Author Archive: Robert Shibley

BLACKFACE STILL EMBARRASSING IN NEBRASKA: Unlike some other states. But one Nebraska university engaged in its own embarrassing behavior by suspending a librarian simply for posting pictures of students in blackface at a 1926(!) campus party. Lesson learned: Never make the “wrong” decision about what goes down the memory hole.

NYT ENDS POLITICAL CARTOONS: Regardless of what you think of the Netanyahu cartoon that seems to have spurred this decision, there is no way to make the case that the nation’s most prominent paper giving up on this historically powerful medium says anything good about the current free speech environment. My advice to anyone who cares about free speech:

TEXAS GOV. GREG ABBOTT HAS A CHANCE TO AVOID A BIG MISTAKE: Two bills awaiting his signature would not only give Texas colleges an unconstitutional (and incorrect) definition of sexual harassment, but promise to send professors to jail for failing to report said non-harassment. Crazy.

SOMEONE “DEMONIZED” ALEXANDRIA OCASIO-CORTEZ! DESTROY THAT DEMON’S LIFE! A Washington Post sportspolitics column written with a wild lack of self-awareness – or maybe a brilliant parody. Hiding blatant power politics behind transparent protestations of principle is setting Americans at one another’s throats. If it doesn’t stop, something’s going to give.

DOUBLE (x85) STANDARDS AT WILLIAMS COLLEGE: Williams College’s student government has recognized around 170 student groups. But in a blatant example of viewpoint discrimination, it has refused to recognize the Williams Initiative for Israel. (Student for Justice in Palestine is recognized, along with many other interest-based clubs.) President Maud Mandel has ensured the club can  meet on campus, but has stopped short of ensuring they are actually treated equally in terms of funding, etc. Today, you can join FIRE in calling on President Mandel to step up and put an end to this separate but unequal treatment.

UPDATE: We’re hearing that Williams may have found a way around the student government. That was quick!

ARE YOU A FED-UP FACULTY MEMBER? Given the shameful business over Ronald Sullivan (my take for FIRE here), you probably should be. Why not do something about it? Submit a paper proposal to FIRE’s faculty conference at Boston University this October and you could get a $3,000 honorarium for doing the research work necessary to advance academic freedom.

FIRST HE CAME FOR THE FRATERNITIES… Now Harvard College Dean Rakesh Khurana shows up to a sit-in protesting African-American law professor Ronald Sullivan. Sullivan is allegedly unfit to be “faculty dean” of Harvard’s Winthrop House because he, a defense lawyer, agreed to defend Harvey Weinstein in court. And this is after Khurana had already commissioned a “climate review” of the dorm “asking students to rate the house on a variety of metrics like homophobia, elitism, and friendliness.” At Dean WormerKhurana’s Harvard, everyone who crosses political correctness is on Double Secret Probation, forever.

TRINITY COLLEGE HITS A NEW LOW: This week, after Trinity’s student government rejected the student Churchill Club because of its focus on Western civilization, allegedly sinister conservative “rhetoric,” etc., administrators recognized the club so it could at least reserve space, even if it would still not be treated equally in terms of funding. Today, the student government went ballistic over the issue, launching a Change.org petition (nearly 700 signatures so far!) demanding that its power to engage in malicious and discriminatory censorship be respected. It even scheduled an actual, physical protest against the ability of students to disagree with the campus political orthodoxy.

FIRE has launched an email campaign aimed at stiffening the spine of Trinity administrators in the face of these nauseating demands for censorship. Please feel free to let Trinity’s president know your opinion – and if you know any Trinity alums, please pass it on!

MIDDLEBURY STUDENT GOVERNMENT DOUBLES DOWN: In the wake of Middlebury’s latest speaker disinvitation, its student government officially demands that those hosting speakers be made to fill out a “due diligence form” issued by the diversity office in order to “remov[e] the burden of researching speakers from the student body.” That’s not even the worst part of what, without a trace of irony, it calls “proposals for community healing.”

POPULATION BOMBED! Ever since Malthus, one environmental panic after another has been driven by the idea that there are just too many people on the Earth. Now comes a book from Profs. Pierre Derochers and Joanna Szurmak, who I had the pleasure of meeting in person, that goes a long way towards explaining why we’re not dead yet – and how the pessimists just keep getting it so wrong.

