Author Archive: Ed Driscoll

HOW WE GOT HERE:

TRUMP GOES THERE, AND IT’S ABOUT TIME: Antifa Is ‘A Major Terrorist Organization.’

We need to take action against this militant group, the president wrote:

President Donald Trump said he is designating the far-left anti-fascism movement Antifa as a terrorist organization, announcing the move on his Truth Social platform in the early hours of Thursday morning UK time.

“I am pleased to inform our many U.S.A. Patriots that I am designating ANTIFA, A SICK, DANGEROUS, RADICAL LEFT DISASTER, AS A MAJOR TERRORIST ORGANIZATION,” Trump wrote Thursday. “I will also be strongly recommending that those funding ANTIFA be thoroughly investigated in accordance with the highest legal standards and practices. Thank you for your attention to this matter!”

It wasn’t immediately clear what mechanism Trump would use to make the designation, and Antifa lacks centralized structure or defined leadership, making it unclear who or what precisely would be targeted.

“This is just one of many actions the president will take to address left wing organizations that fuel political violence,” a White House official told CNN.

As RedState’s Brandon Morse and Bonchie have reported, there appear to be numerous links between Charlie Kirk’s assassin and the “anti-fascist” militant group.

Nahh, it’s a merely an aura of a penumbra of a perturbation of “an idea:”

 

ED MORRISSEY: Throwback Thursday Karma: Kimmel Celebrates Tucker’s Firing.

Hey kids, it’s Throwback Thursday time, and does MAZE have a doozy for us! Remember when Fox News took Tucker Carlson off the air over a content dispute, and everyone on the Left rushed to his defense and accused Fox of violating the First Amendment?

Er … neither do I. However, I do recall a lot of celebrating over Carlson’s abrupt departure on the Left. Among the most, ahem, colorful of these was in fact Jimmy Kimmel. MAZE gives us the flavor of that live-studio monologue, in which Kimmel channeled Noel Coward by claiming that Carlson had emerged from “Satan’s b***hole.”

How charming! What a delightfully classy moment for Disney.

Curiously, David French is not calling yesterday “the Day of Hygiene” for Disney:

Similarly, this 2014 XKCD cartoon summed up the left’s response to cancel culture back in the day:

To be fair, at least the way ABC showed Kimmel the door is far less permanent than the way the left retired Charlie Kirk’s career:

Exit question: Was Jimmy Kimmel’s TV Show an “In Kind Campaign Contribution” With Other Duties For The Democratic Party?

UPDATE:

THE 21st CENTURY IS NOT TURNING OUT AS I HAD HOPED: In love with a Luigi Mangione chatbot.

In this short clip, an unnamed woman proudly declares both her infatuation with – and ability to create an artificial construction of – Luigi Mangione outside of a Manhattan courthouse, where he has recently been absolved of various terrorism-related charges. Wearing an “I ♡ Italian Boys” T-shirt with an illustration of his face, the woman lists the many reasons why an AI chatbot, presumably trained on Luigi Mangione-related trivia, offers her the perfect romantic companionship. She gets to talk to him every day, she says, as a best friend and partner with whom she can plan a future and name their children. And, the woman adds, although she is aware that this might make her something of an imposter, the fact that Luigi studied AI at Stanford meant that this was an all-round reasonable thing to do.

It’s easy to write off this case as simply a harmless, albeit quite eccentric, example of the many ways in which young people are using AI today. But to do so would be to miss something much more provocative about how society has changed in the past decade. It’s the future of romance, she added in her clip. But it’s not. It’s the future of everything.

Something she notes in her monologue is that her Mangione AI-bot “fights her battles for her.” This seemingly innocuous statement is particularly interesting if you remember that a low locus of control – the term psychologists refer to when discussing whether people feel in control of their own lives or not – correlates quite strongly with support for political violence today.

I’m pretty sure that The Matrix and Her were intended to be viewed as warnings, not how-to guides for life in the 21st century.

UPDATE (FROM GLENN): More fodder for my “seductive AI” book.

CHEAT AND RETREAT: ABC news star makes groveling APOLOGY after gushing over Charlie Kirk assassin’s ‘very touching’ texts to his trans lover.

