Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

YOU KNOW WHAT ELSE WOULD HELP? NOT SPENDING TRILLIONS ON BULLSHIT. NY Times Op-Ed: A Progressive Consumption Tax Could Help With Inflation.

Also, instead of “dialing taxes up and down” to suit the economy, how about stable levels of taxation that let people plan and invest? Insufficient opportunity for graft there, I suppose.

EVERYTHING IS GOING SWIMMINGLY:

KEEPIN’ UP THE SKEER: Ukraine could recapture Crimea as fleeing Russians continue to flounder.

Western officials have previously considered retaking Crimea by force impossible, because Russia was expected to fight tooth and claw to defend it.

But a senior US officer told The Telegraph that recent Russian military collapses mean “the recapture of Crimea by Ukraine is now a distinct possibility and can no longer be discounted”.

Pushing into Crimea would mean Ukraine going further than the front lines of Feb 23, when Putin ordered the invasion of Ukraine.

Russia annexed Crimea in 2014 and would likely view a ground assault on the critical strategic enclave as a major escalation.

The US official said: “It is clear that Russia no longer has the ability or willpower to defend key positions, and if the Ukrainians succeed in their goal of recapturing Kherson, then there is a very real possibility that it will ultimately be able to recapture Crimea.”

The comments follow those from Laura Cooper, US deputy assistant secretary of defence, who said that Crimea was within Ukraine’s grasp. “And just to be clear, Crimea is Ukraine,” she added.

Putin is likely to disagree, but his opinion is carrying less weight every day.

Related: Russian Frontline Collapsing Due to Lack of Commanders:

Russia doesn’t have the commanders to stop its frontline collapsing, a defence expert has said.

Ed Arnold, research fellow at the Royal United Services Institute, told Sky News: “Effectively, the Russian front has started to collapse.

“When armies collapse like this they need very good commanders to rally the troops, which the Russians just don’t have at the moment.”

He said there were also “no natural defensive positions” around the Russian army.

As Ukraine has already achieved its “primary political objective” – of “showing the West that it can take back territory – and using the weapons systems provided to do that” – he said that it was now liberating as many settlements as possible before winter.

He added it will also aim to ensure occupied territories are in range of the longer-range weapons systems, “so they can further degrade the Russians”.

Stay tuned. A loss of the Crimea is not an existential threat to Russia, but it may be one to Putin.

#JOURNALISM: Paper of Record? NYT’s embarrassing Emily Litella flip-flop on election conspiracy theories.

Democratic election conspiracy theories (even when obviously bogus): Good old fashioned skepticism. Republican election conspiracy theories (even when true): Ridiculous fever dreams. Threat to democracy.

Democratic political violence (even when cities burn): Good ol’ rough-and-tumble politics. Republican political violence (even when it’s imaginary): Insurrection, basically Hitler.

Takeaway: “Maybe next time, reporters can try reporting rather than just regurgitating their own conspiracy theories as ‘news.’ It would save them embarrassing episodes such as this, and might actually allow for the issues of election security to get discussed in a rational manner.” Haha, you guys crack me up.

FREEDOM OF INFORMATION AND a “conference room contrivance.” “In the mind’s eye it’s possible to see whoever wrote that wording about Knox News’ motives leaning back in their chair and smiling with self-satisfaction. If read to advisers there might have been nods of approval and comments like, ‘That’ll get ‘em.’ Maybe it was hammered out by a group of people in a conference room. The argument has no basis in the state’s public records law.”

I tell my law students that when, as lawyers, you’re patting each other on the back about how smart you are, it’s probably a warning sign.

NOBODY JOE BIDEN PICKS FOR ANYTHING SEEMS TO BE ABLE TO SPEAK CLEARLY AND TO THE POINT: KBJ’s Jumbled Musings on the Fourteenth Amendment.

In today’s oral argument in Merrill v. Milligan, Justice Jackson capped her very long questioning of Alabama solicitor general Edmund LaCour with a speech/question that went on for around four minutes and that runs a full three pages (57:2-60:2) in the transcript. In her speech, Jackson states that the Framers of the 14th Amendment adopted it “in a race conscious way,” as they were “trying to ensure that people who had been discriminated against, the freedmen in — during the reconstructive — reconstruction period were actually brought equal to everyone else in the society.” As she puts it, the Civil Rights Act of 1866 “specifically stated that citizens would have the same civil rights as enjoyed by white citizens,” and the Fourteenth Amendment was designed to ensure that the Act had a solid “constitutional foundation.”

Somehow Jackson leaps from these propositions to the assertion that the 14th Amendment doesn’t embody “a race-neutral or race-blind idea in terms of the remedy” for discrimination against freed slaves.

So if it’s all about remedies for slavery, I guess it’s not going to protect abortion or contraception or gay rights, then. Interestingly, when Robert Bork advanced a similar theory of the 14th Amendment it was poorly received.

But there’s more:

I don’t understand her leap. By her own account, the very purpose of the Civil Rights Act of 1866 was “to make sure that the other citizens, the black citizens, would have the same [civil rights] as the white citizens.” It was designed to remedy a situation in which “people, based on their race, were being treated unequally” by the states. And the 14th Amendment had the same goal.

The proposition that the 14th Amendment requires that the government be color-blind is open to challenge both as to what exactly that means and to whether that meaning is well founded. But Jackson seems to think that the color-blind position is somehow at odds with the fact that the 14th Amendment was designed to ensure equal treatment—when that of course is exactly what advocates of the color-blind position maintain the 14th Amendment requires.

Jackson seems to confuse herself with her own terms.

Well, she’s new on the Court but this doesn’t bode well.