Author Archive: Ed Driscoll

JIM TREACHER: Mea Culpa — I Was Wrong About Charlie Kirk.

I regret not paying more attention to him when he was alive. I’m not MAGA, and a lot of MAGA people hate me for criticizing Trump when I think he’s wrong. So, I figured Kirk was akin to those clowns: “You’re owned, cry about it, cuck,” etc. Anger, resentment, spite. A thirst for humiliation. Some call it “Trumpism.” I put him in that category, if not the worst offender. Alex Jones Lite.

Now I know it wasn’t Kirk’s approach at all, and I wish it hadn’t taken his assassination for me to learn that.

“I may not agree with what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.” Voltaire didn’t actually say that, but he should have.

And that’s exactly what Charlie Kirk did. He was murdered at the precise moment he ceded the floor to an opponent. Tyler Robinson could’ve waited his turn to debate Kirk, but instead he cut in line.

Big mistake.

Read the whole thing.

BREAKING: New York Court Tosses Terror Charges Against Mangione. “In the end, this really belongs in a federal court anyway. The DoJ can pursue this as a domestic terrorism case if they choose; at the moment, they have not yet escalated it to that point, but AG Pam Bondi has already ordered prosecutors to seek the death penalty. After this ruling, we can probably expect the DoJ to push for an accelerated trial schedule to eclipse the New York state courts and settle this matter for good. Once the DoJ wins a conviction and sentence — which would be a minimum of life without parole — Judge Carro’s courtroom will be nothing more than an anti-climactic sideshow.”

WAPO EDITOR: I Got Fired Over Charlie Kirk.

[Karen] Attiah sources this from an article rushed out by The Guardian less than 24 hours after Kirk’s death that attempted to argue sotto voce that Kirk had it coming. Even if one grants the Guardian the presumption that they took his words in context, Attiah changed the quote the Guardian provided at the link she used as a reference. This is the quote that the Guardian allegedly pulled from Kirk’s show in July 2023:

If we would have said that Joy Reid and Michelle Obama and Sheila Jackson Lee and Ketanji Brown Jackson were affirmative action picks, we would have been called racists. Now they’re coming out and they’re saying it for us … You do not have the brain processing power to otherwise be taken really seriously. You had to go steal a white person’s slot to go be taken somewhat seriously.

Note that the quote doesn’t include the phrase “black women” at all. Kirk referenced four specific black women in this criticism, arguing that their own words made them look like affirmative-action charity cases. The “you” in this case refers to the four women he named. Attiah rewrote this quote to make it sound as though Kirk was talking about all black women.

That is journalistic fraud. And that is likely why the Post just handed Attiah her walking papers. She lied to readers, and did so to imply that Charlie Kirk had it coming. She used quotation marks to sell her fraud, knowing damned well that quotation marks mean something to readers, and that falsely representing a quote in that manner is corrupt.

More here: “The real question is how she kept her job this long. While I’m glad the Post finally took action, it is absurd that Attiah was kept on the payroll for years on end, even as she excused violence against her perceived political opponents and promoted the ideas of Islamic terrorists. Lastly, lest anyone believe Attiah was a free speech absolutist, she lobbied to get the editor fired who published Tom Cotton’s 2020 op-ed suggesting the use of the military to quell widespread, left-wing riots.”

Attiah was pro October 7th: WaPo Columnist Celebrates Anti-Jew Terrorism As Exactly What ‘Decolonization’ Means.

And long before she cheerfully smeared Charlie Kirk as a crypto-racist, Attiah was doing the same thing to her fellow leftist, Nancy Pelosi, in 2019:

UPDATE:

Also, since we didn’t mention it in the original post, what’s the message she’s sending in her bon voyage photo?

MARK STEYN: The War on Reality.

I see Rahm Emanuel is complaining that “Democrats have lost touch with Roosevelt, Johnson and Truman“. You would have thought the easiest way to get back on the road to the little haberdasher’s would be to abandon the transanity. As Eva Vlaardingerbroek said on The Mark Steyn Show way back when, in her experience it’s the issue on which even otherwise doctrinaire liberals are a bit queasy – and that’s before the trannies open fire.

