THE NEW SPACE RACE: China displays crewed moon landing mission elements.
Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds
September 30, 2021
MY NEW YORK POST COLUMN: Flawed COVID mandates are speeding up the flight out of public schools.
Condoms, antibiotics, vitamins, to start. I mean, after the obvious stuff.
THE SUPREME COURT WAS “ILLEGITIMATE” WHEN IT WAS A BARRIER TO LEFTY GOALS, SACRED WHEN IT WAS ADVANCING THEM, AND WILL RETURN TO “ILLEGITIMATE” STATUS WHEN IT STARTS THWARTING THEM: A Preemptive Attack on the Supreme Court.
AMERICA’S progressives have spent most of the past year wailing about people who undermine faith in democratic institutions. “Misinformation” that casts doubt on the election of President Biden, they tell us, must be combated at every level — by “calling it out” where possible and censoring it where necessary.
Unfortunately for their case, these same people call into question the legitimacy of virtually every election they lose: George W. Bush “stole” the 2000 election; the Koch brothers’ wicked weaponization of Citizens United gave us the Tea Party wave of 2010; and of course the 2016 election was handed to Donald Trump by Vladimir Putin. And all the while, they have pushed relentlessly to loosen voter-integrity laws, as if making election procedures a partisan issue can’t reasonably lead anyone to question election results.
Simply put, throwing a temper tantrum every time you lose an election has become a bipartisan habit, one that Democrats are at least as prone to as Republicans. Witness the preemptive strikes on the legitimacy of today’s Supreme Court.
The progressive narrative here is based on an essential piece of misinformation, albeit one whose falsity is lost on most proponents, including more than a few law professors. That is the contention that Republicans in the Senate illegitimately blocked Barack Obama’s nominee to fill a vacant seat during the 2016 election but then turned around and confirmed Donald Trump’s nominee four years later. Thus, through what Harry Reid used to call an “untoward maneuver” on Mitch McConnell’s part, the Republicans erected an illegitimate supermajority of conservative justices.
Lawrence Douglas, who holds the James Grosfeld chair in Law, Jurisprudence, and Social Thought at Amherst College, recently argued in The Guardian that, to protect the Supreme Court’s legitimacy, one of the conservative justices should summarily step down so the Democrats can fill the seat. Douglas asserts:
And just as we might hope that a person who, through no fault of their own, has come into possession of a good not rightfully theirs, would return that object, Coney Barrett and Gorsuch could do the right thing for the nation by agreeing that one of them should step down.
Douglas argues that one of the two justices’ seats is “not rightfully theirs” because, “if presidents do not get to replace justices in an election year, then Coney Barrett’s confirmation is illegitimate; if presidents do, then Gorsuch’s is illegitimate. You can’t have it both ways.”
In fact, both confirmations complied with constitutional requirements.
The Constitution provides that Supreme Court seats are to be filled by the president, with the advice and consent of the Senate. This assignment of roles can get confusing, but it’s not rocket science. Critics have argued that Obama’s nomination of Merrick Garland was the same as Trump’s nomination of Amy Coney Barrett: Both occurred in an election year, and Mitch McConnell should have brought both of them up for a vote.
But the two situations were not analogous, for in both situations the Republicans controlled the Senate, and in Obama’s case, that required negotiating with the opposition party, not exactly his forte. In reality, Obama could easily have filled Antonin Scalia’s seat: All he had to do was nominate someone conservative enough that Republicans would be happy to confirm the nominee. But, with the 2016 election looming, Obama naturally saw a chance to flip the seat long held by Scalia and establish a solid progressive majority on the Court. He decided to nominate a solid progressive who was mainstream enough that Republicans might be pressured into confirming him; and if they didn’t, he was betting that Democrats would win both White House and Senate and would soon be able to fill the seat with anyone they liked.
The Constitution provides that Supreme Court seats are to be filled by the president, with the advice and consent of the Senate. This assignment of roles can get confusing, but it’s not rocket science. Critics have argued that Obama’s nomination of Merrick Garland was the same as Trump’s nomination of Amy Coney Barrett: Both occurred in an election year, and Mitch McConnell should have brought both of them up for a vote.
But the two situations were not analogous, for in both situations the Republicans controlled the Senate, and in Obama’s case, that required negotiating with the opposition party, not exactly his forte. In reality, Obama could easily have filled Antonin Scalia’s seat: All he had to do was nominate someone conservative enough that Republicans would be happy to confirm the nominee. But, with the 2016 election looming, Obama naturally saw a chance to flip the seat long held by Scalia and establish a solid progressive majority on the Court. He decided to nominate a solid progressive who was mainstream enough that Republicans might be pressured into confirming him; and if they didn’t, he was betting that Democrats would win both White House and Senate and would soon be able to fill the seat with anyone they liked.
