Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds
June 21, 2023
NO, THIS ISN’T ABOUT HIS WAR RECORD: Watchdog group slaps John Kerry with complaint for wildly exaggerated claims.
HIGHER EDUCATION BUBBLE UPDATE: I Paid for Free Speech at Arizona State: The university is firing me for organizing an event featuring Charlie Kirk and Dennis Prager.
I thought that Arizona State University, my alma mater and employer, was different from other schools when it came to free speech. In 2011 the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression awarded ASU a “green light” rating for its written policies on freedom of expression. The university happily complied when FIRE suggested it adopt the Chicago Principles and protect the “free, robust and uninhibited sharing of ideas among all members of the University’s community.” The ASU Barrett Honors College has even been home to heterodox initiatives like the T.W. Lewis Center for Personal Development, where I served as executive director for the last two years.
But beneath ASU’s written commitment to intellectual diversity lies a deep hostility toward divergent views. The latest trouble started in February when the Lewis Center hosted Robert Kiyosaki, Dennis Prager and Charlie Kirk for an event on “Health, Wealth, and Happiness.” This nonpartisan program was part of a popular speaker series focused on connecting students with professionals who can offer career and life advice.
At the names of Messrs. Prager and Kirk, the faculty of ASU’s honors college were outraged. Thirty-nine of its 47 faculty signed a letter to the dean condemning the event on grounds that the speakers are “purveyors of hate who have publicly attacked women, people of color, the LGBTQ community, [and] institutions of our democracy.” The signers decried ASU “platforming and legitimating” their views, describing Messrs. Prager and Kirk as “white nationalist provocateurs” whose comments would undermine the value of democratic exchange by marginalizing the school’s most vulnerable students.
The faculty protests extended beyond the letter. Professors spent precious class time denouncing the program. On Twitter they lamented the university’s willingness to allow donor input on campus events. Mr. Prager received a death threat, forcing municipal and campus police to enact extensive security measures.
The event’s topic made no difference to the faculty protesting it. The political views of Messrs. Prager and Kirk rendered both men personae non grata on any issue. The message to students was clear: Nuance is impossible in the presence of “wrongthink”; the offender must either comply or face sweeping castigation.
The university administration’s position on the event was no secret. All advertising about “Health, Wealth, and Happiness” was scrubbed from campus walls and digital flyers. Behind closed doors, deans pressured me to postpone the event indefinitely. I was warned that if the speakers made any political statements, it wouldn’t be in the Lewis Center’s “best interests,” which I interpreted as a threat.
I ignored their threats and the event was a resounding success—1,500 people attended in person, another 24,000 joined us online. There were no protests, no disturbances, and no traumatized students. But the faculty’s illiberal tantrum was devastatingly effective on two fronts.
First, the scare tactics worked on undergraduates. Many students told me they were intimidated by professors into not attending. Some would attend only if we promised that cameras wouldn’t face the audience. Students worried that attending or expressing interest in the event would hurt them academically. Grades for ambiguous things like “class participation” give professors the ability to punish students for their politics. The success of professors’ fearmongering was reflected in the audience, where older attendees outnumbered the students.
Second, the event cost its organizers dearly. Shortly after “Health, Wealth, and Happiness,” Lin Blake, the events operations manager at ASU Gammage Theater, was fired by ASU Gammage. Before her firing, Ms. Blake told me that she was “berated by ASU Gammage leadership for coordinating an event that did not align with the values of ASU Gammage.” And as of June 30, ASU will dismantle the Lewis Center and terminate my position as its executive director. Barrett Honors College leadership told me this is purely a business decision, despite my raising more than $500,000 in the last year through the center.
Arizona’s legislature should be asking questions and cutting budgets.
June 20, 2023
THEY USED TO PRETEND TO BE NONPARTISAN, BUT THEY’RE LEFTIST HACKS: Justice Alito Preempts ProPublica “Investigative Journalism.”
ProPublica’s latest research target is (you guessed it) Justice Alito. On Friday, ProPublica contacted Justice Alito, and asked him to respond to questions by a deadline of noon EDT Tuesday. Justice Alito provided such a response–in the Wall Street Journal.
Alito’s decision was a masterstroke. Rather than providing comments to ProPublica, which can be cherry-picked and quoted out of context, Alito spoke directly to the public. Indeed, I long ago decided that if any outlet was running a hit job on me, and asks me for comment, I would pre-empt their story and post my reply on the blog. Alas, most of the hit jobs on me never both seeking comment. But such is life.
