Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

NEWSWEEK: 2021: The Year of the Ruling Class’s Crackdown on Dissent.

The year 2020 was the year of the lockdown, when the Ruling Class arbitrarily, capriciously and selectively suspended the natural rights bedrock upon which American life—indeed, life itself—relies.

The year 2021 closes as the year of the crackdown, when the Ruling Class weaponized its powers to crush dissenters from its Wokeist-Scientist orthodoxy in arguably the most far-reaching, brazen and lawless assault on Americans by the state and its private-sector adjuncts in our nation’s history.

This was the year that the campus became the country. Those engaging in speech that ran afoul of the Ruling Class’ party line were treated as physical dangers to the homeland, demanding the full force of the public and private sectors to deter, punish and subdue them.

Many in our ruling class see what’s happened in Hong Kong as a role model. They need to be made to regret their choice.

THE LAPTOP CLASS GETS COVID.

For nearly two years, we’ve wondered how this will end. In retrospect, the clue is in how it began.

The initial lockdowns had a strong class-based component. The working classes were assigned the job of delivering groceries, tending to the sick, driving the trucks filled with goods, keeping the lights on, and keeping the fuel running. The professional class, among whom were the people who pushed lockdowns in the name of disease avoidance/suppression, were assigned the job of staying home in their pajamas and staying safe.

It all happened seemingly in an instant. We all had to figure out whether our job qualified and what we should do. More striking at the time was the very notion that government bureaucrats could slice and dice the population this way, deciding what can open and what cannot, who must work and who must not, what we can and cannot do based on our station in life.

So it now seems obvious to me. This whole disaster would finally come to an end (or at least the end would begin) when it became obvious that the great strategy of class division and demarcation would fail to protect the Zoom class from infection.

That day has finally arrived, with cases soaring in many parts of the country and hitting everyone of every class, whether they are being “careful” and adhering to the “mitigation measures” or not. What’s even more striking is how even the vaccines, which were supposed to codify the wisdom of class segregation, have not protected against infection.

All of this seems to have taken place over the course of December 2021, with the arrival of the seemingly mild Omicron variant. Still the other variants circulate widely, causing various degrees of severity with or without hospitalization much less death. In other words, millions from among all classes of people are finally getting sick. At this point, we seem to be seeing a big shift in attitudes.

A lot of this comes from casual conversation. A person comes down with Covid, perhaps confirmed by the newly fashionable at-home tests. “Did you get vaccinated?” the person is invariably asked. The answer comes back: yes and boosted. That’s when the chill happens. It appears that nothing can ultimately protect people from this. In which case, it is time we change our tune.

“Thousands who ‘followed the rules’ are about to get covid. They shouldn’t be ashamed,” headlines the Washington Post.

Feeling ashamed about getting covid-19 isn’t healthy or helpful, experts agree…. Remember: You’re not a failure. “Millions of other people have gotten sick,” (Seema) Varma says. “Unfortunately, you’re not alone. You’re not the only one. You’re not the first one to get covid, and you won’t be the last.” And that positive test, she reiterates, “doesn’t make you an irresponsible person.”

So on the piece goes, with a complete flip of the narrative they have long preached: anyone who gets Covid has failed to comply, disregards of Fauci’s advice, probably lives in a Red state, rejects the science, and otherwise bears the mark of selfishness and the desire to put freedom ahead of public health.

Getting Covid has heretofore been part of a human stain, consistent with the very long history of demonization of the diseased and the attempt to attribute sickness to moral sin.

Plus: “The driving ambition here, though never explicitly stated, was to assign the burden of bearing the disease to the lessers among us. That is a conventional model used in illiberal societies throughout history. The elites who had both granted and benefited from lockdowns took it as axiomatic that they deserved disease purity and health more than those who worked to keep society running. And that scheme seemed to work for a very long time. They stayed home and stayed safe and kept clean while the virus circulated in season after season.”

But the press is rushing forward in its commonplace role of helping the gentry class feel good about itself.

Flashback: America’s elites are waging class war on workers and small biz. “Lockdowns — where the laptop class stays home while working-class people bring them stuff — were enacted in many states. States that had them did no better, and often worse, than states that did not. This became obvious early but resulted in no change of policy. . . . So is it fair to call the overclass response to the pandemic a failure? Well, certainly not for the overclass, whose members are richer, more powerful and more secure in their positions than a year ago. For America? Well, that’s another story.”

#RESIST: A reader sends this: “FWIW, from deep-blue Connecticut.”

RULE OF LAW IN HONG KONG: THERE ISN’T ANY. Remember that much of our political class sees this as a model for the United States.

Compare to the prosecution’s behavior with the January 6 protesters, or for that matter the Kyle Rittenhouse case.

Related: “[T]o argue, as Liz Cheney and Nancy Pelosi do, that Trump didn’t have a right to contest the election is to replace the rule of law with the rule of intimidation.”

They know this, they’re okay with it, and that’s precisely why they’re doing it. The rule of law limits the establishment’s power. The rule of intimidation, for now at least, expands it.

WHILE THE NYT EDITORS BLEAT ABOUT DECENCY, DEMOCRACY, AND JANUARY 6, REMEMBER THAT THEY LIED ABOUT A MAN’S DEATH SO AS TO SPREAD POLITICAL HATE ACROSS THE NATION: Will the Times apologize for lying about Officer Sicknick’s death?