So Obama decided to raise the stakes and put the onus on Mitch McConnell. Unfortunately for him, playing political poker against Mitch McConnell rarely turns out well. McConnell raised the bet and announced that no vote would be held on Garland’s nomination, thereby making the crucial seat a key issue in the 2016 election. McConnell has been endlessly pilloried for that move, but all he did was make precisely the same calculation that Obama had made, with just as much right and reason, except that he was arguably cornered into it by Obama’s high-stakes gamble.
It was a considered risk on Obama’s part and would have paid off hugely for progressives — if Democrats hadn’t lost the 2016 election. Instead of paving the way for someone even more progressive than Merrick Garland, the 2016 election paved the way for someone even more conservative than Scalia, if that was possible: Trump quickly nominated Neil Gorsuch, and the Senate quickly confirmed him. Brett Kavanaugh and Coney Barrett followed.
Douglas’s implied argument of “constitutional but illegitimate” recalls Dan Rather’s “fake but accurate” defense of misinformation that he peddled during the 2004 election. But the tactic is even more unavailing here, for Douglas’s position is based not on any democratic principle, but rather on his reading of a principle that he vehemently disputes, namely the “McConnell rule.”
McConnell’s narrow justification for not holding a vote over Garland’s nomination in 2016 was basically this: When nominations occur during an election year, and White House and Senate are controlled by different parties, either the president or the Senate may elect to keep the seat vacant until after the election.
As noted previously, the failure to fill Scalia’s vacant seat during 2016 resulted from a combination of moves in which Obama had first-mover advantage. In fact, if the Democrats had won both White House and Senate in 2016, McConnell’s best move in the lame-duck session would have been to push for the immediate confirmation of Garland, to limit the damage. Obama’s best move would then have been to withdraw the nomination so Hillary Clinton could nominate someone even more progressive. These “manipulations” of the rules are not only not illegitimate — they are precisely the interplay of elected bodies that the Framers had in mind when they chose to divide the power to appoint federal judges between president and Senate.
Like the phrase “our democracy,” which just means “untrammeled Democratic Party power,” Democrats’ talk of legitimacy and the Constitution is just about . . . untrammeled Democratic Party power.
YESTERDAY’S HEROES GET THE CAN:
For most of spring 2020, rattled New Yorkers trudged out onto their stoops and balconies every night at 7 p.m. sharp to bang their pots and pans and holler appreciation for the first responders—cops, nurses, doctors, EMTs, firefighters—who, unlike them, did not really have the choice to stay home from work while the deadly coronavirus ripped through the five boroughs.
As of Tuesday, those same New Yorkers, through their representative government, are telling those same essential workers to go look for a new job, unless they have been vaccinated for COVID-19 or have filed for a religious exception from the statewide mandate.
If it’s really still a crisis, why are we letting health workers go?
THE NEW SPACE RACE: Can China really be on Mars before SpaceX or NASA?
BRITAIN GETS SERIOUS ABOUT GLOBAL WARMING: Government poised to approve 16 mini nuclear reactors to hit net zero. “Ministers are understood to have adopted a ‘change of focus’ towards nuclear power amid the current crisis caused by rocketing global wholesale gas prices.”
Plus: “Chancellor Rishi Sunak is said to have made clear in a meeting on Friday that he thought nuclear should play a more prominent role in future energy policy. A source close to Mr Sunak said his general view was that Britain should have had a weightier focus on nuclear ‘ten years ago, when it was cheaper’ but added that the country ‘can’t rely’ on wind and solar power.” Well, he’s right.
KAROL MARKOWICZ: Parents fight school mask mandates for kids – just follow the science, they plead.
One of the more outspoken pro-mask members of the school board, Alexandria Ayala, was photographed recently partying maskless in a large crowd at the swanky Breakers Palm Beach. Outrage ensued. Ayala took to Twitter to argue she still believes in masking children at school. “Vaccinated adults around other vaccinated people can go maskless. But until students are vaxxed, they need to stay masked.”
Of course, all data shows unvaccinated kids have an even lower risk of a poor COVID-19 outcome than vaccinated adults. It’s this exact rejection of the data that has led people like Ayala to turn masking into a political statement even though they themselves can’t maintain it.
Plus: “In most blue areas, masking has long become a virtue signal instead of a safety measure.”
