Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

THE PEOPLE WHO MAKE RNC COMMERCIALS ARE, TOO: The left is really pleased with these clips of Berkeley law professor Khiara Bridges. “If you check in on Twitter today, the left is uniformly thrilled that UC Berkeley law professor Khiara Bridges has put a couple of white Republican Senators in their place. Seriously, they are over the moon about this performance, especially for her exchange with Sen. Josh Hawley. This started when Sen. Hawley asked about her use of the phrase ‘people with the capacity for pregnancy.’ Hawley asked if that meant ‘women’ and she said not it wasn’t limited to women but included trans people.”

SO IS GETTING BOOSTED SELFISH BECAUSE IT INCREASES THE RISK TO OTHERS? New study: COVID booster significantly delays end of infection. “A new study published in the New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) has demonstrated that people who are triple-vaccinated (boosted) against COVID recover significantly more slowly from COVID infection and remain contagious for longer than people who are not vaccinated at all . . . At five days post-infection, less than 25 percent of unvaccinated people were still contagious, whereas around 70 percent of boosted people were still carrying viable virus particles. For those partially vaccinated, around 50 percent were still contagious at this point. Even more strikingly, at ten days post-infection, one-third of boosted people (31 percent) were found to still be carrying live, culturable virus. By contrast, just six percent of unvaccinated people were still contagious at day 10.”

Here’s the actual report from the New England Journal of Medicine, which looks a bit less dramatic than the report above.

#JOURNALISM: Jonathan Chait Writes the Same Ron DeSantis Column Again, Is Still Wrong.

His latest column warns darkly that “Ron DeSantis Would Kill Democracy Slowly and Methodically.” Both the motive and the rhetorical trick at work here are fairly transparent. The motive is the same one that led Chait, back in 2016, to argue that liberals should prefer Donald Trump to Marco Rubio or Ted Cruz. It is the same one that leads panicked progressives such as Charles Pierce of Esquire to rise up in alarm against a DeSantis presidential campaign: “Dear America, Do Not Walk Away From Ron DeSantis—Run.” Chait, Pierce, and others on this beat recognize that Trump would be more likely to lose in 2024 than DeSantis, and that DeSantis (if elected) would be more effective in advancing conservative policy. So, they prefer another Trump nomination, and if pressed, they prefer Trump in power again to DeSantis in power. That’s what this is all about.

The rhetorical trick is to convince readers that the loudest alarms about Trump — that he’s a threat to democracy who won’t abide by the results of elections, as evidenced by his “stop the steal” campaign and January 6 — can be seamlessly transferred to DeSantis. There is, however, a problem in making that leap, and we can illustrate it with what never appears in any of Chait’s many columns on this same topic: the Democrats. Is it bad and dangerous to peddle stolen-election conspiracy theories, attack the legitimacy of election results, try to get them thrown out in court, object to certifying electors in Congress, and generally treat the winners of elections as if they have no right to exercise the powers of office? If that is your standard, there are a lot of Democrats who are threats to democracy, including Hillary Clinton, Nancy Pelosi, Jimmy Carter, Al Gore, Stacey Abrams, John Lewis, former DNC chairs Terry McAuliffe, Debbie Wasserman-Schultz, Howard Dean, January 6 committee chair Bennie Thompson, and — of course — Jonathan Chait himself. I have documented this in depth here, here, here, here, here, and here, as well as several other places linked in those items. Heck, the current president, Joe Biden, has preemptively attempted to delegitimize the upcoming midterm elections, while the current Senate majority leader, Chuck Schumer, described American elections as a “rigged game.” Chait appears to have no problem with any of this, having participated in some of it himself. Chait complains of a “belief that Democratic election victories are inherently illegitimate” but freely participates in a movement to treat Republican election victories as inherently illegitimate.

Once you realize that it’s all bullshit, you’ll understand that it’s all bullshit.

UPDATE: Sorry for the double post. Leaving both up to preserve the comments in both.

MORE: Link was incorrect for this post; should be working now.

#JOURNALISM: Jonathan Chait Writes the Same Ron DeSantis Column Again, Is Still Wrong.

His latest column warns darkly that “Ron DeSantis Would Kill Democracy Slowly and Methodically.” Both the motive and the rhetorical trick at work here are fairly transparent. The motive is the same one that led Chait, back in 2016, to argue that liberals should prefer Donald Trump to Marco Rubio or Ted Cruz. It is the same one that leads panicked progressives such as Charles Pierce of Esquire to rise up in alarm against a DeSantis presidential campaign: “Dear America, Do Not Walk Away From Ron DeSantis—Run.” Chait, Pierce, and others on this beat recognize that Trump would be more likely to lose in 2024 than DeSantis, and that DeSantis (if elected) would be more effective in advancing conservative policy. So, they prefer another Trump nomination, and if pressed, they prefer Trump in power again to DeSantis in power. That’s what this is all about.

