Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds
October 18, 2022
INSTITUTIONAL SEXISM: Identifying as Female Doubles Your Chances of Getting Into MIT.
BLASPHEMY! Conservative students’ anti-Marxism display shut down at University of Illinois Chicago. “It’s scary that we may face disciplinary action simply because we passed out literature critical of a communist murderer and terrorist.” You left out racist and homophobe.
CULTURE OF CORRUPTION: Hunter Biden’s firm took $40M payment from Russian oligarch “to enter the American market.”
PHIL HAMBURGER: America Needs a New Civil Rights Act: The 1964 law targeted racial discrimination. Today’s problem is the suppression of dissent.
The threat again comes from discrimination, but now by the federal government as well as states and private organizations. Most worrisome is federal and state encouragement for private entities to discriminate against Americans with dissenting views. Also significant is discrimination that bars Americans from participating in services ordinarily open to the public.
An example of the latter is PayPal’s recent announcement that it will confiscate $2,500 from customers who spread “misinformation.”
The company later claimed the announcement was “incorrect information”—dare one say “misinformation”? But it turns out that PayPal still threatens to take $2,500 from customers for promoting “intolerance that is discriminatory.” Perhaps it should fine itself.
At least PayPal’s sharp treatment of its customers ensured a sharp reaction. Many canceled their accounts, and the company’s stock price dropped 6% in one day. When companies are too crude in their censoriousness, cancellation can go two ways.
Too often, however, private and government discrimination isn’t as candid and doesn’t provoke a concentrated response. Private professional organizations—for example, those overseeing lawyers and even real-estate agents—are taking aim at practitioners who don’t have the most up-to-date views on race under the guise of barring racial discrimination. Yet the response is muted because the assault on dissent is subtle and many critics within the professions are fearful. PayPal is exceptional only in its ham-handedness, and we can’t assume market remedies will suffice for more sophisticated discrimination.
Private organizations don’t always act on their own. Government works through social-media platforms to censor Americans who refuse to follow orthodoxy on Covid-19 and election fraud. It uses interpretations of Title IX, which bans sex discrimination in schools, to require private regulation of speech about sex, including dissent on sexual politics. For decades the federal government has demanded that universities establish institutional review boards to license much academic inquiry and publication, predictably with a tilt against scholars whose views are deemed old-fashioned or insensitive.
States are no better. Many leave the regulation of lawyers to bar associations, some of which are adopting rules that penalize lawyers for “discrimination,” understood to include insufficiently advanced opinion. Some police forces tie promotions to education—provided by organizations that discriminate against the unwoke.
If federal or state governments engaged in viewpoint discrimination, they would violate the First Amendment. But they seem to think they can evade constitutional limits by getting private entities to do their dirty work.
Prior to the Civil Rights Act, people said “they’re private companies, they can discriminate if they want to.” That changed, and it can change again with regard to censorship.
OUT: LIBERAL LAW PROFESSORS CALLING THE SUPREME COURT A MORAL TEACHER. In: Liberal Law Professors saying to treat the Supreme Court as a “hostile political actor.”
HAHA, THEY ALWAYS BLAME “MESSAGING” WHEN THE DOG DOESN’T LIKE THE DOG FOOD: Liberal Media Scream: It’s Biden’s communications, not his policies, failing him.
AGAINST THE GREAT RESET: ‘Then Fall, Davos’.
IT’S A ROGUE AGENCY: Durham: The FBI is the “elephant in the room” in Danchenko trial.
TO BE FAIR, HE WAS NEVER A QUICK LEARNER: Charles Blow’s sudden revelation on the universality of racism.
It’s always somewhat amusing to watch a certain kind of anti-racist progressive reckon with the fact that various non-white groups can dislike one another, and that the way that that animosity manifests is — at least in the contemporary United States — often far more bitter and explicitly racist than white racism itself. Blow doesn’t explain how or why the anti-black racism of the Latino L.A. councilmembers is “the work of white supremacy” — these are the kinds of things that are asserted, not argued — but then again, recognizing that ethnic conflict and tribalism exist everywhere, across time, place, and race, would be deeply inconvenient for a number of progressive premises about America and the logic of intersectionality.
The fact is that non-whites are often every bit as racist as whites, for reasons that have far more to do with the brokenness of human nature than any abstract system of white supremacy. Blow himself has acknowledged this in the past — in response to a 2016 story about a Chinese detergent commercial promoting its product’s ability to turn a black man into a fairer-skinned Asian one, the Times columnist thundered: “Anti-black racism is a GLOBAL scourge!” In fact, the United States is far less racist than other comparable multiracial societies — Hollywood movies hoping to make inroads in the Chinese market infamously diminished or fully cut out black characters to appeal to the country’s antipathy to blackness. But I don’t expect Blow to reckon with those contradictions anytime soon. If you’re a hammer, everything starts to look like a nail.