UPDATE: Gutman’s Dog Day Afternoon rerun yesterday is how the vegan sausage gets made by the DNC-MSM:

As is this: MSNBC’s Brandy Zadrozny: In Death, Charlie Kirk Became the Main Character in a Conspiracy Theory.

DAVID DESROSIERS: Prove Charlie Right.

A young man, who was being groomed to be a moral monster by our culture and the passions it unleashes, heard the dog whistle call to arms, seized the opportunity of a public event in his home state, and did what was collectively seen by his ilk as necessary and proper.

To do so, he suspended morality, the rule of law, and human decency in order to serve what he and too many others see as a higher political purpose. Sadly, this moral madness is what is taught in our nation’s colleges. This is the ethic that guided the global left – paired now with America’s identitarian vanguard –to fundamentally remake America.

Their immoral reasoning not only led to the killing of Charlie Kirk, but it is also the rationale of messianic monsters through the ages. In the 20th century alone, under the guise of National Socialism and global communism, it led to the murder of a hundred million souls. Social media has given it another Great Leap Forward. It is the justification for the show trials, the guillotine, the oven, the suicide vest, and the lone sniper.

DesRosiers writes, “What does Charlie Kirk’s assassination portend for our country? I see the potential of a natural turning point towards the good, the restoration of the First Amendment’s spirit, and a return of political, civic, cultural, religious, and economic toleration. That would be a big rainbow following a storm.”

I hope he’s right, because the American left have arrived at a very dark place: When Charlie Kirk Died, So Did the Democratic Party. What’s Coming Next Is Even Worse.

NOT LIBERAL, NOT PROGRESSIVE: Meet the Illiberal Left.

I asked my AI assistant to argue that celebrating Charlie Kirk’s assassination was somehow liberal or progressive. And it told me it couldn’t. Not really.

Oh, it could parrot slogans: “speech is violence,” “silencing hate is progress,” “free speech isn’t free from consequences.” But it couldn’t make a coherent case within the older framework of liberalism, usually referred to today as classical liberalism — the one that prized free speech, debate, and persuasion. Because there is no argument in that framework that justifies shooting a man for talking.

That realization hit me like a hammer.

It’s not just that the left leans differently on facts or values. It’s that we no longer share the same definitions of words. “Liberal,” “progressive,” “justice,” “violence,” “safety,” “democracy” — these words have been redefined until left and right mean opposite things when using them.

  • Violence used to mean fists, knives, bullets. Now, on the left, it means words.
  • Safety used to mean freedom from physical harm. Now it means freedom from disagreement.
  • Justice used to mean fairness. Now it means equity — enforced sameness of outcomes.
  • Liberal used to mean defending speech, even speech you despised. Now it means silencing “dangerous” speech.
  • Progressive used to mean reform. Now it means control in the name of inclusion.We literally are no longer speaking the same language.

    This is why Charlie Kirk’s words were intolerable. He didn’t threaten anyone’s life. He threatened the redefined reality that today’s leftists live in. By speaking clearly and persuasively, by listening and debating, he proved that disagreement was still possible. And that was enough to make him a villain in the new vocabulary of “progress.”

    That’s why his death was mocked, his vigils defaced, and grief for him romanticized away by the media. Because in their framework, silencing him was liberalism. Celebrating him would have shattered their narrative. And seeing us mourn him and lionize him as a martyr is intolerable to the intolerant.

As Melissa Chen tweets, “By refusing to debate, it helped to enthrone their ideological superiority.”

UPDATE:

OBAMA OPENS UP ON KIRK ASSASSINATION, SCOLDS TRUMP FOR ‘EXTREME’ RHETORIC:

Former President Barack Obama addressed the assassination of conservative political activist Charlie Kirk on Tuesday, calling the killing a “tragedy” that poses a “threat to all of us” before scolding President Trump for contributing to a dangerous political climate.

Speaking with journalist Steve Scully at the Jefferson Educational Society in Pennsylvania, Obama cast Kirk’s assassination as part of an escalating trend of political violence.

“Regardless of where you are on the political spectrum, what happened to Charlie Kirk was horrific and a tragedy,” Obama said. “And when it happens to some but even if you think they’re, quote, unquote, ‘on the other side of the argument,’ that’s a threat to all of us. And we have to be clear and forthright in condemning them.”

