OBSCENE MORAL EQUIVALENCE, a continuing series: Here’s how Patrick Bateson, Provost of Kings College, Cambridge, justifies Mona Baker’s removal of two Israeli scholars from an academic journal based on their nationality:
Always,” he said, “science is set in social contexts.” As an example he cited Josef Mengele, the Auschwitz doctor who tortured Jewish children in experiments.
“Supposing we had the possibility of collaborating with a Mengele,” Professor Bateson said. “That would be a case where everybody would say politics would definitely come into science, and say we could not let that happen.”
Sometimes I think I’m too hard on the Euro-academic crowd. But maybe I’m not hard enough.