Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

BARI WEISS: The Washington Post’s Descent Into Middle School Antics: And why we’re building something new.

So let’s get this straight: at the paper that cracked wide open the biggest presidential scandal in history, the paper that has long defined great political reporting, the paper of Katherine Graham and Ben Bradlee and David Broder, journalists lie and publicly attack their colleagues and remain comfortably in their positions. And a reporter is suspended without pay for a retweet. . . .

It’s not that the excellent, old-school reporters aren’t there. They are. They just don’t—or can’t—control the culture.

Partly that’s because of weakness and cowardice at the top of the masthead. Partly it’s because you can pretty much guarantee the kind of worldview you’re going to get when you hire journalists pedigreed by Harvard and Brown and Yale. They tend to think almost exactly the same way about almost every situation—and Twitter only reinforces the groupthink.

So whether the staffers and editors at places like the Times and the Post ignored the riots of summer 2020 while genuflecting to the lunatic idea that op-eds are violence because they were true believers in the new dogma or because they were careerists or because they were just plain scared only meant that some of them broke your heart more than others.

All our institutions have been corrupted. Some of them put up some resistance. Others didn’t. Plus:

What there’s too little of—and here is the second unignorable problem—is trust.

A huge and growing audience of Americans no longer believes the stories the establishment media tells. This has been building for years, decades maybe, and now that skepticism, that irritation with the “liberal press,” has morphed into a gag reflex: tens of millions of readers and watchers who once took for granted that you could more or less depend on The Times or CBS or even CNN to report the facts, to give it to you straight, don’t think that anymore. Their breaking points were different—maybe it was dismissing the Trump phenomenon as a joke; or calling the lab leak theory misinformation; or maybe it was seeing reporters act like mean girls on social media. The upshot is that they are out of trust.

This loss is nothing to celebrate. I would love to live in a world where I trusted what I read in the paper.

Maybe you never could.

THIS WOULD BE A BETTER ARGUMENT FOR CENSORING MEDIA COVERAGE OF GUNS: Kids’ mental health becomes part of the plea for gun control.

It’s actually the hysterical coverage, not the shootings that are doing whatever damage is done. And if we’re going to take away constitutional rights, we might as well do so where it will make a difference.

I BELIEVE HIM:

Who else is trying so hard to save it?

HMM: Russia’s invasion after 100 days: Ukraine goes on the offensive. “The battle for Ukraine has turned into a slugfest of dueling artillery. It’s not the lightning-quick takedown Russian President Vladimir Putin intended. But former CIA Director David Petraeus says there’s no denying Russian progress. . . . The Ukrainians have now gone on the offensive, both in the South (against the Russian-held city of Kherson), and in the north (outside Kharkiv). Petreaus said it is an attempt to outflank the Russians.”

The overall tone of this suggests the Russians are doing better than you might think, despite having failed at their original plan.

EVERYTHING IS GOING SWIMMINGLY: A friend sends this from California.

Heck, I paid $5.19 for premium yesterday in Knoxville, where gas is usually cheap.

Related: Biden tormented by Republican guerrilla campaign and ‘I did it’ stickers.

Also: 100Pcs I Did That Biden Funny Car Stickers. #Resist #CommissionEarned

Plus: Father on MSNBC Summarizes How Bad Democrats Are Getting Shellacked in November With One Perfect Sentence. “One administration had cheaper gas and this administration has more expensive gas.”

Why aren’t American voters appreciating Biden’s self-declared “incredible transition?!” Biden praises high gas prices as part of ‘incredible transition’ of the US economy away from fossil fuels.

RUY TEIXEIRA: The Mallory McMorrow Fallacy: Or Should We Call It The Popeye Fallacy?

Mallory McMorrow is having a moment. The Michigan legislator made a short speech assailing a fellow legislator who had accused her in a fundraising email of “grooming and sexualizing” kindergartners, which was subsequently viewed millions of times on McMorrow’s Twitter feed. Her message, delivered with some well-chosen personal touches, boiled down to: stand up to hate.

The speech was rapturously received in Democratic circles, particularly among activists and Democratic-leaning pundits. One went so far as to compare McMorrow to Nelson Mandela and Vaclav Havel. And many asserted that here, finally, was a blueprint for an effective Democratic midterm strategy.

Democrats should contain their enthusiasm. When you think about it, what McMorrow is recommending is basically what Democrats have already been doing—calling out their opponents for being hateful, bigoted and/or racist—but doing it more loudly and unequivocally. The idea here seems to be that a message’s effectiveness is directly proportional to the vigor with which it is asserted.

This is a fallacy. If a message has underlying weaknesses and fails to connect to significant and real voter concerns, it will not become more effective by simply increasing the volume. The weaknesses will still be there and voters’ concerns will not magically go away. . . .

This has not worked and is highly unlikely to work for the midterms and beyond. The Democrats cannot escape the necessity of moving to the center on sociocultural issues which does not consist of simply opposing hatred, but rather of making it clear that Democrats have a common sense approach to these issues that is different from the approach pushed by their woke activist wing. Until that is done, the Democrats will continue to be highly vulnerable on all these issues.

The woke activists are a crazy fringe. Most people, even most Democrats, aren’t on board with their agenda.