And yet the left is not walking back the transanity. Rather, they have no desire to give it up. As for the right, a decade or more back, when I used to bring this up on Rush, I used to get callers dialling in to denounce me for wasting their time: “This isn’t anything important, Steyn. Why don’t you try talking about the stuff that matters – like whether John Kasich or Phil Gramm is two points up in Iowa?”

Because while you’re having wet dreams about Lamar Alexander in his Brooks Brothers plaid shirt, the left is calling madness to the regeneration of the world. Because, while you’re playing small ball, they play humungous supertrannifragalistic balls. So now, a half-century ahead of schedule, they’ve just taken out one of the few figures on the right who genuinely connected with the young. The idea that “gender” is just something randomly “assigned at birth” with the maternity-ward matron wandering around passing out “internal” and “external genitalia” from an Obamacare grab-bag is an 80/20 issue. But back in my Rush days it was a 95/5 issue – and the current twenty per cent is everyone who matters: teachers, doctors, media, mainline “churches”, Supreme Court judges…

Read the whole thing.

THE STRAWMEN COMETH:

AXIOS: How Charlie Kirk’s killing sparked unfounded theories about Groypers.

What are Groypers?

According to Know Your Meme, “Groyper” refers to a variation of Pepe the Frog, a meme that the alt-right has co-opted.

  • The meme gained traction online on platforms like fringe-right site 4chan in 2017, according to the Anti-Defamation League, and was adopted by alt-right followers.
  • They describe themselves as Christian nationalists, oppose feminism and LGBTQ+ rights and believe the U.S. should close its borders.

Groypers became associated in 2019 with Fuentes, an underground podcaster labeled a “white supremacist” by the FBI.

  • Fuentes, who once dined with President Trump and rapper Ye at Mar-a-Lago, has since turned against the president.

  • He was previously banned from Twitter (both in the pre- and post-Elon Musk era) before Musk announced in May of last year that he would reinstate Fuentes’ account on X.

Iowahawk takes the implication that Kirk’s assassin was a Groyper to its absurd conclusion:

AND YET, NO STORE OWNER BOARDED UP HIS WINDOWS THIS WEEKEND:

For a (likely incomplete) reminder of who got cancelled in 2020, start here and keep scrolling:

BULLETS AND BALLOTS: The Legacy of Charlie Kirk.

Behind all of this was one overarching message: Do not fear. You have truth behind you. An entire fellowship of young conservatives stands behind you too. Charlie is here today to show you that conservatives like you can stand tall in hostile spaces. You can also do this. You should also do this. They do not own the public square. You do not need to be afraid.

That was the message of the man who was murdered this week.

This message had an obvious corollary: if we show up, then we will win. Recall that Trump did not win the 2016 popular vote. This caused a lot of nihilism among young conservatives. Many believed that the American people were too corrupted for a conservative movement to win majority support. Others thought that the American power structure—the en vogue term was “the cathedral”—would never allow a fair fight and would grind actual resistance to dust. He who believes thus either retreats from the public entirely or looks to less democratic solutions to the nation’s problems.

Charlie Kirk thought otherwise. He insisted that conservative populists could win the fight for the public square even if that fight was rigged against them. This faith was the foundation of his public persona and the engine that propelled the organizations he led. Kirk went out of his way to debate his ideas openly with opponents from the other camp. As a true populist leader should, he moved among the people, constantly talking with ordinary citizens of all persuasions. Kirk thought in terms of ballots, not bullets. When many to his right fantasized about Caesar and Sulla, he chased votes. He did not think nationalists needed to adopt extreme measures to win. Persuasion and mobilization—the traditional tools of self-government—would be enough.

Kirk saw America as he saw college campuses: the problem was not that America lacked conservatives or populists, but that too many of the conservatives it had were inexperienced, apathetic, or afraid. All they needed was an invitation to show up. The organizations Kirk built did this inviting.

These were the methods of the man who was murdered [last] week.

Related: Charlie Kirk saw himself as holding back a revolution.

In the wake of the attempted assassination of Donald Trump, there was a brief moment where people of both parties seemed to hope that it would mark a change in direction for the course of the country – an end to the demonization of the other side, a tamping down on the tone of our virulent political debate. That was as fleeting as an election cycle. But now with Kirk’s bloody violent murder while doing exactly the same thing he encouraged so many young people to do – using free-speech rights to stand up for what they believe, publicly and without fear of debate with the other side – the lesson many on the right may take away is that there is no future for such engagement.

The consequences of such a move would break from Kirk’s mission, and serve to accept the message the American left, from its most powerful elites to its core electorate, has been sending loud and clear since 2016: that there is no place for Republican views in society, that they are Nazis and fascists and existential threats, people who should be hounded and punched, and whose deepest pain is your path to joy. And why shouldn’t they take that lesson? There is no purpose to debate when at the end, the other side just wants you dead all the more. Can we even share a country with these people who hate us so much?

The reason not to take that path is because it’s the opposite of what Kirk himself believed and exemplified, as he told us over and over again. In a profile in Deseret published on the eve of his fall campus tour just last week, he vocalized his purpose as calling his fans and fellow young conservatives to something higher than just hating the other side:

“My job every single day is actively trying to stop a revolution,” Kirk said. “This is where you have to try to point them toward ultimate purposes and toward getting back to the church, getting back to faith, getting married, having children. That is the type of conservatism that I represent, and I’m trying to paint a picture of virtue, of lifting people up, not just staying angry.”

The worst thing the young American right could do now in this moment is turn Charlie Kirk’s martyrdom into a lesson fundamentally at odds with his mission. Really, after all this, could you blame them? The American left hated Charlie Kirk. They mocked his approach to debate. They smeared him for his conservative beliefs. But they and the country may be about to learn what comes next, and learn it hard.

More: Charlie Kirk’s Assassination Flipped a Remarkable Switch in the MAGA Movement.

THEY HATE US, THEY REALLY HATE US!

Related: Hollywood insiders lay bare ‘intimidation’ tactics by woke celebrities branded worse than the Ku Klux Klan: ‘Everyone is living in fear.’

UPDATE: Hamas mouthpiece praises Hannah Einbinder’s ‘Free Palestine’ Emmys message — but censors her bare shoulders in video.

JIM GERAGHTY: ‘Consequence Culture’ Comes for the Angry Left.

Back in 2021, actor LeVar Burton — beloved from years hosting Reading Rainbow and his role in Star Trek: The Next Generation — insisted that what many conservatives called “cancel culture” was simply a long-overdue reckoning of consequences for objectionable statements: “‘In terms of cancel culture, I think it’s misnamed,’ Burton said. ‘I think we have a consequence culture. And that consequences are finally encompassing everybody in the society, whereas they haven’t been ever in this country.’”

However you choose to label the phenomenon, I notice that now few folks on the left see the firings and dismissals after Kirk’s death as an example of “consequence culture.”

Last night, the AP wrote, “Some conservatives are seeking to upend the lives and careers of those who disparaged Charlie Kirk after his death.” In the 1,149-word article, you have to get to the 15th paragraph before you get even a description of that “disparagement,” referring to an assistant dean at Middle Tennessee State University and professors at Austin Peay State University and Cumberland University: “All three lost their jobs for comments deemed inappropriate for expressing a lack of sympathy, or even for expressing pleasure, in the shooting of Kirk. One said Kirk ‘spoke his fate into existence.’”

Rolling Stone fumes, “Journalists, publicists, and college faculty have been fired after calling the right-wing influencer a divisive figure and making light of his assassination.” Well, maybe people shouldn’t “make light” of his assassinations, then? Is that too much to ask? Remember how everyone felt when Alex Jones insisted the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting was a hoax? That’s how you sound to someone who liked the slain figure.

Alternatively, all these people who feel good when someone they disagree with politically is gunned down could try not expressing their views on social media for the whole wide world to see. If you say these things to your friends and family, the consequences will be much less severe.

Related: Should the Ghouls Publicly Celebrating Charlie Kirk’s Assassination Lose Their Jobs?

In response to Charlie Kirk’s public execution by a demented sniper, cruel, callous, and frankly demonic expressions of solidarity and pleasure have exploded across social media.  These reactions should not be exploited to attack an entire political party or movement, nor should we despair over the appalling words and conduct of a relative fringe.  But the scope of this ugliness should not be understated either.

More:

UPDATE: Surgeon who cheered Charlie Kirk murder ousted from his job…as nurse punished for exposing him is reinstated.

THE VIEW OF THE WORLD FROM 9th AVENUE, 2025 EDITION:

Even with ubiquitous social media, the New Yorker has never been able to peer into its backyard:

But that’s because New Yorker staffers have always been proud to wear their blinkers: “Pauline Kael famously commented, after the 1972 Presidential election, ‘I live in a rather special world. I only know one person who voted for Nixon. Where they are I don’t know. They’re outside my ken. But sometimes when I’m in a theater I can feel them.’”

OH, TO BE IN ENGLAND: Sadiq Khan’s huge grooming gang failure exposed by Met Police whistleblower.

Sadiq Khan is facing pressure to resign over his failure to accept there is a grooming gang problem in London

It comes after a police whistleblower revealed to the Express that the “horrific crime” has been rife in London for 20 years.

Over the course of 2025, the London mayor has dodged questions on the topic on nine separate occasions, but now a former Metropolitan Police detective has claimed there was a “cover-up.”

Decorated former detective Jon Wedger claims he uncovered a trove of evidence suggesting that there is organised sexual exploitation of children in the capital on a level that goes way beyond notorious scandals in towns like Rotherham or Rochdale.

“I’d actually uncovered kids from the age of nine to 14 that were being trafficked for prostitution on an industrial scale,” he told the Express.

Read the whole thing.

IT’S A RIDDLE WRAPPED IN A MYSTERY INSIDE AN ENIGMA:

BRENT BOZELL: Where Were You When Charlie Died?

“Where were you when Charlie died?” Like the JFK assassination, this brutal murder will not be forgotten, not for many years to come.

You just felt it [Wednesday]. Something happened that pierced America’s soul — deeply. The non-stop media coverage across the dial (and the political spectrum) all afternoon and into the night. One analyst after the next choking back tears. The beautiful, heartfelt notes of sympathy from his political rivals. The announcement of his passing delivered to a shocked nation by the President of the United States himself, who then ordered all flags lowered to half staff.

Like Kennedy’s assassination, and the attempted assassinations of Reagan and Trump, 9/11, and the Challenger explosion, Kirk’s death is one of those moments we’ll all remember where we were when the news first broke, and then the dreadful news, about an hour and a half later that he was gone. RIP.

THE IGNORANCE AND IDIOCY OF HOLLYWOOD’S ISRAEL BOYCOTT:

If an alien descended and was asked whether actors in the West would tend to boycott the democracy or the extremist state, it surely would plump for the latter. The values of toleration, individual rights and free association that we hold most dear must surely be promoted.

You know where I’m going with this. This week, 1,300 actors and filmmakers including Olivia Colman, Mark Ruffalo, Javier Bardem and Tilda Swinton signed a pledge to boycott Israeli film companies (which, tending to be rather left-wing, oppose Benjamin Netanyahu and the war in Gaza with greater venom than anybody else).

As Lee Smith recently wrote at Tablet: 

Obama’s Iran deal restructured the Democratic Party. Inverting U.S. foreign policy by replacing Israel with the regime that embodies exterminationist antisemitism was also a domestic stratagem to break Jewish power in the Democratic Party. It’s helpful to understand the post-Oct. 7 pro-Hamas protests in that light.

While many lifelong Jewish Democrats were shocked that the demonstrations were so openly antisemitic, calling for genocide of the Jews, this was precisely the point of Obama’s design: Negating Israel and prioritizing anti-Israel activists in the party’s hierarchy could lead only to the Democrats sanctioning anti-Israel activists who celebrated the murder of thousands of Israelis. That is, the protests that honored the Palestinians’ campaign of rape, torture, and murder—remember, the rallies started even before Israel launched reprisals—showed how wildly Obama’s policy had succeeded.

Remember how shocking Mel Gibson’s antisemitic outburst seemed almost 20 years ago? 1,300 more filmmakers just signed onboard as well, and in 2025, the news lands with barely a yawn.

FIGHT THE POWER, STICK IT TO THE MAN! Call to overthrow ‘bloodthirsty’ capitalist system ends in TX professor’s firing.

A Texas professor has been fired, accused of “inciting violence” after video surfaced on social media of a speech he gave at a socialist conference.

Thomas Alter, a history professor at Texas State University, in San Marcos*, was fired on Wednesday, Sept. 10 school officials said. His profile on the university website was taken down as of Sept. 11.

In the video, Alter is seen speaking on a Zoom call during a recent online Revolutionary Socialism Conference, wherein he calls for the creation of a “Revolutionary Socialist Party” and discusses why he believes previous attempts to establish a lasting, effective socialist movement in the U.S. have failed.

“Without organization, how can anyone expect to overthrow the most bloodthirsty**, profit-driven, mad organization in the history of the world, that of the U.S. government?” he says.

In a statement, TSU University System Chancellor Brian McCall said the university “will not tolerate conduct by any employee intended to incite violence,” pointing to “video recordings made public this week in which a … professor advocated for the overthrow of our government” as the reason for terminating Alter’s employment.

University president Kelly Damphousse echoed that sentiment in an X post, saying “after reviewing statements made … at a recent conference, I determined that (the professor) engaged in serious professional misconduct.”

* Not to be confused with the San Marcos that already had their communist uprising:

** Wait until the history professor finds out how bloodthirsty the various forms of socialism were in the 20th century!

GREAT MOMENTS IN COGNITIVE DISSONANCE: Roger Kimball: Why the Left Wants the Right to ‘Lower the Temperature.’

In the aftermath of the brutal assassination of Charlie Kirk last week, does the Right need to “lower the temperature” of its rhetoric? That’s what the usual suspects on the Left are saying.

As it happens, “lowering the temperature” while simultaneously raising the intelligence of discussion was one of Charlie Kirk’s specialties. A theme of his campus “American Comeback” tour (which his widow Erika plans to continue) was dignified debate. “Prove Me Wrong” was Charlie’s mantra. He eagerly engaged with college students who disagreed—or, sometimes, merely thought they disagreed—with him about a wide range of political, social, moral, and religious issues.

If you have never seen him debate, I recommend you consult Mr. Google or one of his professional counterparts and watch Charlie in action. He was robust but also unfailingly kind, patient, and attentive to his interlocutors. The reason? He wished to persuade his audience about the rightness of his point of view, about the virtues of America, the wisdom of Christianity, and the leadership of Donald Trump. Charlie was fundamentally a teacher.

How about his opponents? The internet is full of revelatory compilations of left-wingers denouncing their opponents as “fascists,” “Nazis,” and so on.

One series (and here is another) includes CNN’s Anderson Cooper asking Kamala Harris whether she thinks Donald Trump is “a fascist.” “Yes, I do” was her answer.

If we as a nation need to “lower the temperature,” then the left should be thrilled that conservatives are pointing out those went on a virtual wilding spree immediately after Kirk was murdered, but curiously, they’re having the exact opposite response:

Related: A leftist angered to the point of vandalism over the text on a sign.

NICK FREITAS: My Response To The Left (Video).

ROBERT STERLING: “My liberal friends are completely oblivious about how radicalizing the last week has been for tens of millions of normal Americans. Zero clue.”

Read the whole thing.

JONATHAN CAPEHART ON PBS: “I Am Very Concerned” About What The Reaction To Charlie Kirk’s Assassination Will Be.

PBS Newshour: New York Times columnist David Brooks and Jonathan Capehart of MSNBC join Amna Nawaz to discuss the week in politics, including the fatal shooting of Charlie Kirk and the tough questions it raises about the political environment in the country.

* * * * * * * * *

[Capehart:] But because of who the victim was, just in terms of our politics, but also who he was in terms of the president and this administration, this is one thing that I have to factor in to my thinking about all this when I look at the reaction from the president and his administration, that this just this wasn’t just the murder of someone who was a like-minded person.

This was family to them. And I try to keep that in mind as I watch the reaction. But I have to tell you, I am very concerned about what that reaction is going to be in the days and weeks and months ahead.

Norm Macdonald, call your office: