ANOTHER DUMB S.W.A.T. RAID:

A tactical law enforcement team broke into Tom Shiflett’s home and took his 11-year-old son to hospital for court-ordered medical treatment for a minor head injury.

Garfield County’s All Hazards Response Team raided the home Friday night, a day after Jon Shiflett fell after grabbing the handle of a moving car. The child was returned to the family at about 2:30 a.m. Saturday, hours after the raid.

“Inappropriate is not nearly strong enough a word. It was gross irresponsibility and stupidity,” said Ross Talbott, owner of the Apple Tree Mobile Home Park south of New Castle who rents to the Shifletts and who witnessed the raid. “Is this Russia? I don’t know what we’re coming to when they think your kid needs medical help and they send a SWAT team.”

In the end, the injury wasn’t as severe as caseworkers from the Garfield County Department of Social Services thought when they went before a judge seeking a search warrant and order for medical treatment.

The doctor recommended fluids, Tylenol and ice to treat the bruises, according to a copy of Jon’s patient aftercare instructions.

People should lose their jobs over this. But they probably won’t. Accountability is for the little people.

UPDATE: Here’s the police side of the story:

Use of the Garfield County All Hazards Response Team (AHRT) was appropriate to seize Tom Shiflett’s son for medical care because of Shiflett’s confrontational history and repeated lack of cooperation, according to Garfield County Sheriff Lou Vallario.

“I wouldn’t have done it if I didn’t think we would have been able to accomplish it with just the deputies we had on duty,” Vallario said. “The end result of what happened was based on (Shiflett’s) decisions, not mine.”

The team used force to break into Shiflett’s home Friday night in Apple Tree Park near New Castle, and seized his 11-year-old son, Jon Shiflett. The boy was examined and returned hours later with the recommendation to ice his bruises and take Tylenol. . . . Vallario said Shiflett’s statements that his family members were thrown to the ground and that the warrant was never announced are false. He said two Garfield County deputies arrived Friday before the AHRT and explained the warrant and that they would need to take the 11-year-old boy in for medical evaluation.

“He was rather vulgar in his response,” Vallario said Tuesday. “I was given a court order, and I really don’t feel I have any choice but to comply with that court order.”

Read the whole thing. There are two stories here, but this still seems excessive. Meanwhile, reader Herschel Smith makes an excellent point:

Consider the irony. The Marines and Army have now progressed in their counterinsurgency campaign and the understanding of the population to the point that they can cordon and knock. They are respectful, cautious, and unwilling to impose anything foreign or hostile to the culture or the honor of the head of household. Yet in America we have men donning tactical gear to forcibly enter the homes of people and remove them for … forced medical service for non-life threatening injuries. It is a sad picture.

It is indeed.

ANOTHER UPDATE: Reader Phil Dean emails:

Kudos to you for fairly reporting the police’s side of this story, which is something that a lot of internet libertarians seem to consider beneath them.

Based on the facts we know, I don’t agree that the raid was necessarily excessive. Consider: the police have to enforce the court order. They sent two deputies to knock on the door and ask. They were unsuccessful. THEY STILL HAVE TO ENFORCE THE COURT ORDER. Now, whether this particular court order was reasonable or not is a separate issue, but that’s not the cops’ doing. And as far as “accountability” goes, they can also be held accountable for NOT executing a court order pertaining to the health and safety of a child. Just another one of the damned-if-you-do-damned-if-you-don’t scenarios that make modern law enforcement so much fun.

Here’s my thing: critics of SWAT teams invariably say that the police’s legitimate interests can be served without tactical uniforms and big guns, that if the police would just be reasonable and knock on the door, all would be well. Fine. But here the police did that, and it didn’t do any good. When they escalate, of course, they’re fascists.

Fair points. Though I doubt they’d have gone this route in a fancy neighborhood nearly as quickly as in a trailer park.