Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

WELL, JUST LOOKING AT THEM YOU CAN UNDERSTAND WHY THEY’D BE OPPOSED: Ruy Teixeira: The Democrats’ Merit Problem: They No Longer Seem So Sure It’s a Good Idea.

The traditional Democratic theory of the case ran like this: discrimination should be opposed and dismantled and resources provided to the disadvantaged so that everyone can fairly compete and achieve. Rewards—job opportunities, promotions, commissions, appointments, publications, school slots, and much else—would then be allocated on the basis of which person or persons deserved these rewards on the basis of merit. Those who were meritorious would be rewarded; those who weren’t would not be.

But Democrats have lost interest in the last part of their case, which undermines their whole theory. Merit and objective measures of achievement are now viewed with suspicion as the outcomes of a hopelessly corrupt system, so rewards should instead be allocated on the basis of various criteria allegedly related to “social justice.” Instead of dismantling discrimination and providing assistance so that more people have the opportunity to acquire merit, the real solution is to worry less about merit and more about equal outcomes—“equity” in parlance of our times.

Arguments can be made in defense of the anti-merit approach. You can’t swing a dead cat on most university campuses without hitting some academic who will give you 10,000 words on why this is actually a great idea. In my view, these arguments are universally specious but what shouldn’t be debatable is that ordinary people—ordinary voters—don’t buy the idea. They believe in the idea of merit and they believe in their ability to acquire merit and attendant rewards if given the opportunity to do so. To believe otherwise is insulting to them and contravenes their common sense about the central role of merit in fair decisions. As George Orwell put it: “One has to belong to the intelligentsia to believe things like that: no ordinary man could be such a fool.”

What ordinary voters understand — and the academics understand it too, but they approve — is that the fewer objective criteria for advancement, the more opportunities for cronyism, favoritism, and ostracism.

Plus: “This is true today as the Supreme Court prepares to render a decision next month on affirmative action in higher education as practiced by Harvard and the University of North Carolina. The Harvard case turns particularly on whether Asians have been discriminated against in admissions to that college. Given the proclivities of the Court and the blindingly obvious pattern of such discrimination—denying it seems as plausible as professing one’s belief in the Easter Bunny—it is a safe bet that the Court will decide against the universities. In so doing, the Court will find itself on the good side of public opinion and Democrats, who will no doubt denounce the decision in histrionic terms, will find themselves very much on the wrong side. In typical polling from Pew in 2022, just 7 percent of the public thought high school grades should not be a factor in college admissions and a mere 14 percent thought standardized test scores should not be a factor. But an overwhelming 74 percent thought that race or ethnicity should not be a factor in college admissions. . . . None of this should come as a surprise to those who are attuned to real-world political trends, as opposed to media treatment of racial issues.”

21ST CENTURY RELATIONSHIPS: A 23-year-old Snapchat influencer used OpenAI’s technology to create an A.I. version of herself that will be your girlfriend for $1 per minute. “Though CarynAI has only been charging users for a week in beta testing, it’s already generated $71,610 in revenue from her 99% male partners, according to an income statement Marjorie’s business manager shared with Fortune. With this, Marjorie sees having an A.I. doppelgänger as a promising way to level up her career as an influencer.”

On a less titillating level, there’s HarveyAI’s AI lawyer. Though it probably will cost more than $1 a minute.

So if women were choosing AI “men” over the real thing, it would be presented as evidence that there’s something wrong with men. I predict that if men choose AI “women” over the real thing it will be presented as . . . evidence that there’s something wrong with men.

I’M NOW READING Lee Jackson’s After Dunkirk series. Solidly entertaining.

OPEN THREAD: Enjoy!

LEAKED: Emails Show Biden State Department Sought to Protect China During Spy-Balloon Fiasco. “In other words, instead of punishing China for its insanely provocative violation of US airspace and sovereignty, Blinken had his lackeys pause major human rights and trade measures. That included already planned actions to sanction Chinese tech companies like Huawei and to combat China’s genocide of the Uyghurs.”

CIVIL RIGHTS UPDATE: US Prohibition Against 18-to-20-Year-Olds Buying Handguns Tossed.

The US government’s prohibition on 18-to-20-year-olds buying handguns violates the Second Amendment and “cannot stand,” a federal judge in Virginia ruled.

The right to purchase a handgun falls under right to “keep and bear arms,” and young adults are among “the people” protected by the Second Amendment, Judge Robert E. Payne of the US District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia at Richmond said Wednesday.

Restricting the right of 18-to-20-year-olds to buy handguns, via an interlocking collection of federal law and regulations, isn’t supported by the nation’s history and tradition, Payne said. The government presented numerous militia laws from around the time of the nation’s founding, but they showed that 16 or 18 was the age of militia service then, he said.

The government did not present any evidence supporting “age-based restrictions on the purchase or sale of firearms from the colonial era, Founding, or Early Republic,” Payne said.

The earliest age restrictions for buying guns the government pointed to were laws passed in Alabama and Tennessee in 1856, Payne said. But none of the antebellum laws provided a definition of “minor” and “it is unclear to whom exactly they applied,” he said.

Here’s the opinion. Freedom advances, bit by bit.

WELL, I EXPECTED IT BEFORE THE TURN OF THE MILLENNIUM: Is nuclear fusion going to arrive way sooner than expected?

Of course, greens will be horrified if it actually works. The last thing they want is “an inexhaustible supply of energy, without pollution or global warming.” Otherwise they’d support nuclear fission, which is available now.