SETH BARRETT TILLMAN: On Reconciliation. “It is said that at the negotiations at Appomattox Courthouse Lee and Grant were both frank and civil during the course of discussing the surrender of Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia. Afterwards, Grant sent food to Lee to feed his (and, then, their) nation’s former enemy soldiers. Celebrations for Grant’s soldiers came only later not while Lee’s soldiers remained present. Again, in ending active hostilities, the first step towards national reconciliation was frank and civil discourse. I do not think our present and future is or will be as difficult as was Grant and Lee’s. But we too have to think about national reconciliation.”
Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds
September 14, 2025
I’VE BEEN WRITING ABOUT THE SECRET SERVICE’S PROBLEMS SINCE THE BEGINNING OF INSTAPUNDIT: Secret Service Faces New Scrutiny After Agent Cheers Charlie Kirk’s Murder.
JONATHAN TURLEY: ‘Prove me wrong’ — Charlie Kirk and the age of rage.
Charlie was brave, and he was brash. He refused to yield to the threats while encouraging others to speak out on our campuses.
He was particularly hated for holding a mirror to the face of higher education, exposing the hate and hypocrisy on our campuses. For decades, faculty have purged their ranks of conservatives and libertarians. Faced with the intolerance of most schools, polls show that a large percentage of students hide their values to avoid retaliation from faculty or their fellow students.Charlie chose to change all that. TPUSA challenges people to engage and debate them. The response from some on the left has been to trash their tables and threaten the students. Recently, at UC Davis, police stood by and watched as a TPUSA tent was torn apart. . . .
Charlie was hated because he exposed the left’s intolerance of opposing views … all in the purported cause of achieving greater tolerance. By challenging others to debate, he triggered a generation of speech-phobics who are more interested in silencing others than speaking on their own account.
Charlie was hated for stripping away the pretense and self-delusion of those canceling, blacklisting, and attacking others for holding opposing views. He did so by standing in harm’s way.
The conservatives that Kirk coaxed out of the shadows can honor his memory by showing that they will not be silenced. They can step forward and renew his same challenge: “Prove me wrong.”
Yes.
September 13, 2025
OPEN THREAD: You know what to do.
PROFESSOR CARRINGTON, CALL YOUR OFFICE: Aurora alert! Butterfly-shaped ‘hole’ in sun’s atmosphere could spark geomagnetic storm Sept. 13-14.
“IF YOU STRIKE ME DOWN” . . .
Crowds are now chanting “we are Charlie Kirk” in South Korea 🇰🇷
This movement is worldwide..
pic.twitter.com/cQvkSTrciI— Benny Johnson (@bennyjohnson) September 13, 2025
NEW STATUS QUESTION: What’s your protocol?
MY LATEST SUBSTACK ESSAY: When the Preference Cascade Becomes a Flood: Everything is becoming clear.
UPDATE:
That’s why “it feels like something is different now.” They have realized the left is playing for keeps and sees them as subhuman monsters. Watching otherwise pleasant leftist friends or family or colleagues celebrating Kirk’s death on main with their real names attached. It’ll…
— nic carter (@nic__carter) September 13, 2025
YEP.
This is what they would have done to Trump and his supporters if he had lost.
We cannot risk letting these people take power again. https://t.co/7LGEsRdvrs
— Nate Fischer (@NateAFischer) September 13, 2025
WELL, THAT SOUNDS NICE: Tested! The Porsche Panamera Turbo S E-Hybrid Is a 5,700-Pound Sedan That Runs Like a Supercar.
SOLID ADVICE:
The British government should listen to it’s people.
The government of Nepal didn’t.— DToecutter (@DToecutter) September 13, 2025
NEWS YOU CAN USE: Concealed Carry: The First Steps.
BEWARE OF CUTENESS: The perfect robot guide dog shouldn’t be cute.
My guess is that they wasted 17+ months on pointless meetings, then threw something together at the last minute, cheating with ChatGPT.
THERE ARE TOO MANY: Vandals spray-paint ‘Kill all Charlie Kirks’ on Seattle Central College sign.
THE LEFT’S BIGGEST FEAR IS THAT THE NORMALS WILL START TO STAND UP FOR THEMSELVES. That’s why they hate Kyle Rittenhouse, and that’s why they killed Charlie Kirk.
He shot a burglar, domestic abuser, and child rapist in self-defense.
