Author Archive: Ed Driscoll

AND NOW, A FEW WORDS FROM JOE BIDEN:

As with Democrats’ previous tough talk on immigration, Trump should run this clip and add, “I’m Donald Trump, and I approve this message.”

Related: The View: Trump Crime Crackdown About Literal ‘War’ Against Americans.

Wow, they turned against Joe Biden even more than Biden himself did.

CHRISTIAN TOTO: Graham Linehan: My Arrest ‘Blew Up in Their Faces.’

The corrupt, biased press went silent after Tara Reade accused Joe Biden of sexually assaulting her in 1993.

Nothing to see here. Move along. It lasted for weeks.

The only mainstream journalist to seek Reade out for an interview at the time? Megyn Kelly.

The former Fox News superstar wasn’t the media force she is today, though. Kelly had been unfairly jettisoned by NBC after some innocent comments about blackface were weaponized against her.

Kelly still saw the obvious news value in speaking with Reade, and she used her then-modest platform to conduct the interview.

Today, Kelly is one of the media’s biggest stars. She recently launched several new programs as part of her podcast empire, MK Media, featuring hosts like Link Lauren, Maureen Callahan, Emily Jashinsky and Mark Halperin.

And, once again, Kelly interviewed a subject with an amazing story to tell, who you won’t find anywhere else. This story also doesn’t align with the Legacy Media’s narrative.

She did it anyway.

Here’s the interview:

FRIEND WHO SPARKED ‘HANDS UP, DON’T SHOOT’ LIE IN MICHAEL BROWN POLICE SHOOTING, FATALLY SHOT IN FERGUSON:

The man whose lies helped propel BLM, causing death, riots, and destruction, has died in a fatal shooting in Ferguson, Missouri. In 2014, Dorian Johnson witnessed his friend Michael Brown rush a police officer in Ferguson. The officer fatally shot Brown in self-defense. But before the truth finally came out, lies were spread about the killing by Johnson, which created a national media-fueled outrage that was driven on by the later-debunked ‘Hands up, Don’t Shoot’ chant and narrative. Johnson died on Sunday, less than a mile from where Brown was killed. No police were involved… Posters are not missing the irony that a person who sparked an anti-police crusade died by the very violence that more policing could have helped prevent.

Flashback: CNN Host Angry Conservatives Don’t Trust the Media, But Here’s a Few Examples Why. Including:

EVERGREEN: French government collapses.

The French government has collapsed after prime minister François Bayrou lost a confidence vote in the National Assembly.

MPs overwhelmingly backed the motion to remove Mr Bayrou, voting 364-194 – a 170 majority.

Mr Bayrou is expected to resign on Tuesday, leaving Emmanuel Macron to search for a replacement or call snap elections.

The French prime minister called the vote of confidence in an attempt to force MPs to adopt his austerity budget.

During an impassioned speech to MPs, he warned: “You can get rid of the government, but you can’t get rid of reality.”

Though the French have certainly been giving the latter a try since 1789.

1619 PROJECT CREATOR ON ZARUTSKA STABBING:

The Gray Lady is too busy working out its own “Republicans Pounce” angle before it can actually report this news to its readers:

So why does the Times appear to be paralyzed? “This incident really does combine all the kryptonite elements into one:”

HARRY METCALFE AND JEREMY CLARKSON: Is Jaguar’s rebrand clever or a disaster, and when was peak car? (Video.)

AXIOS GOES INTO FULL REPUBLICANS POUNCE MODE TO TUT-TUT ZARUTSKA MURDER: Stabbing video fuels MAGA’s crime message.

MAGA influencers are drawing repeated attention to violent attacks to elevate the issue of urban crime — and accuse mainstream media of under-covering shocking cases.

  • Shocking video of the fatal Aug. 22 knife attack on 23-year-old Iryna Zarutska on a light-rail car in Charlotte, North Carolina, dominated weekend conversation on Trump-friendly social media.

