Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

THE PRESS IS NOT A FRIEND OF FREEDOM, NOR AN ENEMY OF TYRANTS TODAY, IF IT EVER WAS:

WHY DOES THE NEW YORK TIMES HATE WOMEN? A response to the NYT’s ad unpersoning J.K. Rowling.

#RESIST: I saw this myself in Knoxville yesterday while buying gas.

Note that it was placed over an earlier one that someone, presumably a Biden supporter, tried to peel off.

Meanwhile, a reader sends this from Montgomery County, Pennsylvania:

Plus, from Newport, Rhode Island:

And there’s this from North of Dallas:

He writes: “Photo from ‘Far North’ Dallas last night (2/19). Resist Is Real. 5 stickers. 2 poorly removed stickers placed over 2 earlier poorly removed stickers. One recent sticker. Very busy 8 pump 7/11 location.”

Plus, from another reader: “Not sure if you’ve seen this phenomenon yet, but in hindsight it seems inevitable. I was filling up my gas tank in Manchester, TN yesterday and discovered they were selling Biden ‘I did that’ stickers at the check out counter. Why not? You can fight it or get your cut. I laughed out loud.”

And, finally, this variant from San Juan Capistrano, California:

The #Resistance is real, and it’s everywhere.

WELL, I DUNNO ABOUT A KNIGHTHOOD:

THOUGHTS ON ACADEMIC FREEDOM:

Institutional academic freedom, however, is commonly more limited than personal academic freedom. A professor’s freedom to teach English 101 is limited to what the English department requires in that course. The English department’s freedom to set the curriculum is limited by the minimum graduation requirements for each degree. And the university’s freedom is limited by the legislature’s decisions about what to fund and what not to fund.

Usually, legislators are content to leave universities alone to make their own funding decisions. This forbearance fails, however, when the academy becomes a force of ideological conformity. An egregiously imbalanced faculty can limit the ability of a college to expose students to a wide range of ideas, undermining its core mission. Furthermore, there is evidence that faculty on the left use their majority influence to enforce conformity through hiring and promotion decisions. That influence introduces bias in curriculum, speakers, programs and federal grants, inhibiting the robust academic dialogue that facilitates an apolitical search for truth.

In these cases, where there is viewpoint discrimination against ideas and scholars who are outside the norm, and even more so when that norm is at odds with the norms of the non-university community, there is a democratically justifiable reason for elected officials to intervene. The intervention should not reach to the level of defunding individual professors, but it certainly reaches to the funding of new academic units desired by the funding public.

Such an intervention may even be necessary to preserve the very basis on which academic freedom is justified in the first place: a true marketplace of ideas.

In my opinion, administrators have no claim to academic freedom, but they’re the ones calling the shots in many cases. If they attract the attention of the legislature, that’s their problem.

Plus:

Arizona led the nation in establishing “freedom centers” to promote civic education, leadership, statesmanship and the understanding and appreciation for freedom. The centers are now national models of debate and dialogue. Texas and Tennessee are now also considering or taking action on similar proposals at their flagship universities.

Left-leaning faculty at these institutions resist these programs, claiming that their very existence threatens academic freedom and faculty governance. But a public institution serves the public, and the real principle is not faculty governance but shared governance. Furthermore, the complaining faculty may need to check their privilege as members of the dominant ideology on campus. The lived experience of their colleagues with minority viewpoints may reveal that faculty governance can itself undermine academic freedom.

Just look at the political donation records of the faculty at any state university — including mine — and it looks like an ideological monoculture. If we want universities that “look like America,” maybe they should break down politically like America. Which would be a dramatic, wrenching change for basically all universities. But we’re told that we should embrace dramatic, wrenching, painful change in the name of diversity. So be it.

I REMEMBER WHEN ALL THINKING PEOPLE MADE FUN OF BOWDLERIZATION: How Sensitivity Readers Corrupt Literature. Instead of “sensitivity readers” we need “suck it up!” publishers.

PROFESSOR CARRINGTON, CALL YOUR OFFICE: “FLARES ON THE HORIZON: The northeastern limb of the sun is surging with flares–a sign that old sunspot AR2936 (described below) is about to return. NASA’s Solar Dynamics Observatory recorded this C5-class explosion during the early hours of Feb. 20th. The flare was stronger than it appeared. It was partially eclipsed by the edge of the sun. Unobstructed, the explosion was probably M-class. The underlying sunspot will soon emerge into view, potentially exposing Earth to a source of strong flares.”

ELIZABETH NICKSON: The Reason for the Police Violence in Ottawa Isn’t What You Think: It’s Way Worse.

The black clad army of mercenaries and police brutalizing a peaceful protest in Ottawa this weekend has been planned for years. It is overkill for a reason. It is theatre. It is an othering, a willful flagrant statement on the future of the working class everywhere. It instructs them: you will die. If not now, then sometime in the next ten years. Your towns will be gutted, your jobs will evaporate, you will scramble for pennies until you fall over dead and your children will have nothing to look forward to. You are Tutsi, you are Jew, you are Kulak, you are compromador, you are Othered. You are headed for the slagheap of history. Fight back and you will be deemed domestic terrorists and encamped indefinitely.

It’s funny, the gradualistic approach was working but now they seem desperate, like a window is closing somewhere.

Related:

DEEP THOUGHTS FROM KAMALA: