GOOD IDEA: GOP talks of narrowing ‘blue-slip’ rule for judges.
GOP senators are talking about changing an obscure Senate tradition to make it more difficult for Democrats to block certain judges from advancing to a confirmation hearing.
The change to the “blue-slip rule” would involve preventing individual senators from blocking nominees to circuit courts that have jurisdiction over several states.
If the rule change were made, it would make it easier for President Trump to win confirmation for his circuit court picks. Trump currently has 20 vacancies on the lower courts of appeals to fill.
GOP members on the Senate Judiciary Committee say this would leave the tradition in place for district court vacancies, meaning a single senator could still hold up a nomination to those courts.
“I want to separate it,” said Sen. Jeff Flake (R-Ariz.).
“Blue slips for district court judges has been time honored and I think needs to stay,” he said. “There is a question now does it apply to circuit court judges. That history is a little more mixed and I don’t think myself it ought to apply there.”
Sen. John Cornyn (Texas), the No. 2 Republican in the Senate, seemed to agree.
The “blue slip” rule is antidemocratic, and probably racist. It should go.