The big picture: The rising number of surveillance cameras in public spaces, including on Charlotte’s light rail, has become a big accelerant in these cases.

  • The video is easily shared or leaked, and can instantly pollinate across social media — a visual counterpoint to statistics showing crime decreases.

Driving the news: President Trump, asked about the Charlotte video by a reporter Sunday, said he wanted to find out more about the stabbing before commenting.

  • “I’ll know all about it by tomorrow morning,” Trump said.

  • A Trump adviser told Axios: “This is exactly what he’s talking about, and it’s going to be an issue he’s going to highlight. This is not just about North Carolina. Other campaigns will deal with this.”

As Glenn wrote on his Substack last night, “Since the number one rule for the legacy media is ‘thou shalt not support anything Trump does,’ naturally the Zarutska murder can’t be covered. And it won’t be, unless they can find — or manufacture — some alternative angle that will make Trump look bad. So far, they’ve come up a dry hole. So nothing.”

And that’s why Axios started off Monday by blaming the video of Zarutska’s murder, and Republicans’ response to it. It’s adjacent to their fellow leftists originally demanding omnipresent police body cams, and then being shocked that almost invariably, they show the police responding competently to violent crimes being committed:

As Matt Walsh notes, “It’s interesting that police shootings are the one kind of story where it’s less likely to be a national story if there is a video of it. What does that tell you?”

JOSH HAMMER: Trump’s National Guard Deployment and the Art of the 80-20 Issue.

Trump knows that when he floats these proposals, Democrats and their corporate media allies won’t respond with nuance. They’ll respond with knee-jerk outrage — just as they did in 2020, when Trump sent federal agents to Portland to stop violent anarchists from torching courthouses. The media framed it as martial law; sane Oregonians saw it as basic governance.

This dynamic plays out again and again. When Trump highlights the border crisis and the need to deport unsavory figures like Mahmoud Khalil and Kilmar Abrego Garcia, Democrats defend open borders. When Trump attacks gender ideology indoctrination in schools, Democrats double down on letting teachers hide children’s “transitions” from their parents. When Trump condemns pro-Hamas rioters in American cities, Democrats can’t bring themselves to say a word of support for Israel’s war against a U.S. State Department-recognized foreign terrorist organization. When Trump signs an executive order seeking to partially recriminalize flag burning, Democrats defend flag burning.

On and on it goes. By now, it’s a well-established pattern. And it’s politically devastating for the Left. Moreover, the relevant history is on Trump’s side. This sort of federal corrective goes back all the way to the republic’s origins; those now freaking out might want to read up on George Washington’s efforts to quash the Whiskey Rebellion in 1794.

Call it the art of the 80-20 issue. Along with his sheer sense of humor, Trump’s instinctual knack for picking such winning battles is one of his greatest political assets. And this time, the winner won’t just be Trump himself — it will be Chicagoans and Baltimoreans as well.

Related:

Baltimore’s last Republican mayor left office almost 60 years ago. Why do Charm City’s mayors in the decades since want to keep maintaining plenty of “space to destroy,” despite such anarchy leading to collapsing real estate values and a fleeing tax base?

STARTING FROM ZERO: Take the nuclear option: Let Mamdani win the mayoral race so NYC can start over from scratch.

As alarm bells ring over the New York City mayoral race, an odd sentiment is starting to gain traction across the business community: Just give up.

Just sit tight and let the ill-equipped Maoist Zohran Mamdani win in November.

Let him unleash his creepy, dogmatic socialist policies on the masses to teach them valuable lessons — both economic and cultural — about wokeness and progressivism, and more broadly its stranglehold on the Democratic Party.

I’m starting to agree.

A fleeing middle class

Let the city sink into the abyss.

Let Mamdani’s policies force out business and prod more upper- and middle-class residents to flee.

Let the city declare bankruptcy — which will happen if Mamdani gets his way.

We can then start from scratch.

