Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

THE NEW CIVIL LIBERTIES ALLIANCE, WHOSE BOARD I’M ON, JUST CHALKED UP ANOTHER WIN, THIS TIME IN THE FIFTH CIRCUIT: Cochran v. SEC. ” In order to ‘faithfully execute the laws,’ which is his duty under the Constitution, the president must not only be able to appoint all federal officers, he must be able to remove them as well. But SEC ALJs, like most civil servants, are protected by what amounts to life tenure. If the president cannot remove ‘officers’ such as ALJs, then he can’t control the administrative agencies he’s charged with overseeing.”

The opinion is here.

THE LEFT IS CONSISTENTLY INCONSISTENT: Furor Over Conservative Judges. Silence Over Left-Leaning Law Schools.

Commentary about Dobbs has noted the Court’s so-called conservative Justices, though they’re probably more accurately described simply as those appointed by Republican Presidents. On one side are Justices Amy Coney Barrett, Brett Kavanaugh, Neil Gorsuch, Samuel Alito, Clarence Thomas and John Roberts; and on the other are Justices Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan.

This political composition actually seems to resemble the country’s right now — or what we’re told the country is — which is to say, the Court is divided. That sounds bad, of course. One might just as well say that the Court is not monolithic, which sounds better.

The same cannot be said, however, of American legal education, the system which produces our judges.

The National Association of Scholars has long tried to call attention to the rather shocking under-representation of Republicans at America’s law schools and the fact that actual conservatives were purged long ago. Democrats outnumber Republicans on faculty at a ratio of about 50 to 1, for example, and law professor political donations skew almost exclusively to progressive candidates. Law school publications routinely advocate not just abortion and euthanasia but gender ideology, illegal immigration, and every other pet cause of the political left. All this is said to be legal “scholarship” and is subsidized at state schools by tax dollars and at private schools by federal student loans, among other public subsidies, including Justice Department grants.

Most conspicuous and also relevant for abortion law is the complete absence of conservative women in legal academia with one study by Northwestern Law Professor James Lindgren finding, “Republican women are almost missing from law teaching.” …

Why do Supreme Court nominees receive a blinding spotlight while the politicized law schools which produce them get a news blackout?

We all know why, don’t we? If we actually had institutions that “look like America,” the left would be in deep, deep trouble.

OPEN THREAD: There’s no reason we should give in. There’s no reason we should stop.

SETH BARRETT TILLMAN, NON-PEOPLE:

REPORT FROM BUDAPEST: Mel Gibson, Hungary, And The Sense Of Normal. “I called Budapest a safe haven for Western conservatives; but, of course, I know this is not the reason they’re shooting The Continental here, but rather because Hungary is a popular movie location. Nevertheless, if Mel Gibson walks around Budapest, he can experience something that’s natural for the locals but remarkable for many conservative expats: a sense of normal. From a Hungarian point of view, the absurdity of cancel culture and P.C. terror is easy to understand. We have the Brussels elites, our own P.C. police who are more furious and frustrated every year, because, despite their efforts, Hungary is still a well-functioning country.”

They do hate those.

NEWS FROM THE BLUE ZONES: NBC crew robbed in Oakland. “An NBC Sports crew working on assignment in Oakland, Calif., was robbed at gunpoint Saturday morning, according to a report from The Mercury News, and the robbers got away with a camera from the crew’s vehicle.”

But wait, there’s more: “This robbery is reportedly the third involving news organizations in Oakland within 2 1/2 weeks’ time.”

Related: “And progressives—I count myself as one of them—do ruin cities. Or, at least, they put in place policies that cause profound harm to the people living in them. An obvious case-in-point is the call to defund the police. It’s a slogan that fits nicely on a bumper sticker, but what are its consequences in practice?”

I MISS THE OLD COLLEGE INN: Peyton Manning Brings Back Cheese Bings. It’s gone now, but when it first opened I was in college and my then-girlfriend was one of the opening crop of waitresses. I attended the “practice night,” which meant that I could tell people I had been going there longer than it had been open. It was still around for the first decade-and-a-half or so I was back here teaching at the law school. I miss it.

COUNTESS BATHORY, CALL YOUR OFFICE: Scientists who injected idle mice with blood from athletic mice found improvements in learning and memory. The findings could have implications for Alzheimer’s research and beyond.