He didn't commit political violence, he defended himself from it. https://t.co/hn9gWChHnd
— Kangmin Lee | 이강민 (@kangminjlee) September 12, 2025
Related:
He RIPPED the sign off my table just after saying that I am “destructive” to society and that someone must stop me.
What did the sign say?
“People shouldn’t be killed over opinions – R.I.P. Charlie” pic.twitter.com/E7hwra0Gjf
— Cam Higby 🇺🇸 (@camhigby) September 13, 2025
Also:
🚨BREAKING: More than one MILLION patriots conquer London for a Tommy Robinson march
They just made a million Charlie Kirks. pic.twitter.com/rDfZzV4J0b
— Inevitable West (@Inevitablewest) September 13, 2025
NAILED IT:
I don’t post memes often, but the one sent by a close friend was too good to not post: pic.twitter.com/d1uZWaGTIG
— DataRepublican (small r) (@DataRepublican) September 12, 2025
MEANWHILE, IN LONDON:
THE UK's LARGEST FREE SPEECH FESTIVAL – UNITING THE KINGDOM https://t.co/VjHYVFr422
— Tommy Robinson 🇬🇧 (@TRobinsonNewEra) September 13, 2025
Millions & millions are rising , we will honour @charliekirk11 ❤️❤️ pic.twitter.com/pBmElv44cK
— Tommy Robinson 🇬🇧 (@TRobinsonNewEra) September 13, 2025
Is see the mainstream media have started with the smears of “far-right”.
They just can’t help themselves. https://t.co/WNgwIEI74s
— J Stewart (@triffic_stuff_) September 13, 2025
“Far-right” is hate speech. As we’ve seen with Charlie Kirk, it’s a dog-whistle for leftist violence.
EUGENE VOLOKH ON Firing Public Employees Who Publicly Praise Violent Criminal Attacks. “There is no categorical exception even as to government employment for speech that praises violence.”
Related: Is It Cancel Culture to Go After the Charlie Kirk Assassination Celebrators?
Flashback: Hair Pulling Time.
There’s an old joke about a boy who complains to his mother that his little sister keeps pulling his hair.
“Oh,” responds the mother, “she doesn’t know that it hurts.”
A few minutes later, the mother hears the girl scream and runs into the other room. “She knows now,” the boy explains.
There’s a lesson for Republicans in that old joke, if they’re smart enough to absorb it.
I have doubts about these firings, but no doubts about the importance of the lessons being driven home. The courts can sort it out later, just like they did (sometimes) when so many people on the right were being cancelled. In the meantime, the leftist culture of impunity — where they can’t even imagine paying a price for their behavior because they feel insulated by their politics — is taking a much-needed hit.
Related:
So, they think Charlie Kirk (who was far kinder and more patient than they deserved) should die for his words.
But they should face no consequences whatsoever for theirs. Quite the contrary.
— A Ruthless (@ARuthless8) September 12, 2025
As science shows, tit-for-tat is a highly effective strategy.
YEP:
They could have hit the brakes after the softball shooting. They didn't.
They could have hit the brakes after the SPLC shooting, but they didn't.
They could have hit the brakes after the Rand Paul beating, but they didn't.
They could have hit the brakes after the 2 Trump… https://t.co/Kx1Z8dsdwX
— Stephen L. Miller (@redsteeze) September 13, 2025
Either we fight back or they will kill us https://t.co/pCQHFHCVml
— Elon Musk (@elonmusk) September 13, 2025
For years, Nancy Pelosi blamed Republicans for their rhetoric, declaring “words matter. Truth matters. Accountability matters.” No longer. Now she insists that “we can’t take responsibility for the minds that are out there and how they hear it"… https://t.co/ClIkeFXFoD
— Jonathan Turley (@JonathanTurley) September 13, 2025
This is a fun way to say government schools are teaching children to murder republicans https://t.co/gFvVoMJuoD
— Auron MacIntyre (@AuronMacintyre) September 13, 2025
People losing their jobs after cheering Charlie Kirk’s death isn’t about “sharing opinions” in the abstract
This is about openly celebrating cold-blooded murder while claiming that the victim deserved what he got@NBCNews, you have stooped too low—again https://t.co/JGJfNVJODs
— Mike Lee (@BasedMikeLee) September 13, 2025
The firings make them realize they are losing culturally https://t.co/zn3xToFJMM
— Tim Pool (@Timcast) September 13, 2025