Detroit did it and the last time I was there, its downtown was pristine.

Plus, we’re headed there anyway, right?

“Downtown Detroit has rebounded since the city’s 2013 bankruptcy, but acres of vacant land, blighted properties and a lack of private capital have kept the city’s other neighborhoods from enjoying a similar renaissance,” Real estate Website CoStar noted last year.  New York similarly collapsed in the late ’60s thanks to John Lindsay:

The crisis of 1965 was comparative. Liberal politicians like Lindsay believed Lyndon Johnson’s Great Society had worked out scientific answers to our great social problems, so that the city should be judged not by its own past but by what it could be if men of vision were given the power to remake it.

In the series, which cleared Lindsay’s path to City Hall, he vowed to get New York “going again.” Instead, he oversaw as mayor (and with the editor of “New York City in Crisis” soon joining his administration as a top aide) the city’s decent into the very catastrophe the Trib had imagined.

In the midst of an economic boom, crime exploded. Instead of reforming what had, in fact, been the best big city school system in America, he left it in tatters. He promised to better incorporate African Americans but left the city polarized.

It wasn’t until Rudy Giuliani was elected in 1993 that the city began to claw its way back, until Bill de Blasio took office in 2014. Are New Yorkers prepared for another decades-long collapse?

(Classical reference in headline.)

NICE WORK IF YOU CAN GET IT: So, That Protest Of Old White Lefties in D.C. Pushing for MORE Crime? Insurrection Barbie Just Busted ‘Em.

As the late P.J. O’Rourke wrote in his 1991 magnum opus, Parliament of Whores:

Not long after Andy [Ferguson] and I met, we were driving down Pennsylvania Avenue and encountered some or another noisy pinko demonstration. “How come,” I asked Andy, “whenever something upsets the Left, you see immediate marches and parades and rallies with signs already printed and rhyming slogans already composed, whereas whenever something upsets the Right, you see two members of the Young Americans for Freedom waving a six-inch American flag?” “We have jobs,” said Andy.

And so do the protestors:

“So, once again, taxpayers are funding protests they do not necessarily agree with. Yay.”

Related:

Earlier: Stephen Miller’s Rant on ‘White, Crazy Communist Hippie’ Rent-a-Mobs in D.C. Is Standing-O Worthy.

ROGER KIMBALL: The Issue Is Never the Issue: Senate Hearing Turns Into Proxy War.

But in an important sense, the criticism of Kennedy for his views on COVID, vaccines, and the staff at the CDC was merely a pretext. The issue is never the issue. Yes, Senator Elizabeth Warren, who has received $1,224,145 from Big Pharma, did her psychotic squaw routine against Kennedy. Bernie Sanders ($1,953,613) and Ron Wyden ($1,207,873) joined in the war dance, as did many others.

But the thing to appreciate about the melodrama is that it had very little to do with COVID or the CDC or even U.S. health policy writ large. The real protagonist was someone who wasn’t even present, viz. Donald Trump. The fire was directed at Kennedy, but the ultimate target was Trump. The strategy is to discredit and then destroy Kennedy, a potent outgrowth of the Trump administration. If the Dems can destroy Kennedy, he would represent the outer skin of the onion. They would then proceed against other Trump lieutenants.

Robert Kennedy wants to find out why Americans are fatter, sicker, and more plagued by chronic disease now than ever before. He wants to know why cases of autism have skyrocketed and why 8 out of 10 young adults are not fit enough to join the military. Is it because of what they eat, the medicines they are forced to take, or something else? The Democrats want to play what Bill Clinton (and later Hillary) called “the politics of personal destruction.”

The issue is never the issue, but determined truth-tellers like Robert Kennedy and his boss in the White House are a demonstration that “the issue” can be made to succumb to the awful clarity of common sense, bolstered by that other real issue, the executive power of the presidency.

