Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

SCIENCE: NC Commission for Public Health taps brakes on 17-year-old COVID vaccination request.

A body with the ability to alter immunization requirements has tapped the brakes on adding COVID-19 vaccination requirements for students 17 and up.

The N.C. Commission for Public Health (NCCPH) is the only other body in the state besides the legislature which can alter immunization requirements for K-12 public school students. The NCCPH is housed within the N.C. Department of Health and Human Services. (NCDHHS).

The NCCPH voted unanimously to deny the petition. The motion made included directions for the commission’s staff and legal counsel to draft a letter of denial which will be circulated to the other members before being sent.

Prior to the vote, members Dr. Gene Minton and Dr. Michael Riccobene both voiced support for denying the petition.

“I think that based on the fact there is an especially high incidence of adverse effects in children and adolescents – particularly myocarditis and those type things – that we would really be making a not wise choice to require the least affected population of this country, which would be students… adolescents and children…to have the most stringent requirement,” Minton said.

Minton added he is a strong proponent of vaccinations for those who need it and restated that they should not be requiring it of those who least need it. He also noted there are no long-term studies on the adverse effects of the vaccines on kids.

“I am a 52-year-old with hypertension and high cholesterol and I am a frontline healthcare worker and I have chosen to be vaccinated and boosted and I believe I have acquired natural immunity,” said Riccobene. “I am a proponent of people in high-risk categories to being vaccinated, however, I do strongly believe in people’s personal freedoms.”

Riccobene continued, “I have chosen not to vaccinate my children. I think every parent and adult should have the right to choose whether or not they receive the COVID vaccine. I do not think it is in the best interest of the public to take away that right.”

Dr. Doug Sheets remarked that he had contacted the medical society and said that “the feeling” of their board of directors was they “could not currently support any COVID vaccine mandate for minors.”

That sounds sensible and cautious.

AS LONG AS IT’S NOT ICE 9: Direct evidence emerges for the existence of two forms of liquid water.

Thirty years ago, a team working at Boston University made the dramatic suggestion that there are not one but two forms of liquid water, which can interconvert at high pressure well below water’s normal freezing point.1 Researchers have been searching for this putative liquid–liquid phase transition ever since, and evidence has slowly accumulated that it really exists. New experiments now supply what seems to be a direct observation of such a transformation between liquid states of different density – not in pure water but in solutions of the sugar trehalose.2 Understanding how such supercold solutions behave could have implications for biology and cryopreservation – where damage to biological tissues by ice crystals must be avoided – as well as for the water-rich states that might exist in the atmospheres of gas giants.

Liquids are structurally disordered, so it’s not immediately obvious how they can support two distinct structures with different densities. But that does seem to be possible for liquids in which some degree of directional bonding, such as hydrogen bonds between adjacent water molecules, makes distinct local structures possible.

Fascinating.

WE’RE FROM THE GOVERNMENT AND WE’RE HERE TO HELP: Group accuses Utah agency of ruining ancient dinosaur tracks. “Donnelly said that the land management’s construction equipment, which included a backhoe left on site, had driven directly over the fossil dinosaur tracks, permanently destroying as much as 30% of the site.”

STANDING UP TO CAMPUS KANGAROO COURTS: TRO Against Brown University’s Interim Suspension of Student for Alleged Sexual Assault. “[T]he facts suggest that … the Threat Assessment Team failed to demonstrate anything that would indicate they afforded the plaintiff a presumption that he was not responsible for the alleged conduct as required by contract.”

You’re not actually supposed to start with a presumption of guilt.

VITAMIN D UPDATE: Israeli study offers strongest proof yet of vitamin D’s power to fight COVID. “Israel scientists say they have gathered the most convincing evidence to date that increased vitamin D levels can help COVID-19 patients reduce the risk of serious illness or death. Researchers from Bar Ilan University and the Galilee Medical Center say that the vitamin has such a strong impact on disease severity that they can predict how people would fare if infected based on nothing more than their ages and vitamin D levels. Lacking vitamin D significantly increases danger levels, they concluded in newly peer-reviewed research published Thursday in the journal PLOS One.”