Of course, you can improve your own blood by being more athletic. In other news, I’m delighted to report that the Insta-Daughter is now doing deadlifts and sled pulls. This represents a big shift from her previous routine of fencing, pilates, barre, etc.

IT’S OBVIOUS, BUT IT’S STILL A BIG DEAL TO SEE IT ADMITTED IN THE ATLANTIC: The Democrats Fighting to Protect the Coastal Elite: Who Benefits From Progressive Climate Policy? “Menendez wants to shield those people too, because in high-cost New Jersey, owning a million-dollar home is not a signifier of extreme wealth. The state has one of the country’s largest percentages of homes valued at more than $1 million, and its median home price is well over the national average. On that score, the battle over flood insurance resembles the debate among Democrats over the state and local tax deduction, or SALT. Lawmakers from New Jersey, New York, and other high-tax states have demanded that Congress revive the tax break—which Republicans gutted under President Donald Trump—despite the fact that its biggest beneficiaries would be millionaires.”

Related: Climate Change: Tax the Blue Zones!

OF THE DECADE: Elon Musk is Time’s Person of the Year.

A friend comments: “Good call. He’s a delightfully odd human being. His eccentricity and ingenuity are truly historic and worthy of the title. Give me the Elons of the world any day over the self-important pencil-pushing desk poghs within the sad little DC bubble….the utterly useless, wholly uninspiring political elitists of recent past. Elon is a real mover and shaker – he’s among a select few worldwide who truly make things happen. An actual genius. Time got it right for the first time in a very long while.”

She’s right.

FOREIGN COLLUSION: Peter Lucas: Joe Biden needs to answer questions on Hunter Biden’s Chinese connections.

Two weeks after the meeting, Bobulinski set up SinoHawk Holdings LLC, a global investment firm seeded with $10 million in Chinese money to buy projects in the U.S. and around the world, according to Devine.

Twenty percent of the equity shares of the company were for Hunter Biden, 10% for Jim Biden and another 10% held by Hunter for “the big guy,” who is Joe Biden.

All of this barely touches the surface of Hunter Biden setting up meetings for Joe Biden with Hunter’s benefactors from Russia, the Ukraine and Kazakhstan, all the while that Burisma, the corrupt Ukrainian energy company, is paying Hunter $83,333 a month for doing nothing.

The Russian oligarchs have nothing on the Bidens. The Bidens are American oligarchs.

In the pay of the Russian and Chinese ones.

SEVERAL READERS RECOMMEND THE PRECINCTSTRATEGY.COM WEBSITE. Become a Precinct Committeeman — it’s not hard and you’ll meet interesting people.

SEEMS FAIR: Jake Sullivan’s Wife Faces Growing Calls for Recusal From Durham Probe: Margaret Goodlander serves as counsel to AG Merrick Garland, who oversees the probe.

A top adviser to Attorney General Merrick Garland is facing calls to recuse herself from the Justice Department’s investigation of the Trump-Russia probe, which has looked into the actions of her husband, National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan.

Margaret Goodlander serves as counsel to Garland, who oversees Special Counsel John Durham’s investigation. Garland has oversight of Durham’s budget, the scope of the investigation, and the release of a report Durham is believed to be writing. Sullivan, who married Goodlander in 2015, has been referenced in Durham’s indictment of a cybersecurity lawyer who worked for the Clinton campaign. While there is no indication that Durham is targeting Sullivan, the national security adviser could be a witness for the investigation given that he was a foreign policy adviser to Hillary Clinton’s 2016 presidential campaign. Durham’s report could also reveal embarrassing details about Sullivan’s work on the campaign to dig up dirt on Donald Trump’s possible links to Russia.

A spokesman for the Justice Department said Goodlander “has no role in Mr. Durham’s investigation,” but it is unclear whether she has formally recused herself from the matter or whether the Durham probe is outside her Justice Department portfolio. Fox News reported that Goodlander advises Garland on antitrust and international issues.

Sen. Chuck Grassley (R., Iowa) and the watchdog group Empower Oversight say Goodlander should be formally recused from the Durham investigation to maintain public trust in the probe.

Our incestuous ruling class.