THIS WILL MAKE THINGS EASIER: Smith & Wesson Move Continues the Migration of Gun Makers to States That Support Gun Rights.
NEWS YOU CAN USE: Why We Need to Encourage New Shooters to Get Training.
GETTING FROM CHEMISTRY TO BIOLOGY: Self-replicating protocells created in lab may be life’s “missing link.”
DAVID BARON, CALL YOUR OFFICE: Basta! Romans say enough to invasion of wild boars in city.
They’re wily and dangerous, but delicious.
GLEICHSCHALTUNG: US Marine seen in viral video rescuing baby at Kabul airport investigated for appearing at Trump rally.
Meanwhile General Milley still has an office and a book deal in the works.
“PREGNANT PEOPLE:” CDC urges pregnant people to get vaccinated against COVID-19.
Science!
THIS PREDICTION HELD UP WELL: Sorry, there will be no return to normalcy under Joe Biden. “As the presidential campaign enters its final phase, one of the messages of the Biden campaign is that putting him, a 47-year veteran of national politics, into the White House will return us to something approaching normal. With Biden in charge, all the Trump craziness will expire, and things will be safe, sane and familiar. In fact, there’s no chance of this happening.”
More recently, from Conrad Black: “As we get to the midpoint between the last presidential election and next year’s midterms, all political sides are expending extraordinary effort to ignore the 900-pound gorilla in the formerly smoke-filled room of American politics. This, of course, is Donald Trump. The Democrats are still outwardly pretending Trump has gone and that his support has evaporated. They also pretend they can hobble him with vexatious litigation and, if necessary, destroy him again by raising the Trump-hate media smear campaign back to ear-splitting levels.”
WOULD THE WORLD BE A BETTER PLACE if Marx and Freud had never lived?
I REMEMBER WHEN WE WERE TOLD WE SHOULD SUPPORT HIGHER EDUCATION BECAUSE IT FOSTERED CRITICAL THOUGHT AND GOOD CITIZENSHIP: Students angry at invitation to journalist who advised against rush to judgment in cop shootings.
SMITH AND WESSON IS moving from Massachusetts to my neck of the woods. “Smith & Wesson joins more than 20 small arms and ammunition manufacturers located in Tennessee. Tennessee ranks No. 1 in the nation for employment in the small arms and ammunition sector, with employment increasing by 54% over the last five years.”
WHY WOULD UCSD HONOR A RACIST, HOMOPHOBIC MASS MURDERER? Inspired by ‘radical’ politics, the CHE Cafe attempts to reopen at UCSD.
WHY INDEED? BMJ: Vaccinating people who have had covid-19: why doesn’t natural immunity count in the US?
The substantial number of infections, coupled with the increasing scientific evidence that natural immunity was durable, led some medical observers to ask why natural immunity didn’t seem to be factored into decisions about prioritising vaccination.234
“The CDC could say [to people who had recovered], very well grounded in excellent data, that you should wait 8 months,” Monica Gandhi, an infectious disease specialist at University of California San Francisco, told Medpage Today in January. She suggested authorities ask people to “please wait your turn.”4
Others, such as Icahn School of Medicine virologist and researcher Florian Krammer, argued for one dose in those who had recovered. “This would also spare individuals from unnecessary pain when getting the second dose and it would free up additional vaccine doses,” he told the New York Times.5
“Many of us were saying let’s use [the vaccine] to save lives, not to vaccinate people already immune,” says Marty Makary, a professor of health policy and management at Johns Hopkins University.
Still, the CDC instructed everyone, regardless of previous infection, to get fully vaccinated as soon as they were eligible: natural immunity “varies from person to person” and “experts do not yet know how long someone is protected,” the agency stated on its website in January.6 By June, a Kaiser Family Foundation survey found that 57% of those previously infected got vaccinated.7
As more US employers, local governments, and educational institutions issue vaccine mandates that make no exception for those who have had covid-19,8 questions remain about the science and ethics of treating this group of people as equally vulnerable to the virus—or as equally threatening to those vulnerable to covid-19—and to what extent politics has played a role.
A very large extent. Plus:
Gandhi and others have been urging reporters away from antibodies as the defining metric of immunity. “It is accurate that your antibodies will go down” after natural infection, she says—that’s how the immune system works. If antibodies didn’t clear from our bloodstream after we recover from a respiratory infection, “our blood would be thick as molasses.”
“The real memory in our immune system resides in the [T and B] cells, not in the antibodies themselves,” says Patrick Whelan, a paediatric rheumatologist at University of California, Los Angeles. He points out that his sickest covid-19 patients in intensive care, including children with multisystem inflammatory syndrome, have “had loads of antibodies … So the question is, why didn’t they protect them?”
