in 1968. Jimmy Page spent the late ‘60s and much of the ‘70s putting Aleister Crowley references into Led Zeppelin artwork and for Led Zep III, even in the LP’s run-out grooves. AC/DC released “Highway to Hell” in 1979. Ozzy Osbourne released “Mr. Cowley” in 1981. So many heavy metal groups spent the ‘80s using devil worship as a pose that VH-1 has an article headlined, “6.66 Hot Points Of The ’80s Heavy Metal Satanic Panic.”
Find something controversial from the 21st century to actually épater les bourgeois rather than a sub-genre of rock that’s over 50 years old to bore them, Grammys!
(Updated and bumped.)
UPDATE (FROM GLENN): Heh.

“Listen, folks, I enjoy demonic sexual perversion just as much as the next guy, but this is just too much,” said the frustrated Father of Lies. “I’m the god of this world! I appear as an angel of light! It’s supposed to be sneaky and subtle! Has Hollywood lost its ability to be subtle? What on earth happened to this town?”
“And how am I supposed to corrupt the next generation when no one watches this garbage anymore?” he lamented. “At least I still have TikTok.”
Did I say “heh?” Yes, yes I did.
UPDATE (From Ed): John Nolte: Fat Satan Grammys Deliver Ratings Catastrophe of Just 12.4M Viewers.
THE NEW SPACE RACE: United States and India expand civil space cooperation.
MY NEW YORK POST COLUMN IS ABOUT THE K-12 IMPLOSION: “Can graft and racial politics save public schools? Just maybe. Let me explain.”
I WAS SPECULATING ABOUT THIS EARLIER, AND NOW: Top Republican claims Trump’s Defense Secretary James Mattis may have KNOWN that Chinese spy balloons flew over the U.S. but opted not to tell the president because he was ‘too provocative and aggressive.’
That would be a serious dereliction of duty on Mattis’s part if true. Between that and Milley reportedly refusing Biden’s order to shoot the balloon down on Wednesday, do we have civilian control of the military anymore?
What did Mattis know, and if he knew, why didn’t he tell the President?
UPDATE: Considerable skepticism in the comments, and on an email list I belong to, that this report is true. Well, that’s why I said “if true” above. As I noted earlier Trump’s appointees say it didn’t happen during his term. So either they’re all lying (unlikely, especially as some have authored tell-all books about their time in the Administration), the Biden people are lying when they claim it happened, or it happened but nobody told Trump or his people. I’d have to put “the Biden people are lying” at the top of the likelihood list for sure. It’s entirely believable, based on past conduct, that people in the defense establishment would keep Trump in the dark, though just because it’s believable doesn’t mean it happened. It seems least likely that all the former Trump people are lying, though one can never assign a probability of zero to political actors’ telling untruths.
ANOTHER UPDATE: From the WSJ: Prior Chinese Balloon Incursions Over U.S. Went Undetected, Officials Say: They say prior intrusions by surveillance craft into the continental U.S. were likely of short duration.
China previously sent high-altitude surveillance balloons over the U.S. that went undetected until after leaving American airspace, Biden administration officials said, as the military salvaged debris Sunday from the downed balloon in a bid to learn more about the Chinese operation.
After the Pentagon disclosed last week that it was tracking the balloon that the Air Force shot down Saturday off the Carolina coast, defense officials said that there have been prior intrusions over the continental U.S. At least three of those occurred during former President Donald Trump‘s term in office and once previously under President Biden.
Those previous balloon flights were much shorter in duration, possibly explaining why some went undetected at the time, the senior administration officials said. One official said that much of the information on the flights was pieced together later.
“This information was discovered after the prior administration left,” one of the officials said. The official said that intelligence agencies are preparing to brief key figures in the previous Trump administration.
That’s a rather convenient discovery. But if this story is true, the people who missed it should be sacked, at the very least.
GET MORE REST ELON, YOU’RE NOT 30 ANYMORE. Elon Musk confides working morning, day and night is taking a toll on his health.
And you’re as close to an indispensable man as exists right now. But the cemeteries are full of indispensable men.
I LIKE THE IDEA OF A BALLOON DROP, PERSONALLY:
What to watch for in the #SOTU:
– What will come out of his mouth. Which is worse, what they wrote or how he garbles it.
– McCarthy. Pelosi set a high bar for childish petulance. McCarthy needs to own it. Spitballs at the old geezer, or a big white balloon. https://t.co/z2Elczjy8S
— BullshitSquared (blue check) (@xenophonrocks) February 6, 2023
I DUNNO, MAYBE STOP CRAPPING ALL OVER THEM AND THEIR LIFESTYLE? Paul Krugman: Can Anything Be Done to Assuage Rural Rage? (Non-paywalled text here.)
A THREAT THAT CAN BE DELICIOUSLY MANAGED: Wild Hogs Are A Threat All Over.
LIVE LONG AND PROSPER — IF THEY WILL LET YOU. My latest Substack column. (Bumped).