Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

THAT’S BEEN THE MAIN CONTROLLING CLAUSE SINCE 1937: Please show us the Experts Clause of the Constitution, Justices Sotomayor and Kagan. “There is no provision within the United States Constitution that accords unlimited power to bureaucrats simply because some people consider them to be well-credentialed.”

Well, there’s nothing in the text, but there’s a lot of caselaw to the contrary.

THE NATION, SIX YEARS AGO: Are We Witnessing a Coup Operation Against the Trump White House? Our intelligence apparatus is doing far more than stoking paranoia about the Russian bogeyman—it’s threatening democracy. “Read the histories. The Ivy League culture that still suffuses the CIA has from the first been far more liberal than conservative. The Democratic Party’s Clintonian era is perfectly exemplary on this point. As a smart friend said the other day, John Brennan, who served Bill Clinton and then Obama at the CIA and wanted to serve in an HRC administration, had a lot of trouble sorting out his role in Langley and his relations with the Democrats. Now look.”

Plus: “Either the media are Clintonian liberals before they are newspapers and broadcasters, or they are servants of power before they serve us. This is the media’s disgrace, but our problem.”

Well, that certainly turned out to be the case here.

HIGHER EDUCATION BUBBLE UPDATE: U.S. News, Department Of Education, And Law Schools Take The Gloves Off In Rankings Battle.

The real objection to the rankings is that they make it harder to discriminate on the basis of race, and they want to discriminate on the basis of race. There are legitimate concerns with the rankings, but that’s what’s driving this.

Meanwhile, U.S. News is fighting back by asking the Secretary of Education “to demand that all schools – including elite law schools – provide open access to all of their undergraduate and graduate school data, using a common data set. This would enable prospective students and their families to make meaningful comparisons between institutions, based on factors such as financial information, admissions data, and outcome statistics, including employment rates at graduation.”

That’s fair. These schools, whether public or private, sit atop a geyser of public funding. They wouldn’t exist in their current form without it.

HETERODOX ACADEMY DISAPPOINTS.

UPDATE: A response from Heterodox Academy: “I’m the Executive Director of Heterodox Academy. I’d like your readers (and Instapundit readers!) to know that the past membership policy described here has not been in effect since 2019. Membership in HxA includes no ideological litmus test whatsoever; faculty and staff affiliated with a college or university, current or retired, can learn more and join us at HeterodoxAcademy.org.”

(Bumped).

ANTISEMITISM IN BIDEN’S AMERICA: The Vanishing: The erasure of Jews from American life.

A tenure-track humanities professor at a prestigious public university tells of the finalists for her department’s next graduate school cohort. Of the 20 or so candidates, four to five are Jews. One is a working-class yeshivish applicant with an incredible backstory and even better recommendations. He is passed over for not being “diverse” enough. Of course our professor doesn’t complain— her own tenure is at risk. In the end, not a single Jew is offered admission.

Another Jewish professor applies to work in the UC system. In his mandatory diversity statement, which he describes as “the most shameful piece of writing I’ve ever done,” his sole aim is to convey the impression that he hopes to be the last Jewish man they ever hire. He still doesn’t get the job.

And why would he? Using YouGov data, Eric Kaufmann finds that just 4% of elite American academics under 30 are Jewish (compared to 21% of boomers). The steep decline of Jewish editors at the Harvard Law Review (down roughly 50% in less than 10 years) could be the subject of its own law review article.

The same pattern holds across America’s elite institutions: a slow-moving downward trend from the 1990s to the mid-2010s—likely due to all sorts of normal sociological factors—and then a purge so sweeping and dramatic you almost wonder who sent out the secret memo.

Museum boards now diversify by getting Jews to resign. A well-respected Jewish curator at the Guggenheim is purged after she puts on a Basquiat show. At the Art Institute of Chicago, even the nice Jewish lady volunteers are terminated for having the wrong ethnic background. There’s an entire cottage industry of summer programs and fellowships and postdocs that are now off-limits to Jews.

In 2014 there were 16-20 Jewish artists featured at the Whitney Biennial. After a very public campaign against a Jewish board member with ties to the Israeli defense establishment, the curators got the message. The 2022 biennial featured just 1-2 Jews.

Comb through the dozens of Jewish names for the 2012 Guggenheim Fellowship (I count 30-40). You’ll have a much harder time finding them 10 years later (14-16). There were 3-4 Jewish Marshall Scholars in 2014. I don’t see any in 2022.

Disgraceful. The only comfort is, most of them voted Democrat, and now they’re getting what they wanted, good and hard.

Related: Asians Get The Ivy League’s Jewish Treatment.

OPEN THREAD: Why not?

HIGHER EDUCATION BUBBLE UPDATE, BIDEN ERA VERSION: Dishonor Code: What Happens When Cheating Becomes the Norm? “Students say they are getting ‘screwed over’ for sticking to the rules. Professors say students are acting like ‘tyrants.’ Then came ChatGPT . . .”

ACCOUNTABILITY IS FOR THE LITTLE PEOPLE:

ICYMI: BRANNON DENNING AND I TALK ABOUT HOW THE SUPREME COURT RETCONNED HELLER IN THE BRUEN OPINION. The new opinion is certainly an improvement, but it is a new opinion and new doctrine.

Download it early and often — it’s good for us and our topic if we rise in the rankings. Thanks! (Bumped).

And thanks to everyone who’s downloaded it so far. I really appreciate you.