Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

ICYMI: LETTER FROM “PUBLIC HEALTH” EXPERTS URGING PFIZER TO HOLD THE VACCINE UNTIL AFTER THE ELECTION: “I didn’t even remember this but wow. I doubt the same letter would have been sent had 2020 not been an election year or had a Democrat been in office.” That’s Nate Silver I just quoted.

Quoth Tyler Cowen: “No, this was not a conspiracy in the strictest, most intentional sense (it didn’t need to be!), but it did kill thousands of people and manipulate our politics. . . . C’mon, people, let’s not be afraid to admit this one.”

Well, I’m not afraid to admit it. (Bumped).

MARK STEYN: America Sticks Out Its Tush. Plus: “There is a strange lack of desire for a future.”

WELL, STARTED TO PAY: Don Surber: 2021: the year the media paid for its lies.

The data in this report are grim. In the last 12 months, the Washington Post’s online traffic is down 44%. The New York Times is down 34%.

Prime-time viewership is down 38% at CNN, 34% at Fox, and 25% at MSNBC.

Nightly news viewership is down 14% at NBC, and down 12% at both ABC and CBS.

It’s a good start, but only a start.

Related:

LOL, JEN RUBIN:

UPDATE: From the comments:

Democrats have done their polling. They know the “pandemic” will drag the party down in the 2022 elections. So they are trying to tie the pandemic to state governors, over half of whom are Republicans.

The marching orders have gone out to all the propagandists in the MSM, which is almost all of them.

Jen Rubin has her orders and she’s tweeting stupidity as fast as she can.

Let’s Go Brandon!!

LGB. Maybe we should make it “Let’s Go Brandon, Today, Quit!” so people will be confused when they see LGBTQ posters and think the groundswell for a Biden resignation has exploded. . . .

THOUGHTS ON SCIENCE AND CHAINSAWS:

I think I’m right on these things, though I recognize that future evidence might say otherwise. I’m grateful for the scientists who developed the vaccines but strive to maintain an open mind on all scientific matters, along with a sense of humility and a generous spirit toward those who disagree with me. A proper understanding of science demands no less.

The history of medicine offers ample reasons to avoid smug certitude which, unfortunately, is abundant on social and traditional media. Science is always about likelihood and never about certainty, though word apparently hasn’t reached Twitter and TV news.

Then there is the flagrantly political demeanor of so many COVID experts. I’m not at all prepared to say whether red states or blue states were wiser in their public policies. Too many confounding variables. I’ll make one exception, which is to say that the press and others besoiled themselves by relentlessly lionizing ex-New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo. Today, few Democrats or Republicans quote his tweet from May 5, 2020: “Look at the data. Follow the science. Listen to the experts. … Be smart.”

Here’s why they shouldn’t. Science, like a chainsaw, is an exceedingly powerful and useful tool. But “follow the science” makes no more sense than “follow the chainsaw.” The chainsaw doesn’t know the safest way to cut a tree, and science—let alone some anthropomorphic vision of it—can’t weigh the tradeoffs between slowing COVID and shutting down schools and cancer surgeries.

Science informs individual and collective choices, which depend not only on those scientific findings but also on subjective preferences and one’s degree of confidence in those scientific findings. As for “listen to the experts,” Cuomo wrote the book on COVID expertise, and that book’s fall has been as spectacular as its author’s plummet.

Medical history is littered with experts who were spectacularly wrong. When Ignaz Semmelweis suggested that doctors employ antiseptic medical procedures (e.g., washing hands in maternity wards), medical experts were offended and conspired to destroy Semmelweis. When Stanley Prusiner suggested that misfolded proteins could cause mad cow disease and its human equivalent, Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease, he was pilloried as a heretic—a pejorative that didn’t entirely vanish when he received a Nobel Prize for his work. As physicist Max Planck said, “Science progresses one funeral at a time.”

In October, novelist and essayist Ann Bauer wrote a poignant column, “I Have Been Through This Before,” on her discomfort with the parade of cocksure COVID experts issuing ever-changing diktats and pronouncements. When vaccines didn’t end the pandemic, she wrote, “doctors and officials blamed their audience of 3 billion for the disease. The more the cures failed, the greater the fault of the public.”

