Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

THAT’S BECAUSE THEY’RE STUPID, AND ENDORSED UTTERLY BY PROGRESSIVE POLITICS: How School Closures Made Me Question My Progressive Politics: I’ve never felt more alienated from the liberal Democratic circles I usually call home. “I’m well aware of the stereotypes of white parents choosing the private-school option when the going gets tough at public schools. I told myself that prioritizing being a ‘good leftist’ at the expense of my son’s well-being wasn’t good parenting, but as a red-diaper baby myself, the white guilt dies hard.”

So long as it dies, because it’s butt-stupid.

EMORY LAW JOURNAL SCANDAL UPDATE: Prof. Andrew Koppelman (Northwestern) on the Emory Law Journal Controversy. “The editors do not allege falsity or offer any evidence of scholarly dereliction. It’s been claimed that he resisted editing, but the editors did not ask for his claims to be better supported. They demanded the deletion of the entire final third of the article. The editors think that academic work ought not to describe what the scholar takes to be reality if revealing or calling attention to that reality is ‘hurtful’ and ‘divisive.’ That notion, which is increasingly common, attacks the scholarly enterprise at its root.”

Law firms should be reluctant to hire the Emory Law Journal editors involved in this debacle, for poor judgment.

RESIGN! Education Secretary Miguel Cardona under fire for soliciting parents-as-terrorists letter.

A conservative education activist is calling for Miguel Cardona’s job after emails revealed the education secretary solicited the infamous letter from the National School Boards Association calling parents protesting at school board meetings domestic terrorists.

Ian Prior, the executive director of the Fight for Schools PAC, told the Washington Examiner that every political officer involved in colluding with the NSBA should lose their jobs, especially Cardona and Attorney General Merrick Garland.

I agree. Characterizing political opponents, or parents, as “domestic terrorists” is a poisonous abuse of power. It should be a crime, or at the very least a firing offense.

ZAID JILANI: It’s coups all the way down. “This elitist and anti-populist ethos increasingly permeates virtually all institutions that progressives control in the United States.”

THAT WAS ALWAYS THE SUSPICION: Incoming North Korean Missile Warning Prompted FAA’s Mysterious Air Traffic Halt. “What’s also of interest is that minutes before the initial ground stop order and details surrounding it were communicated to some air traffic controllers, NORAD notified the FAA to have Los Angeles Air Traffic Control Center clear the airspace around the northern stretch of Vandenberg Space Force Base, which is located about 170 miles northwest of Los Angeles. We assume this was meant to ready the area for a potential launch of a Ground-Based Midcourse Defense (GMD) interceptor capable of knocking down ICBMs. While the vast majority of GMDs are based in Alaska, a handful are based at Vandenberg for limited operational contingency and test duties.”

HOWIE CARR: All the COVID heroes of yore are now being flattened.

It’s early, but this may be the quote of the year so far, from CDC Director Dr. Rochelle Walensky, because it puts the lie to everything they’ve been telling us about the Panic for the last two years:

“The overwhelming number of deaths, over 75%, occurred in people who had at least four comorbidities. So, really, these are people who were unwell to begin with.”

It’s unfortunate that anyone had to die from a Chinese virus. But the fact is, as skeptics have been saying all along, most of those who perished already had one foot in the grave and another on a banana peel.

Anyone paying attention to the daily grim milestones in the corporate media understood this very quickly. This is why the administration of Gov. Charlie Baker quickly tried to bury the devastating charts that showed the ages of the dead, and why one night his corrupt Department of Public Health abruptly removed 3,500 deaths from the nursing-home tolls.

Anything that didn’t fit the Panic Porn narrative had to be deep-sixed by the Ministry of Truth.

Walensky’s unforced confession came on ABC “News” — the Pravda of Panic Porn. After realizing just how devastating Walensky’s admission was, the Ministry of Truth began pushing back, claiming that her quote was taken “out of context.”

Problem is, she said it. Period. This wasn’t one of those 60 Minutes-Katie Couric type interviews, where the Democrat operatives with press passes cover jump cuts with, say, cutaways of the reporter or a wide shot. This was her speaking directly into the camera, and it’s killing the narrative.

The Deep State’s Cleanup in Aisle 5 involves pointing out that Walensky also said that while the vaccines “are working exceptionally well,” there are certain things that they can’t do.

“What they can’t do anymore is prevent transmissions.”

Anymore? Someone should clue in Supreme Court Justice Elena Kagan. She claimed exactly the opposite at that Supreme Court hearing Friday. She said workers “have to get vaccinated so that you’re not transmitting the disease.”