An unruly crowd entered the US Capitol on Jan. 6, while then-President Donald Trump addressed a rally several blocks away. One member of that crowd, Ashli Babbitt, an unarmed woman and a veteran, was shot by the Capitol Police. The next day, Capitol Police Officer Brian Sicknick died in the hospital.

On Jan. 8, The New York Times reported that Officer Sicknick had died after being struck in the head with a fire extinguisher by violent Trump supporters. This story was quickly repeated by numerous other media outlets. Millions believed it.

The story was false.

Sicknick died of two strokes, which occurred many hours after the invasion of the Capitol. The blue-check-media fallback was that bear spray used by the Capitol invaders had caused the officer’s strokes.

That also turned out to be false. After a curiously long delay, the DC medical examiner’s office released its report this week, and it concludes that Sicknick suffered no injuries, internal or external. He didn’t have a reaction to bear spray, the chief medical examiner reported.

So the single most important “fact” about the events of Jan. 6 was false. That leaves some questions.

First, who were the Gray Lady’s sources? The Times story quoted two anonymous “law-enforcement officials,” but anyone associated with the Capitol Police, or any investigation, should have known that Sicknick wasn’t struck in the head with a fire extinguisher. Having been misled by its sources, will the Times tell us who they were?

Will the Times apologize for its error? It could have independently confirmed its claims by checking with Sicknick’s family or with the hospital. Or the paper could simply have waited until it had definitive confirmation of the facts and refrained from reporting a falsehood in the meanwhile.

As leftist journalist Glenn Greenwald notes, the Times didn’t check the facts because the paper needed the story to be true.

And it still hasn’t apologized. They actively encourage and excuse violence from the left, while manufacturing lies about violence from the right — remember when the NYT blamed Sarah Palin for Gabby Giffords’ shooting? They’re despicable, awful people and have no standing to talk about decency or democracy.

WHAT THE RICH DO WHEN CRIME THREATENS: “I’m shocked. You mean they want BLM to destroy your city but not their own? In other news, they are demanding the police do something about it. . . . Anyway, the rich folks know the police can’t be there all of the time. They want shotguns. They want Gucci protection. They want up-armored cars. They want drones. If you demand the same thing, 44% of them will tell you to pound sand.”

THE WAY THIS ADMINISTRATION IS GOING, HOW LONG UNTIL PEOPLE LOOK ON JANUARY 6 AS A LOST OPPORTUNITY RATHER THAN AN INSURRECTION? New polling on January 6 is a MAJOR BUZZKILL to Brian Stelter and many other journos.

Plus: “The criticism would resonate more with the public if the press had condemned all forms of political violence, left and right, instead of condoning & cheering on deadly riots all summer.” (Bumped).

ALL HYSTERIA ALL THE TIME: Every day is January 6 now.

The Establishment is telling what it’s afraid of, and it’s desperately afraid of a grassroots movement on the part of the Normal-American community.

The funny thing is, if Trump had wanted an “insurrection,” he could have called on the huge crowd he was addressing to go seize the Capitol. Tens of thousands would have done so and stopped the election certification. Trump didn’t do that because he didn’t want to seize power in a coup. But not everyone feels that way, and all this coup-and-insurrection talke from the left makes something like that more likely, not less so.

THE FIGHT AGAINST SEXISM: The New Political Cry in South Korea: ‘Out With Man Haters.’ Their battle cry: “Feminism is a mental illness.”

Perhaps they’ve looked at the contemporary United States and drawn their own conclusions about what feminism leads to. This would appear to be part of the global backlash — especially outside the Anglosphere — against contemporary campus-left politics. See also the French government’s anti-woke crusade.

PRETENDIANS: Who knew that Elizabeth Warren was part of a movement? “Apparently she is one of a great number of people who try to advance their careers by pretending to be American Indians. We noted here a news report to the effect that close to 20 percent of white kids ‘identify’ as Native American on their college applications–a strategy that apparently is often successful. Now the New York Post reports on a list of some 200 people, prominent in academia, politics and the arts, who have falsely claimed to be part Indian. Real Indians, it seems, are outraged that others are trying to horn in on their privileged status.”

I would distinguish between people who have a family story of being part Indian, who number in the many millions, and people like Elizabeth Warren, who doubled down on her self-serving gambit long after it was plain that she had no such ancestry. Real Indians weren’t particularly obsessed with bloodlines anyway, it was more about whose side you were on: Many Cherokees refused to participate in the Dawes Register, seeing it (correctly) as a white man’s thing. (I had an interesting discussion with a Cherokee tribal judge about this stuff quite a few years ago.)

Plus:

Too, what do we make of the rush to claim the evidently privileged status of Native American? Why are there hundreds of “Pretendians,” falsely alleging they are Indians to advance their careers? If Native Americans are discriminated against and “marginalized,” whatever that means, why do so many people pretend to be Native Americans?

Pretty much everything that is said about race in the USA is a lie. The prevalence of “Pretendians” is one more data point indicating the sickness of our race preference-obsessed culture.

If white supremacy were real, we wouldn’t see so many people pretending to be Indians, or blacks, in order to gain prestige and promotions. A University of Chicago freshman told me not long ago that U. Chi was kicking out students who pretended to be black to gain admission. Nobody was doing that sort of thing in the Jim Crow days; now it’s everywhere.