I’m not a huge fan of RFK Jr., but to understand how he got to the CDC, it’s useful to look back at who was working there during the previous administration:

WHAT COULD POSSIBLY GO WRONG? Orson Welles Meets AI in a Restoration of The Magnificent Ambersons — and Its Lost Ending.

The lost 43 minutes of Orson Welles‘ “The Magnificent Ambersons” is the holy grail of cinema. The legend goes that after a bad test screening, RKO tacked on a happy ending and chopped the film from 131 minutes to 88. The missing minutes were melted for their silver nitrate, but cinephiles have spent years seeking a print that retained the the footage; TCM even sponsored a trip to Brazil in pursuit of a complete print.

Like other efforts, Brazil didn’t pan out. Welles believed that the studio butchered a movie that would be seen as greater than his debut, “Citizen Kane,” but would he have used generative AI if it offered the possibility of recreating what he lost?

Showrunner, which bills itself as the “Netflix of AI,” is either betting Welles would (or, has the hubris not to bother with the question). It is using “The Magnificent Ambersons” to develop its latest model, FILM-1, which Showrunner hopes will let people generate lifelike short films.

Working with Brian Rose, who spent the last five years trying to recreate the film with charcoal drawings, physical models of the sets, and researching storyboards and screenplay drafts, Showrunner will spend next two years to get as close as possible to Welles’ vision.

“Perhaps in its reconstructed form, we will all say, in the words of an audience card at the disastrous preview in Pomona that ended the film’s chances: ‘I think that this is the best picture that I have ever seen,’” Showrunner CEO Edward Saatchi said in a statement to IndieWire.

Or perhaps not. But it was inevitable that sooner or later, someone would use AI in an attempt to restore Welles’ original ending to Ambersons. I’m extremely apprehensive about how this will turn out, but I can’t wait to see the results.

For a look at how to do it right — check out Walter Murch’s re-editing of Welles’ 1957 classic b-movie, Touch of Evil, using a 58-page memo Welles wrote after another film was yanked away from him by meddling studio executives, a topic I explored at length in my recent review of Murch’s new book, Suddenly Something Clicked.

THE REAL CRIME IS NOTICING:

A deranged career criminal murders innocent woman for no reason. What does the Mayor (Vi Lyles) think? From her post on Twitter (X),

The video of the heartbreaking attack that took Iryna Zarutska’s life is now public. I want to thank our media partners and community members who have chosen not to repost or share the footage out of respect for Iryna’s family.

The murder isn’t the real crime. The real crime is noticing the murder.

* * * * * * * *

“We will never arrest our way out of issues such as homelessness and mental health,” Lyles said. “Mental health disease is just that — a disease like any other that needs to be treated with the same compassion, diligence and commitment as cancer or heart disease.”

Do not visit Charlotte. Do not invest money in Charlotte.

But you can arrest your way out of homelessness and mental health:

 

LEE SMITH: The Choice: Trump or Obama.

Bannon is zeroing in on the strategic aspect of the U.S.-Israel relationship by claiming that Netanyahu is corrupt and Israel is weak and worthless as an ally. Israel is a protectorate, says Bannon. The Jews needed Trump to finish the job in Iran, and now they’re trying to drag America into a regime-change war. To help sell his case, Bannon draws on Obama partners such as Iran lobbyist Trita Parsi, a chief spokesman for the Iran nuclear deal.

Carlson, on the other hand, is focused on the American majority. Obama went after the Jews, but for Carlson, it’s Christians, in particular evangelicals, the bedrock of pro-Israel America. It seems that his slate of shows on religious or spiritual topics is purposed to build an evangelical audience—a potentially self-defeating endeavor, since selling despair, sowing confusion, and peddling lies about the Jews while comforting their hunters may give evidence to believers that a man who claims to have been attacked by demons lost that skirmish.