Which is totally false, if you believe Walensky. Will Kagan be suspended from YouTube for a week? Will Twitter cancel her?

How about Sonia Sotomayor, who thinks 100,000 children are hospitalized with COVID? Or Stephen Breyer, who somberly told the nation that there were “750,000,000 new COVID cases yesterday.”

You know, Sotomayor has acknowledged publicly that she’s an “affirmative action baby,” so maybe that explains her profound ignorance. But how do Kagan and Breyer explain their jaw-dropping stupidity? Didn’t all three go to Harvard?

The great thing about all this finger-pointing back and forth is that 100% Beautiful People are now turning on one another.

Walensky is bogged down in a two-front war, contradicting two of her BFF’s, both ABC “News” and Justice Kagan. Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot is sputtering in rage as she condemns her fellow travelers in the teachers’ union who want to keep their Christmas vacations going forever.

Closer to home, Mayor Michelle Wu is being heckled by city workers as she leaves her house in the morning as a “fascist” (or maybe it was “Faucist”)?

Moonbat-on-moonbat attacks! Pass the popcorn. It’s like the Iran-Iraq War — isn’t there some way they can all lose?

They will. Plus:

All the COVID heroes of yore are now being flattened, just like the curve, one by one.

Dementia Joe, Anthony “I Am the Science” Fauci, the Cuomos, Charlie Baker. Karma, ain’t it grand?

Fake media heroes generally implode. Just ask Andrew Cuomo.

CHINESE VIRUS PROBLEMS IN CHINA: Chinese Authorities Seal Residents’ Doors in COVID-Hit Xi’an, Depriving Them of Food Supplies.

Chinese authorities sealed residents’ homes in the city of Xi’an on Jan. 8 because of a COVID-19 outbreak, but didn’t arrange for a reliable food supply, residents say. Now, after being locked down for almost three weeks, they’re lacking in food and are on the edge of mental breakdown.

The Chinese regime has claimed that the outbreak in Xi’an has been under control since Jan. 5. However, the regime has upgraded some of its control measures, although some Xi’an residents still weren’t able to leave their homes as of Jan. 11.

“I had never been diagnosed with COVID-19. Why did they seal my door?” Cai Jiaying (a pseudonym), a resident of the Rongshang Compound, Changyanbao Community, Yanta District in Xi’an, told the Chinese-language Epoch Times on Jan. 9. “Our residential compound has been locked down for 21 days. … In the beginning [of the lockdown], I consoled myself. I was disappointed days later and then felt hopeless and despair.”

Cai said she and her husband had bought only a little food in the past three weeks, and they didn’t know when they would be able to buy more.

Lockdowns don’t work anywhere. Why are they so popular with officialdom?

OPEN THREAD: Take California. Please.

EVERYTHING IS GOING SWIMMINGLY:

Related:

It was a clownshow, not an “insurrection,” and given how the Whitmer kidnap “plot” story has unfolded it’s hardly crazy to suggest that the FBI or some other government agency played a dishonorable role here. Indeed, the past few years have revealed one government agency after another playing a dishonorable role.

UPDATE: From the comments: “If Rubio is saying it, the weathervane has shifted. Good news.”

THIS WHITE HOUSE HAS HARDLY BEEN A LEADER IN THAT UP TO NOW: White House task force aims to promote scientific integrity. “The task force, part of the White House Office of Science & Technology Policy, makes no mention of COVID-19 but maintaining the public’s trust in scientific-based information about coronavirus, for example, has been a challenge since President Joe Biden’s administration took office a year ago.”

WHEN SCIENTISTS DON’T “FOLLOW THE SCIENCE:” Why did scientists suppress the lab-leak theory? In private, they said it was plausible. In public, they called it a conspiracy theory.

We were assured by leading scientists in China, the US and the UK that this really was a coincidence, even when the nine closest relatives of the new virus turned up in the freezer of the laboratory in question, at the Wuhan Institute of Virology.

Now we know what those leading scientists really thought. Emails exchanged between them after a conference call on 1 February 2020, and only now forced into the public domain by Republicans in the US Congress, show that they not only thought the virus might have leaked from a lab, but they also went much further in private. They thought the genome sequence of the new virus showed a strong likelihood of having been deliberately manipulated or accidentally mutated in the lab. Yet later they drafted an article for a scientific journal arguing that the suggestion not just of a manipulated virus, but even of an accidental spill, could be confidently dismissed and was a crackpot conspiracy theory. . . .

