ABOLISH THE CIVIL SERVICE? I have thoughts at Substack.
Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds
October 15, 2023
BOB GRABOYES: Arugula for Asphalt Crews: Unintended Elitism of Healthcare Wonks. “The biggest problem with healthcare policy may be that those who design healthcare policy mostly design it for people who design healthcare policy. . . . We policy folk reside in a variety of institutions: medical facilities, corporations, universities, think tanks, legislative offices, regulatory agencies and advocacy groups. But we broadly share certain characteristics. . . . The problem is that many of America’s most serious health problems reside in people whose lives and jobs do not remotely resemble those of healthcare professionals or policy-shapers.”
SELF-DEFENSE ADVICE: Troubled Times.
AT HARVARD, STANDING UP FOR MURDER, RAPE, AND TORTURE: More Than 1,000 Rally on Harvard’s Campus to ‘Free Palestine’ Ahead of Expected Ground Invasion of Gaza.
GEE, MAYBE YOU GUYS SHOULDN’T HAVE BEEN INFILTRATING CATHOLIC CHURCHES, PARENTS’ GROUPS, AND MAGA RALLIES THEN: FBI director warns of rise in terror threats against Americans, potential copy-cat attacks on US soil.
But hey, maybe he’s reading my columns: Israel’s intelligence failure is a warning for America’s politicized agencies.
SCIENCE, UNSETTLED: Officially extinct fish is alive and well, according to DNA analyses.
NOW OUT FROM ANDREW WAREHAM: The Pinchbeck Peer: Book 7: A New Veneer.
SO HERE’S A STORY BRIMMING WITH SYMPATHY FOR THE HARVARD STUDENTS WHO ENDORSED HAMAS. But it’s worth reading for what it reveals.
Such comments represent a sea change in the cozy relationship between Harvard and the elite institutions where its alumni have traditionally forged their careers. An investor at an asset management firm in Silicon Valley privately told Insider that he recently spoke to a hedge-fund founder who made no bones about how he approaches hiring. When a résumé hits his desk, the founder said, he skips over the sections on experience and education and instead races to the bottom of the page, where applicants list their “activities.” Then, if he sees something he doesn’t like, he will simply “rip up” the résumé and reject the applicant as a “bad cultural fit.”
For Harvard students — especially those in the business and law schools — having prominent leaders in your chosen profession openly declare that they won’t hire graduates who hold political views they disagree with is not an academic issue — it’s an existential threat. In a visit to Harvard, Insider spoke with a range of students about the backlash to the statement on Israel. Many expressed qualms about the tone of the letter, or the way it was handled. But even some who opposed it felt that the threats against its signatories had gone too far.
One MBA student, who thinks the statement was “too strong,” believes it is unfair for companies to demand the names of students who signed it. (Like most students, she spoke on the condition of anonymity, given the potential for reprisals.) Similarly, a Jewish graduate student in Middle Eastern studies said he is “frustrated and angry and sad” to see the truck circling campus branding signatories as antisemitic.
“My take is everyone is free to hire or not hire who they want,” he said. “But I don’t think anyone’s personal information should be made public. I don’t think a 19-year-old who feels something right now and decides to put their name on something should have the rest of their lives decided in this moment. We’ve all done things that we would rather we hadn’t.” . . .
But now, some Harvard students fear that the backlash from the business community will have a chilling effect on student speech. Like it or not, they say, students have to think about how expressing their views could affect their financial and professional prospects. That’s especially true when Wall Street billionaires are posting on X, formerly Twitter, and professional network LinkedIn has become a home for all kinds of sharing. There’s every chance today that what’s said on campus won’t stay on campus.
A first-year law student told Insider that students would be wise to think through what voicing their opinions could mean for their future employment, especially in a buttoned-down field like law. “The general advice,” he said, “is to keep your opinions to yourself for the most part.”
