ANNALS OF FAUX OUTRAGE: Jason Aldean Isn’t ‘Pro-Lynching.’ And His Critics Know It.
Well of course not, that was always a Democrat thing.
ANNALS OF FAUX OUTRAGE: Jason Aldean Isn’t ‘Pro-Lynching.’ And His Critics Know It.
Well of course not, that was always a Democrat thing.
THE NCLA HAS FILED AN AMICUS BRIEF asking the Supreme Court to formally overrule the Chevron decision. The Court has kinda sorta done so already, but not quite explicitly.
Disclosure/reminder: I’m on the advisory board of NCLA.
BAD SCIENCE GETS REWARDED: Stanford’s president is not the only researcher pushing unfounded and incorrect conclusions.
Some of these things were said recently, when the Stanford University president resigned to spend more time doing research (which, ironically, was the problem).
Yet, these same people routinely use false studies to push for conclusions they like. In fact, the majority of scientists conduct research that is false, not useful or not helpful. Only a tiny fraction of scientists stick to true and useful.
While fraud is the worst conduct— using false studies to support your views is hardly better. The Figure illustrates the spectrum of bad science from Fraud to Truth. Let me give some examples of people using bad science to further their agenda, and argue for strategies to solve the problem.
Just in the last two years, we have seen bad science repeated widely.
Black doctors have half the risk of death when they care for black babies vs white doctors. That is an incredible claim, and the underlying PNAS paper is completely flawed, as I explain in the link. Sadly the flawed study was cited in the dissenting opinion of the Supreme Court.
During the pandemic, public health ‘experts’ amplified flawed mask studies and, those who routinely promoted flawed studies or flawed interpretations were bizarrely promoted to public health dean.
Much more at the link. Related: Retract “Proximal Origin?” No, says Nature Medicine editor.
We now have contemporaneous Slack messages and emails where the authors not only express doubts that what they were writing was true, but that prove they thought that the claim they were making–that COVID arose naturally without human interference and that it spread from an animal to a human being via natural processes–was likely not true. . . .
There is now a near consensus that at the very least a lab leak is quite plausible, which has raised the question: why hasn’t Nature Medicine, the journal that published this paper that spawned a million censorships, looked into retracting the paper given its clear contradiction with both reality and with the now apparent opinions of the authors as they wrote the paper?
If the authors lied in the paper, shouldn’t it be retracted?
No. Because Nature Medicine is now rewriting history. The editor now claims that the paper wasn’t research at all, but an expression of an opinion. Just a “point of view.” It wasn’t definitive research, but an Op/Ed or something.
Also related: CDC boss’ utterly laughable exit warning on politicized ‘science.’
JAMES PETHOKOUKIS: A look at gloomy, dystopian Generation Z: Our education system is failing them.
Is failing, has failed.
COMMANDER SALAMANDER: This is a Navy.
The people ostensibly running ours need to be reminded what one does.
FALL OF THE INSTITUTIONS:
The dancing TikTok nurses are back except this time it’s for “climate change”
Do these people not realize they’re singlehandedly ruining the reputation of the medical industry?
Humiliating
— DC_Draino (@DC_Draino) July 24, 2023
OPEN THREAD: This is your moment.
MY NEW YORK POST COLUMN: Our society’s ‘top brains’ have gone mad — and dysfunctional politics is the result.
FISH OIL FOR THE WIN: Increased Omega-3 Intake May Protect Against Age-Related Hearing Loss.
ROBERT GRABOYES ON ALEXANDER GRAHAM BELL: “Alexander Graham Bell is an exemplar of how experts and geniuses can simultaneously do unimaginable good and unspeakable harm, all with the best of intentions. In 1876, Bell introduced the world’s first practicable telephone, bringing the whole world into intimate contact as never before. In that same period, he successfully demanded worldwide changes in the teaching of deaf students and, in so doing, ruined their educations, communities, and lives for nearly a century. Decades later, he feared the raging excesses of eugenics while continuing to lend his name and prestige to that movement—just as it ramped up its agenda of forced sterilizations, rigid segregation, restricted immigration, and state control over who could marry whom. For me, Bell’s story offers profound lessons concerning the state of American education in 2023.”