Two years later, no such natural furin-cleavage-site insertion has yet turned up in the many wild SARS-like viruses found since then. But what has turned up is a grant proposal put to the US’s Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) in 2018 to fund experiments that would deliberately insert novel furin cleavage sites into novel SARS-like coronaviruses to help them grow in the lab. And who was party to that proposal? Why, the Wuhan Institute of Virology. Indeed, it had already done a similar experiment with the spike protein of a MERS-like virus a few years before. It’s not quite a smoking gun, because the proposal was turned down, but it’s an open secret in science that you sometimes put things into grant proposals that you have already started doing, and the Chinese Academy of Sciences was funding most of the work in the Wuhan Institute of Virology anyway.

The emails unveiled this week reveal no good scientific reason at all for why these leading virologists changed their minds and became deniers rather than believers in even the remote possibility of a lab leak, all in just a few days in February 2020. No new data, no new arguments. But they do very clearly reveal a blatant political reason for the volte-face. Speculating about a lab leak, said Ron Fouchier, a Dutch researcher, might ‘do unnecessary harm to science in general and science in China in particular’. Francis Collins was pithier, worrying about ‘doing great potential harm to science and international harmony’. Contradicting Donald Trump, protecting science’s reputation at all costs and keeping in with those who dole out large grants are pretty strong incentives to change one’s mind.

In short, the fatcats lied to cover their asses.

I DID THAT: Reader Randall DeGeorge sends this: “This is from the Giant supermarket near my house in Fredericksburg, VA, yesterday. I actually went to 3 different Giants looking for a particular item my wife likes, but took pictures only in this one. The pictures are fairly representative of all the stores I hit. To be fair, not all of the shelves were like this; most of the shelves with canned goods and staples were pretty well stocked. Fresh food, though, including the meat section, was scarce. I’m fortunate enough to live within a 15 minute drive of at least 6 different supermarkets, so I can find what I need most of the time. But I don’t recall ever seeing stuff like this. Interesting times.”

Yeah, the shortages are spotty and uneven but they are increasingly widespread.

Then there are the prices. Another reader sends this:

THE INTELLECTUALS IN CHARGE: Navigating the fixations of the overthinking class. “One professor there, an eminent authority in what is probably my major interest — south Texas and Mexican-Americans — told me outright that he wouldn’t take on a Republican student. (This is, at it happens, illegal — set aside immoral — but how would I prove it happened?) . . . What I am gathering is that the history department at Major State U is extremely politicized, and dominated by neurotics.”

Plus: “The question is why. Why has the whole of society adopted the aesthetic and proclivities of the history department at Major State U, obsessed and obsessive to the point that those failing to obsess themselves are cast out? It’s a strange eruption of the style and mindset of what used to be an inconsequentially small cohort of Americans, now gripping the whole of society. . . . In fixation, in anxiety, in mania for control, in encompassing neuroses, the past is present again. The intellectuals are in charge. We allow them, we emulate them, and we suffer for it.”

Bullying and media power. Related: Can too many brainy people be a dangerous thing? Some academics argue that unhappy elites lead to political instability.

Ten years ago Peter Turchin, a scientist at the University of Connecticut, made a startling prediction in Nature. “The next decade is likely to be a period of growing instability in the United States and western Europe,” he asserted, pointing in part to the “overproduction of young graduates with advanced degrees”. The subsequent surge in populism in Europe, the unexpected votes in 2016 for Brexit and then for President Donald Trump in America, and a wave of protests from the gilets jaunes to Black Lives Matter, has made Mr Turchin something of a celebrity in certain circles, and has piqued economists’ interest in the discipline of “cliodynamics”, which uses maths to model historical change. Mr Turchin’s emphasis on the “overproduction of elites” raises uncomfortable questions, but also offers useful policy lessons.

Related: To quote Neal Stephenson, from In The Beginning Was The Command Line, “During this century, intellectualism failed, and everyone knows it. In places like Russia and Germany, the common people agreed to loosen their grip on traditional folkways, mores, and religion, and let the intellectuals run with the ball, and they screwed everything up and turned the century into an abbatoir. Those wordy intellectuals used to be merely tedious; now they seem kind of dangerous as well. We Americans are the only ones who didn’t get creamed at some point during all of this. We are free and prosperous because we have inherited political and values systems fabricated by a particular set of eighteenth-century intellectuals who happened to get it right. But we have lost touch with those intellectuals.”

That was last century. This century the intellectuals are trying to bring to America what they did to Europe in the 20th.

EVERYTHING IS GOING SWIMMINGLY:

To be fair, this is only because he’s a terrible, awful president.