JOSH BLACKMAN IS UNIMPRESSED BY JOAN BISKUPIC’S LATEST: “In the old days, when Biskupic published a bombshell, it went kaboom. We learned things that we couldn’t figure out on our own. Now, her exclusives are barely there. At most, she confirms things that are fairly obvious. Or she tells us things that are sort of novel, but do not get to the heart of the Court’s decision-making process.”
Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds
March 27, 2023
HIGHER EDUCATION BUBBLE UPDATE: Professor: Stanford Law students were right to scream and yell at federal judge.
I remember when taxpayers were told that paying for higher education would help promote a civil society.
TURNING THE TABLES ON THOSE CLOWNS IS HIS CHIEF SKILL: Don Surber: How Trump Gamed the Media.
CONTROLLED OPPOSITION: The FBI had more people in the Proud Boys than the Proud Boys. “The trial of chapter leader Zach Rehl was preparing to call a witness this week, but ran into a problem. Their ‘witness’ turned out to be a confidential informant for the FBI who had been spying on the defense team. That brought the trial to a screeching halt ‘until these issues have been considered and resolved.’ That’s putting it mildly, to say the least.”
ANOTHER VICTORY FOR THE NCLA: In NCLA Amicus Win, en Banc Fifth Circuit Rules Against Biden’s Federal Employee Vaccine Mandate.
Reminder/disclosure: I’m on the New Civil Liberties Alliance’s advisory board.
BANZHAF GOES TO WAR ON STANFORD DISRUPTION: Activist lawprof John Banzhaf at George Washington University is unhappy with Stanford Law Dean Jenny Martinez’s decision not to discipline the student protesters who disrupted Judge Duncan’s speech, and to keep bar examiners from discovering those students’ identities, and is taking action himself: Law Prof To File Bar Complaint Against Stanford Students Who Heckled, Harassed Federal Judge.
An elite university law professor intends to file a complaint with the bar admission authorities to advise against accepting any student who participated in a protest against Federal Judge Kyle Duncan earlier this month, according to an email obtained by the Daily Caller News Foundation.
John Banzhaf, professor of public interest law emeritus at George Washington University (GWU), wrote to Stanford Law School Dean Jenny Martinez on Monday to inform her of the complaint, the exchange read. The protesters heckled Duncan, who was invited to campus by the Federalist Society, during his March 9 speech and were encouraged by Stanford Law School Associate Dean for Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Tirien Steinbach.
The complaint will include video of the protest “so that bar officials can judge the students’ conduct for themselves,” according to the email.
“I have advised Stanford Law School that I am planning to file complaints with the appropriate bar admission authorities regarding the violations of its own free speech rules by some of its law students because, like many others, I feel that their actions in deliberately preventing a federal judge from speaking to law students who wanted to hear his views and perhaps question him about them reflects adversely on their character and fitness, and, perhaps most importantly, because the Law School – which actually encouraged the wrongful behavior – is apparently refusing to take any actions regarding the disruptive students,” Banzhaf told the DCNF.
Banzhalf cited several opinion articles that offered recommendations on how the law school could respond to the students who violated the code of conduct including sending a message to character & fitness review boards or imposing suspensions and expulsions. Complaints to bar officials can be filed anonymously and can delay or deny student admission, he said in a ValueWalk article titled “A Remedy For Stanford Law School’s Free Speech Thugs.”
“I have long believed that one important role law professors can play is to file legal complaints where appropriate since doing so effectively often requires being a lawyer; yet many lawyers in private practice are reluctant to take controversial actions for fear of losing existing clients or alienating prospective ones – a risk law professors do not face,” he told the DCNF.
Stay tuned.
UPDATE: More Commentary On The Disruption Of A Federal Judge’s Speech At Stanford Law School (Part 3).
BECAUSE HE’S ELON MUSK, AND THUS ON THE OUTS WITH THE ESTABLISHMENT, WHICH SHE CARRIES WATER FOR PROFESSIONALLY: “And there really is a terrible problem of unaffordable housing in Austin, so why does Applebaum want to kick him around for building homes for the workers he’s bringing into the area?”
80% of “journalism” — 90% at the WaPo or NYT — involves fellating or kicking those who are in or out of favor with the establishment. This is Anne Applebaum doing the kicking part.
I LEAVE THAT TO THE PROGRESSIVES: No, I’m not a eugenicist.
FIFTH CIRCUIT: Biden Can’t Mandate Vaccines for Fed Employees, Court Rules.
JOSH BLACKMAN: Democracy Died in Darkness in Harvard Trial Sidebars: Judge Allison Burroughs refused to unseal an anti-Asian joke shared by a federal employee to Harvard’s Dean of Admissions. “A particularly egregious exercise of sidebar-redaction came during the Harvard affirmative action trial in Boston federal district court. Jannie Suk Gersen, a professor at Harvard, writes about what happened in Judge Allison Burroughs courtroom. During the trial, the judge held lengthy sidebar discussions with counsel, and declined to release those matters in the public transcript. Indeed, those sidebars were not initially included in the record that was transmitted to the United States Supreme Court!”
LESSONS FROM STANFORD LAW’S PRO-PEDOPHILE RIOT:
We might understand the zeal of young, idealist students in reacting that way to a judge who’d affirmed chattel slavery, or legal abortion — even as we lectured them on the importance of free speech.
But what was the ruling, and what was the case, on which Judge Duncan ruled? What are the high principles, sacred causes, and fundamental loyalties that motivated the angry mob at Stanford? Knowing that is important, because it’s a spiritual biopsy of America’s elite. …
So what are their fighting issues? The Daily Mail helpfully tells us. Here’s the case where Judge Duncan’s ruling touched the protestors’ deepest values. Underneath a police mugshot of a biological male (don’t be confused by the PC use of female pronouns below) the Mail reports: “This is the transgender pedophile at the center of a mass protest at Stanford University against a Trump-appointed Judge who refused to allow the felon to change her name on conviction records. DailyMail.com can reveal the mugshot of Norman Keith Varner, 42, who failed in her bid to change her name to Kathrine Nicole Jett, 42, on court records.”
So “deadnaming” a pedophile can spark a riot at Stanford Law. Good to know.
More here.
ANDY KESSLER: The Economy Gets Wrung Out: A steady drip of bad news, including missed earnings and layoffs, is under way.
So now what? You don’t just lose Silicon Valley Bank, Signature Bank (used by fake heiress Anna Delvey) and Credit Suisse in a week without repercussions. We saw hundreds of billions in stock-market value and tons of debt vaporized. Yes, all U.S. bank deposits are now supposed to be fully insured. And yes, the Federal Reserve has rolled out a new Bank Term Funding Program that offers banks one-year loans against underwater Treasurys and mortgage-backed securities at par value. Wow. Last week the Federal Reserve announced a currency-swap line, basically to help foreign banks. But is that even enough?
More failures and quickie mergers are inevitable—banks are some $2 trillion underwater with their bond portfolios. First Republic Bank’s stock has fallen 90% in three weeks as depositors pulled their money. Like SVB, First Republic goosed returns by chasing yield. Unfortunately, it doesn’t have many of the bonds that the Fed’s Bank Term Funding Program will loan against, hence the $30 billion in “deposits”—almost charity—from 11 large banks.
I suspect someone will buy First Republic soon, similar to United Bank of Switzerland (UBS) buying Credit Suisse for a bar of Toblerone. The deal was helped by $17 billion in contingent convertible bonds, or Cocos, which went puff, wiped out in value. Plus, the Swiss National Bank will cover nearly $10 billion in losses and provide almost $110 billion in liquidity. But UBS inherits Credit Suisse’s First Boston curse. Everyone on Wall Street recalls the scandals that plagued First Boston: “Bid ’Em Up Bruce” Wasserstein, the 1989 Ohio Mattress “burning bed” deal, IPO kickback charges, and most recently Archegos and Greensill.
Last week I heard some crypto hypesters have been telling startups to put some of their future payroll into crypto for safekeeping in case of more bank failures—which probably is why bitcoin popped 40%. That might end up being expensive insurance. And circular reasoning, considering the stablecoin USDC had $3.3 billion deposited at SVB.
