Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

IT’S ALWAYS A CRIME NOT TO COMPLY WITH THE DEMANDS OF TYRANTS:

DAVID LAT ON THE BERKELEY PROTEST:

So at the end of the day, after the UVA and UC Berkeley protests, I’m left with this question: what’s the purpose of protest?

Is it about public persuasion, winning over the hearts and minds of the undecided people on any given issue? If so, then a UVA-style protest is the way to go. Most outside observers would read about what happened at the Chemerinsky home, identify with the Chemerinskys, and think less of both the protesters and any cause they’re pushing. This is especially true in the legal profession, which is culturally conservative, i.e., more focused on rules and decorum than many other fields.

I have similar concerns about the effectiveness of pro-Palestine protests that blocked the Holland Tunnel in New York and the Bay Bridge in San Francisco for hours, causing hours of traffic delays. If I’m a commuter—perhaps a working-class commuter, who might be docked pay or fired for being late to my job—will protests like that persuade me that the pro-Palestinian cause is just? Or are they just going to make me angry at the protesters?

But in the year 2024 on a university campus, maybe protest isn’t about public persuasion, but performance. And that performativity is for the benefit not of the public, but of the protesters—who get to congratulate themselves on how they took bold action to bring attention to serious injustice.

It’s about harassment and intimidation, not about persuasion. “No justice, no peace” isn’t a request, any more than “your money or your life.”

Related: Students Don’t Have a Right to Use Public University Social Events for Their Own Political Orations, whether at administrators’ homes or in law school classrooms.

For Erwin Chemerinsky, welcome to the party, pal. You were warned.

GOOD FOR HER: JK Rowling to Radcliffe, Watson: Go Stuff Yourselves. “Celebs who cosied up to a movement intent on eroding women’s hard-won rights and who used their platforms to cheer on the transitioning of minors can save their apologies for traumatised detransitioners and vulnerable women reliant on single sex spaces.”

BUT IF YOU’RE STILL A NEVER TRUMPER ARE YOU CAPABLE OF THOUGHT? Kurt Schlichter: Time to Rethink Your Never-Trumpism. “This is getting real. This is life and death. Not just for cops and soldiers, but maybe even for you and your family.”

Plus: “Now, this column isn’t directed towards the professional Never Trumper dorks, the treacherous weirdos who make a living off of going on MSNBC and selling out their former allies. This is for the Republicans who have thought about it and have a real problem with Donald Trump. I get it, even if I don’t agree. I would not particularly like voting for somebody who I don’t like. However, I like Donald Trump and will eagerly support him following his victory over my primary candidate, Ron DeSantis. But sometimes you need to do things you would rather not do. You have to let go of the anger. Even the governor got on board and endorsed the president once the primary results became clear.”

OPEN THREAD: So get to work.