STATE LAW MUST SUPERSEDE ACCREDITOR REQUIREMENTS. If a school can’t be accredited and also follow the law, it should take the conflict up with both legislators and accreditors, but it has to follow the law.

Ultimately, the solution may be that some state regulations against any concept even DEI-adjacent are loosened (Plato? Come on…), while accreditors dial back their DEI requirements. Both sides have something to lose if they don’t come to an agreement. But the major share of the blame has to be on accreditors, who should have understood that their power up until now relied on a nearly universal belief that their requirements weren’t used to play political games. But they played stupid games, and now they’re winning stupid prizes.

LET’S RETURN TO TEACHING STUDENTS HOW TO ARGUE. In the sense of “we are discussing the crux of the issue” rather than “I am (X identity) so I feel (Y feeling) and you can’t challenge that.” An idea so crazy it just might work (and that is also thousands of years old).

THE MISSING MEN OF UNC. UNC-Chapel Hill is now slightly more than 60/40 women to men. This is more lopsided in terms of sex balance than most big state schools because NC’s big engineering school is at NC State, but this is just another wake-up call that there is a mismatch between what our culture (likely) needs and what our institutions are designed to deliver. (I say “likely” because you can credibly argue that men are less likely to need a college degree because of the nature of the jobs they may select.)

FEDERAL DEPT OF ED MAKES AN INVESTMENT IN CIVIC EDUCATION: $1.9 million to The American Civic Tradition at 250, at two Texas universities. Weird, I thought my tax money was reserved for teaching people to be ignorant of and hate America.

COULD THE CAMPUS MINDFULNESS FAD ACTUALLY BE…DANGEROUS? “The scientific literature identifies a wide range of other negative effects associated with mindfulness meditation. Studies have documented adverse psychological, physical, and spiritual side effects, including depersonalization, psychosis, hallucinations, anxiety, increased seizure risk, disorganized speech, loss of appetite, and insomnia.” I admit, I’m surprised.

DISABILITY “ACCOMMODATION NATION” IN THE UNC SYSTEM. And it’s the same just about everywhere else. The perverse incentives to get diagnoses are just too strong. After all, your kid probably has struggles too. Are you letting him or her down by not going the extra mile?

DO WE NEED A FACULTY MERIT ACT? “The Faculty Merit Act requires state universities to publish every higher-education standardized test score (SAT, ACT, CRT, GRE, LSAT, MCAT, etc.) of every faculty member, as well as the standardized test score of every applicant for the faculty member’s position.”

EXPOSING ‘A STORY OF FRAUD AND BETRAYAL’ IN ACADEMIA. There’s a new book out about the famous “signing first” paper that claimed promising to be honest ahead of time made people more honest in follow-up data gathering. Turns out the data on honesty was faked, which, cosmically, seems like pushing it.

HOW TO DEFINE ACADEMIC FREEDOM? The UNC system faculty is–get this!–actually thinking through it. I know, I know, professors being professor-y seems old-fashioned these days, but I feel like Americans like it when higher ed sounds like a place where smart people consider things thoughtfully.

THE PROGRESSIVE UNIVERSITY IN THE DOCK. Was requiring specialization and Ph.Ds really as good an idea as we seem to assume it was? (It wasn’t always like that.)

“DISECONOMIES OF SCALE” IN HIGHER ED. Higher ed is so screwed up it seems to have managed to make economics work backwards.

HARVARD ADMITS ITS GRADES HAVE LOST ALL MEANING: Hey, they’re not paying a jillion dollars a year to not get A’s…

IS ONLINE LEARNING ‘COMPLIANCE THEATER’? If you have to ask…

PEER REVIEW IS BROKEN. HERE’S HOW TO FIX IT. An actual idea here! We need more of this.

THE NEXT STEP IN ENDING HIGHER ED RACIAL PREFERENCES: Grants for [name your favored ethnicity] serving institutions?

SHOULD STATES ELECT OR APPOINT UNIVERSITY BOARDS? Kind of like with judges, no option seems to be clearly best (at least, to me). Appointed cronies or elected hacks?

TOMORROW AT UTAH VALLEY U., SITE OF CHARLIE KIRK’S ASSASSINATION: Greg Lukianoff, my friend, boss at FIRE, and occasional Instapunditeer, speaks on the topic of “Free Speech: An Antidote to Violence.” I’m proud that Greg and FIRE are part of this event, honoring Charlie Kirk’s legacy of engaging friend and opponent alike.

TIME TO BRING BACK GEOGRAPHY? I mean, if people are going to mock Americans for not knowing where countries are on a map, it might help to actually make some kind of effort…

‘STOP MEETING STUDENTS WHERE THEY ARE.’ It can tend to turn into an excuse…

BOULEVARD OF BROKEN DREAMS WALLETS: “The school (allegedly!) ‘self-financed thousands of temporary employment opportunities for their graduates through schemes with non-profits and paid-off vendors to give the false impression to incoming students and federal regulators that their graduates were gainfully employed.'”

COLLEGE IS WORTH SAVING. I hope so, I’ve spent my career trying!

HOW TO REFORM SCHOOLS OF EDUCATION. I tend to think they are too far gone, myself.

ANTI-DISCRIMINATION ADVOCATES’ NEW WEAPON: Cold, hard, numbers.

CHARLIE KIRK REPORTEDLY SHOT IN NECK AT UTAH VALLEY U.

Charlie Kirk and the TPUSA event at UVU – let’s wait to get info. pic.twitter.com/907f7Etq28

— An Intelligent Home (@AnIntelHome) September 10, 2025

Actual video with the gunshot here; it’s from far away but as you see him get hit, so I am not going to embed.

From Fox News, he’s hospitalized.

UPDATE: Ok, this is extremely graphic, and I think we need to be cautious that someone did not do some quick AI editing, but if authentic, this looks extremely serious.

WOKE CAMPUS WITCH HUNTS ARE LOSING IN COURT. Finally. But you have to get to court, and that’s difficult and expensive.