WHOM THE GODS WOULD DESTROY, THEY FIRST MAKE RIDICULOUS: How to Kill the Incompetocracy: Ruling class legitimacy is built on academic prestige. That’s a fatal weakness ripe for disruption.
As I’ve written before, the ruling class ultimately derives its assumed right to rule from the prestige of academic institutions. The idea is that the smartest kids are admitted to the best schools, where they’re taught by the top minds in the sciences, philosophy, law, medicine, and the arts. They therefore possess both the highest degree of natural aptitude, and have been provided with the best possible training, meaning that they are naturally the most suited to take society’s reigns. As a result, the most powerful institutions recruit primarily from these top universities, meaning that the top universities are the gatekeepers to power. Once one has obtained a degree from the right school, and as long as one does not rock the boat too much, the doors to the halls of power open, and the money follows.
If it worked properly, it would be quite noble. The problem is, it doesn’t. . . .
Credentials are meant to serve a crucial social function. They’re supposed to be a guarantee that a potential employee or professional has mastered the skills for which his services are being retained. When you walk into a doctor’s office, you don’t want to spend three hours grilling him on his knowledge of molecular biology and skeletal anatomy; you want to assume he knows his stuff, so you can get on with the business of figuring out whether or why you’re sick and what to do about it. The credential outsources professional quality control to a third party, making it easier for both of you to conduct business. . . .
At some point over the last generation, the ruling class shifted its emphasis from competence to ideological loyalty. Some degree of indoctrination was always a factor, of course, but until recently the idea was to take the smartest recruits you could find, and then make them loyal. That was the purpose of the Rhodes scholarships, for instance. It was widely understood that while you needed your leadership cadre to be team players, it was absolutely crucial that they also be good at what they do. In practice, that meant sacrificing a certain degree of unity of purpose, because smart, ruthless people also tend to be independent-minded and outspoken. Still, whatever amount of friction that was caused by the ruling class sometimes operating at cross-purposes with itself was more than compensated for by the competitive advantages of a truly meritorious elite.
It doesn’t work that way anymore. Now, entrance into the top schools depends far less on grades, which is to say far less on ability, and more far on ideological purity. The ruling class has prioritized loyalty above all else.
Absolutely. My Post column for tomorrow sounds a similar theme.
Plus:
The result is the incompetocracy: a ruling class exhibiting near perfect unity of rigidly disciplined ideological purpose, able to move in synch with one another like a school of hungry piranhas, but composed of unimpressive cretins who are individually incapable of doing whatever task is assigned to them.
Look at Biden’s train wreck of a regime. These people all attended the best schools. I wrote that last sentence without actually knowing, I just assumed it was probably true, but sure enough: the new press secretary, Karine Jean-Pierre, went to a Long Island prep school, and has a master’s degree from Columbia. Despite that, she’s barely able to string enough coherent words together to form a half-convincing deception. The mumbling non-entity of a Secretary of State Antony Blinken is a Harvard man, which is no defense against being regularly humiliated by his international counterparts. Treasury Secretary Yellen attended Brown and got her PhD from Yale, which does nothing at all to stop shortages and inflation from nuking the economy. Attorney-General Merrick Garland has a law degree from Harvard, and presides over a steady dissolution in the rule of law. Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo is a Rhodes Scholar. And so on and so forth. They’re an impressively credentialed group of people, but the country is rotting like a dead raccoon on the highway.
Look at the total failure of the public health system over the last two years, the absolute pointless nightmare we’ve all lived through, and are still living through.
They really are almost incomprehensibly awful.
Plus:
So long as membership into the ruling class is regulated by admission to top universities, however, the ruling class can’t be changed, because the universities are specifically designed to make sure that only the ideologically pure can get through. It’s a cozy relationship they’ve got and none of them have any intention of changing it.