Related: The Suicide of Expertise.

GOOD: Polls Show More Hispanics Turning Their Backs on Gun Control, Civilian Disarmament Advocates. “An Axios/Ipsos poll showed Hispanic swing voters are concerned about crime, criminal violence and personal safety. That finding wasn’t a surprise to NSSF. Hispanic-Americans, along with nearly every other demographic group, are embracing their right to lawfully purchase and own a firearm. Firearm industry retail survey data revealed this growing trend a year ago. That’s when law-abiding Latinos purchased firearms in big numbers and the demographics of America’s gun owners continued to show growth. Hispanic-Americans aren’t an outlier community and examples are plenty. Suburban swing voters and other minority groups demonstrated similar patterns as they saw policy failures affecting their safety, fully embraced lawful gun ownership and exercised their Second Amendment right.”

MICHAEL WALSH: How The New York Times abuses the ‘public’s right to know.’

Now the shoe is on the other foot, and it couldn’t happen to a nicer bunch of journalists: a judge in the New York State Supreme Court (despite its name, not the top court in the state) has ruled against the Times in its ongoing attempt to destroy independent journalist James O’Keefe and his Project Veritas by publishing private communications with his lawyers regarding a lost diary purportedly belonging to President Joe Biden’s daughter, Ashley. The Times and Project Veritas have been locked in legal combat since O’Keefe filed a 2020 defamation suit against the Times.

In the suit, O’Keefe—who first came to public attention in 2009 with his “sting” videos against the leftist community-organizing group Acorn, now defunct, and which put Andrew Breitbart’s “Big” sites on the national map—alleges that the Times defamed him by claiming he has “a long history of releasing manipulated or selectively edited footage” and that his methods were “deceptive” and “a coordinated disinformation campaign.” (Full disclosure: I was the founding editor of Breitbart’s Big Journalism in 2010; that site has long since been folded into Breitbart.com.)

Well, nothing says “deceptive” like fencing stolen property that serves your ideological needs under the guise of freedom of the press, but here we are. The Times and other legacy media have abused the Pentagon Papers decision for years, often by hiding behind another errant Supreme Court decision involving the Gray Lady, New York Times Co. v Sullivan (1964), which essentially gave newspapers carte blanche to slander their enemies without fear or legal penalty.

The judge in the Ashley Biden diary case, Charles D. Wood, has forbidden the Times to publish the Project Veritas documents—protected lawyer-client material, it should be noted—that it mysteriously obtained, and ordered the return all the physical copies to O’Keefe and the destruction of any and all electronic copies it may have.

This brought an immediate bleat from publisher A.G. Sulzberger, the latest in the long line of Sulzbergers who control the family-run paper: “This ruling should raise alarms not just for advocates of press freedoms but for anyone concerned about the dangers of government overreach into what the public can and cannot know. In defiance of law settled in the Pentagon Papers case, this judge has barred The Times from publishing information about a prominent and influential organization that was obtained legally in the ordinary course of reporting.”

Well, that’s rich. Just how the Times got the material the Times, of course, won’t say—so much for the public’s right to know. Most likely, it was leaked to the newspaper by the FBI, which conducted an intimidating November raid on Project Veritas, including on O’Keefe himself, during which he was reportedly handcuffed.

But why was the FBI acting like the Bidens’ private Praetorian Guard in the first place? No one alleges that Ashley Biden’s diary was stolen, and even if it was, so what? A lost diary, even one belonging to yet another troubled Biden offspring, is not a federal case. And in any event, Project Veritas never published the contents of the diary. The FBI investigation was concerned with “how a diary stolen from President Biden’s daughter, Ashley, came to be publicly disclosed a week and a half before the 2020 presidential election.”

As it turns out, the diary was simply left behind in Florida by a “rehabbing” Ashley, where it was found by a third party and offered around to various outlets.

The press and the FBI are pretty clearly just partners in defending the Democrats by any means necessary. This corruption — because that’s what it is — has already destroyed their reputations, but there should be a much greater reckoning.