Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

FROM A FRIEND: “Don’t look at the midterms as an election; it’s more like a restraining order.”

OOPS: Blunder in Affirmative Action Case May Cost Harvard $15 Million: A missed insurance notice opened a window onto the cost of litigating challenges to race-conscious admissions programs to be heard this month by the Supreme Court.

As Harvard prepares to defend its race-conscious admissions program at the Supreme Court this month, a federal judge in Boston is considering a related dispute arising from a fumbled insurance filing, one that could cost the university $15 million.

Harvard failed to file a timely formal claim with one of its insurance companies for its expenses in defending the lawsuit challenging its admissions policies. That company, Zurich American Insurance, refused to pay, and Harvard sued. In the process, the university disclosed that its legal fees and expenses in the admissions lawsuit and a related Justice Department investigation had topped $27 million.

“One of the nation’s top universities is apparently not great about doing its homework,” said David Lat, a legal commentator.

Days after Students for Fair Admissions sued Harvard in 2014, arguing that its practice of taking account of race in its undergraduate admissions decisions was unlawful and harmed Asian American applicants, the university formally notified its primary insurance carrier to seek payment of its defense costs. That policy had a $25 million limit, after Harvard paid $2.5 million.

But Harvard did not alert Zurich, its excess insurer, which was meant to cover the next $15 million, until long after the policy’s deadline had passed.

That additional money is at issue in the case before the federal judge in Boston.

“Somebody seriously messed up,” said Tom Baker, a law professor at the University of Pennsylvania. “I teach about this stuff. One of the things you teach people about claims-made policies is that you’ve got to provide notice early and often.”

Make them pay. Plus:

U.N.C.’s own litigation expenses have exceeded $24 million as of July, according to a response to a public records request from the James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal, a nonprofit group that says it seeks to broaden the diversity of ideas taught at universities.

“No state-appropriated or tuition dollars are being used,” U.N.C. told the center.

Uh huh.

ROGER KIMBALL: Not Consensus, But Truth.

Perhaps the most popular meme floating about in polite society today is the contention that any hint of the 2020 presidential election being tainted is a “Big Lie.” It is so popular, in fact, that some journalists and politicians appear to present themselves to the Office of Acceptable Propaganda each day before setting off on their rounds. They collect their allotted quota of different ways of ridiculing and dismissing those imprudent enough to suggest that, as a matter of fact, there were lots of problems with the 2020 elections.

It is important that these approved scribes and politicians engage in this ritual because there are many different ways in which this rhetorical epithet needs to be expressed if it is to achieve its goal: to silence debate by intimidating people.

To this end, a number of different rhetorical registers must be sounded. Some are blunt and angry, as for example this tweet from a writer for The Bulwark, a marginal NeverTrump site supported by leftist billionaires: “Chris Sununu, Doug Ducey, Brian Kemp, and Glenn Youngkin . . . every single one of them is campaigning either for or with an election-denying lunatic.”

The obloquy is directed not simply against certain ideas, but also against the people who express, or might express, them. Thus we find Michael Steele, an anti-Trump Republican and former chairman of the Republican National Committee, castigating supporters of the former president as “lice, fleas, and blood sucking ticks.” The formula does have the advantage of clarity: I mean, partly because of its unsavory historical echoes, you know where you stand with Steele.

The left views all of its opponenets as vermin to be exterminated. They say that routinely. Believe them.

I’M NOT PLEASED: How Worried Should We Be About Boston University’s Gain-of-Function Covid Virus That Kills 80% of Mice? “Thus restated, it becomes difficult to ascertain the genuine need for doing this experiment (whose results seem obvious, predictable and axiomatic). Einstein favored Gedankenexperimente (‘thought experiments’) using conceptual rather than actual experiments in creating the theory of relativity. There’s nothing like the ‘real thing’, but I’m imagining 99% of virologists could have foreseen a conclusion similar to this without having done any of the study. Moreover, most would not have seen a real point in doing this study in the first place. Of course, getting paid and churning research grants can help provide motivation.”

Plus: “By focusing so intently within the micro-world, it’s perhaps forgivable virologists lose sense of the macro. Conversely, the general public has earned every right to be twitchy and tetchy over ‘gain of function’ engineered augmentations to SARS-CoV-2 after the many millions of excess deaths following what many suspect was a Wuhan lab leak.”