WELL, FOR ONE THING THEY’VE TURNED OUT NOT TO BE VERY EXPERT: Why the experts are losing.

Rogan’s problem is quite different: The Joe Rogan Show has been subject to open threats of strike action by the employees at Spotify, which distributes his podcast. Their principal demand is to be handed editorial oversight over the podcast, with the power to veto what Rogan says or does.

This campaign was bolstered by an open letter signed by 270 “experts” concerned by his “history of broadcasting misinformation, particularly regarding the Covid-19 pandemic”. Interestingly, the list of signatories was not populated by people actually working in virology or vaccine research. Many of those who signed were nurses or students, others were general practitioners, a few were dentists, and at least one was a licensed marriage and family therapist.

It’s a bizarre situation: a call to censorship justified by the incapability of non-experts to handle a subject like vaccine research is then inundated with people who by the same metric should themselves be disqualified from having an opinion. But, ultimately, that’s the point — this was not a list of 270 of experts in the field, but rather a list of 270 of people from the expert class.

These class dynamics are hardly very subtle. Take Greta Thunberg, whose claim to fame, to put it pithily, is the fact that she refuses to go to school. While many of us can probably empathise with this desire, there is something strange about a person who hasn’t even finished high school acting like she belongs to a group of people who justify their rule through technocratic language.

But while Greta may not really have much of a formal education, she does have rich parents, and a slew of contacts in the international NGO world. It would be foolish to think that the mere act of having a PhD would allow you to countermand someone like Greta Thunberg, even though the echelon she occupies openly ridicules the vast hordes of “deplorables” for the high crime of only having a high school diploma.

Like medieval nobles claiming a right to rule based on being a superior breed, and then openly practising inbreeding, our current elites rarely live up to their own hype. Often, the experts are stupid and wrong, sometimes to an almost comical degree. And yet they persist in trying to convince us that they deserve to rule us, and get mightily upset whenever someone dares to challenge their power. Their fixation with Joe Rogan is not hard to understand through this lens.

Related: The Suicide of Expertise.

It was experts who brought us the housing bubble and the subprime crisis. It was experts who botched the Obamacare rollout. And, of course, the experts didn’t see Brexit coming, and seem to have responded mostly with injured pride and assaults on the intelligence of the electorate, rather than with constructive solutions.

By its fruit the tree is known, and the tree of expertise hasn’t been doing well lately. As Nassim Taleb recently observed: “With psychology papers replicating less than 40%, dietary advice reversing after 30 years of fatphobia, macroeconomic analysis working worse than astrology, the appointment of Bernanke who was less than clueless of the risks, and pharmaceutical trials replicating at best only 1/3 of the time, people are perfectly entitled to rely on their own ancestral instinct and listen to their grandmothers.”

Then there’s the problem that, somehow, over the past half-century or so the educated classes that make up the “expert” demographic seem to have been doing pretty well, even as so many ordinary folks, in America and throughout the West, have seen their fortunes decaying. Is it any surprise that claims to authority in the form of “expertise” don’t carry the same weight that they once did?

If experts want to reclaim a position of authority, they need to make a few changes. First, they should make sure they know what they’re talking about, and they shouldn’t talk about things where their knowledge isn’t solid. Second, they should be appropriately modest in their claims of authority. And, third, they should check their egos. It doesn’t matter what your SAT scores were, voters are under no obligation to listen to you unless they find what you say persuasive.

And you know what makes you less persuasive? The kind of contempt displayed by Foreign Affairs. If expertise is dead, it’s because those who claimed it overplayed their hands. It’s not the death of expertise, so much as a suicide.

I’ve been flashing back to this and other items from a few years ago a lot lately, because things look to be coming to a head.

HIGHER EDUCATION BUBBLE UPDATE: Duke mum on whether it apologized for calling Tibet a country. “If Duke University’s engineering department emailed an apology to students and faculty for calling Tibet a country separate from China, it isn’t admitting to it. On January 27, director of We the Hongkongers and pro-democracy activist Frances Hui tweeted a screenshot purportedly from the diversity department of Duke’s Pratt School of Engineering. In the email, the school apologizes for a previous email announcing ‘Lunar New Year Paint Night’ that categorized Tibet as an independent country.”

ON THE ONE HAND, THEY DESERVE IT. ON THE OTHER HAND, IT MAY DRAG THE WHOLE ECONOMY DOWN. Mark Zuckerberg’s Disaster Is Taking Silicon Valley With It. “Meta’s was the largest one-day loss by a U.S. company ever, and the ripple effects were closer to tsunamis throughout Silicon Valley. The list of tech losers reeling from the Meta Platforms (formerly Facebook) reckoning is long and full of familiar names: Spotify was 16 percent lower; Twitter was down about 6 percent; and even companies that were relatively safe, such as Apple and Microsoft, saw hundreds of billions of dollars erased from their market value.”

MY NEW YORK POST COLUMN: Truckers are starting a working-class revolution — and the left hates it. “A working-class revolution led by the working class is the left’s worst nightmare because the working class doesn’t want what the left wants. The working class wants jobs, a stable economy, safe streets, low inflation, schools that teach things and a conservative, non-adventurous foreign policy that won’t get a lot of working-class people killed. It’s not excited about gender fluidity, critical race theory, ‘modern monetary theory,’ foreign adventures and defunding police.”

EVERYTHING IS GOING SWIMMINGLY: Russia threatens power grids if Biden moves in Ukraine. “The nation’s leading expert on protecting the electric grid from attack urges governors to take the lead because the Biden administration won’t. In a new alert, Peter Vincent Pry, the executive director of the EMP Task Force on National and Homeland Security, said concerns are growing that Russia, North Korea, and Iran are inching closer to testing an electromagnetic attack on the U.S. grid, or parts of it.”

ANALYSIS: TRUE. Georgetown Law’s actions against Ilya Shapiro lack credibility: Criticizing racial discrimination is protected by the university’s ‘Speech and Expression Policy.’

Ilya Shapiro spoke out against racism in a tweet, and this week the Dean at Georgetown law school placed him on administrative leave, pending further investigation. The decision is disgraceful.

During the 2020 Democratic primaries, Joe Biden was granted the endorsement of South Carolina Rep. James Clyburn, in a quid pro quo exchange for Biden’s promise to nominate a black woman to the Supreme Court. Many previous Supreme Court nominations have considered the political advantages of potential nominees’ home state or region, ethnicity, religion, sex, race, or other biographical elements. Never before has a President announced such a narrow rule about who would be considered.

While reasonable people can differ, an ABC News/Ipsos poll found that 76% of Americans agree that Biden “should consider all possible nominees” rather than “only nominees who are Black women.” Those who disagree with Biden’s limit include 54% of Democrats and 72% of nonwhite Americans.

Ilya Shapiro, who was slated to join Georgetown Law as a senior lecturer on Feb. 1, agrees with the American majority. This is no surprise. He headed the Cato Institute’s Center for Constitutional Studies. As Cato’s Executive Vice President David Boaz has long made clear, Cato hires on merit alone. Thus, all Cato’s employees—whatever their race, sex, religion, ethnicity, sexuality, or other identity—know that they were chosen because they were the best candidates for the job, and not because of favoritism. . . .

Georgetown Law’s Dean, William Treanor, issued a statement denouncing Shapiro. Treanor claimed that Shapiro had suggested that “the best Supreme Court nominee could not be a Black woman.” This is true only in the sense that Shapiro was explicitly discussing a 2022 nomination by a Democratic President, and since Shapiro thinks Sri Srinivasan is the “best” nominee for a Democratic President, then the “best” nominee could not be a black woman, a white man, a Native American, or anyone else.

In fact, Shapiro has said that the best nominee for the Supreme Court could be a black woman—namely D.C. Circuit Judge Janice Rogers Brown. In a 2016 event at the University of Chicago Law School, he listed Judge Brown as among several he would consider nominating, if he had the power. Judge Brown, who retired from the D.C. Circuit in 2017, is perhaps even more distinguished that Judge Srinivasan. She joined the D.C. Circuit in 2005, having served since 1996 on the California Supreme Court, and before that in several high-level legal roles in the California state government. But she is an originalist and therefore anathema to Biden, who led a filibuster against her nomination to the D.C. Circuit. When President Bush was considering nominating Brown to be the first black female Supreme Court Justice, Biden specifically threatened to filibuster her, and her alone.

On Monday, Dean Treanor placed Shapiro on administrative leave, citing the “pain and outrage” of Georgetown’s black students, professors, staff, and alumni. He added, “Ilya Shapiro’s tweets are antithetical to the work that we do here every day to build inclusion, belonging, and respect for diversity.”

The Dean’s statement is true if “inclusion, belonging, and respect for diversity” means that racial preferences may never be criticized. Some people who favor racial preferences, or perceive themselves has having benefited from such preferences, are outraged at criticism of racial discrimination. However, law schools are supposed to be places where all ideas can be debated logically. Lawyers who cannot bear to hear ideas they don’t like will be poor advocates for their clients in our adversarial legal system, and professors who can’t tolerate criticism of their own ideology are poor role models for students.

The only actual principle involved here is that Georgetown will not tolerate disagreement with the Democrat/Lefty narrative of the moment.

It’s a disgrace.

Plus: “Students considering which law school to attend might have more confidence in a school whose dean has never libeled anyone. Donors to any law school might consider the state of the school’s academic freedom.”

THERE WAS NEVER MUCH DOUBT: Failed Democrat Congressional Candidate Says Gina Carano Should Be in Prison, Proving the Hard Left Are the Fascists.

Mark Judson is a failed Democrat congressional candidate from North Carolina who believes that actress Gina Carano, popularized in the Star Wars series “The Mandalorian,” should be imprisoned instead of in movies because she said something he didn’t like.

In 2021, Carano was fired from Disney following a tweet she released that featured a 1940’s picture of a Jewish woman running in her underwear away from German citizens, including children, who seemed to be chasing her with sticks. Carano posted a caption with the picture that told the story of how the hatred that developed around the Jewish people in Germany made even their own neighbors turn violent against them and made it easier for Nazis to round them up.

“Jews were beaten in the streets, not by Nazi soldiers but by their neighbors…even children,” wrote Carano. ” Because history is edited, most people today don’t realize that to get to the point where Nazi soldiers could easily round up thousands of Jews, the government first made their own neighbors hate them simply for being Jews. How is that any different from hating someone for their political views?”

Carano’s post was historically correct, but what reportedly angered Disney is that she compared the plight of the Jewish people in Nazi Germany to today’s divisive political climate. Carano’s point was simply saying that those who don’t learn from their history are doomed to repeat it, but the left threw a massive tantrum around it. Disney promptly fired Carano over the post literally telling people not to look at each other as “others,” a seemingly silly move, but one that highly suggests Disney was looking for a reason to fire Carano already over her socio-political views.

Since then, Carano was hired by Ben Shapiro to create movies for the Daily Wire, taking that win from cancel culture and giving Carano more acting opportunities.

Fast forward to last Wednesday, and the news began circulating around that Whoopie Goldberg was suspended from her show “The View” after her comments about how the Holocaust wasn’t about race. One article from the Daily Wire discussed how “liberal privilege is real” since Goldberg was simply suspended for saying something horribly racist while Carano was fired for simply saying something that encouraged less hate among those who disagree.

This infuriated Judson who declared that it was good Carano got fired for pushing “The Big Lie” and promptly suggested she should actually be in jail.

What a clown.

MARK JUDGE: The Long, Failed Drive of the Washington Redskins. “At least the new name of the Washington Redskins is not the Washington Communists, as some on the internet began calling the team after the announcement that it would now be known as the Commanders. Although that might at least be accurate, as there are a few communists — or at least socialists — on Capitol Hill these days. . . . The larger problem is that Commanders is not a very fun-sounding name — say, like the Jets or the Chargers. Commanders sounds bleak. Serious. Militant. Perhaps it is a fitting name after all, because that is what the Washington Redskins have been in the 30 years since they last won a Super Bowl.”