It’s hard to teach a man something when his salary depends on not learning it. And Blow’s role at the NYT depends on not recognizing certain obvious truths that, if recognized, would wreck the preferred narrative.
GOOGLE IS BUILT ON LIES AND EXPLOITATION: Google employees joked about how ‘Incognito mode’ is ‘not truly private.’
Google employees cracked jokes about the Chrome browser’s “Incognito mode” and criticized the company for not living up to its users’ expectations for privacy, according to a series of internal communications unearthed in court.
In one 2018 chat, a Google engineer proposed changing Incognito mode’s icon to “Guy Incognito,” a character from the Simpsons known for looking identical to protagonist Homer Simpson except for a mustache, according to court documents reported by Bloomberg.
The character’s lazy disguise “accurately conveys the level of privacy [Incognito mode] provides” in comparison to Chrome’s standard browsing mode, the employee said.
Don’t trust Google.
October 17, 2022
OPEN THREAD: Do your best work.
GOOD: Puerto Rico gets Jones Act waiver for liquefied natural gas shipments.
Should probably provide one for New England, too: New England risks winter blackouts as gas supplies tighten. “New England has been grappling with fuel-supply challenges for more than a decade because the region has limited pipeline capacity. Imports of LNG can make up more than a third of the region’s natural-gas supply during periods of peak demand, according to the Energy Information Administration. The Jones Act, a law restricting the movement of ships between U.S. ports, makes maritime delivery of domestic supplies nearly impossible, so the region relies on gas produced abroad. Now, intense competition for LNG cargoes driven by European demand makes securing supply ad hoc a costly proposition”
Some new pipelines would be nice.
“LUXURY BELIEFS” NOT WINNING OVER NON-LUXURY VOTERS: Republicans Gain Edge as Voters Worry About Economy, Times/Siena Poll Finds. “With inflation unrelenting and the stock market steadily on the decline, the share of likely voters who said economic concerns were the most important issues facing America has leaped since July, to 44% from 36% — far higher than any other issue. And voters most concerned with the economy favored Republicans overwhelmingly, by more than a 2-1 margin. . . . The biggest shift came from women who identified as independent voters. In September, they favored Democrats by 14 points. Now, independent women backed Republicans by 18 points — a striking swing given the polarization of the American electorate and how intensely Democrats have focused on that group and on the threat Republicans pose to abortion rights. The survey showed that the economy remained a far more potent political issue in 2022 than abortion.”
A friend writes: “My observation: just as the right to your life is a prerequisite to enjoy any other right like free speech, bearing arms, or voting; basic needs like food, shelter, and energy must be met before people can afford to focus on wonky policy disagreements over abortion and democracy.”
Yep. You have to work your way up from the bottom of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, not down from the top.
THE OPPOSITE OF CLARENCE THOMAS IN SO MANY WAYS: Justice Jackson Sets Record for New Justice in October Arguments: The Court’s newest justice was an extremely active questioner during the Supreme Court’s October arguments.
LAW REVIEWS ARE RUN BY LAW STUDENTS. SOMETIMES WELL, SOMETIMES NOT. Law Prof Bemoans His Experience Publishing An Article In The Iowa Law Review.
TEACH WOMEN NOT TO RAPE! (CONT’D): Ohio softball coach pleads guilty after sleeping with student, begged them not to tell.. “Ashley Rison, 31, an employee at New Miami High School, is facing five years in jail after pleading guilty Wednesday to sexual battery and gross sexual imposition in response to allegations she had sex with a 17-year-old student, WXIX-TV reported.”
HOW THE BORDER WENT MAGA:
Democrats underrate the regional appeal of conservatism at their own peril. From 2015 to 2021, Will Hurd was the congressman for the sprawling border district now represented by Tony Gonzales. “In 2020, the number of Latinos voting for Republicans was not a surprise,” he asserts. Citing the high proportion of people across the borderlands who work in law enforcement and the concentration of oil and natural gas production in the Permian Basin that bridges West Texas and eastern New Mexico, Hurd believes it was the progressive embrace of criminal-justice reform and green energy that motivated many in the region to vote for Trump. “What was happening in 2020 was these initiatives within the Democratic party were impacting the livelihoods of people that lived along the border, that was the significant difference.” . . . As Laura Gómez, a law professor at the University of California, Los Angeles, put it when I reached her at her home in Albuquerque, “From the Trump years on, the nation has gone through tremendous changes. Politically, ideologically. Why wouldn’t we expect that Latinos have also been changing?”
Via a friend, who comments: “Author also visibly puzzles over how some Mexican immigrants make a distinction between those who did so legally vs. illegally after remarking upon how bizarre it is that Trump’s support went up [after he] supposedly called immigrants rapists. It’s like the author sees it but can’t make sense of it due to such deep bias.”
IMPORTANT HEALTH ADVICE: “Colonoscopy is not effective if you don’t do it.”