The former president also took it as an opportunity to criticize President Donald Trump and his administration’s handling of the aftermath of the assassination.

“When I hear not just our current president, but his aides, who have a history of calling political opponents ‘vermin’, enemies who need to be ‘targeted,’ that speaks to a broader problem that we have right now and something that we’re going to have to grapple with, all of us,” Obama said. “But I will say that those extreme views were not in my White House. I wasn’t embracing them. I wasn’t empowering them. I wasn’t putting the weight of the United States government behind extremist views.”

Bill Ayers, Bernadine Dohrn, Al Sharpton, Eric Holder, and Joe Biden could not be reached for comment. Not to mention Barry himself:

 

CHRISTOPHER RUFO: Charlie Kirk Did It All the Right Way.

He was a conservative willing to wade into controversial territory. But he was always guided by the idea that debate is the great clarifier and that, in a democratic society, persuasion is the primary means of political change. He set up tables on campus. He debated his opponents. And he believed he could win through the ballot box.

Kirk’s death, and the subsequent reaction to it by the radical Left, underscored the arguments he had made during his time on the stage. For nearly ten years, Kirk had argued that transgender ideology, especially when paired with experimental medical procedures, would result in disaster. From the reports now emerging, it appears likely that the alleged assassin, Tyler Robinson, was radicalized online into anti-fascist and transgender politics. In their most extreme forms, both lines of thinking advocate a nihilistic embrace of violence—the antithesis of Kirk’s approach.

In fact, when he was murdered, Kirk was answering a question about the relationship between transgenderism and mass shootings, a phenomenon that seems to have accelerated in recent years. Kirk sought to engage his opponents in debate; his killer, quite possibly inspired by the trans-radical movement, sought to end that debate with a bullet.

The reaction to Kirk’s death by the mainstream Left has been equally troubling. Thousands of Americans, including students, professors, and even active-duty military members, have publicly cheered his assassination. Some have called for further violence against conservatives. Though I have covered left-wing radical movements for years, I was surprised by the number of people in the “helping professions,” including teachers and doctors, who embraced violent rhetoric.

How should conservatives respond? First, by drawing a line that Kirk himself exemplified: debate is healthy; violence is unacceptable. I’m glad to see that some institutions have terminated the employment of those who cheered on Kirk’s murder.

Kirk wanted to debate, and the left wants to end conversations — by any means necessary, to coin a phrase.

JOE CONCHA: Dark days: The young Left increasingly embraces assassination culture.

A father of two was murdered in Manhattan last December. And some either joked about it or tried to justify the killer’s motive.

A father of two was murdered in Utah last week. And according to polls and studies, far too many people say it was justified because they disagreed with him.

The country has headed to a very dark place.

POLITICAL VIOLENCE ON THE RISE IN THE US: A TIMELINE OF KEY INCIDENTS

Will social media and gaming dehumanize so many more young adults that we’re embarking into a terrifying cycle of violence and hatred with no remorse?

Can we ever recover?

Read the whole thing.

OPEN THREAD: Never wear anything that panics the cat.

IN DEFENSE OF KAREN ATTIAH. Sort Of:

On October 7, 2023, as terrorists raped and pillaged Israelis, Attiah reposted tweets justifying the unfolding massacre:

“What did y’all think decolonization meant? Vibes? Papers? Essays? Losers.”

“Liberation, self-determination, and peace for all oppressed + colonized people,” with a meme that read “That’s my politics.”

About white women, Attiah has said that they are “lucky” black women are “just calling them ‘Karens.’ And not calling for revenge.” She followed up: “Indeed, black revenge is one of America’s greatest fears.”

About the writer Maureen Dowd and former Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, Attiah wrote that they formed an “axis of shevil” with Donald Trump.

After the Post declined to endorse Kamala Harris, Attiah wrote: “Today has been an absolute stab in the back. What an insult to those of us who have literally put our careers and lives on the line. . . ”

My point is that it’s not as if The Washington Post found out this past week that Attiah held views far outside the mainstream, or acted unprofessionally, including toward her own colleagues. It seems that they kept her around for these views.

Given all this, she could have reasonably expected that her Bluesky post about Kirk wouldn’t draw the ire of her bosses. And that expectation would have been entirely in keeping with her past conduct, and the culture her bosses allowed to persist.

She could have left earlier, with much more than a Substack as her reward:

GEORGE CLOONEY, CLOSET CONSERVATIVE? The Anti-Communist Film Festival: Hail, Caesar!

 Since I announced the Anti-Communist Film Festival last month, the response has been fantastic. Conservatives understand that a film festival showcasing some of the great anti-communist movies can be a powerful – and fun – inoculation against a poisonous false god.

What’s also been surprising is how many anti-communist movies there are. I’ve heard from people not only in the United States but with ties to Cuba, China, and the old Soviet Union. I’ve also heard from directors and actors in Hollywood. We’re planning the festival for fall 2026 if we can raise the money for it and attract a sponsor or two.

We also want the festival to have not only serious films, but fun ones. We want it to be a party that entertains and brings people together. That’s why I think a great addition to the lineup would be Hail, Caesar! Hail, Caesar! produced and directed in 2016 by Joel and Ethan Cohen, delves into the deepest question of our time – the question of God and our place in the universe. It also makes communists look like absolute idiots.

It makes for a nice double-feature with 1999’s Three Kings, in which Clooney made the case for the Iraq War.

PAST PERFORMANCE IS NO GUARANTEE OF FUTURE RESULTS:

● Chaser: S.E. Cupp: Slamming Media Is ‘Dangerous,’ Fox News Is Like a Dictator’s Tool.

—NewsBusters, December 26th, 2017.

● Hangover:

SEAN HANNITY, HOST: The mainstream media’s hostility towards Christianity is no secret. But a new book explores why the liberal elite is only suspicious when conservatives invoke religion. Now, the book is called “Losing Our Religion: The Liberal Media’s Attack on Christianity.”

The author, S.E. Cupp, joins me now.

Right there, my blurb, your book.

S.E. CUPP, AUTHOR, “LOSING OUR RELIGION”: I know! Right on the front.

—Transcript from Hannity, Fox News, April 28, 2010.

DOG DAY AFTERNOON: ABC’s Gutman: Alleged Kirk Assassin’s Texts With Trans Lover Were ‘Intimate,’ ‘Touching.’

On Tuesday’s ABC News Special Report about Utah County officials formally announcing charges against the suspect in Charlie Kirk’s murder, chief national correspondent Matt Gutman expressed affinity for the suspect and admiration for his love story with a trans person, gushing the text messages released by authorities were “lovingly” stated, “very intimate,” and “very touching.”

Gutman was reporting from the site of the press conference when he told World News Tonight anchor David Muir something “that stood out” was “those text messages” between the suspect and his roommate/lover.

“I don’t know if we have seen an alleged murder with such specific text messages about the alleged murder weapon, where it was hidden, how it was placed, what was on it, but also it was very touching in a way that I think many of us didn’t expect,” Gutman declared.

But, wait, there was more: “A very intimate portrait into this relationship between the suspect’s roommate and the suspect himself, with him repeatedly calling his roommate, who is transitioning, calling him ‘my love’ and ‘I want to protect you, my love.’”

Related:

QUESTION ASKED: Does Pam Bondi know what free speech is?

Katie Miller, hosting Bondi on the Katie Miller Pod, said that Kirk’s murder last week was what happened when college campuses don’t take action against or expel students who harass conservative speakers. Using anti-Semitism as an example of left-wing campus “hate speech,” Bondi claimed in reply: “There’s free speech, and then there’s hate speech, and there is no place, especially now, especially after what happened to Charlie, in our society.”

Does the Attorney General know that “hate speech” is protected under the Constitution? She continued: “We will absolutely target you, go after you, if you are targeting anyone with hate speech, and that’s across the aisle.”

If this all gives you flashbacks to the days of social-justice warrior campus protests (“keep your hate speech off this campus!”) you’re not alone. Bondi didn’t elaborate on exactly what she meant by “targeting anyone with hate speech.” Did she mean people gloating over Kirk’s death, saying he deserved to die for his beliefs? That’s certainly hateful and disgusting, but is it illegal? Not in America.

