HIGHER EDUCATION BUBBLE UPDATE: High-paying trade jobs sit empty even as college degrees drop in value.
Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds
February 18, 2023
WE WOULD BE BETTER OFF WITHOUT EDUCATION COLLEGES: National K-12 teacher shortage due to education colleges pushing ‘radical philosophy’, expert argues.
Related: Texas professor instructs elementary school teachers on how to ‘interrogate whiteness.’
HOW THE WORKING CLASSES ARE BEING SACRIFICED to elite virtue-signaling.
FETTERMAN NATION INDEED: Navy drops physical fitness requirement, offers travel for abortions.
21ST CENTURY RELATIONSHIPS: Judge Rules Woman Has No Parental Rights For Son She Raised With Ex-Wife, But Sperm Donor Does.
PERSONNEL IS POLICY: Top Biden Nat Sec Official Finds Time To Talk About His Top 40 Albums of 2022.
Well, it’s not like there’s much going on in the world right now. Seriously, I wouldn’t care about any of this stuff if people in this Administration — and especially its national security apparatus — were doing their jobs. But they’re not, and it shows.
ANDREW SULLIVAN: The Greatest Scandal In Gay Rights History? How journalists – yes, journalists – want to shut down reporting on child transition.
Five years ago when I wrote “We All Live On Campus Now,” I noted how illiberal practices that originated in elite colleges — bullying, ostracism, public condemnation, speech shutdowns, purges of dissenters — were becoming common in every sphere of life, super-charged by social media. From 2020 on, that dynamic has intensified, especially in journalism, with the media purges of 2020 lifted straight from the campus woke playbook.
And this week, we saw another campus maneuver: an open letter from a thousand or so New York Times contributors, accusing the NYT of “follow[ing] the lead of far-right hate groups” in its coverage of transgender issues. Other campus tactics: a loud demo outside; alliance between insiders and outsider activists; public shaming of named journalists; accusations that the NYT is a “workplace made hostile by bias” (the now-familiar HR gambit); and non-negotiable demands for even more hiring solely on the basis of identity and ideology.
It’s an echo of Evergreen and Yale and Middlebury and Reed. The ploys are repeated because they work and there’s no downside. And almost all the university presidents caved. They held meetings and meetings; they apologized; they appeased; they conceded core liberal principles of free speech and dissent; they terminated dissident faculty; they equivocated and collaborated in the pursuit of “diversity” and then “equity.” In a word, they were pathetic.
Get the Dish free every Friday
And in the summer of 2020, when campus tactics invaded newsrooms, and writers and editors were purged for committing journalism that violated the orthodoxies of social justice, we saw a similar collapse of nerve.
But this time was different. Check this out, from the executive editor of the NYT. It’s the response we always needed from the leadership of besieged liberal institutions before and never got.
Plus:
The letter has no factual criticisms. It has three quibbles: that Grace Lidinsky-Smith was presented as “an individual person speaking about a personal choice to detransition, rather than the President of GCCAN, an activist organization that pushes junk science and partners with explicitly anti-trans hate groups.” Yes, Lidinsky-Smith became an activist after a traumatizing de-transitioning, but GCCAN is an organization designed for “gender-affirming care” patients.
Another NYT piece “failed to make clear that court cases brought by parents who want schools to out their trans children are part of a legal strategy pursued by anti-trans hate groups.” But the piece has several paragraphs highlighting the acute discomfort many liberal parents had when allying with conservative groups, which they otherwise opposed. The third complaint: that Bazelon used the term “Patient Zero” as a slur to describe the first minor patient to undergo the new affirmation-and-medicalization experiment in Holland. Please.
And that’s it. Seriously, it’s all they’ve got. The point of the letter is not that the pieces had errors, but that they were published at all. They shouldn’t have run because opposition to affirmation-only transition for gender dysphoric children is entirely illegitimate, and the task of journalists who already know this is to suppress rather than describe the argument. As the sign at the protest outside the NYT blared: “The Science Is Settled,” as if science is ever “settled,” and as if journalism is about ignoring and censoring controversy, not reporting and airing it.
Also:
One historical analogy does seem salient to me, though: the drugs they now give to gender-dysphoric teens are very closely related to the drugs they used to “cure” Alan Turing of his gayness. Every time I think of that I shudder.
And this attempt to suppress reporting on the subject comes at a very strange time. Next week, a new book will be published about the Tavistock Centre, the place responsible for the medical and psychological treatment of children with gender dysphoria in Britain. It’s written by a liberal female journalist, Hannah Barnes, of a flagship British documentary show, Newsnight.
Her book exposes a huge medical scandal, in which countless children were put on puberty blockers with almost no psychological evaluation, and with rates of autism and domestic abuse that were already through the roof. It shows what happened when the new affirmation-only puberty-blocker experiment, only begun in the late 1990s, was left to run its course, with no opposition and no dissent allowed. Check out an extract here. . . . More than a third of the kids pushed onto the trans track had autism, sometimes severe. Others were victims of domestic abuse: “[A natal girl] who’s being abused by a male, I think a question to ask is whether there’s some relationship between identifying as male and feeling safe,” one clinician at the center said. No questions about other aspects of a child’s mental health were considered if the kid was identifying as the opposite sex. And this took place in a socialized system, with constant oversight, and no massive financial incentives to treat children. Just imagine what could be happening in the US private system where trans patients are among the most lucrative to have in your care, and are under treatment their entire life.
Actually, don’t imagine — check out the affidavit of Jamie Reed, a lefty progressive whistleblower who worked at a similar clinic in the US.
Read the whole thing.
DON’T HAND OVER YOUR GOVERNMENT TO LOONY THUGS — A CAUTIONARY TALE: Vikings are RACIST: Life in the British police state.
IF IT WEREN’T FOR DOUBLE STANDARDS, THEY’D HAVE NO STANDARDS AT ALL.

AND THEY’RE MISINFORMED: Only 25% of Americans believe the news media.
THIS COULD BE AN INTERESTING COURSE, DONE RIGHT: Law school course praised for studying ‘Historical Origins of White Supremacy.’
Here’s how I’d structure it if I were teaching it, each item indicating a phase of the course:
I. Pre-modern times: Basically no real concept of race. People from southern latitudes were considered to be burned black by the sun, but not thought inferior because of that. (Before Isabella, Ferdinand’s family negotiated to marry him to an Ethiopian princess, since Ethiopia was a rich and powerful Christian kingdom. Nobody cared about race, though there might have been religious issues (I think she was Coptic), but those could be dealt with, apparently.)
II. Early trade with Africa: Portugese explorers, etc.: Hey, these people are a lot like us. They have cities, kings, taxes, armies, etc. We can’t beat them militarily but they’re happy to trade. They’ll sell us slaves for gold, and for firearms and manufactured goods! We can use those in our sugar colonies, etc. [Africans: These Europeans will buy slaves for gold, and better yet firearms and manufactured goods! That will help us finance our wars, where we will capture more slaves to sell!]
III. Europeans: Now that we’re buying a lot of slaves, we’ve decided that they must be inferior, which justifies the slavery, about which we feel a tiny bit uncomfortable. [Africans: This trade is great! Keep it up!]
IV. White people rule! “White supremacy” is just taken for granted almost everywhere. New scientific community gives a scientific sheen to theories of superiority. “Progressives” push segregation, discriminatory government policies, eugenics.
V. General theories of equality make this less and less appealing, then Nazi racial ideology suddenly makes race-supremacy theories unacceptable basically everywhere post-war.
VI. Move toward equality, we’re all the same under the skin, etc. Peaking in early to mid 1970s.
VII. Progressives rediscover theories of race, repackage white supremacy and segregation as woke politics. Return of racial identity politics, institutional segregation, etc. Denial of common humanity as more important than racial character. Brings us to today.
You can teach almost anything and make it interesting and educational. The course syllabus linked in the story isn’t all bad, but the heavy reliance on the likes of Howard Zinn and the 1619 Project seems dubious.
Related: A Syllabus for the Occupy Movement.
February 17, 2023
EVERY INSTITUTION HAS BEEN CORRUPTED: How Biden and Fetterman Crushed My Faith in Doctors.
IF WHITE SUPREMACY IS REAL, WHY ARE PEOPLE CONSTANTLY PRETENDING TO BE MINORITIES? Arab-Latina activist working as chief equity officer for progressive group is actually a white woman.
The obvious question raised by this incident is how Rachel was able to get away with it. The Intercept notes that the DEI has become a big business very quickly and, as a result, the qualifications and backgrounds of people claiming jobs are sometimes not looked at as carefully as they should be. Sana Saeed, an Al Jazeera media critic, told the Intercept the hiring of Raquel/Rachel was “a damning indictment of how superficial and detrimental, to safe and inclusive workplaces, DEI can often be.”
I see something besides sloppiness at work here. Oskar Pierre Castro, who led the search committee to fill the DEI position, described how Raquel/Rachel seemed like an ideal candidate.
“It really touched all the points,” said Castro…
Castro added, “In my mind it was, ‘Great, a person of color, a queer person of color, who happens to be a Muslim, it’s a woman, all these things, and someone who seemed to get it. I definitely feel conned. … I feel deceived.”
He feels conned because he was conned.
Raquel/Rachel presented exactly what he was looking for in a candidate. Saying she “touched all the points” is a nicer way of saying she checked all the boxes. Queer – check. Person of color – check. Muslim – check. Woman – check. If you think of intersectionality as a kind of progressive credit score, Raquel Evita Saraswati would have scored near the top thanks to her fake identity. If she’d just been a Muslim white woman, that wouldn’t have been quite as impressive. Maybe then they’d have taken a little more time thinking about her actual qualifications in that case. But as it was, she was simply too perfect to pass up.
Like I said, if there’s so much bigotry out there, why all the fakery? Back when white supremacy was actually a thing, black people tried to pass as white, not the other way around.
A WHITE HOUSE OF HATE: Biden: White people love watching lynchings, even now.
THE ENEMY WITHIN: Head of German intelligence unit was a Russian double agent.
I don’t have a lot of confidence in our intelligence agencies ither.
ANALYSIS: TRUE.

BOB MCMANUS TO KATHY HOCHUL: An iron fist in a velvet glove, gov? You wish Kathy!
OPEN THREAD: Discuss the events of the day.
UP, UP AND AWAY: Ingenuity helicopter aces 43rd Mars flight, its longest in 10 months. “During its 43 Mars flights to date, Ingenuity has covered a total of 28,968 feet (8,829 m), according to the mission flight log — nearly 5.5 miles (8.9 kilometers). That’s quite impressive for a technology demonstration that was originally supposed to fly just five times on the Red Planet.”
HUGH HEWITT: Anti-Catholic Bigotry at the FBI.
Related: Majority see FBI as Biden’s ‘personal Gestapo’ after Trump raid.
Yeah, the other Gestapo didn’t much like Catholics either.
HOW’S THAT SPACE PROGRAM COMING ALONG? Experts on the Future of Planetary Defense 10 Years After the Chelyabinsk Asteroid Impact’s 440 Kiloton Explosion.
COMMIES GONNA COMMIE, AND DANIEL ORTEGA’S A COMMIE: Nicaragua Strips Citizenship From Hundreds Days After Prisoner Release: The country’s increasingly authoritarian government stripped more than 300 people of their citizenship, including political prisoners recently released and sent to the United States.
“For years, President Daniel Ortega has methodically crushed dissent, cracking down violently on protesters, undermining democratic institutions and making sweeping arrests.”
Who does he think he is, Justin Trudeau?