Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

MY NEW YORK POST COLUMN: Democrats throwing black voters under bus for new progressive agenda. “Sorry, black voters. You’re being replaced. . . . Public housing, already in short supply, is being diverted from black citizens to illegal immigrants. Is it really surprising Chicago’s blacks are unhappy? But, you know, when you’re a pushover, you get taken for granted. And when your community goes 97% for the Democrats, you’re a pushover.”

21st CENTURY EDUCATION: I’m a Student. You Have No Idea How Much We’re Using ChatGPT. “There’s a remarkable disconnect between how those with influence over education systems –– teachers, professors, administrators –– think students use generative AI on written work and how we actually use it. As a student, the assumption I’ve encountered among authority figures is that if an essay is written with the help of ChatGPT, there will be some sort of evidence –– the software has a distinctive “voice,” it can’t make very complex arguments (yet), and there are programs that claim to detect AI output. This is a dangerous misconception. In reality, it’s very easy to use AI to do the lion’s share of the thinking while still submitting work that looks like your own.”

TAR. FEATHERS. Diverse Group of Organizations, Law Professors Call on Supreme Court to Hear Case of Grandmother Arrested for Criticizing Local Government Officials.

At the end of April, IJ filed a petition for certiorari with the U.S. Supreme Court asking it to reverse the Fifth Circuit’s ruling providing qualified immunity to a mayor and a police chief who threw a 72-year-old grandmother in jail, after she criticized a city manager, their ally.

Since then, five groups consisting of public interest organizations, renowned advocates, and acclaimed scholars filed their own briefs asking the Supreme Court to grant review and overturn this grievously wrong decision.

“The outpouring of support has been absolutely remarkable,” said IJ Attorney Anya Bidwell. “This has been such a morale boost for Sylvia Gonzalez, our client, who’s been terribly hurt by this whole experience. In addition, it has shown that we’re absolutely right in our interpretation of the law.”

Sylvia was arrested in 2018 after she petitioned her government to remove the city manager. As it turns out, the city manager had powerful friends determined to ensure that Sylvia and others opposing the powers that be knew their place. To punish Sylvia for speaking out, the mayor and the police chief engineered an arrest of the 72-year-old grandmother. Her offense? She supposedly tried to steal the petition to remove the city manager that she herself championed.

The district court saw through this charade and denied qualified immunity to the officials. The Fifth Circuit reversed, holding that Sylvia had not been able to prove that the arrest was only done to retaliate against her, despite evidence that no one had been prosecuted for a similar action in the last decade in Texas. In a 2-1 decision, the judges relied on a previous case that was about police acting in a split-second decision. But again, Sylvia wasn’t arrested at the meeting; her opponents took months trying to figure out how to put her in jail.

“‘Show me the man and I will show you the crime’ is what notorious Soviet secret police leader Lavrentiy Beria once said in boasting about his ability to weaponize the law to punish government critics. What happened to Sylvia is not far removed from that. It’s not the kind of thing that’s supposed to happen in America,” said Patrick Jaicomo, IJ senior attorney.

Too many officials operate in a culture of impunity.

ATOMIC BETTY: Then and Now.

MY NEW YORK POST COLUMN: Democrats throwing black voters under bus for new progressive agenda. “Sorry, black voters. You’re being replaced. . . . Public housing, already in short supply, is being diverted from black citizens to illegal immigrants. Is it really surprising Chicago’s blacks are unhappy? But, you know, when you’re a pushover, you get taken for granted. And when your community goes 97% for the Democrats, you’re a pushover.”

BLUE ON BLUE: Identity politics eats itself in Hispanic-majority Compton. “The story of people of color calling on White leaders to cede power for more diverse representation is deeply rooted in American history. But Compton reflects a newer power struggle, which experts say the nation may see more of in the years to come as traditional White and Black strongholds grow more Latino and the Latino community demands more political representation. . . . It’s important to keep Black people in charge, said Jasmine Gates, 27, founder of the New Black History Makers in Compton, who supported Reynaga’s opponent, Sharif.”

OPEN THREAD: Thread it. Thread it good.

ROBERT STEINBUCH: Academia Is Not A Sideline Career.

I smile when lawyers tell me they want to become professors after they retire. Apparently, to them, academia is equivalent to playing shuffleboard at Del Boca Vista.

The false perception that academia is a side hustle largely arises from confounding the entire enterprise with the act of classroom lecturing–which is merely part of one of academics’ three responsibilities of teaching, scholarship, and service.

Indeed, teaching itself is far more than just lecturing. Good instructors spend more time preparing for classes than conducting them.

I point out to students who complain about the length of my assignments that I read all the assignments myself before every class. I teach without notes, which means I have to load everything into my brain’s equivalent of RAM. Sure, I can remember the important part of cases from year to year, but I can’t quote footnote 4 on page 567 without a refresher.

I could just teach from the same notes every year (or, nowadays, just read from the same Powerpoints) and save myself a lot of work, but then it wouldn’t be fresh.

Plus: “I’m disquieted by the displacement of professional academics resulting from the significant growth of part-time (adjunct) faculty. These folks–earnest as they are–generally teach without engaging in scholarship and service, without dedicating comparable time to class preparation, and without honing their skills in the vocation.”

But they’re cheaper, and cause fewer problems for administrators.

MORE OLDER ADULTS dying from falls. “For one, she said, more older adults these days are surviving serious medical conditions like heart attack and stroke — a good thing. But living with the aftereffects of those conditions can also put people at increased risk of falls. Another factor, Tripken said, is that so many older adults now are taking multiple medications — some of which, or combinations of which, can cause dizziness or other side effects that contribute to falls.”