Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

HMM: There’s a glaring issue with the AI moratorium letter: The statement makes some valid notes—but critics argue signatories missed the point. Well, criticisms like this don’t overwhelm me: “The ‘open letter’ says nothing about social justice.”

Also, all things being equal I’m inclined to give more weight to the thoughts of Elon Musk and Steve Wozniak on this subject than to the thoughts of professors of history and philosophy. Not that there’s anything wrong with those.

THAT WOULD TAKE A LONG LINE: Deepest ever fish caught on camera off Japan. “The species – a type of snailfish of the genus Pseudoliparis – was filmed swimming at 8,336m (27,349ft).”

MICHAEL WALSH ON CLIMATE CHANGE: Actually, It Is ‘Blah, Blah, Blah.’ “They have driven themselves so mad that the sight of a puff of smoke coming from a chimney or the sight of a cow’s ass throws them into paroxysms of panic. And to accommodate their madness, we have to stop driving, stop heating our homes, stop cooking our food, stop traveling, stop. We’ve even got our military believing that ‘fighting ‘climate change’ is its top priority instead of killing our enemies. Which is why they are, at root, a Suicide Cult.”

DON SURBER: Blaming White Republicans. Well, you know, the font of all evil.

Plus: “AP leaves a lot of important stuff out of stories.” They see leaving out important stuff as the most vital part of their job.

Related: CBS News reportedly barring staff from using term ‘transgender’ to reference Nashville shooter: A trans male murdered six people, including three children, at a private Christian school.

If you know unapproved things, you might start thinking unapproved thoughts.

I’VE SEEN THE LOCKDOWNS AND THE DAMAGE DONE: 2023 Multistate Bar Exam Scores Fall To All-Time Low, Likely Due To Covid Disruptions Faced By Class of 2022.

Looking at the graphic, the big news to me is the huge falloff — quite steep — since 2012. What happened a decade ago? More on that here.

Law schools want to get away from the LSAT in order to allow more affirmative action. But it’s well established that below a certain LSAT score, students have virtually no chance of passing the bar exam. Getting rid of the LSAT won’t help those students pass the bar, though. The next step is probably watering down the bar exam in the name of “equity.”

SETH BARRETT TILLMAN: Jeffrey Blehar and the Problem at National Review. “It is virtue signaling.”

On the right, class and tribal loyalties often trump politics. On the left, not so much. This is why so many people on the right go wobbly.

ANDY KESSLER: Does AI Dream of Electric Sheep?

I had a weird dream last night. I’m sure you’ve said that many times. But why? From Sigmund Freud to Carl Jung to Calvin Hall, dreams have been researched ad nauseam and there’s still no good answer to what shapes them. Unconscious desires? Keeping neurons active? Memory consolidation? Psychosexual wish fulfillment? No one knows. Even Freud supposedly noted, “Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.”

But clues are starting to emerge from artificial intelligence and its use of brain-mimicking neural networks. In 1968, Philip K. Dick published the novel “Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?”—on which the 1982 movie “Blade Runner” was based. Turns out the answer is yes. . . .

In 1970 Finnish student Seppo Linnainmaa proposed “back-propagation”—again oversimplifying here—sending errors backward through neural-network layers to generalize the weightings and better find patterns. It wasn’t until a 1986 paper “Learning representations by back-propagating errors”—whose co-authors included Geoffrey Hinton, a patriarch of neural-network research—that back-propagation research took off. It took another 20 years for the method to scale, which is why voice and facial-recognition AI work well today.

Now the current theories: In 2020 neuroscientist Erik Hoel, then a professor at Tufts University, postulated that human brains get stuck overfitting in the same way and need to generalize to overcome the problem. Mr. Hoel suggests the brain “does that by having wild, crazy experiences every night.” He hypothesized that “dreams as a form of purposefully corrupted input likely derived from noise injected into the hierarchical structure of the brain.” Sound familiar? Yes, maybe dreams are back-propagation that inject noise and errors to unfit or generalize our own pattern recognition. That would explain why our dreams are so weird.

Interesting.

IT’S NOT ENOUGH TO BE HOT: Finland: Sanna Marin Loses. “Finland’s main conservative party claimed victory in parliamentary elections Sunday in a tight three-way race that saw right-wing populists take second place, leaving Prime Minister Sanna Marin’s Social Democratic Party in third, dashing her hopes for reelection. . . . While Russia’s invasion of Ukraine prompted Finland to seek NATO membership in May 2022, neither the historic decision to abandon the nation’s non-alignment policy nor the war emerged as major campaign issues as there was a large consensus among the parties on membership.”

OPEN THREAD: Enjoy each other’s company.