Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

MICKEY KAUS NOTICES A HOLE IN THE NARRATIVE:

DO TELL: Jack Goldsmith: The Prosecution of Trump May Have Terrible Consequences.

The indictment alleges that Mr. Trump lied and manipulated people and institutions in trying to shape law and politics in his favor. Exaggeration and truth-shading in the facilitation of self-serving legal arguments or attacks on political opponents have always been commonplace in Washington. Going forward, these practices will likely be disputed in the language of, and amid demands for, special counsels, indictments and grand juries…. Watergate deluded us into thinking that independent counsels of various stripes could vindicate the rule of law and bring national closure in response to abuses by senior officials in office. Every relevant experience since then — from the discredited independent counsel era (1978-99) through the controversial and unsatisfactory Mueller investigation — proves otherwise. And national dissensus is more corrosive today than in the 1990s, and worse even than when Mr. Mueller was at work….”

The message of the Trump prosecution is Thou Shall Not Challenge The Establishment. If you do, the rules and conventions go out the window and they do whatever dirty things they can to you. And the usual promoters of “decency,” “civility,” and “rule of law” will back them out of class interest and tribal loyalty.

Does this mean that our government — and media/academic establishment, but I repeat myself — is deeply, perhaps hopelessly corrupt and fundamentally illegitimate? Yeah, probably.

And if only there had been some sort of warning about the downsides of this sort of lawfare.

FROM ANTHROPIC: Frontier Threats Red Teaming for AI Safety.

“Red teaming,” or adversarial testing, is a recognized technique to measure and increase the safety and security of systems. While previous Anthropic research reported methods and results for red teaming using crowdworkers, for some time, AI researchers have noted that AI models could eventually obtain capabilities in areas relevant to national security. For example, researchers have called to measure and monitor these risks, and have written papers with evidence of risks. Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei also highlighted this topic in recent Senate testimony. With that context, we were pleased to advocate for and join in commitments announced at the White House on July 21 that included “internal and external security testing of [our] AI systems” to guard against “some of the most significant sources of AI risks, such as biosecurity and cybersecurity.” However, red teaming in these specialized areas requires intensive investments of time and subject matter expertise.

In this post, we share our approach to “frontier threats red teaming,” high level findings from a project we conducted on biological risks as a test project, lessons learned, and our future plans in this area.

Our goal in this work is to evaluate a baseline of risk, and to create a repeatable way to perform frontier threats red teaming across many topic areas. With respect to biology, while the details of our findings are highly sensitive, we believe it’s important to share our takeaways from this work. In summary, working with experts, we found that models might soon present risks to national security, if unmitigated. However, we also found that there are mitigations to substantially reduce these risks. . . .

We discovered a few key concerns. The first is that current frontier models can sometimes produce sophisticated, accurate, useful, and detailed knowledge at an expert level. In most areas we studied, this does not happen frequently. In other areas, it does. However, we found indications that the models are more capable as they get larger. We also think that models gaining access to tools could advance their capabilities in biology. Taken together, we think that unmitigated LLMs could accelerate a bad actor’s efforts to misuse biology relative to solely having internet access, and enable them to accomplish tasks they could not without an LLM. These two effects are likely small today, but growing relatively fast. If unmitigated, we worry that these kinds of risks are near-term, meaning that they may be actualized in the next two to three years, rather than five or more.

Well, two or three years takes us to 2025, when Vernor Vinge predicted that technology would put world-ending technologies within reach of anyone having a bad hair day.

IT HAPPENS: Team Haley says the quiet part out loud about the first GOP debate. “Haley’s adviser was honest about the attitude toward Trump. None of them are going to be bold enough to attack Trump. They could challenge him and his record in office. His record is mostly a good one, to be sure, but he has vulnerabilities, too. He accepted the pandemic mandates and advice from Fauci with little more than an off-hand comment about wanting to keep the economy strong and businesses open. That didn’t happen, though, and Team Fauci got what they wanted. The country shut down and everyone stayed home. The economy that had been so robust during Trump’s time in office took a nose dive because so many people were at home and unable to work. It was something we’ve never seen in our lives. . . . Nikki Haley won’t lay a glove on Trump. Heck, she called Trump before she entered the primary and all but asked for his permission to run, according to how Trump tells the story. The only person standing in the way of Nikki’s campaign is Ron DeSantis. And Vivek Ramaswamy. And Mike Pence. You get the point. Haley isn’t even in the top three in the primary race. She’s running for vice president.”

OPEN THREAD: Happy Monday!

SO WHAT? IF IT WAS, WHAT WILL BE DONE ABOUT IT? Was COVID response a coup by the intelligence community? “You can see his point. The IC has been deeply involved in both the censorship regime and the spread of sketchy information that was pushed out. It helped monitor the flow of information, the implementation of draconian policies that limited people’s liberties, and infiltrated social media companies and search engines to manipulate public perception and acceptance of hitherto unheard-of policies that fundamentally altered Western Culture.”

Read the whole thing.