Bondi’s fudge, whether it was purely idiotic or a more sinister attempt to roll back speech rights, expresses an outlook totally at odds with Kirk’s: he didn’t believe in hate speech. The idea that words can be dangerous is antithetical to his belief in dialogue and open debate.

As Christopher Rufo notes:

Still though, consider what the near-universal condemnation of Bondi implies:

DISPATCHES FROM THE EDUCATION APOCALYPSE: How the Left Programmed Young People to Hate.

Thus, the question of 1975 — “Who’s sick?” — has found its answer. It is no longer only the young who jeer at murder, though they remain responsible for their choices. Yet their conduct reflects more than personal failing. It is the outcome of a society that abandoned its traditions, hollowed out its own authority and left its youth open to manipulation by those who profit from discord. Individuals may bear the guilt, but the culture that fashioned them must also stand condemned.

The signs of decay are no longer hidden. It is the parable of the Emperor’s New Clothes: the pretence sustained only so long as no one dares to speak what all can see. What we are living through is an epidemic of noticing — a slow, reluctant recognition that the social fabric is threadbare and that the fractures are premeditated, not incidental.

David Horowitz, who as editor of the radical 1960s periodical Ramparts once marched in the ranks of the radical Left before renouncing it, understood these dynamics better than most. He argued that the upheavals of the era were not motivated by the “longing for justice”. It was “not a quest for peace but a call to arms. It is war that feeds the true radical passions, which are not altruism or love, but nihilism and hate.” The reality of their political programme, he lamented, “entails only permanent war, that observes no truth and respects no law, and whose aim is to destroy the only world we know”.

Related: Nihilism and the Crisis of the West.

At the deepest level, Charlie Kirk was executed because he attempted to live out his animating principle, “Prove Me Wrong.” The anti-civilization Left could tolerate his conservative values and policy prescriptions, but they could not tolerate his method of public discussion. Charlie was winning over tens of thousands of young people to his cause because of his benevolent, reasoned approach to public debate. The Left was losing to Charlie’s benevolence and his reason, and they knew it. This is what they hated most.

I have no doubt that the public assassination of Charlie Kirk is a defining moment in American history in the way that, say, the assassination of Martin Luther King, Jr. was. It will be engraved on the public psyche for decades to come.

Where to from here, America?

PAST PERFORMANCE IS NO GUARANTEE OF FASCIST RESULTS:

FIRST MAN ARRESTED FOR CHARLIE KIRK SHOOTING WANTED TO HELP SHOOTER ESCAPE: Documents.

George Zinn, 71, was taken into custody following the shooting, but he was later cleared on having any direct involvement with the shooting. He was arrested on suspicion of obstruction of justice.

Currently, investigators have a suspect in custody for the shooting. Tyler Robinson, 22, was arrested on September 11 after he told a family member that he was the one who shot and killed Charlie Kirk.

According to the affidavit of probable cause that was filed today, immediately after the shooting, Zinn allegedly walked up to a police officer and started yelling, “I shot him, now shoot me.” The officer could not see a weapon in his hands and placed him in handcuffs. The officer asked him where the gun was, and he reportedly said, “I am not going to tell you.”

As he was transported to the UVU Police Department, he allegedly continued to say that he shot Kirk and to just shoot him. At the Police Department, Zinn was advised of his rights and asked for a lawyer.

According to the affidavit, after he asked for a lawyer, without being asked any questions by investigators, he stated that he did not shoot Kirk and that he said he did to draw attention away from the real shooter.

Zinn was later taken to the hospital because of a medical condition, and Zinn reportedly told an officer that he was glad he said he shot the individual so the real suspect could get away. He also said he “wanted to be a martyr for the person who was shot,” according to the probable cause statement.

He was admitted to the hospital and released on September 15, and he was then booked into the Utah County Jail on suspicion of obstruction of justice in a capital/first-degree felony case, which is a second-degree felony.

WebMD defines “Main Character Syndome” as “the perception that your life is a story or a movie where you’re the central character.” Evidently Zinn believed he was the main character in an Oliver Stone or John Frankenheimer movie: “In 2013, Zinn threatened to bomb the Salt Lake City Marathon and spent a year in the can for that incident, according to reports.” And according to TMZ, “The man accused of obstructing the Charlie Kirk murder probe is in even more hot water … he’s now been charged with possessing child porn.”