It might be “forgivable,” but they should expect the predictable shitstorm. And they haven’t done a lot to earn the public’s trust lately.

ICYMI: THIS IS BULLSHIT: Ejaculate Responsibly?

Responsibly? Men are so responsible, they’re charged with child support when the ejaculation occurs when they’re raped while unconscious, when it occurs into a condom that is later salvaged from a trash can, or when they’re pubescent boys molested by adult women. See this: Fatherhood by Conscription: Nonconsensual Insemination and the Duty of Child Support.

Nathaniel was a California teenager who became a father in 1995. The mother of Nathaniel’s child was named Ricci, and at the time of conception, she was thirty-four years old. Nathaniel, however, was merely fifteen. Although Nathaniel admitted to having sex with Ricci voluntarily about five times, the fact that he was under sixteen years of age at the time made it legally impossible for him to consent to sexual intercourse. In other words, under California law, Nathaniel was not only a new father, but was also a victim of statutory rape. Nonetheless, in a subsequent action for child support, the court held that Nathaniel was liable for the support of the child who was born as a result of his rape. According to the court, “Victims have rights. Here, the victim also has responsibilities.”

Post-Dobbs, I can see the appeal of trying to shift responsibility for pregnancy to men, but the fact is men have never enjoyed “reproductive rights” as women have known them. If anything, Dobbs narrows that gender gap a bit. The notion that it’s only men who resist condom use because it interferes with sexual pleasure is also a fiction.

But post-Dobbs there’s a market for attacks on men and their sexuality, so this should do well.

But it’s not really new: “The rise of personal genomics has not created this phenomenon, of course. Nonpaternity results can arise even in the course of routine medical testing. What happens if a doctor sees that a baby’s blood type could not have come from its father? (If the baby’s is AB and the father’s turns up O, the doctor knows that something is amiss.) In the last few decades, the medical establishment has decided that these findings should be concealed, to protect the mother’s privacy and avoid unnecessary harm.”

“Unnecessary harm” to whom?

JEFFREY CARTER: Rigging Markets: Washington Seems To Be Pretty Good At It. “Over the years I have written a lot about how people in Washington DC take advantage of inside information and trade the market. If you were a corporate executive you would go to jail for the same actions. This is not a new issue. It’s a recurring issue. . . . There will be no high crimes and misdemeanor Congressional hearings on this since they often are in on the game. I will tell you that if I was in office, I would put a stop to it once and for all. Rigging markets is one of the worst things that can happen in a capitalistic society.”

NOT MY FIRST CHOICE, BUT NOBODY CONSULTED ME: Rishi Sunak Gains Edge in U.K. Prime Minister Race as Boris Johnson Drops Out. “Former U.K. Chancellor Rishi Sunak looks set to become Britain’s next prime minister after his rival for the job Boris Johnson pulled out the race late Sunday evening, clearing the path for Mr. Sunak to win the ongoing contest to become leader of the Conservative Party.”

More here.

I would have preferred Penny Mordaunt but, as I said, I wasn’t consulted.

OPEN THREAD: Express yourself.

DAVID BERNSTEIN: I’ve Read Harvard’s Brief in the Pending Racial Preferences Case, and I Have a Question. “How, for that matter, did Harvard conclude that Hispanics, who federal rules tell us “can be of any race,” constitute a racial minority such that Hispanic students are the only students who can be of 100% European ethnic heritage and still get a racial preference? Did Harvard even ever consider this question, and if not, how can its claim to deference for its academic decision-making regarding admissions be taken seriously?”

I highly recommend David’s excellent new book, Classified: The Untold Story of Racial Classification in America. As you can see at the link, I blurbed it. #CommissionEarned

JULIETTE OCHIENG: The Spiritual Nature of Race-Baiting.

Hit her tipjar if you like her.

UPDATE: People are saying that this is paywalled, but I just clicked through and I’m not a subscriber.

A REVIEW FROM TAMARA KEEL: Bond Arms Roughneck: Cyberpunk Derringer. “The very idea of a 9mm Luger stainless derringer has a sort of cyberpunk vibe to it, like a hideout gun for a riverboat gambler … in space.”