Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

SOCIALIST STORIES USUALLY DO: Socialist CEO Dan Price’s story takes a dark turn. “Perhaps the most interesting part of the NY Times report is that it really doesn’t shy away from the idea that Price used his fame as a social justice campaigner to make contact with nearly all of the women who accuse him of assault. One alleged victim, a left-wing activist, even described it as painful that Price is ‘the poster child for this politics that I really care about.'”

Do tell.

MARY KATHARINE HAM REVIEWS THE STOLEN YEAR: “The Stolen Year acknowledges the public schools’ COVID failures but refuses to hold anyone responsible. . . . Twelve years after he was acquitted of murder, O.J. Simpson and a ghostwriter penned a book called If I Did It. I was reminded of that when The Stolen Year arrived on my doorstep. A chronicling of the horrors wrought by COVID policies that kept American kids from their school buildings and childhood milestones for more than a year, this book was written by someone at the scene of the crime, intimate with the gory details, and ultimately uninterested in reckoning with who was responsible for it. This is a whodunnit without a culprit.”

Plus: “It seemed like depraved indifference to children’s welfare.”

MARK JUDGE: Abortion and the Arts. “We won the Cold War and overturned Roe. Watching Ben Shapiro annihilate college students is fun, but it’s now time to do something different. The response to cancel culture is not just counterpunching, but creating the kind of questing, beautiful, and provocative art that Hollywood is too scared to attempt anymore. We’ve won the arguments. Now it’s time for the hard part – creating culture.”

PARSING THE LIES:

I cannot get my head around the Democrat Party as “committed to defending First Amendment freedoms.” What’s that based on? It doesn’t resonate with me, and I’ve been watching the Democratic Party closely every day since January 14, 2004. I’m going to omit that phrase entirely and edit the rest into something as clear as I can make it: TV news, coopted by the Democratic Party, would like non-Democrats to watch.

Well, if you don’t watch, they can’t propagandize you. Also, they need ad dollars.

OPEN THREAD: Take the wheel.

IT’S NOT PARANOIA WHEN THEY REALLY ARE OUT TO GET YOU: Rich Lowry: In Defense of GOP Paranoia.

The Russia investigation was a national fiasco that brought discredit on the F.B.I. and everyone who participated in it. The probe prominently featured a transparently ridiculous dossier generated by the Clinton campaign, eventually spinning into a special-counsel investigation that became, to some significant extent, about itself and whether Mr. Trump was guilty of obstruction. People who should have known better got caught up in the feeding frenzy and speculated that “the walls were closing in” on Mr. Trump, or that he might have been a Russian asset going back decades.

It all came to naught with almost no one expressing any regret about the unnecessary, yearslong psychodrama. It would be better if more people acknowledged — life being complicated — that even someone you hate and fear can be treated unfairly.

That experience guarantees that no Republican is going to take assurances about the Mar-a-Lago search, or any other Trump investigation, at face value.

Nor should they. Once you’ve seen that institutions — and alleged “straight shooters” like James Comey — are willing to prostitute themselves in service of a political vendetta, you would be foolish to believe that the vendetta suddenly stopped. That’s not how vendettas work. Or prostitutes.

IT’S JANUARY 6 ALL OVER THE WORLD: “Sri Lanka’s new government came under international censure Monday over the use of tough anti-terror laws to detain protesters who forced Gotabaya Rajapaksa to step down from the presidency last month. Irony:

The PTA allows suspects to be detained for 90 days without judicial review.

“Using laws that don’t conform with international human rights standards – like the PTA – erodes democracy in Sri Lanka,” said US ambassador to Sri Lanka Julie Chung.

“We encourage the government to uphold the rights of the people to express their views,” she tweeted.

I encourage all governments to do that.

Related: Sri Lanka Faces International Censure Over Arrests.

ALL THE INSTITUTIONS HAVE BEEN CORRUPTED: WSJ: The Trump Warrant Had No Legal Basis: A former president’s rights under the Presidential Records Act trump the statutes the FBI cited to justify the Mar-a-Lago raid.

The warrant authorized the FBI to seize “all physical documents and records constituting evidence, contraband, fruits of crime, or other items illegally possessed in violation of 18 U.S.C. §§793, 2071, or 1519” (emphasis added). These three criminal statutes all address the possession and handling of materials that contain national-security information, public records or material relevant to an investigation or other matters properly before a federal agency or the courts.

The materials to be seized included “any government and/or Presidential Records created between January 20, 2017, and January 20, 2021”—i.e., during Mr. Trump’s term of office. Virtually all the materials at Mar-a-Lago are likely to fall within this category. Federal law gives Mr. Trump a right of access to them. His possession of them is entirely consistent with that right, and therefore lawful, regardless of the statutes the FBI cites in its warrant.

Those statutes are general in their text and application. But Mr. Trump’s documents are covered by a specific statute, the Presidential Records Act of 1978. It has long been the Supreme Court position, as stated in Morton v. Mancari (1974), that “where there is no clear intention otherwise, a specific statute will not be controlled or nullified by a general one, regardless of the priority of enactment.” The former president’s rights under the PRA trump any application of the laws the FBI warrant cites. . . .

Nothing in the PRA suggests that the former president’s physical custody of his records can be considered unlawful under the statutes on which the Mar-a-Lago warrant is based. Yet the statute’s text makes clear that Congress considered how certain criminal-law provisions would interact with the PRA: It provides that the archivist is not to make materials available to the former president’s designated representative “if that individual has been convicted of a crime relating to the review, retention, removal, or destruction of records of the Archives.”

Nothing is said about the former president himself, but applying these general criminal statutes to him based on his mere possession of records would vitiate the entire carefully balanced PRA statutory scheme. Thus if the Justice Department’s sole complaint is that Mr. Trump had in his possession presidential records he took with him from the White House, he should be in the clear, even if some of those records are classified.

In making a former president’s records available to him, the PRA doesn’t distinguish between materials that are and aren’t classified. That was a deliberate choice by Congress.

So much for all the “rule of law” talk justifying this lawless raid by a lawless agency.

Related, from a friend:

THIS IS ONLY IN OCCASIONAL POWER EMERGENCIES: Those with Tesla Solar Power and Tesla Powerwalls who have opted into Tesla’s Virtual Power Plant program get $2 per kwh when their power utility uses the Tesla Virtual Power plant. Plus, an experience:

About 25 kwh was used from my home during this event. This was about $50 generated from the event.

Powerwalls and solar have reduced my monthly energy bills from $200-400 down to about $30-50 mainly from natural gas for water heating and a gas stove. This VPP event offset the charge for one to two months of power bills.

Not bad. I have two concerns. First, is this going to be scalable? And second, as power becomes less reliable over the coming decade, which seems likely, will people want to participate in this program, or would they rather hold on to their reserves?