Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

THE DOJ’S LEGAL WORK HAS BEEN EITHER SUBPAR OR OUTRIGHT DISHONEST HERE: Judge Appoints Special Master, Temporarily Bars FBI/DOJ Review Or Use Of Records Seized in Mar-a-Lago Raid.

Related: Judge throws Mar-a-Lago probe into chaos. “The Justice Department blithely assumed that Trump had no executive privilege even though this is an unsettled question in the law. When a salient point of law is unclear, the responsible course for prosecutors is to flag the issue for the court and get a ruling before taking controversial actions. Instead, in seeking the search warrant, DOJ advised Magistrate Judge Bruce Reinhart that the filtering process that would be implemented in connection with documents seized in the search would screen only for attorney-client privileged documents, not executive privileged documents. The latter category is apt to be considerably more expansive. It does not appear that DOJ alerted Reinhart to the possibility that Trump could have a colorable executive-privilege claim, and there’s no indication that Reinhart raised the question on his own.”

EVEN THE ATLANTIC IS NOTICING: Biden’s Student-Debt Rescue Plan Is a Legal Mess. “The Biden administration’s recently announced plan to reduce student debt for borrowers who earn less than $125,000 is popular, according to recent polls. Unfortunately, the plan has a major legal flaw: The administration’s arguments for its executive power to make such a broad effort under federal law will likely lose—and should lose—in the courts.”

JEFFREY CARTER: Ignorance of Economics. “Trump did a lot of good things, but he wasn’t a particularly sharp President when it came to cutting government deficits and putting in place great long-term economic policies. The problem is when you put his policies up against the Democrats, Trump’s look sterling.”

To be fair, it’s a low bar.

DON SURBER: A raid to get 1,693 newspapers? “Why on Earth did U.S. Magistrate Bruce Reinhart issue a warrant to raid Mar-a-Lago? The stuff the FBI collected was not nuclear codes. It was a bunch of old magazines and newspapers. He and the FBI had no business confiscating them. A detailed list of what the FBI claims it took shows Reinhart’s was a general warrant, which the 4th Amendment bans. I suppose this is FBI standard operating procedure because although they are sworn to defend the Constitution, the agents never seem to bother following it. The full list of items taken is here. Overwhelmingly, what the FBI took were newspapers and magazines, either in full or just articles clipped from them. President Trump obviously needed the 1,693 articles, newspapers and magazines to help his ghostwriter write his presidential memoirs.”

EVERYTHING IS GOING SWIMMINGLY: A US Freight Rail Crisis Threatens More Supply Chain Chaos: Federal regulators and the White House have been scrambling to prevent poor service and a possible strike from jamming up a vital but often overlooked network.

Well, if “federal regulators and the White House” have been working on it, what can go wrong?

UPDATE: From the comments: “This proves they can’t be fascists! The trains aren’t running on time! They’re not even running!”

OPEN THREAD: Ring out the long weekend.

FROM THE DEPARTMENT OF EARTH-SHATTERING KABOOMS: In 2021, a deadly volcano erupted with no warning. Here’s why. “Nyiragongo’s last two eruptions, in 1977 and 2002, were both presaged by days of distinct seismic rumblings strong enough to be felt by people living nearby. But before the eruption on May 22, 2021, even the sensitive monitoring stations near the volcano seemed to detect no clear warning signs of magma on the move underground.”

EUGENE VOLOKH: My Skepticism About Fears of a Constitutional Convention. “If a constitutional convention is called and proposes amendments, they still have to be ratified by legislatures or conventions (the convention gets to decide which) in 3/4 of all states. . . . Maybe I’m wrong, but I expect that this will be a pretty serious bar to any particularly radical proposals. If you disagree, tell me this: What amendments do you think a convention could propose that would get the support of legislatures or conventions in at least 38 of the 50 states, and how conservative (or liberal) do you think those amendments would be?”

Well, Russ Feingold seems pretty worried that they’d be conservative.

Plus: “By the way, the New York Times article does mention the 38-state ratification requirement—in the 24th out of 28 paragraphs.” Well, the New York Times.