Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

HMM: US FDA staff raise no concerns about Otsuka, Medtronic blood pressure devices. “The surgery, known as renal denervation, is allowed in Europe and other parts of the world, but is not yet approved in the U.S., after initial studies of older devices used in the procedure failed key trials. The staff reviewers said the available safety data for the device made by ReCor, a unit of Otsuka Holdings, did not raise concerns, while pointing that there was limited long-term data. There was no specific comment on Medtronic’s device. ReCor’s device, a balloon-like structure inside a catheter, is inserted through a small cut into the kidney’s arteries and sends ultrasound energy to burn nerves that are believed to control blood pressure. On the other hand, Medtronic’s device is a spiral shaped catheter and generator combination that uses targeted radiofrequency energy to destroy select nerves.”

OPEN THREAD: Aren’t you glad you’re here with me, and not drinking in some honky tonk bar?

SOCIALISM HURTS. SO DOES THE TRUTH: The Mississippi Question is real, spectacular — and the UK is losing. “It was nine years ago when Fraser Nelson, the editor of The Spectator, first suggested that the U.K. was poorer than any U.S. state but Mississippi. This came as an uncomfortable shock for many in Britain for whom Mississippi, as a byword for backwardness, conjures up clichés about the Deep South. Every time anyone has made the comparison since, there has been an indignant outburst from Britons keen to denounce the data.”

ABA STEPS UP ON FREE SPEECH: Professors, administrators and counsel applaud proposed ABA standard on academic freedom.

The memo suggests creating a new standard, which would include language saying it applies to full- and part-time faculty, affords due process to people who claim their academic freedom has been violated and condemns disruptive behavior that hinders free expression.

The memo marks the first step of the proposed revision, and its authors suggest it go out for notice and comment if approved, as is customary with standards changes. The Legal Education and Admissions to the Bar council is scheduled to vote on the matter Friday when it meets in Chicago.

Details of the Stanford Law School speech are not included in the memo, but it does cite an incident from March 2023, which was when Judge Stuart Kyle Duncan of the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals at New Orleans spoke at a campus Federalist Society event. While in private practice and on the bench, Duncan has done work that some find harmful to transgender individuals. A video of the event shows members of the audience heckling Duncan as well as an exchange with Tirien Steinbach, then the law school’s associate dean of diversity, equity and inclusion.

According to the August memo, the U.S. House Committee on Education and the Workforce requested that the council investigate Stanford Law’s compliance with Standard 405. The memo also says the request did not influence the proposal to add a standard specifically addressing academic freedom and freedom of expression.

Lawyers interviewed by the ABA Journal say the Stanford incident raises issues of free speech, but not academic freedom. They also think more guidance is needed on both topics, and a new, more detailed accreditation standard would be helpful.

Additionally, there’s a strong sense that while freedom of expression rights may protect some speech that leads to disruptions, there is generally not a protected right to disrupt a speaker.

“It’s important for schools to clearly state that the disruption of speakers is not tolerated, and if students do that, they will face academic discipline,” says Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of the University of California at Berkeley School of Law and an ABA Journal contributor.

He sees protests outside or inside a building, including standing in the back of an event space or classroom with signs, as protected speech, providing the actions don’t disrupt the speaker or prevent the audience from hearing and seeing what is said.

The proposed standard, which Chemerinsky describes as “terrific and well done,” suggests condemning disruptive behavior that prevents or interferes with law school functions and activities.

Yes.

REMEMBER, ONLY TRAINED GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS CAN BE TRUSTED TO USE FIREARMS SAFELY: IRS special agent killed at Phoenix gun range during training exercise. “According to the Federal Bureau of Prisons, the shooting happened at the firing range at the Federal Correctional Institutional in Phoenix, located near Pioneer Road and Interstate 17 in north Phoenix. Aimee Arthur-Wastell, spokesperson with the FBOP, said the range was being used by multiple federal agencies at the time. The FBI specified that the agent was there for ‘routine’ training when they were killed, but didn’t offer specifics as to how the agent was killed or if anyone was in custody.”