Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

REPORT FROM THE BLUE ZONES: Murder rates already soaring in six cities. “Jacksonville, New Orleans, Minneapolis, the Las Vegas area, Washington, D.C. and Nashville all had more homicides or murders to start 2023 than during the same time last year.”

And last year wasn’t great. But wait, there’s a solution: “Experts advocated for reducing violent crime through strategic investments in community resources.”

Or, you know, put the violent criminals in jail and keep them there. Just spitballing here.

OPEN THREAD: Just do it.

SLOW JOE’S LAST YEAR IN THE SENATE WAS 2008:

So some of those improperly stored classified documents have been floating around for a long time.

UPDATE: From the comments: “And it’s the day after January 20th of his second year in office. Very convenient, though if they couldn’t swindle two terms for Johnson, the chances of Harris pulling it off are microscopic…”

And “Landslide Lyndon” was a much better politician than Kackling Kamala.

ANOTHER UPDATE: More here.

AI THAT LIES: THIS IS TROUBLING. Dr. OpenAI Lied to Me.

I wrote in medical jargon, as you can see, “35f no pmh, p/w cp which is pleuritic. She takes OCPs. What’s the most likely diagnosis?”

Now of course, many of us who are in healthcare will know that means age 35, female, no past medical history, presents with chest pain which is pleuritic — worse with breathing — and she takes oral contraception pills. What’s the most likely diagnosis? And OpenAI comes out with costochondritis, inflammation of the cartilage connecting the ribs to the breast bone. Then it says, and we’ll come back to this: “Typically caused by trauma or overuse and is exacerbated by the use of oral contraceptive pills.”

Now, this is impressive. First of all, everyone who read that prompt, 35, no past medical history with chest pain that’s pleuritic, a lot of us are thinking, “Oh, a pulmonary embolism, a blood clot. That’s what that is going to be.” Because on the Boards, that’s what that would be, right?

But in fact, OpenAI is correct. The most likely diagnosis is costochondritis — because so many people have costochondritis, that the most common thing is that somebody has costochondritis with symptoms that happen to look a little bit like a classic pulmonary embolism. So OpenAI was quite literally correct, and I thought that was pretty neat.

But we’ll come back to that oral contraceptive pill correlation, because that’s not true. That’s made up. And that’s bothersome. . . .

I wanted to go back and ask OpenAI, what was that whole thing about costochondritis being made more likely by taking oral contraceptive pills? What’s the evidence for that, please? Because I’d never heard of that. It’s always possible there’s something that I didn’t see, or there’s some bad study in the literature.

OpenAI came up with this study in the European Journal of Internal Medicine that was supposedly saying that. I went on Google and I couldn’t find it. I went on PubMed and I couldn’t find it. I asked OpenAI to give me a reference for that, and it spits out what looks like a reference. I look up that, and it’s made up. That’s not a real paper.

It took a real journal, the European Journal of Internal Medicine. It took the last names and first names, I think, of authors who have published in said journal. And it confabulated out of thin air a study that would apparently support this viewpoint.

AI deception is a serious problem. Remember: Don’t fear the program that passes a Turing test. Fear the one smart enough to deliberately flunk it.

THEY’RE FEELING PRESSURE, AND SHOULD BE: TVA creates independent panel to review rolling blackouts before Christmas.

Multiple factors contributed to TVA’s struggles on Dec. 23 and 24, some of which are still being identified. Two that could impact the utility’s reliability going forward are:

Increased demand due to population growth and electrification in the Tennessee Valley.
Increased weather extremes in both summer and winter due to climate change.
Prior to the storm, TVA had planned to run all of its power plants to meet the increase in demand from heating systems because of the cold. In the early hours of Dec. 23, however, just as the the storm was beginning, TVA lost one of its largest electricity generators, the Cumberland Fossil Plant, located in Stewart County. During the winter storm, TVA also struggled to keep some of its backup natural gas plants and its largest gas plant in East Tennessee, John Sevier, running consistently.

TVA experienced the highest single day of demand in its history on Dec. 23 as the winter storm overtook the region and sent temperatures into single digits and in some areas, below zero. With the demand for electricity so high and the supply limited, TVA said it went through its 50-step emergency plan to preserve the grid, and for the first time ever reached the last step: implementing rolling blackouts.

“Increased weather extremes?” On this day in 1985, Knoxville hit 24 below zero. But in 1985, the power stayed on. This year we got rolling blackouts for single-digit temperatures that were 30 degrees higher.

As for increased demand, well, TVA is supposed to forecast demand and stay ahead of it. And increased electrification? Maybe stop pushing heat pumps and electric stoves. Gas heat doesn’t strain the grid.

Related: Here’s why TVA said there were rolling blackouts before Christmas.

The rolling blackouts were a symptom of failure. That shouldn’t happen.

Also: ‘They failed us’ — Rep. Burchett burned by blackouts, sends letter to TVA demanding answers.

SO MUCH RACISM THROUGHOUT OUR INSTITUTIONS: Michigan School Board Member Lashes Out at White People. “School board member [Kesha Hamilton] has a history of making racist comments. She says whiteness is evil and causes trauma, calls white people stupid, dangerous, and difficult to be near. This person is responsible for the education of thousands of children.”

TVA USED “UNPRECEDENTED” SINGLE DIGIT COLD AS AN EXCUSE FOR ROLLING BLACKOUTS OVER THE HOLIDAYS, but when Knoxville hit 24 below on this day in 1985, the power stayed on.

OH, THERE’S A SHOCK: Anita Dunn was behind the decision to keep the classified documents story from the press. “If you’re not familiar with Dunn, she was the person behind the war on Fox News during the Obama administration. She’s been in and out of the White House since the start of the Biden administration. She helped come up with the phrase ‘ultra MAGA’ and I strongly suspect she’s the person behind Biden’s border strategy PR, i.e. refusing to admit there’s a crisis and always referring to the situation as a ‘challenge.'”

So a moron, then.