Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

MAKE THEM PAY: Why Colleges Don’t Care About Free Speech: It’s incentives more than ideology, and there’s a simple fix.

Regardless of Mr. Treanor’s political views, he has every reason to do this. University administrators get no reward for upholding abstract principles. Their incentive is to quell on-campus outrage and bad press as quickly as possible. Success is widely praised, but there is no punishment for failing to uphold the university’s commitment to free speech.

The solution is to create an incentive for schools to protect open inquiry—the fear of lawsuits. First, universities should add a “safe harbor” provision to their speech policies stating: “The university will summarily dismiss any allegation that an individual or group has violated a university policy if the allegation is based solely on the individual’s or group’s expression of religious, philosophical, literary, artistic, political, or scientific viewpoints.” This language would be contractually binding. Second, free-speech advocates should organize pro bono legal groups to sue schools that violate the safe-harbor provision. This would make it affordable for suppressed parties to bring suits over the violation of their contractual rights.

University counsel, whose primary job is to protect the institution from being sued, would then have incentive to curb administrators’ behavior. They might require that allegations of harassment be reviewed by a member of the counsel’s office who knows how to distinguish complaints about speech from genuine harassment. They almost certainly would revise the university’s antiharassment training to stress that students and faculty shouldn’t file complaints based solely on the content of the viewpoint being expressed. These and other steps they might take would give universities’ abstract commitments to freedom of speech some real bite.

In the absence of damage awards, university administrators won’t act against their own interests merely to uphold an abstract commitment to free speech. The threat of such awards would make universities like Georgetown put their money where their mouths are.

A federal civil rights statute, allowing civil suits by injured parties in which one remedy is removal of a university’s tax-exempt status in cases of political discrimination, would help.

LIKELY INCITED BY JUSTIN TRUDEAU’S HATE SPEECH: Canadian man plows through Freedom Truckers protest, criminally charged. Trudeau identified the peaceful protesters as bigots, homophobes, racists and transphobes. It’s not surprising that some nut would listen to him, especially given that Canadian media amplified the message endlessly.

WELL, IN THE MODERN WORLD, IT’S LESS USEFUL AND MORE LIKELY TO BE ANNOYING: People’s sense of smell may be declining, study suggests. And some of it is just mental filtering. Most people’s sense of smell is much better than they think. Richard Feynman used to have a parlor trick where he’d have someone take a book off a shelf and put it back. Most people could tell which book by smelling the shelf, and which person by smelling hands.

Most people can see and hear a lot more than they realize too. Modern society encourages filtering this data.

LIKE KHADDAFY, THEY F*CKED UP, THEY TRUSTED US: Ukraine gave up nukes 30 years ago. Today there are regrets.

“We gave away the capability for nothing,” said Andriy Zahorodniuk, a former defense minister of Ukraine. Referring to the security assurances Ukraine won in exchange for its nuclear arms, he added: “Now, every time somebody offers us to sign a strip of paper, the response is, ‘Thank you very much. We already had one of those some time ago.’”

Ask Muammar how that worked out for him.

UPDATE: From the comments: “What is the likelihood that a consequence of Joe Biden’s presidency is that many technologically advanced nations are going to obtain nuclear weapons. I look forward to the same folks who were surprised at how quickly Afghanistan fell expressing surprise at this new development.”

Yep. As the Pax Americana ends, that’s the rational thing to do.

SOROS PROSECUTORS GONNA SOROS PROSECUTE: Chesa Boudin’s office accused of rigging case against cop. “It’s bad enough that Boudin is working overtime to make sure that as few actual criminals as possible ever spend a day behind bars. But if these allegations prove to be true and it turns out that he’s been working to unjustly frame cops so he can put them in jail, then this situation has shifted from gross incompetence to criminal malfeasance.”

WHITE GUY SAYS THERE ARE TOO MANY ASIANS:

#RESISTANCE:

A reader sends this: “In Blue Illinois.”

Another from Salton, California:

Plus this from Farmingdale, New York:

The #resistance is everywhere, and it’s just getting started.

And in a related development, a reader sends a pic that could use an “I did that” sticker: “I took this photo at a Giant supermarket that is about 3 miles from the President’s place in North Shores near Rehoboth Beach. Sussex County is the No. 1 broiler producer in the entire US, with Kent County just north of it in the top 15. Just amazing-or maybe not.”

Everything is going swimmingly.

ICYMI: READING THE NEW YORK TIMES DOESN’T HELP: NYT: Suburban women stuck in “politics of gloom” ahead of midterms. “Well, who isn’t? Inflation has hit a 40-year high, we’re edging up to another wage-price spiral, another war is brewing in eastern Europe, and we’re entering Year 3 of pandemic life. Anyone not perceiving political and cultural gloom at this moment might need their head examined. Even so, the second successive focus-group test covered by the New York Times shows the risks for Democrats in perhaps one of the most significant demographics. Suburban women may not dislike Joe Biden, but they are very unimpressed by his handling of the presidency.” Well, with reason. Plus: “Despite claims from Biden that he’d “outperformed” expectations in his first year, those voters unanimously had an entirely different assessment. And they’re also rejecting the January 6 argument just as completely.”

Flashback: Democrats’ war on suburban women includes inflation-fueling reckless spending.

YEP:

The old decentralized blogosphere had the advantage that it had no single points of failure, and was virtually impossible to censor. A cynic might suggest that that’s why the powers that be rolled out social media to displace it. But the real problem of the Establishment Media, as with the rest of the Establishment, is that people don’t trust them because they’re not just liars, they’re bad liars, and they’re not just bad liars but people who can’t help — in fact who glory in — displaying contempt for their audiences.

Related:

HEATHER HAVRILESKY HAS A NEW NOVEL OUT, and Ann Althouse invokes Erma Bombeck. The NYT reviewer didn’t like it much, which isn’t necessarily bad, but I was reminded of this Havrilesky quote from 20 years ago, during the early days of InstaPundit and the Blogosphere: “In the language of wedding porn, there’s an unspoken expectation that a man will squeeze comfortably into a preset role: handsome, sweet, neutered wage earner. He works hard so you don’t have to.”

I miss those early days of the blogosphere. I remember meeting Heather Havrilesky at a party at Eugene Volokh’s where an all-star crowd ranging from Mickey Kaus to Alex Pournelle provided glittering conversation. There were even lefty bloggers like Tony Pierce there and everyone got along so well because we were all just excited about this new thing we were all doing. Those days are long gone now, of course.