The more practical problem is that evangelicals understand not only scripture but also American history better than Carlson and his guests do. Americans’ love of Israel didn’t start at the dawn of the 20th century, thanks to a best-selling Bible commentary; rather, it’s contemporaneous with our founding. That is, the small upstate New York town founded in 1714, for instance, was named Goshen not because of the 1902 Scofield Bible, but because our forefathers believed that the American project is rooted in the history, faith, and trials of the Jews.

Replacing Israel and the Jews with the negation of Israel and the Jews means not only undermining our historical and cultural foundations but also exposing our constitutional republic to extinction-level danger. A Palestinian Youth Movement conference last week in Dearborn, Michigan, gave evidence of what happens when the enemies of the Jews are raised to pride of place: threats of assassinating pro-Israel officials and disrupting American supply lines and commerce, all in the name of anti-Zionist resistance.

Even before Biden collapsed our borders, we lost thousands of miles from our eastern-most frontier, Europe; the continent is on the verge of collapse under the weight of foreign populations whose values and ideas are incommensurate with the civilization the West built on the foundations laid long ago in Jerusalem. Our flank is increasingly exposed because we have no other ally who can or wants to fight to preserve our past and ensure our future. It’s the United States and Israel alone. Thus, the choice for us is stark: America or the hellfire, Trump or Obama.

Read the whole thing.

QUESTIONS NOBODY IS ASKING: Nate Silver: What is Blueskyism?

Why this failure to achieve escape velocity? Well, as I’ve written about before, it might be Twitter itself was the outlier, created by tech nerds and for tech nerds at a time when the Internet was less tribal. Not only is anything else unlikely to supplant Twitter, but Twitter itself would probably fail to realize the same prominence if it were launched today, even if there were no dominant Twitter-like platform competing with it.

Founder effects are powerful in predicting network growth: if you go to a new club and everyone there has very peculiar tastes, it’s unlikely to become the hot new thing in town. Especially if everyone there is annoying and doesn’t seem to want you at their party in the first place.

Bluesky was initially popular with Twitter refugees who disliked Musk’s takeover of the platform, some of whom proclaimed that Elon had unleashed the “gates of hell” by restoring banned accounts or predicted that the platform would implode due to a shortage of engineering talent. I suppose I have no problem with this; ironically, the first post in Silver Bulletin history is entitled “In case Twitter goes to zero”. (I wanted a hedge in case it did, although if we’re being honest, I also had one eye out the door as ABC News was beginning to dismantle FiveThirtyEight.3) However, this also self-selected for a certain type of user, adherents of an attitude that I call “Blueskyism”.

Blueskyism should not be mistaken for general left-of-center political views. Google search traffic for Bluesky over the past year is highly correlated with Kamala Harris’s vote share, but has some other skews: controlling for the Harris vote, it’s (statistically) significantly higher in states with a large white population and where the percentage of people with advanced degrees is higher. Bluesky is disproportionately popular in D.C., but also in crunchy white states like Vermont and Oregon. Search traffic for Twitter/X over the same period shows the same bias toward highly educated states, but less toward Harris voters4 and actually an inverse correlation with the white population share. (X gets more search traffic in more diverse states.)

After quoting several paragraphs on Bluesky from “economist and former Bloomberg Opinion columnist Noah Smith” on Wednesday, Jim Geraghty concluded:

Rush Limbaugh used to joke that after the final victory of conservatism, the right should keep some liberals around to ensure no one forgot what they believed and how harmful their ideas were. “So you will never forget what these people were like . . . keep one Marxist and two liberals on the staff of every university so you can show your children . . . living fossils. Living fossils.”

If the goal is to keep progressives walled off from the rest of society, minimally influential among those who don’t already agree with them, and arguing amongst themselves about who’s the purest, Bluesky is a masterpiece.

Progressives, including advocates for athletes born male participating in women’s sports, could attempt to convince the broader public, if they wanted to, but they would have to engage with those who disagree with respect, and attempt to persuade, not shame, demonize, mock, or sneer. And even before the question of whether they could do that . . . how many progressives actually want to do that?

Flashback: Glenn on “Our caveman politics.”

