Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

WELL, TO BE FAIR, THE PRESS LIES A LOT: Another MSM meltdown: The DeSantis/Florida “book ban” that was … none of those. “Did Florida and Ron DeSantis embark on a crusade to ban a poem read at Joe Biden’s inauguration from public schools? As it turns out, the incident in question had nothing to do with DeSantis, nothing to do with the state of Florida, and poet Amanda Gorman’s book never left the one school library in question. But if you read the story in the national media — fueled by Gorman’s own misinformed Instagram post — you’d think that DeSantis spent the day dancing around a poetry pyre.”

WILFULLY AND FOR POLITICAL REASONS? RealClearInvestigations: How Black Lives Matter Got Police Violence Wrong.

The collapse in race relations began in 2014. Exactly why this year was pivotal is unknown, though it coincides with the debunked “hands up, don’t shoot” framing of the Michael Brown killing and a larger “great awokening” wherein extreme identitarian views became more influential on the political left. Since 2014, little data suggests race disparities have gotten worse. Racist attitudes in the United States are at historic lows. However, news media coverage worrying over racism soared.

I studied this issue empirically in 2021. I wanted to see whether actual police shootings of unarmed black men correlated with race relations or whether news media coverage highlighting police shootings of black men was a better predictor. It turns out race relations are unrelated to actual police shootings, but correlate with news media coverage, which tends to obsess over shootings of black Americans while ignoring shootings of other individuals.

This pattern holds up in so many places. Think of the news media as hostile disinformation sources and you won’t go far wrong.

DON SURBER: Already lying about Trump’s second term. “The reporter — Sophia Cai — neither talked to the president nor did she quote his public statements much. She just speculated and exaggerated his positions. In other words, she did the same piss-poor reporting that one has come to expect from the DC press corps. . . . What Cai did reveal was the 2024 version of Orange Man Bad. Spoiler alert: They will call him a fascist again.”

Wow. Didn’t see that one coming.

FIGHT THE POWER:

MICHAEL WALSH: Never Forget, Never Forgive, Never Again. “Latterly, there’s a movement afoot by those who brought you the continuing Covid disaster to feign remorse over what they did. Don’t buy a word of it. These crocodiles — a cabal of frightened women and pusillanimous yet power hungry men — enjoyed every minute of your misery, even as they swan about on their mini non-apology tours and warn direly about the next iteration of the Black Death that is surely headed our (but not their) way. Meanwhile, they’re allowed to quietly resign and cash in their enormous pensions, courtesy of you.”

BOB GRABOYES: The Fatal Conceit and Effective Altruism.

The greatest economics lesson of all may reside in the Yiddish expression, “Der mensch tracht, un Gott lacht” (“Man plans, and God laughs.”) That, writ small, is the message of Friedrich Hayek’s broadsides against central planning in The Fatal Conceit and “The Use of Knowledge in Society.” The latter was one of the most influential economic essays of the 20th century, and in a gentler time, when philosophical adversaries actually listened to one another (some, at least), a significant number of socialists and would-be planners found the anti-socialist Hayek’s arguments persuasive (or at least informative). . . .

In recent decades, charitable giving has been a somewhat atomized endeavor. Even John D. Rockefeller, Andrew Carnegie, and Henry Ford each controlled a relatively small percentage of charitable donations. The socialism suggested above by Nathan Robinson envisions a world where charity is planned by the monopolized, centralized might of government. EA, it seems to me, seeks a middle ground, where a goodly percentage of donations are directed (or at least strongly suggested) by a relatively compact set of EA organizations. The question is whether this leads to groupthink—a world where a relatively like-minded cadre of EA organizations mutually self-reinforce and direct themselves toward similar visions of optimal giving. I write often on early-20th century eugenics, where the charitable arms of Carnegie, Ford, and others did, in fact, fall prey to groupthink, with horrific consequences.

EA received a certain taste of this risk when Samuel Bankman-Fried (“SBF”) emerged as perhaps earth’s most visible public face of EA. Given the adulation he had received and the spectacular manner of his fall, one might guess that divine laughter was especially hearty in the wake of that particular man’s plans.

He was a grifter, too, which ought to be some kind of a clue.

OPEN THREAD: Enjoy!

MY NEW YORK POST COLUMN: The biggest threat to our military just might be DEI indoctrination.. “Last fiscal year, the Army fell 25% short of its recruiting goals. This is a Bud Light-level failure. . . . Back in his anti-war days, former Sen. John Kerry asked who wants to be the last man to die for a mistake. Today the question is: Who wants to be the first?”

I DUNNO, I THINK THIS ARGUMENT MIGHT GET TRACTION WITH THE SUPREME COURT: Harlan Crow’s Lawyers Say Congress Doesn’t Have Authority to Investigate Supreme Court.

Harlan Crow, the Texas billionaire and GOP megadonor with close ties to Clarence Thomas, refused to answer questions from a Senate committee about his years of gifts to the Supreme Court justice.

Crow’s lawyers in a letter to the Senate Judiciary Committee argued that Congress does not have “the authority to investigate Mr. Crow’s personal friendship” with Thomas, according to a copy of the letter reviewed by Bloomberg News.

“The Committee has not identified a valid legislative purpose for its investigation and is not authorized to conduct an ethics investigation of a Supreme Court Justice,” wrote Crow’s lawyers, who are from the law firm Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher. They added that the committee is “targeting Justice Thomas for special and unwarranted opprobrium.”

They just can’t stand a strong Black man in a position of power.

But while Congress has the power to set some constraints over the Court, this mean-spirited and obviously political effort is pretty shady. And I very much doubt that Dick Durbin could withstand the kind of scrutiny he wants to aim at Thomas and Crow.

SIDE EFFECTS OF DYSON SPHERE CONSTRUCTION: Betelgeuse Is Being Weird Again. What Gives?

Not much of a puzzle: When the construction is on our side of the star, it blocks light and dims it. When it orbits around to the far side it reflects light and makes it look brighter. Easy peasy. Remember: The answer is always aliens.

TRUE:

https://twitter.com/aethelamerican/status/1661028805186551808

THIS SHOULD BE OBVIOUS, BUT GOOD: Preliminary Injunction Against ‘Disparag[ing]’ or ‘Frivolous’ Claims About School Board or Employees violates the First Amendment, holds the Louisiana Court of Appeal.

“The School Board also accused Ms. Kellett of being critical of the School Board and publicly discussing ‘her child’s special needs’ and individual education plan with the media. Ms. Kellett allegedly maintained a ‘live web blog and other ongoing social media posts’ that involved discussion and disclosure of information related to the School Board, the special education program, and other identified individuals.”

In other words, know your place, peasant, and don’t criticize your betters.

Make them pay for this arrogance.