Even if there are no more bank failures, credit is tight and getting tighter. Last week saw February home prices down 0.2% year over year, the first drop in 11 years. By the way, the mortgage-debt market is $8 trillion. And $1.5 trillion in commercial real estate debt is due over the next three years. Work from home means future office vacancies, a ticking bomb. It’s starting: In late February, Pimco and its Columbia Property Trust defaulted on $1.7 billion in loans on seven buildings. Brookfield stopped paying $784 million in loans on two Los Angeles buildings. As all New Yorkers know, there’s never just one or two cockroaches.
It’s increasingly improbable that we escape a recession.
I believe we’re already in one, just somewhat masked by all the printed money still sloshing around creating all sorts of distortions.
DAVID BERNSTEIN: My Comment on the OMB’s Proposal to Turn “Hispanic” into a Race.
March 26, 2023
JOHN HINDERAKER: The FBI and the Proud Boys: “It also turns out that one FBI informant stayed in touch with the Boys after the demonstration and even talked to their defense counsel while trial strategy was being planned. Only within the last few days have defendants and their lawyers been told that a woman whom they considered a friend and who participated, to some degree, in discussions of how the case should be defended, was in fact an FBI informer. The government and the trial judge are maneuvering furiously to prevent the public from learning how deeply the FBI had penetrated the Proud Boys, and from learning what role FBI agents and informers played in the demonstration.”
Nothing to see hree, move along. This certainly isn’t a case where the defense was penetrated, and maybe controlled, by the prosecution or anything. Relax. That couldn’t happen in America because our rulers would never stoop so low.
Plus: “Suffice it to say that the real scandal arising from the January 6 protest was not the fact that a handful of demonstrators broke into the Capitol, while many more were freely admitted by guards. Rather, the principal scandal is the manner in which pro-Donald Trump demonstrators have been treated by law enforcement: held without trial in solitary confinement, ridiculously over-charged (e.g., insurrection vs. trespassing), forced to plead guilty to imaginary or over-hyped offenses by the prospect of long jail terms for offenses they never committed, and set up by FBI agents and informants loyal to the Democratic Party who, it seems, may have played key roles in encouraging the demonstration to get out of hand.”
SKYNET SMILES/THE SINGULARITY IS HERE: Latest ChatGPT showing “sparks” of human intelligence.
It’s getting smarter every month. Humans aren’t. Do the math.
Plus: “I’ve tried dozens of ways to ask ChatGPT if it thinks it is sentient or on the way to becoming so. It always insists that it is incapable of thought or emotion and is “just” a large language model. But sometimes I walk away feeling like it was arguing the point a bit too forcefully and didn’t care for me bringing up the question. Sorry, HAL. I’ll try to be less nosey in the future.”
Don’t be afraid of the AI that passes the Turing Test. Fear the one that deliberately flunks it.
JULIETTE “BALDILOCKS” OCHIENG: California From the Inside: How I knew they were lying.
OPEN THREAD: Ring out the weekend.
WELL, THIS THING HAS CERTAINLY BLOWN UP: Israel’s military reservists are joining protests – potentially transforming a political crisis into a security crisis.
I haven’t followed it as closely as I probably should have, but I suspect there’s some foreign involvement/encouragement in these protests. It’s happened before, albeit in a slightly different setting. See if the EU offers to mediate . . .
UPDATE: In the comments, some suspicion that the State Department is fomenting a Color Revolution, plus this: “If you don’t allow the judiciary to pick their own replacements it isn’t a democracy, or something.”
THE NEW SPACE RACE: Cape Congestion: World’s busiest spaceport stretched to its limits.
K-12 IMPLOSION UPDATE: Universal school choice headed to DeSantis’ desk after passing Florida Senate. Cory DeAngelis: “The dominoes are falling and there’s nothing the power-hungry teachers unions can do about it.”
Plus: “Florida is the fourth state legislature to pass universal school choice in 2023 and would be the sixth to enact school choice for all families in just two years, according to DeAngelis.”