A second-year law student, who was appalled by the letter, likewise sympathized with fellow students who were unnerved by having their words provoke such ire beyond the campus. “There is a real employment consequence for people — and that is a scary situation,” she said. “We are all here with a lot of student loans, and we need to work.”
Sorry, guys, I didn’t make the new rules. But those are the new rules.
HIGHER EDUCATION BUBBLE UPDATE: ‘Take Back Pride at Clemson’ protest held after tampons removed from men’s bathrooms.
You can’t make this up.
NOTHING TO SEE HERE, MOVE ALONG: France quietly putting 7000 troops on the streets. Prediction: Soon they’ll be arming select groups of military veterans.
HIGHER EDUCATION BUBBLE UPDATE: Students for Pogroms in Israel: By excusing murder and kidnapping, activist groups have already changed campus politics in America.
Across America, millions of people with wildly diverse opinions on the longstanding conflict between Israel and Palestine denounced those atrocities, because it is always wrong to deliberately target and slaughter civilians and it is always wrong to abduct, let alone kill, children.
I naively believed that those were near-consensus beliefs on college campuses––that whether one sided with Israelis or Palestinians in the long and heartrending conflict between them, almost everyone could agree that certain actions were evil regardless of who took them. Then this week, on dozens of campuses, student groups reacted to the attacks by attempting to absolve the murderers and child abductors of all responsibility.
To the left, no act is too monstrous if it’s performed by a designated victim group. And our campuses are infested with this toxic stuff.
THE ENEMY WITHIN: Intimidation: Pro-Palestinian U Mass students surround Fox videographer. “The aggressive exchange comes as pro-Palestine groups across America sparked outrage at their support for Hamas’ brutal attack that killed 1,300 Israelis, with tempers flaring from the other side as Israel launches retaliatory sieges on the Gaza Strip.”
ARNOLD KLING: I Condemn. . .But.
BUT TRUMP SUPPORTERS ARE FAIR GAME: DOJ Warns Financial Institutions That They Can’t Reject Illegal Immigrants’ Credit Applications.
October 14, 2023
VIA EMAIL FROM A FRIEND ON THE NORTHWESTERN LAW FACULTY:
October 12, 2023
TO: Northwestern Pritzker Law School Community
FROM: Concerned Faculty
RE: Terrorism in Israel
On Saturday, October 7, Hamas terrorists perpetrated the greatest mass murder of Jews since the Holocaust. The massacre took the lives of over 1300 peaceful civilians of many nationalities, including at least 20 Americans. Many children were among the dead. Adjusted for population that would be about 45,000 deaths in the U.S., or fifteen 9/11 attacks in a single day.
Celebrants at a music festival were gunned down without mercy. Homes were invaded by gunmen, who used explosives to ensure there would be no survivors. There was no military purpose to the attack, only the goal of murdering as many Israeli civilians as possible. The terrorists posted videos of their barbarous acts. Over 100 hostages were kidnapped and taken back to Gaza, evidently including two women from Evanston.
These events have affected many students and faculty, of all faiths and backgrounds, in the Northwestern Pritzker community. In Israel, 23 students and community members from our partner Tel Aviv University are among the murdered.
As faculty members dedicated to the rule of law, we choose to make clear that we unequivocally condemn Hamas’s wanton acts of terrorism, which have made the establishment of a just peace, recognizing the human rights of every community, all the more difficult to achieve.
Some have claimed that the Hamas atrocities must be blamed on Israel. What Hamas perpetrated was unspeakably evil. It is dehumanizing to blame the murders on the victims. We absolutely reject such acceptance, and near-endorsement, of terrorism.
[67 Signatures.]
OPEN THREAD: Bring the excitement.
THE NEW SPACE RACE: UK’s Asteroid Mining Corp. unveils SCAR-E robot.
A WARNING FROM AUSTIN BAY: Pay Attention: Don’t Let Ukraine-Gaza Lead to WWIII Taiwan.