TROLL LEVEL: POTUS DJT. President Trump warns that Chicago is ‘about to find out why it’s called the Department of WAR’ in incendiary Truth Social post:

President Donald Trump threatened Illinois‘s biggest city with a ‘Chipocalypse’ ahead of expected Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE) raids. 

Trump, 79, took to his social media platform, Truth Social, on Saturday to post a meme about himself, where he wrote: ‘I love the smell of deportations in the morning.

Chicago about to find out why it’s called the Department of WAR.’

Trump rebranded the Pentagon to the Department of War this week.

His threat comes as ICE readies a raid on the Windy City after Trump said he selected it for the next federal military takeover.

The Department of Homeland Security asked the Pentagon to have access to Naval Station Great Lakes – the largest military base in Illinois – to base the operation, The Washington Post reported.

It’s quite a striking image:

A decade ago, Spike Lee made a film in which he dubbed the Second City “Chi-Raq.” As CNN reported at the time:

Violence in this great American city matures so notoriously that film director Spike Lee now purportedly seeks a new nickname for the Windy City: Chiraq.

The name merges Chi-town with Iraq – as if Chicago sinks like the godforsaken Iraq, a hopeless war zone to the world.

The label signals a long fall for Chicago, whose official motto is the elegant “Urbs in Horto,” or “City in a Garden.” Once upon a time, Chicago even inspired poetry when Carl Sandburg declared it the “City of the Big Shoulders.”

But “Chiraq” is another story altogether for America’s third-largest city.

Naturally, Trump has leftists pivoting on a dime to defend the crime-ridden hellscape. In late August, CNN reported: Pritzker tells Trump to stay out of Chicago: ‘You are neither wanted here nor needed here.’

To be fair, I hope the soldiers of the newly minted Department of War are as tough as the denizens of Chiraq:

(If you know, you know.)

GREAT MOMENTS IN PHILADELPHIA FANDOM: Phillies Fan Sparks Outrage After Taking Home Run Ball From Young Boy.

The video went viral on social media, with over 10 million views.

Fans condemned the woman’s behavior. “Insane to me that an adult cares this much. Balls and pucks should always go to the nearest kid. This is the hill I will die on,” one X user said.

Sports journalist Jeff Drummond said on X: “Embarrassing. I’ve yet again failed to go 48 hours without saying “What’s wrong with people?” I feel like that’s a modest goal, but it keeps coming up short.”

Another sports journalist, Harrison Smajovits, wrote on X: “Pro tip for being a decent person: Don’t do this.”

Former Fox News journalist Adam Housley wrote on X: “What is wrong with people? The ball is the boys. Deal with it.”

Both teams later stepped in to make amends. A Marlins staffer gave the boy a bag of team merchandise and baseballs, telling him, “I saw what happened, it wasn’t right,” according to a video posted on X.

After the game, the Phillies arranged for him to receive a signed bat from Bader.

“Going home with a signed bat from Bader,” the Phillies wrote on X.

Did she stop in DC on her way to Miami?

In any case, you can take the Karen out of Philadelphia, but you can’t take the Philadelphia out of the Karen:

Related: Phillies and Marlins rally around young fan after woman confronts his father to get home run ball.

TEN YEARS OF MIGRATION CRISIS: The Fracture that Changed Europe.

On September 5, 2015, after Angela Merkel uttered the now infamous words “Wir schaffen das” (“We can do it”) on August 31st, Germany’s borders were effectively opened to hundreds of thousands of asylum seekers waiting in Austria and Hungary. With that gesture, celebrated by left-wing media as a show of humanity, one of the most convulsive stages of contemporary Europe began: the era of mass immigration. Today, a decade later, the data, the social problems, and the political transformations prove that the decision marked a turning point in the continent’s history.

