Author Archive: Robert Shibley

IN WAR [AGAINST WRONGTHINK], TRUTH IS THE FIRST CASUALTY: The University of Pennsylvania had long been one of the few colleges that did not have any written speech codes. Now that it’s brought them back, surprise–admins aren’t telling the truth about it!

“YIKES, NOPE, DENIED”: University of Scranton just stands by as student government denies recognition to conservative group.

FIRE’S 2020 SPEECH CODE RATINGS OUT TODAY: Of the 471 rated colleges across the country, 89% still have red- or yellow-light ratings for having written policies that censor speech, which is outrageous. But for the very first time, more than 10% have green lights. (OK, 11%, but hey, it’s more than 10!) Odds are good your alma mater is in the ratings. How’d it do?

THE STATE OF MISSISSIPPI GOES GREEN (FOR FREE SPEECH ON CAMPUS): Hooray for Jackson State University, whose move to a green-light speech code rating from FIRE means that Mississippi joins Arizona as the only two states whose top colleges have eliminated all unconstitutional speech codes. For once, taxpayers least hard hit!

INVESTIGATE ALL THE THINGS! Congress doesn’t get to have all the fun today. Six(!) Ohio universities have called in the FBI to investigate stickers, graffiti, or other offensive postings. The Kekistani culprit at Western Connecticut appears to remain at large despite FBI involvement. George Washington University is investigating Snapchats all on its own, though, so it’s possible that the FBI is running out of agents to throw at the national crisis of people saying stuff other people don’t like.

IT IS IN FACT OK TO SAY ‘IT’S OK TO BE WHITE’ ON A PUBLIC CAMPUS. As long as you follow the posting rules! That’s not going to change just because Western Connecticut State University’s president is running around with his hair on fire promising “the severest disciplinary actions, including dismissal as well as possible civil and criminal actions” if a student is found to be the culprit. Also, talk about making the anonymous poster’s point for him (or her)…

FORMER SLAVE FREDERICK DOUGLASS, 1860: “To suppress free speech is a double wrong. It violates the rights of the hearer as well as those of the speaker.”

CHAPEL HILL PROF AT UNC-GREENSBORO CONFERENCE, 2019: “The very idea of freedom, postulated in universalist terms in the 19th century, and serving as the ontological structure for the First Amendment, doesn’t allow the black.”

You kind of have to read the description of this conference to believe it.

THE ARREST OF UCONN STUDENTS FOR USING A RACIAL SLUR IS CLEARLY UNCONSTITUTIONAL. As will be any action that UConn, a state institution, takes against them. These unlawful abuses need to stop, now, and people and organizations need to stop excusing them, or we’re all next.

YOU HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO REVERSE COURSE. WE URGE YOU TO TAKE IT.” Five members of Congress, led by Sens. Wyden and Rubio, give some sound advice to the CEO of Activision-Blizzard over kowtowing to the Chinese Communist Party. I get that China has lots of money, but I suspect that buys them a lot less pull with voters and consumers than many in government and business seem to think.

AT U. OF IOWA, “UNIVERSITY OFFICIALS HELD ‘PERSONALLY LIABLE’ FOR DISCRIMINATION AGAINST CHRISTIAN STUDENT GROUP.” More of this needs to happen. There has to be some cost to college officials who just flat-out ignore the law when it comes to disfavored groups on campus. Those denied “qualified immunity,” a doctrine that effectively gives public college administrators a blank check to abuse nearly any and all student rights, include Vice President for Student Life Melissa Shivers, Associate Dean of Student Organizations William Nelson, and Coordinator for Student Organization Development Andrew Kutcher. It takes serious work to lose this immunity, so whenever a college administrator does so, it’s worth sitting up to take notice.

WESTERN ILLINOIS’ WALKING DEAD: 16 years after its supposed elimination, WIU’s “zombie free speech zone” still hobbles along. As one victim of the undead menace put it, “I was four when this policy was supposedly eliminated, but the unconstitutional free speech zone somehow still lives on.”

ANOTHER CAMPUS FREE SPEECH LAWSUIT: “Some people get in trouble for smoking weed, but at Jones College, I got in trouble just for trying to talk about it.”

A SOLID WIN FOR ACADEMIC FREEDOM: New School prof charged with racial harassment for using the “n-word” in class while discussing author James Baldwin has charges dropped just days after FIRE took the case public. This business of treating certain words as though their mere utterance, regardless of context, has some kind of mysterious and unstoppable power, is not reasonable. It’s purely magical thinking, and has no place at a university.

‘SILENCED STAGES’ ON CAMPUS: It’s not just your imagination. George Leef reports on a new book out from Prof. George LaNoue: “Based on his study of 97 colleges and 28 law schools during the 2014-2015 academic year… [f]or most students in American higher education, the opportunity to hear on-campus debates about important public policy issues does not exist.”

I HAD HEARD LAW SCHOOL WAS UNFRIENDLY: Might you be just “taking up space” in a discussion if your identity is insufficiently “minoritized?” Is “minoritized” even a word? Find out during orientation at University of South Dakota Law School!