The rhetorical trick is to convince readers that the loudest alarms about Trump — that he’s a threat to democracy who won’t abide by the results of elections, as evidenced by his “stop the steal” campaign and January 6 — can be seamlessly transferred to DeSantis. There is, however, a problem in making that leap, and we can illustrate it with what never appears in any of Chait’s many columns on this same topic: the Democrats. Is it bad and dangerous to peddle stolen-election conspiracy theories, attack the legitimacy of election results, try to get them thrown out in court, object to certifying electors in Congress, and generally treat the winners of elections as if they have no right to exercise the powers of office? If that is your standard, there are a lot of Democrats who are threats to democracy, including Hillary Clinton, Nancy Pelosi, Jimmy Carter, Al Gore, Stacey Abrams, John Lewis, former DNC chairs Terry McAuliffe, Debbie Wasserman-Schultz, Howard Dean, January 6 committee chair Bennie Thompson, and — of course — Jonathan Chait himself. I have documented this in depth here, here, here, here, here, and here, as well as several other places linked in those items. Heck, the current president, Joe Biden, has preemptively attempted to delegitimize the upcoming midterm elections, while the current Senate majority leader, Chuck Schumer, described American elections as a “rigged game.” Chait appears to have no problem with any of this, having participated in some of it himself. Chait complains of a “belief that Democratic election victories are inherently illegitimate” but freely participates in a movement to treat Republican election victories as inherently illegitimate.

Once you realize that it’s all bullshit, you’ll understand that it’s all bullshit.

K-12 IMPLOSION UPDATE: Build a Charter School, Get Sued by the Teachers Union.

If you’re looking for proof that teachers unions don’t care about the interests of schoolchildren, you can find it in the impoverished Bronx neighborhood of Soundview. A school building on Beach Avenue has been shuttered for almost a decade, and the United Federation of Teachers is suing to keep it closed.

On Aug. 22, a new charter high school, Vertex Academies, will begin classes here. In the local school district, only 7% of students who enter ninth grade are ready for college four years later. For black students, the figure is 4%. The new school promises to deliver “a high-quality education to 150 minority students from low-income backgrounds” in its first year, says founding principal Joyanet Mangual.

Vertex will use the premises of the defunct Blessed Sacrament School, where Sonia Sotomayor was valedictorian in 1968. When the school shut down in 2013, the justice declared herself “heartbroken.” Her mother had scrimped and saved to send her there: “She watched what happened to my cousins in public school, and worried if we went there, we might not get out,” Justice Sotomayor told the New York Times. . . .

That’s where the UFT comes in. Mr. Rowe explains that Vertex is a “charter management organization.” The State University of New York gave the four feeder schools the authority to run a high school: “They could choose to run it themselves, but they’re hiring Vertex to run it on their behalf.” The union alleges that Vertex isn’t an extension of an existing charter but a new school masquerading as an extension. New charters are prohibited in New York City because of a cap imposed by state legislators at the union’s behest.

Mr. Rowe is undaunted by the legal challenge. “There is no chance at all that we cannot open on Aug. 22,” he says.

Win, and exact come costs to deter future such efforts.

I’M BACK, AS YOU CAN SEE! No, I wasn’t scuba diving, I was actually in London, where I saw a bunch of fun people including Samizdata bloggers Perry De Havilland and Adriana Cronin. International travel wasn’t as bad as reports have it. Nobody asked for a vax card, no mask rules, zero bullshit. Flights were on time and smooth, though immigration in Philly was a debacle that barely let us make our flight. But we did!

YOU’RE NOT SUPPOSED TO TALK ABOUT THIS: What About All the Other R. Kellys? I Knew Many Growing Up. “I also saw other things, like the tall, muscular, light-skinned brother who looked like LL Cool J. It was said he could get any woman he wanted, but chose kids. He got my brother, who then did the only thing he could to protect me: He made sure I was never alone around Lafayette. He never told me why until I was older. . . . There always seemed to be an ‘uncle’ or ‘mother’s old friend from high school,’ who was diving into little girls’ beds. These R. Kellys were the open-secret. The closed-secret was how many boys were being taken advantage of.”

Plus: “Our fraught relationship with America has resulted in the tension that so many of us felt over R. Kelly. How could we champion sending another Black man to prison when the state has imprisoned so many unjustly? And yet, his victims were also Black. They were ours. Don’t they deserve justice? Don’t all the boys and girls whose abusers continue to roam free?”

OPEN THREAD: Gonna use my imagination.

OPEN THREAD: Because the night belongs to comments.