More than one million people arrived in the European Union that year, mainly from Syria, Iraq, and Afghanistan. Germany received more than 440,000 asylum applications, Sweden 156,000, and Austria 88,000. Routes were saturated: Greece became the main entry point, Italy and Spain endured massive landings, and Hungary built fences to stop the flow—something harshly criticized at the time but now proven to be the only effective way to resist migratory suicide.

Thousands died—and continue to die—in the Mediterranean, yet the official narrative focused on “solidarity” and the promise that these newcomers would sustain the European welfare state. Today, those who once promoted open borders tell us that the system has failed and that massive cuts are needed, ‘discovering’ that the immigrants do not contribute to the sustaining of the welfare system but overwhelm it.

Fortunately, Europe has learned its lessons. No, sorry, just kidding of course: MP who backed boycott of Israel named Britain’s Home Secretary. “UK PM Keir Starmer appoints Shabana Mahmood as Home Secretary. Known for pro-BDS activism, Mahmood once led a protest that shut down a supermarket over Israeli goods and has accused Israel of “collective punishment” in Gaza.”

UPDATE:

ROGER KIMBALL IN THE LONDON TELEGRAPH: Trump’s 11 life-changing lessons are wiser than the Left will ever admit.

Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics is full of good advice and wise observations. So is the upbeat epitome of Donald Trump’s practical ethics, summarised in his new video “Eleven Life-Changing Lessons”.

Did you snicker when you saw the names “Aristotle” and “Donald Trump” juxtaposed? Aristotle is one of the greatest philosophers in history, and his Ethics, along with his Politics, may lay claim to be among the greatest repositories of practical wisdom in the Western tradition.

And Donald Trump? Well, he is a conspicuously successful businessman, a devoted father, and a celebrated media personality. He is also, for the second time, President of the United States of America.

Exit quote: “What do you think? Trump’s Eleven Life Lessons are not the Nicomachean Ethics. But they are plenty wise. They are a useful appendage to that great work. Added benefit: they are a lot shorter.”

 

EVE BARLOW: “Have you tried turning it off and on again?

That was one of the most quoted jokes from The IT Crowd. A British series written by Graham Linehan, who is a comedian from the Republic of Ireland and was once considered a national treasure. He is still a national treasure, I imagine, to many people too afraid to say so. The IT Crowd is a show based around an IT department as the internet implemented itself in everyday working environments, and it first aired almost 20 years ago. In the show, the more committed geeks of the IT department were ignored in favor of Roy, played by Chris O’Dowd, who hated the job and would regularly offer: “Have you tried turning it off and on again?” Or “Is it definitely plugged in?” These running jokes summarize Linehan’s humor. He dryly mocks societal roles and stereotypes, in a way that challenges their core identity. Which in this day and age is dangerous, I guess. Because self-imposed identity has demanded serious treatment by non-serious people, to such an extent that there is no more poetic license to make jibes about people’s behavior without it being a crime.

Prior to The IT Crowd, Linehan was one half of the team that created Father Ted. The latter series, which aired in the mid-90s, was a beloved satire about the Catholic priesthood, and is often cited next to Fawlty Towers in the canon of British TV. Father Ted was full of impolite jokes. Father Jack repeatedly shouts “Feck! Arse! Drink! Girls!” at inappropriate moments. There were Nazi jokes, racist jokes, sexual innuendos surrounding the milk man, and not to mention The Lovely Girls Contest, which was a spoof on a beauty pageant, and intended to expose misogyny, not condone it. However, in doing so necessarily aired sexism. Breaking taboos in humor is necessary to make light of the hypocrisy of authority – of humans. Irreverent jokes bring the absurdity of our lives to the surface. That’s why making an example out of someone who is celebrated for writing comedy cuts to the soul of free speech issues.

In Fahrenheit 451, Ray Bradbury famously says:

“You don’t have to burn books to destroy a culture. Just get people to stop reading them.”

The story of Graham Linehan is appalling. And it has had me asking earnestly for days: what are we doing to each other? Can we reset the system? Should we try turning it off and on again?

Read the whole thing.