Why did Alito speak directly to the public? Because there is a sustained movement to destroy the Supreme Court. In the past, the Court could have expected members of the Bar and the Academy to defend the Court. But no longer. Because five justices had the audacity to let the people cast votes on abortion (and in the past year, that decision has overwhelmingly resounded in favor of Democrats), the Supreme Court must be obliterated. I think several of the Court’s moderates and swinging left this term to forestall more attacks. Who would have predicted that Justice Sotomayor would the Justice in the majority the most on 6-3 “conservative” Court? Stay tuned for the affirmative action cases.
I have described Justice Alito as the heart of the Supreme Court. He defends the Supreme Court in ways that Chief Justice Roberts simply cannot.
Plus: “And who are you going to believe? ProPublica’s shoddy reporting in the past has undermined any benefit of the doubt.”
ProPublica is as trustworthy and accurate as Media Matters these days, which is to say only by accident.
NOTHING TO SEE HERE, MOVE ALONG:
Children with dynamite attempt to blow-up packed grocery store
This should be the top story, this could've killed scores of people…@ATFPhiladelphia @FBIPhiladelphia https://t.co/7b7lebzqKw
— PhillyCrimeUpdate (@PhillyCrimeUpd) June 20, 2023
OPEN THREAD: Take the ball and run with it.
AS LONG AS THE CHECKS KEEP CLEARING: Boeing CEO says company still committed to Starliner.
IT DOESN’T LOOK ESPECIALLY “PENIS-LIKE” TO ME, NOR DOES THE CARVING ON IT: This Ancient Blob May Be The Oldest Phallic Depiction Ever Found. Some scientists agree with me: “It’s not even like the object screams ‘sexual organ’. Boston University archaeologist Curtis Runnels, who was not involved in the recent study, told Science the ornament looks ‘rather shapeless’, and at first glance, it’s hard to disagree.”
Plus: “Compared to a full-body artwork, detecting a lone penis can be tricky work, especially when a phallic-like artifact could have more than one use. A curious-looking wooden tool described earlier this year, for instance, could be a 2,000-year-old dildo, or it could be a drop spindle used to spin fiber. Hey, maybe it was both.”
TRUST THE EXPERTS: CDC Director knew COVID vax did not prevent infection. “This revelation comes via a FOIA request that, you can see, was redacted. Given that the email was in no way classified, the excuse for removing 90% of the content is a mystery. Perhaps the content was embarrassing? Who can say? Perhaps she included war plans against Iran or secret intelligence that Russia was planning an invasion of Ukraine.”
MY LACK OF CONFIDENCE IN HER IS COMING TO A MIDDLE: Army Sec Wormuth says we’re way wrong worrying about WOKE warriors.
HARSH BUT FAIR: How would Justice Barrett have voted in United States v. Lopez?
ALIENS! Senator says UFO whistleblower revelations track with briefings.
I have thoughts here.
AMERICA’S NEWSPAPER OF RECORD: Hunter Avoids Jail Time After Pleading Biden.
WE KNOW THE ANSWER: Science: Has Importing New York-Style Gun Control Laws Made Vermont Less Safe?
BAD NEWS FOR INTOXICATED RATS: Intoxicated teenage rats wearing ‘FitBites’ found to experience sleep disturbance long after withdrawing from alcohol.
SWEETHEART DEAL: Hunter Biden will plead guilty to skirt prison time. And it’s only gotten this far because they need at least a figleaf for their Trump prosecution.
Related:
The whole idea of blind justice is motivated by the fear that one bad turn will be repaid by another. But the obvious way to avoid that outcome is to ensure you call the shots forever.
— wretchardthecat (@wretchardthecat) June 20, 2023
WHEN ARSON MASQUERADES AS “CLIMATE CHANGE:” Authorities Arrest Democrat Donor for California Wildfire Blamed on ‘Climate Crisis’.
YEAH, WELL, THE WHOLE “VIRTUALLY NORMAL” THING FADED AWAY A LONG TIME AGO: Backlash: Support for same-sex relationships drop — among Republicans and Democrats.
Also, of course, the Democrats have been importing voters who are much more socially conservative than the average American. Republicans should greet immigrants at the border with leaflets explaining, in their own languages, that Democrats want to cut of their boys’ penises and their girls’ breasts. It would be fun just for the reaction. But word gets around anyway.