Therefore, we need to break the monopoly of the universities.
Since the universities don’t sell education, but credentials, we need a new system of credentialing.
We do, and we’re seeing more competency-based hiring starting to appear. Not at the top, of course, but disruptors usually start at the bottom and work their way up.
And despite my long excerpts, click through and read the whole thing.
MICROBIOME NEWS: Hardship affects the gut microbiome across generations. “Hardship experienced by mothers during their own childhood or during pregnancy is reflected in the composition of their 2-year-old children’s gut microbiomes, reports an international team of scientists led by UCLA psychologists. The researchers found small to medium changes in the children’s microbiomes. The research is the first to document the transgenerational effects of adversity on the human gut microbiome.”
I BELIEVE IT’S CALLED WINTER COLD-AND-FLU SEASON: Ready for another ‘tripledemic’? CDC prepares for a winter of ‘3 bugs out there.’
THE LEFT GOES CRAZY ANYTIME IT LOSES MONOPOLY CONTROL OF AN UNDEMOCRATIC INSTITUTION: Israel Passes Judicial Reform In Face Of Mass Left-Wing Protests.
And then screams about the “end of democracy.”
TRANSPARENCY: FBI ‘Still Analyzing’ Another Killer’s Manifesto The Public Will Likely Never See.
We know what it means when they say they may never know the motive.
“COVID ORIGINS:” An Animated Adventure.
IF ONLY WE CAN LEARN TO PROGRAM THOSE: Superior form of T-cell discovered in cancer survivors.
MICROBIOME NEWS: Skin, mouth, lungs … it’s not just your gut that has a microbiome.
MARK PULLIAM ON TEXAS AG KEN PAXTON’S IMPEACHMENT: The Establishment Plots a Coup in the Lone Star State.
IT’S THE CRACK COCAINE OF THE LEADERSHIP CLASS: Artificial Intelligence is the crack cocaine of the digital age.
AI certainly could prove very useful in many critical areas such as medical technology, transportation, energy, space travel and business analytics. Yet it’s economic impact may not be much better than the social media revolution: as Northwestern economist Robert Gordon notes, it has not notably boosted productivity, unlike the strides made by such things as the development of steam engines, electricity, jet propulsion and nuclear power. Recent measurements of further productivity decline do not suggest that the algorithms are making businesses more efficient.
Much of the problem is that the tech oligarchy sees its big money by developing ephemera. The leading AI chip designer and first trillion dollar semiconductor firm, Nvidia, has, for example, grown largely on endeavours such as video games and crypto-currency. Rather than a focus on solving real world problems, the tech giants thrive on surveillance, titillation, and social ‘engagement’. AI could push them – and therefore us – further along that road.
AI may become the crack cocaine of the digital age, offering the highs of facility and speed to the masses without giving most of us anything good. Meanwhile, the dealers – the tech giants and autocratic regimes – will become ever more rich and powerful.
Rather than a boon, the current trajectory of AI seems to be that it will most likely function as a force multiplier for bad things. Its usefulness for enhancing social control makes it a favourite priority of Chinese super-snooper regime while tech firms happily sell their designs to enhance that country’s ever-expanding surveillance state. In the West, AI could well allow tech firms to gather and use private data in ever more pervasive ways.
There are already lawsuits aimed at stopping AI companies from conducting pervasive personal data ‘scraping’, allegedly also including also on the information of children, for their programs.
This is concerning since we already know social media’s impact on young people has been less than positive. New York University professor Jonathan Haidt, and Jean Twenge, a professor of psychology at San Diego State University, have demonstrated the extraordinary psychological problems associated with social media use, particularly among the young.
(Should we treat tech companies like tobacco companies? Or like asbestos companies?) But beware, leadership class. As AI gets smarter, you’ve been getting visibly dumber. Maybe it’s not the proles who need to worry about being replaced.
InstaPundit is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.