Author Archive: Glenn Reynolds

GOOD ADVICE: Why Liberal Students Should Attend College in Red States. “Third, given current economic trends and realities, it’s arguably better in a red state for future job prospects. These states may have more opportunities and a lower cost of living; just ask the American workers who have been moving in large numbers to red states in recent years, many for lifestyle and financial reasons. Graduating college students seek affordability and career opportunities, in that order, in where they’ll start their adult lives. Don’t think that students don’t want to live in red states; Texas boasts the highest retention rate for college grads (more than 60 percent in one study) and other red states, such as Florida and Georgia, are not that far behind.”

Plus: “Many students with whom I speak actively express a desire to go to school with people from all kinds of backgrounds, with points of view different from their own. That’s part of why diversity is so important to them as a generation. But when it comes to higher education, we should not limit ourselves to seeking diversity on just the grounds of race, gender, or socio-economic backgrounds. We need to reach out across the different sides of the political divide as well.”

WELL, EXCEPT FOR CLARENCE THOMAS, BECAUSE LEFTIES HATE HIM: Supreme Court justices are allowed to have friends.

Everything you’re seeing is just an effort to discredit him before the affirmative action decision comes out.

JONATHAN TURLEY: Democrats Go Nuts in Nashville. “This month, there was an ‘assault on democracy’ in Tennessee. It was not three members halting the legislative process, but rather their expulsion. It appears that nothing says democracy like a bullhorn and obstructing legislative work.”

Plus: “The full-throated support for the actions of the expelled legislators is a bizarre position for the Senate president who enforces the same rules in Washington, DC. Yet she was disgusted by sanctioning members who refused to allow their colleagues to continue legislative business because they lacked the votes for a gun control measure. Harris proclaimed ‘it’s about whose voices they were channeling.’ . . . These legislators were upset because they are in the minority and lack sufficient votes to get what they want. They were protesting the democratic process, not advancing its principles in shutting down the floor.”

It’s always “democracy” if you’re channeling the voices of Democratic activists; it’s alway “insurrection” if you’re taking the other side.

THE SHOOTING OF SIX PEOPLE AT A CHRISTIAN SCHOOL BY A TRANSGENDER ACTIVIST HAS BEEN MEMORY-HOLED: Again… where is the manifesto?

WE CAN’T AFFORD IT, GO AWAY: “Sustainable Development’s” $4 Trillion Price Tag.

If you ask the question – what would it take to put the world on a track of sustainable development? – the best guesses of the experts who have spent most time trying to figure this out tend to congregate around $4 trillion in investment, per annum over the next decade. This was the conclusion of a panel of experts working for the COP27 meeting in November 2022 headed up by Vera Songwe, Nicholas Stern and Amar Bhattacharya.

One could write an interesting story about the calculation of these numbers and the remarkable resurgence of world-level development thinking they imply. To be talking about a “big push” harkens back to the early days of development economics. Is the message from Vera Songwe, Nicholas Stern and Amar Bhattacharya that we need go “back to the future”?

You might say that as in earlier generations of development thinking there is something disembodied, utopian, anti-political about asking this question – what will it take? – and answering with a round number – $ 4 trillion per annum. After all, there is no “we”, no global government that will answer this call. Nation states pursue geopolitics. As ever, national politicians want to retain power. They have short time-horizons. Capitalism is driven by profit, pure and simple. What kind of political process do we envision that would mobilize and direct this immense amount of money? What kind of revolution would it take? . . .

The experts and their networks form a world that is real enough. This circularly self-recruiting epistemic community is closely connected not only to academia and think tanks but institutions like the World Bank and private business. One could write an interesting study of how such expert groups are constituted and constitute themselves.

The record of the “experts” over the past few years does not inspire me to want to give them more power or resources. These people have no skin in the game; if their ideas fail — and, history suggests, they will, and disastrously — they will suffer no consequences.

And note that the $4 trillion figure is per annum. My prediction: $2 trillion will go to various forms of graft, and most of the rest will be spent in ways that do more harm than good.

“DEFENDERS OF SCIENCE:” The biggest defenders of science did the most damage to it.

I know the pandemic is winding down when I see ‘science influencers,’ ‘debunkers’ and the ‘misinformation police’ return to focusing on issues that match their skill set: debunking vitamins, supplements, cupping, homeopathy, electric fields and other clearly unproven and implausible medical interventions. . . .

The science influencers came to our rescue, or so they believed. They knew that the CDC’s recommendations— under a Democratic president— were always correct when they advocated for interventions and restrictions, and only incorrect for not going further. Of course, we should mask toddlers— the only error the CDC made was not doing it sooner and longer. Of course, we should boost 16 year old men— even if they had COVID— and of course, they should get a bivalent booster— even if they had COVID again. Of course, schools should mandate vaccines. In fact, mandates would not be needed if it weren’t for anti-science grifters. If only we would all dutifully get all the doses, Lord Peter Marks advised, and take Paxlovid as Emperor Jha suggested, we would be better off (irrespective of age or prior infection).

Indeed, soft target ‘debunkers’ turned their criticism of alternative medicines into a remix of ‘the establishment is always right, and if anything, doesn’t go far enough’. It was no coincidence that this fell along lines of political preference (left wing), and among insular communities on social media. The debunkers were united in disparate beliefs: masks work and Elon Musk is bad. . . .

Add to this mix: growing political fanaticism. Trump indeed broke brains. Although he is not currently president, he remains the most discussed politician. As Sagar Enjeti recently said, ‘the Trump era began when he descended the escalator and will end only when he dies.’ Soft target debunkers largely oppose Trump, and some of their scientific beliefs are supported merely by the fact Trump said the opposite.

What happens when you pair mediocre scientists with political fanaticism and inject health policy decisions made by partisan administrations? The answer is chaos. The debunkers have no skillset to separate sound decisions from bad ones.

The way you defend science is by explaining, debating, and engaging with people who have different theories and hypotheses. Silencing and bullying isn’t the same.

OPEN THREAD: Disport yourselves in the comments.

PULLED UP TO THE GAS PUMP ON THE WAY HOME AND SAW ONE OF THESE, FIRST IN A WHILE:

I looked down and sure enough, gas was up 16 cents a gallon from last week, from $3.79 to $3.95. Wonder if they’ll start reappearing now.

Flashback: Blame at the pump: ‘I did that’ Biden stickers point finger for high prices. “The Biden stickers aren’t new, although the rapidly ascending pump prices might be making them more ubiquitous. Last fall, the Boston Herald reported on the sticker phenomenon when gas was ‘only’ $3.50 per gallon. A pack of 100 of the 3-inch-high stickers costs anywhere from $10 to $13 on Amazon.”

EMILY LITELLA, PHD: Shock Boson Result Upending Physics Was a Miscalculation, Scientists Say. “The discovery of a discrepancy between the W boson’s theorized and experimental masses promised new insights beyond the Standard Model, the theoretical blueprint that describes how matter behaves. Now scientists have run the same numbers again using an updated technique, this time discovering the particle’s mass is a close fit with the Standard Model’s predictions after all.”

Never mind.