YOUR KID IS NEXT: Hans Bader breaks down why the criminal charges against an Ohio high school senior for ranking the appearances of female classmates on Twitter are unconstitutional. (The actual tweets, as per usual, have been memory-holed, but a few are listed here.) The level of totalitarianism in public high schools is bad enough already without the police piling on. But after the Internet hate machine gets done with this kid – or yours – will anyone, including the legal system, care?

MIDDLEBURY CANCELS POLISH POLITICIAN’S SPEECH: 55 grand in tuition apparently doesn’t leave enough for Middlebury to keep you safe if you’re a student who wants to hear from a speaker with the “wrong” views. I’d say Middlebury admins should be embarrassed to have this happen after the violence over Charles Murray in 2017, but I see no evidence that they’re capable of embarrassment. (Assuming they’re not just using a fake safety rationale to cancel the speech, of course.)

TIMELINE: HOW A SCHOOL GOES GREEN: Not in the ecological sense, but in terms of eliminating unconstitutional speech codes and getting a green light from FIRE. At N.C. State, it took 10 years – but it got there.

“NAZI-PUNCHING” IS STILL A BAD IDEA EVEN IF CBS IS ENCOURAGING IT: I don’t watch “The Good Fight” on CBS’s online network, so I don’t know the full context of this clip. Maybe the main character monologuing here is shown to have done the wrong thing, or is the bad guy. I can hope, anyway. But apparently the episode aired the very same evening that a protester at the University of Missouri-Kansas City engaged in his own version by spraying chemicals on Daily Wire writer Michael Knowles for giving a speech titled “Men are Not Women.” We’re going to live to regret this cultural moment.

CORNELL HAS A REUNION SPEECH CODE: A FIRE supporter passed this along to us today, saying he found it highly insulting. I can see why. Its threats of “consequences for unacceptable behavior” sound like a parent scolding a child.

Cornell sent this infantilizing pamphlet to alums attending their 55th class reunion. But don’t worry, Big Higher Ed assures us there’s no problem.

SURVEY ON POLITICAL IMPEDIMENTS TO RESEARCH FREEDOM: If you are a faculty member (of any rank) at an American college or university, and you have a few moments, please help me (and FIRE) out by taking a quick survey on how political or ideological pressure might affect your research. I would greatly value your input. Thanks!

COULD ANYTHING BE WORSE THAN DISAGREEMENT? When it comes to learning, lots of things are worse, as the longstanding partnership of Princeton’s Robbie George and Cornel West demonstrates. One of the many overlooked crimes of the campus language and feelings police is that they have conned students into thinking that intelligent disagreement is not only not fun – a lie – but that it’s painful, even harmful. George and West are showing us a way out, if anyone cares to take it.

CAN STUDENTS DEMAND UNLAWFUL ACTION?: Students at Sarah Lawrence want, among other things, Professor Sam Abrams’ tenure reviewed by a panel that includes “at least three faculty members of color.” Given the horror this kind of de jure discrimination strikes in a civil libertarian (and should strike in anyone with a rudimentary knowledge of American history), many have written in to ask FIRE our position on student demands for such obviously illiberal measures. The answer is that FIRE would defend their right to make such demands despite our strong disagreement with them. But colleges are not free to give in to them, and FIRE will also defend faculty or students whose college targets them as a result.

PORTLAND STATE SAYS “HECK(LERS) YES!” TO VIGILANTE CENSORSHIP: Last week’s incident where a guy with a cowbell disrupted a College Republicans event for an hour while police did nothing wasn’t even the first time this year that Portland State let hecklers control campus speech. FIRE’s been investigating; my favorite part was when the entire college claimed to have fewer A/V abilities than you probably have in your pocket. For more, hit the link — where you can also feel free to comment to PSU about it, if you’re so inclined.

THIS SHOULD MAKE FOR SOME GREAT A CAPELLA CONCERTS: Harvard’s student government wants to “audit” student group membership selection processes (called “comps”). “UC President Sruthi Palaniappan ’20 said she and UC Vice President Julia M. Huesa ’20 proposed that the committee consider the topic because they are concerned about the equity of students’ access to ‘exclusive’ extracurricular opportunities. Many undergraduate organizations require some kind of comp, which can take the form of an application, audition, demonstration of proficiency, interview, or required meetings.”

Sorry for two Harvard posts in one day, but the place has gone crazy enough to warrant it – and if it happens at Harvard, there’s a great chance it’s coming soon to a school near you.