Antonio Bertoletti, a professor of infectious disease at Duke-NUS Medical School in Singapore, has conducted research that indicates T cells may be more important than antibodies. Comparing the T cell response in people with symptomatic versus asymptomatic covid-19, Bertoletti’s team found them to be identical, suggesting that the severity of infection does not predict strength of resulting immunity and that people with asymptomatic infections “mount a highly functional virus specific cellular immune response.”
InstaPundit readers have known this for quite a long time. The CDC still hasn’t figured it out. Or admitted it.
Also: “‘As we continued to put effort into vaccination and set targets, it became apparent to me that people were forgetting that herd immunity is formed by both natural immunity and vaccine immunity,’ says Klausner.”
BYRON YORK: Milley’s Dishing.
The job of chairman of the Joint Chiefs is a very busy one. The debacle of U.S. forces’ withdrawal from Afghanistan, for example, demanded round-the-clock attention. But in recent months, Gen. Mark Milley has found time to talk to a number of authors writing books that were very critical of former President Donald Trump.
Three of the biggest such books, all bestsellers, were Peril , by Bob Woodward and Robert Costa; I Alone Can Fix It , by the Washington Post’s Carol Leonnig and Philip Rucker; and Frankly, We Did Win This Election , by the Wall Street Journal’s Michael Bender. All featured quotes and information that appeared to come directly from Milley.
At Tuesday’s hearing of the Senate Armed Services Committee, Republican Sen. Marsha Blackburn asked Milley whether he had spoken to the authors. “Did you talk to Bob Woodward or Robert Costa for their book, Peril?” asked Blackburn. “Woodward, yes, Costa, no,” answered Milley. “Did you talk to Carol Leonnig and Philip Rucker for their book, I Alone Can Fix It?” “Yes,” said Milley. “Did you talk to Michael Bender for his book, Frankly, We Did Win This Election?” “Yes,” said Milley.
Blackburn asked Milley whether the authors had accurately represented his interviews in their books. Milley said he does not know because he hasn’t read any of them.
Milley told Leonnig and Rucker that he feared Trump might try to stage a coup after losing the 2020 election. “This is a Reichstag moment ,” the authors quote Milley telling aides. “The gospel of the Fuhrer.” And more: “They may try, but they’re not going to f—ing succeed,” the authors quote Milley telling his deputies. “You can’t do this without the military. You can’t do this without the CIA and the FBI. We’re the guys with the guns.”
Then the coup never came. “Thank God Almighty we landed the ship safely,” Milley told Leonnig and Rucker. The authors described a scene at the inauguration of President Joe Biden in which Milley expressed relief to former first lady Michelle Obama. “No one has a bigger smile today than I do,” Milley told Obama. “You can’t see it under my mask, but I do.”
Where does such dishing fit in the job description of the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff? At Tuesday’s hearing, Republican Sen. Rick Scott asked, “Why would you as the sitting chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff talk to a reporter who is writing a book about a prior administration? Why would that be part of your job description?”
Milley said he talks to the media regularly, multiple times a week. “I think it’s very important that senior officials talk to the media, in all its various forms, in order to explain what we’re doing,” he said.
But Scott wanted to know why Milley was dishing about a former president. “Why would you … talk to a reporter who is writing a book about a prior administration? Why would that be part of your job description?”
“I think it’s important to make sure that the American people are transparent with what our government does, is all,” Milley said. “Nothing more complicated than that.”
But Milley’s talks with Woodward, Leonnig, Rucker, Bender — and possibly other authors as well — clearly went beyond ensuring “transparency” about the Joint Chiefs’ activities. The general’s “Reichstag moment” quote spoke volumes about the statement he wanted to make for the books that would describe the Trump administration’s final days.
And then Milley got burned by Woodward’s and Costa’s sensational portrayal of his conversations with a top Chinese general, which led to some critics accusing Milley of “treason.” As it turned out, the critics were not being fair, and events did not transpire exactly as the book said. Milley suffered some unjustified criticism. But that’s the lesson for the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff: Live by the media, die by the media.
He should be on trial. Fired at the very least, and I mean the very, very least.
ANTI-SEMITIC GARBAGE PEOPLE AREN’T A PROBLEM FOR THE DEMOCRATS, THEY’RE A CORE CONSTITUENCY NOW: College Democrats Leader Under Fire For Anti-Semitic Tweets.
Democrats used to push the “punch a Nazi” line, but now they’re pushing people who think of Jews the way Nazis did.