Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

FROM JONATHAN ADLER: Supreme Court Rejects Broad EPA Authority to Regulate Greenhouse Gases from Power Plants. “The decision also makes clear that the EPA does not have broad, free-ranging authority to address climate change under the Clean Air Act. (This is also a warning for other federal agencies, including FERC and the SEC.)”

Plus: Supreme Court Gives Biden Administration a (Temporary?) Win on Immigration with Final Decision of Term.

EVERYONE IS JUMPING ON THE “ANTIRACISM” BANDWAGON:

IN BIDEN V. TEXAS, SUPREME COURT RULES FOR BIDEN. Roberts and Kavanaugh join the three liberal justices. Opinion here. Biden’s decision to end the “Migrant Protection Protocol” — better known as the “Remain In Mexico” policy — is held to be lawful.

Republicans should set up a special “Welcome Wagon” program for these immigrants, explaining that the Democrats are the ones who want Drag Queen Story Hour in the schools. . . .

SUPREME COURT STRIKES DOWN EPA CLEAN AIR RULES, holds that agency rules that address “major questions” must have clear authorization from Congress. The decision, sadly, is less sweeping than it might have been, but still moderately good news for restraining administrative agencies. Here’s the link.

Gorsuch has a nice concurrence spelling out the democracy-threatening aspects of administrative law, which includes this footnote throwing shade at the father of Administrative Law, Woodrow Wilson:

For example, Woodrow Wilson famously argued that “popular sovereignty” “embarrasse[d]” the Nation because it made it harder to achieve “executive expertness.” The Study of Administration, 2 Pol. Sci. Q. 197, 207 (1887) (Administration). In Wilson’s eyes, the mass of the people were “selfish, ignorant, timid, stubborn, or foolish.” Id., at 208. He expressed even greater disdain for particular groups, defending “[t]he white men of the South” for “rid[ding] themselves, by fair means or foul, of the intolerable burden of governments sustained by the votes of ignorant [African-Americans].” 9 W. Wilson, History of the American People 58 (1918). He likewise denounced immigrants “from the south of Italy and men of the meaner sort out of Hungary and Poland,” who possessed “neither skill nor energy nor any initiative of quick intelligence.” 5 id., at 212. To Wilson, our Republic “tr[ied] to do too much by vote.” Administration 214.

All true. Wilson was a racist, an elitist, and an entitled twit with a wildly exaggerated opinion of his own intellect and competence.. In short, the perfect progenitor for modern progressivism.

Also, a nice cite for Phil Hamburger’s excellent book Is Administrative Law Unlawful? (Spoiler: Yes.)

HMM: Ukraine: Russia pulls back forces from Snake Island. “Russia claimed the move was a ‘goodwill gesture’ to allow the export of Ukrainian agricultural products. Meanwhile, fighting intensified in Lysychansk, in the Donbas region.”

YOU WIN SOME, YOU LOSE SOME. In this case, it’s the Oregon Supreme Court, and I was on the losing side. But still right!

As Uncle Mal says:

OPEN THREAD: No one expects a symphony orchestra. “This is the epitome of ‘No one asked for it, but it’s exactly what we needed’.”